LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
MARK TWAIN
yjb 1 rou* ts])i< vt
LETTERS OF
MARK TWAIN
WITH A BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH
AND COMMENTARY
BY
ALBERT BIGELOW PAINE
LONDON
CHATTO & WINDUS
1920
AU righto reserved
NOTE
T|t is selection of letters has been made from
she American edition of 1917. In order
to read with the ' text, the commentary
has been, where necessary, abridged.
CONTENTS
MARK rflfctfN : A BIOGRAPHICAL SUMMARY
PAGE
1
LETTERS
1868
To Mrs, Moffett
20
Mrs. Moffett
22
Orion Clemens
24
1866
To Mrs. Jane Clemons and Mrs, Moffett
27
Henry Clemens
28
1858
To Orion Clemens and his Wife
30
Mrs. Orion Clemens
33
1859
To Orion Clemens
36
1881
To Orion Clemens
37
Mrs. Jane Clemens
41
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs'. Moffett
43
Mrs. Moffett
46
1862
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
50
Orion Clemens
54
Orion Clemens
55
1868
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
57
Mrs* Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
59
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
60
1864
To S. Pixley and G. A. Spears
62
1666
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
68
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
64
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
65
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
67
Mts. Jane Clemens
69
Ytt
CONTENTS
1867
To Bret Harte
Mrs. Jane Clemens, etc.
Mrs. Jane Clemens, etc.
Mrs. Jane Clemens, etc.
Mrs. Jane Clemens , etc,
Elisha Bliss, Jr.
1808
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
Elisha Bliss, Jr.
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
Orion Clemens
Elisha Bliss, Jr.
Mrs. Jane Clemens, etc.
Mrs. Jane Clemens, etc.
1869
To Mrs. Jane Clemens, etc.
Mrs. Jane Clemens, etc.
California Pioneers of New York
1870
To Elisha Bliss, Jr.
James Bedpath
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
Orion Clemens
Orion Clemens
Mrs. Moffett
Orion Clemens
Rev. J. H. Twichell
Rev. J. H. Twiohell
1871
To Thomas Bailey Aldrich
Thomas Bailey Aldrich
Orion Clemens
Elisha BUsb, Jr.
James Bedpath
James Bedpath
Mr. Fall
James Bedpath
James Bedpath
James Bedpath
Bedpath and Fall
1872
To James Bedpath
William Dean Hbwells
Orion Clemens
Mrs. Clemens
Elisha Bliss, Jr.
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
Mrs. Jervis Langdon
1878
To Dr. John Brown
TO
TO
«
n
TO
+W
79
81
88
84
86
88
89
90
90
92
94
97
98
98
99
100
100
101
102
103
105
106
108
110
112
113
113
118
1 14
114
115
116
118
119
120
120
122
123
mmmm
it
1874
To Dr. John Brown
Dr* John Brown
Bet. wd Mrs. Twiohell
W. D. Howells
W. D, Howells
t <Mrs. Olemena
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W^D* Howells
Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett
PASS
124
1S6
127
128
129
180
188
184
185
136
1875
To W. D. Howells
Mrs. W. D. Howells
OharHs Langdon
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
Mrs. Clemens
138
139
140
142
143
145
146
148
149
151
1876 /
To W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. HowellB
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
151
154
165
156
158
160
162
164
1877
To W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. P. Howells
1878
To Mrs. Jane Clemens
Mrs. W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
Mrs. Clemens
W. D. Howells
166
166
168
170
175
177
178
179
180
183
186
h 1879
To W. P. Howells
Be?. J, H. Twiohell
W. P. Howells
Orion Clemens
W. P. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. P. Howells
136
188
192
196
198
199
200
CX3!fWWfl8
*
3,980
To W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
Orion Clemens
W. D. Howells
W. J>. Howells
Rev. J. H Twichell
T. B. Aldrich
W. D. Howells
Orion Clemens
1881
To Joel Chandler Harris
Joel Chandler Harris
Mrs. Clemens
Mrs. Clemens
Mrs. Clemens
W. D. Howells
1889
To W. D. Howells
Joel Chandler Harris
Mrs. Clemens
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
1883
To W. D. Howells
Col. Be Winton
W. D. Howells
Orion Clemens
1884
To W. D. Howells
1885
To W. D. Howells
Rev. J.
Charles L. Webster
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
Henry Ward Beecher
W. D. Howells
W. D. Howells
1886
To Mrs. Jane Clemens
Hartford Gas did Eleotrio-Idghting Co
1887
Answers mailed and unmailed
To H. 0. Christiancy
Mrs. T.
Jeanette Gilder
W. I). Howells
Chatto & Windua
m
915
916
917
918
919
290
994
996
997
999
930
938
936
987
938
940
948
943
944
945
946
948
953
255
956
956
959
961
xi
im
To ho uifl Pendleton
Theodore W. Crane
Orion Clemens
Edward W. Bok
To Orion Clemens
Prod* 4* Hull
Joaoph T. Goodman
Sylvester Baxter
Chatto <& Wmdus
Andrew Lang
1890 #
To J7T. Goodman
The Editor of Free Russia
PAOS
270
272
278
274
277
279
280
284
286
287
290
291
1891
A Fragment 295
To W. D Howells 297
W. D Howells 298
Mrs. Clemens 299
Mrs. Clemens 800
Clara Clement 301
F. J. Hall 302
1892
To Susy Clemens
F. J. Hall
Mrs. Crane
303
304
305
1898
To F. J Hall
Mrs. Clemens
Mrs. Clemens
306
309
310
1894
To Mrs. Clemens
Mrs. Olemens
Clara Clemens
Mrs. Clemens
Mrs. Clemens
H. H. Rogers
H. H. Rogers
H. H. Rogers
812
313
818
819
321
324
325
326
1896
To Rudyard Kipling 828
1896
To Rev. J, H. Twioheii 829
Rev. J. H. Twiohell 882
1897
To Rev. J. H Twichell 884
Frank E. Bliss 886
lit cwfiips
nm
1898
To W. D. Howells
m
Bov. J. E. Twiohell
m
Bev. 3. H. Twiohell
841
W. D. Howells
m
Bw.J.H. TwioheU
§ «
1899 *
To Wm. T. Stead, b%9
m
W. D. Howells
set
W. D. Howells
8ft
W* D. Howells
886
We D. Howells
861
1900
To Bev. J. H. Twiohell
85 8
W. D. Howells
861
Bev. J. H, Twiohell
863
Bev. J. H. Twiohell
864
The Editor of The Times
865
J Y. M. MaoAlister
366
Sylvester Baxter
367
1901
To Mrs. Charles MoQuiston
867
Prof. William Lyon Phelps
868
Edward L. Dimmitt
869
Bov. J H. Twiohell
371
1902
To The President of the Western Union
374
Bev. J. H. Twiohell
378
Mrs. Clemens
379
1908
To J. Y. M. MaoAlister
880
Brander Matthews
882
Brander Matthews
884
T. F. Gatts
884
T. F. Gatts
885
Bev. J. H. Twiohell
886
F. N. Doubleday
887
1904
To Bev. J. H Twiohell
888
W. D. Howells
891
Gov. Francis
392
W. D Howells
893
F. N. Doubleday
894
Bev. J. H. Twiohell
895
1905
To Bev. J. H. Twiohell
396
Bev. J. H. TwioheU
897
St. Clair MoKelway
401
Frederiok A. Duneka, bis
402
Frederick A. Duneka
408
Frederiok A Duneka
405
Bev. L* M. Powers
409
Mr. Bow
410
CONTENTS
1906
To Andrew Carnegie
W, P, Howells
Heniy Alden
1907
• 4
Mrs. F. G. Whitmore
as Joy Agnew
1908 •
Together Fitz-Slmon
Bev. F. V. Christ
Mrs Hookway
1909 .
To Henniker-Heaton
J. Wylie Smith
1910
To Albert Bigelow Paine
Charles T. Lark
INDEX
m
415
416
417
419
421
424
425
426
429
ILLUSTRATIONS
MARK TWAIN
FACING FAGS
Frontispiece
BRET HABTE, JOSH BILLINGS, ARTEJIU8 WARD, JOHN HAY! A GROUP OP
MARK JfWAIH'S EARLY FRIENDS 64
MARK TWAIN AT HARTFORD ABOUT 1875 144
MARK TWAIN AND GEORGE W. CABLE 240
MBS . CLEMENS ABOUT 1885 272
TWAIN ON HIS TRIP ROUND THE WORLD: A TRICK PHOTOGRAPH
made from two Aegatiyeb 828
MARK twain in 1826 886
BTORMPIBLD 416
MARK TWAIN
A BIOGRAPHICAL SUMMARY
Samuei* Langhorne Clemens, for nearly half a century
known and celebrated as “ Mark Twain,” was bom in
Florida, Missouri, on November 30, 1835. He was one of
the foremost American philosophers of his day ; he was
the world’s most famous humorist of any day. During
the later years of his .life he ranked not only as America’s
chief man of fetters, but likewise as her best known and
best loved citizen.
The beginnings of that life were sufficiently unpromising.
The family was a good one, of old Virginia and Kentucky
stock, but its circumstances were reduced, its environment
meagre and disheartening. The father, John Marshall
Clemens — a lawyer by profession, a merchant by vocation
— had brought his household to Florida from Jamestowm,
Tennessee, somewhat after the manner of Judge Hawkins
as pictured in The Gilded Age. Florida was a small town
then, a mere village of twenty-one houses located on Salt
River, but Judge Clemens, as he was usually called,
optimistic and speculative in his temperament, believed
In its future. Salt River would be made navigable ;
Florida would become a metropolis. He established a
small business there, and located his family in the humble
frame cottage where, five months later, was bom a baby
boy to whom they gave the name of Samuel — a family
name — and added Langhome, after an old Virginia friend
of his father.
The child was puny, and did not make a very sturdy
1 B
2
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
r
fight for life. Still he weathered along, season after season,
and survived two stronger children, Margaret and Ben-
jamin. By 1889 Judge'Clemens had lost faith in Florida.
He removed his family to Hannibal, and in this Mississippi
River town the little lad whom the world was to know -as
Mark Twain spent his early life. In Tom Sawyer wchave
a picture of the Hannibal of those days and the atmosphere
of his boyhood there.
His schooling was brief and of a desultory kind. It
ended one day in 1847, when his father died and it became
necessary that each one should help somewhat? in the
domestic crisis. His brother Orion, ten years his senior,
was already a printer by trade. Pamela, his sister, also
considerably older, had acquired music, and now took a
few pupils. The little boy Sam, at twelve, was appren-
ticed to a printer named Ament. His wages consisted of
his board and clothes — “ more board than Clothes,” as he
once remarked to the writer.
He remained with Ament until his brother Orion brought
out a small paper in Hannibal in 1850. The paper, in
time, was moved into a part of the Clemens home, and
the two brothers ran it, the younger setting most of the
type. A still younger brother, Henry, entered the office
as an apprentice. The Hannibal Journal was no great
paper from the beginning, and it did not improve with
time. Still, it managed to survive — country papers nearly
always manage to survive — year after year, bringing in
some sort of return. It was on this paper that young Sam
Clemens began his writings — burlesque, as a rule, of local
characters and conditions — usually published in his brother’s
absence; generally resulting in trouble on his return.
Yet they made the paper sell, and if Orion had but realized
his brother’s talent he might have turned it into capital
even then.
In 1858 (he was not yet eighteen) Sam Clemens grew
tired of his limitations and pined for the wider horizon
of the world. He gave out to his family that he was
PILOT ON THE MISSISSIPPI 8
going to St. Louis, but ho kept on to New York, where a
World’s Fair was then going on. t In New York he found
employment at his trade, and during the hot months
of 1858 worked in a printing-office in Cliff Street. By
ancf by he went to Philadelphia, where he worked a
brief tima ; made a trip to Washington, and presently set
out for the West again, after an absence of more than a
year.
Orion, meanwhile, had established himself at Musca-
tine, Iojya, but soon after removed to Keokuk, where the
brothers were once more together, still following their
trade. Young Sam Clemens remained in Keokuk until
the winter of 185G-57, when he caught a touch of the
South-Amcrican fever then prevalent, and decided to go
to Brazil. He left Keokuk for Cincinnati, worked that
winter in a printing-office there, and in April took the
little steamer, Paul Jones, for New Orleans, where he
expected to find a South-American vessel. In Life on
the Mississippi we have his story of how he met Horace
Bixby and decided to become a pilot instead of a South-
American adventurer — jauntily setting himself the stupen-
dous task of learning the twelve hundred miles of the
Mississippi River between St. Louis and New Orleans — of
knowing it as exactly and as unfailingly, even in the dark,
as one knows the way to his own features. It seems in-
credible to those who knew Mark Twain in his later years
— dreamy, unpractical, and indifferent to details — that he
could have acquired so vast a store of minute facts as were
required by that task. Yet within eighteen months he
had become not only a pilot, but one of the best and
most careful pilots on the river, entrusted*with some of
the largest and most valuable steamers. He continued
in that profession for two and a half years longer, and
during that time met with no disaster that cost his owners
a single dollar for damage.
Then the war broke out. South Carolina seceded in
December, 1860, and other States followed. Clemens was
4 LETTERS Of MARK TWAIN
in New Orleans in January, 1861, when Louisiana seceded,
and his boat was put into the Confederate service and
sent up the Red Rive#. His occupation gone, lie took
steamer for the North— the last one before the blockade
closed. A blank cartridge was fired at them from Jeffetsbn
Barracks when they reached St. Louis, but they did not
understand the signal, and kept on. Presently, ft shell
carried away part of the pilot-house and considerably
disturbed its inmates. They realized, then, that war had
really begun.
In those days Clemens’ sympathies were with the
South. He hurried up to Hannibal and enlisted with a
company of young fellows who were recruiting with the
avowed purpose of “ throwing off the yoke of the invader.”
They were ready for the field, presently, and set out in
good order, a sort of nondescript cavalry detachment,
mounted on animals more picturesque than beautiful.
Still, it was a resolute band, and might have done very
well, only it rained a good deal, which made soldiering
disagreeable and hard. Lieutenant Clemens resigned at
the end of two weeks, and decided to go to Nevada
with Orion, who was a Union abolitionist and had received
an appointment from Lincoln as Secretary of the new
Territory.
In Roughing It Mark Twain gives us the story of the
overland journey made by the two brothers, and a picture
of experiences at the other end — true in aspect, even
if here and there elaborated in detail. He was Orion’s
private secretary, but there was no private-secretary
work to do, and no salary attached to the position. The
incumbent presently went to mining, adding that to his
other trades.
He became a professional miner, but not a rich one. He
was at Aurora, California, in the Esmeralda district,
skimping along, with not much to eat and less to wear,
when ht was summoned by Joe Goodman, owner and
editor of the Virginia City Enterprise, to come up and
"MARK TWAIN” S
• take die local editorship of that paper. He had been
contributing sketches to it now and then, under the pen-
name df “ Josh,” and Goodman* a man of fine literary
instincts, recognized a talent full of possibilities. This
wtuf in the late summer of 1862 . Clemens walked one
hundred ,and thirty miles over very bad roads to take
the jdbs and arrived way-worn and travel-stained. He
began on a salary of twenty-five dollars a week, picking
up news items here and there, and contributing occasional
sketches — burlesques, hoaxes, and the like. When the
Legislature convened at Carson City he was sent down to
report it, and then, for the first time, began signing his
articles “ Mark Twain,” a river term, used in making
soundings, recalled from his piloting days. The name
presently became known up and down the Pacific coast.
His articles were copied and commented upon. He was
recognized as* one of the foremost among a little coterie
of overland writers, two of whom, Mark Twain and Bret
Harte, were soon to acquire a world-wide fame.
He left Carson City one day, after becoming involved
in a duel, the result of an editorial squib written in Good-
man’s absence, and went across the Sierras to San
Francisco. The duel turned out farcically enough, but
the Nevada law, which regarded even a challenge or its
acceptance as a felony, was an inducement to his
departure. Furthermore, he had already aspired to a
wider field of literary effort. He attached himself to the
Morning Call, and wrote occasionally for one or two
literary papers — the Golden Era and the Californian —
prospering well enough during the better part of the year.
Bret Harte and the rest of the little Pac^ic-slope group
were alsQ on the staff of these papers, and for a time, at
least, the new school of American humour mustered in San
Francisco.
The connection with the Call was not congenial. In
due course it came to a natural end, and Mark Twain
arranged to do a daily San Francisco letter for his old
6
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
paper, the Enterprise. The Enterprise letters stirfed up ,
trouble. They criticized the police of San Francisco so
severely that the officials found means of making the
writer’s life there difficult and comfortless. With Jim
Gillis, brother of a printer of whom he was fond, and Vho
had been the indirect cause of his troubles, he ( Went up
into Calaveras Country, to a cabin on Jackass Hilh Jim
Gillis, a lovable, picturesque character (the Truthful
James of Bret Harte), owned mining claims. Mark
Twain decided to spend his vacation in pocket-mining,
and soon added that science to his store of knowledge.
It was a halcyon, happy three months that he lingered
there, but did not make his fortune ; he only laid the
corner-stone.
They tried their fortune at Angel’s Camp, a place well
known to readers of Bret Harte. But it rained pretty
steadily, and they put in most of their ‘lime huddled
around the single stove of the dingy hotel of Angel’s,
telling yams. Among the stories was one told by a dreary
narrator named Ben Coon. It was about a frog that had
been trained to jump, but failed to win a wager because
the owner of a rival frog had surreptitiously loaded him
with shot. The story had been circulated among the
camps, but Mark Twain had never heard it until then.
The tale and the tiresome fashion of its telling amused
him. He made notes to remember it.
Their stay in Angel’s Camp came presently to an end.
One day, when the mining partners were following the
specks of gold that led to a pocket somewhere up the hill,
a chill, dreary rain set in. Jim, as usual, was washing,
and Clemens was carrying water. The “ colour ” became
better and better as they ascended, and Gillis, possessed
with the mining passion, would have gone on, regardless of
the rain. Clemens, however, protested, and declared that
each pail of water was his last. Finally he said, in his
deliberate drawl :
“ I won’t carry any more water. This work is too
“THE JUMPING FROG*’ 7
disagreeable. Let’s go to the house and wait till it clears
up.”
GilH% had just taken out a pan of earth. “ Bring one
more pail, Sam,” he pleaded.
* * I won’t do it, Jim ! Not a drop ! Not if I knew there
was a million dollars in that pan ! ”
Thfcy left the pan .standing there and went back to
Angel’s Camp. The rain continued and they returned
to Jackass Hill without visiting their claim again. Mean-
time the rain had washed away the top of the pan of
earth feft standing on the slope above Angel’s, and
exposed a handful of nuggets — pure gold. Two strangers
came along and, observing it, sat down to wait until
the thirty-day claim-notice posted by Jim Gillis should
expire. They did not mind the rain — not with that gold
in sight — and the minute the thirty days were up they
followed the Ifcad a few pans further, and took out — some
say ten, some say twenty, thousand dollars. It was a good
pocket. Mark Twain missed it by one pail of water.
Still, it is just as well, perhaps, when one remembers The
Jumping Frog.
Matters having quieted down in San Francisco, he
returned and took up his work again. Artemus Ward,
whom he had met in Virginia City, wrote him for some-
thing to use in his (Ward’s) new book. Clemens sent the
frog story, but he had been dilatory in preparing it, and
when it reached New York, Carleton, the publisher, had
Ward’s book about ready for the press. It did not seem
worth while to Carleton to include the frog story, and he '
handed it ov<r to Henry Clapp, editor of the Saturday
Press — a perishing sheet — saying :
“ Here, Clapp, here’s something you can use.”
The story appeared in the Saturday Press of
November 18, 1865. According to the accounts of that
time it set all New York in a roar, which annoyed, rather
than gratified, its author. He had thought very little of
it, indeed, yet had been wondering why some of his
g LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
paore highly regarded work had not found fuller' recog-
nition.
But The Jumping Frog did not die. Papersrprinted
it and reprinted it, and it was translated into foreign
tongues. The name of “Mark Twain” became kdbflm
as the author of that sketch, and the two were permanently
associated from the day of its publication. «*
Such fame as it brought did not yield heavy financial
return. Its author continued to win a more or less pre-
carious livelihood doing miscellaneous work, until March,
1866 , when he was employed by the Sacramento Union,
to contribute a series ot letters from the Sandwich Islands.
They were notable letters, widely read and freely copied,
and the sojourn there was a generally fortunate one. It
was during his stay in the islands that the survivors of
the wrecked vessel, the Hornet, came in, after long priva-
tion at sea. Clemens was sick at the time, but Anson
Burlingame, who was in Honolulu, on the way to China,
had him carried in a cot to the hospital, where he could
interview the surviving sailors and take down their
story. It proved a great “ beat ” for the Union, and added
considerably to its author's prestige. On his return to
San Francisco he contributed an article on the Hornet
disaster to Harper's Magazine, and looked forward to its
publication as a beginning of a real career. But, alas !
when it appeared the printer and the proof-reader had
somehow converted “ Mark Twain ” into “ Mark Swain,”
and his dreams perished.
Undecided as to his plans, he was one day advised by
a friend to deliver a lectin e. He was already known as
an entertaining talker, and his adviser judged his possi-
bilities well. In Roughing It we find the story of that first
lecture and its success. He followed it with other lectures
up and down the Coast. He had added one more pro-
fession to his intellectual stock-in-trade.
Mark Twain, now provided with money, decided to
pay a visit to his people. He set out for the East in
0
MEDITERRANEAN TRIP
• December, 1866 , vid Panama, arriving in New York in
January. A few days later he was with his mother, then
living $ith his sister, in St. Ltfuis. A little later he
lectured in Keokuk, and in Hannibal, his old home.
• ft was about this time that the first great Mediterranean
steamship excursion began to be exploited. No such ocean
picnic *had ever been planned before, and it created a
good deal of interest East and West. Mark Twain heard
of it and wanted to go. He wrote to friends on the Alta-
Califomia, of San Francisco, and the publishers of that
paper had sufficient faith to advance the money for his
passage, on the understanding that he was to contribute
frequent letters, at twenty dollars apiece. It was a liberal
offer, as rates went in those days, and a godsend in the
fullest sense of the word to Mark Twain.
Clemens now hurried to New York in order to be there
in good season for the sailing date, which was in June. In
New York he met Frank Fuller, whom he had known as
territorial Governor of Utah, an energetic and enthusi-
astic admirer of the Western humorist. Fuller immediately
proposed that Clemens give a lecture in order to establish
his reputation on the Atlantic coast. Clemens demurred,
but Fuller insisted, and engaged Cooper Union for the
occasion. Not many tickets were sold. Fuller, however,
always ready for an emergency, sent out a flood of com-
plimentarics to the school teachers of New York and
adjacent territory, and the house was crammed. It turned
out to be a notable event. Mark Twain was at his best
that night ; the audience laughed until, as some ot them
declared when the lecture was over, they were too weak to
leave their seats. His success as a lecturer was assured.
The Quaker City was the steamer selected for the great
Oriental tour. It sailed as advertised, June 8, 1867, and
was absent five months, during which Mark Twain con-
tributed regularly to the Alta~California, and wrote several
letters for the New York Tribune. They were read and
copied everywhere. They preached a new gospel in
10 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
travel literature— a gospel of seeing with an oveflflowing
honesty ; a gospel of sincerity in according praise to
whatever he consider#d genuine, and ridicule* to the
things believed to be shams. It was a gospel that Marie
Twain continued to preacli during his whole career? *Jt
became, in fact, his chief literary message to the world,
a world ready for that message. ,«
He returned to find himself famous. Publishers were
ready with plans for collecting the letters in book form.
The American Publishing Company, of Hartford* pro-
posed a volume, elaborately illustrated, to be Isold by
subscription. He agreed with them as to terms, and went
to Washington to prepare copy. But he could not work
quietly there, and presently was back in San Francisco,
putting his book together, lecturing occasionally, always
to crowded houses. lie returned in August, 1808, with
the manuscr’pt of the Innocents Abroad, anti that winter,
while his book was being manufactured, lectured through-
out the East and Middle West, making his headquarters
in Hartford, and in Elmira, New York.
He had an especial reason for going to Elmira. On the
Quaker City he had met a young man by the name of
Charles Langdon, and one day, in the Bay of Smyrna,
had seen a miniature of the boy’s sister, Olivia Langdon,
then a girl of about twenty-two. He fell in love with
that picture, and still more deeply in love with the original
when he met her in New York on his return. The Langdon
home was in Elmira, and it was for this reason that as time
passed he frequently sojourned there. When the proofs
of the Innocents Abroad were sent him he took them along,
and he and sweet “ Livy ” Langdon read them together.
What he lacked in those days in literary delicacy she
detected, and together they pruned it away. She became
his editor that winter— a position which she held until
her death.
The book was published in July, 1809, and its success
was immediate and abundant. On his wedding-day.
MARRIAGE
11
.Febttiafy 2, 1870, Clemens received* a cheque from his
publishers for more than four thousand dollars, royalty
accumulated during the three months preceding. The
sales soon amounted to more than fifty thousand copies,
and4iad increased to very nearly one hundred thousand
at the end of the first three years. It was a book ot
travel, i^s lowest price three dollars and fifty cents. Even
with our increased reading population no such sale is
found for a book of that description to-day. And the
Innocents Abroad holds it place — still outsells every other
book in Its particular field.
Mark Twain now decided to settle down. He had
bought an interest in the Express, of Buffalo, New York,
and took up his residence in that city in a house presented
to the young couple by Mr. Langdon. It did not prove
a fortunate beginning. Sickness, death, and trouble of
many kinds put a blight on the happiness of their first
married year and gave them a distaste for the home in
which they had made such a promising start. A baby
boy, Langdon Clemens, came along in November, but
he was never a strong child. By the end of the following
year the Clemenses had arranged for a residence in Hartford,
temporary at first, later made permanent. It was in
Hartford that little Langdon died, in 1872.
Clemens, meanwhile, had sold out his interest in the
Express, severed his connection with the Galaxy, a magazine
for which he was doing a department each month,
and had written a second book for the American Publish-
ing Company, Roughing It, published in 1872. In
August of the same year he made a trip to London, to get
material for a book on England, but was too much sought
after, too continuously feted, to do any work. He went
alone, but in November returned with the purpose of
taking Mrs. Clemens and the new baby, Susy, to England
the following spring. They sailed in April, 1873, and spent
a good portion of the year in England and Scotland. They
returned to America in November, and Clemens hurried
12 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
back to London alone to deliver a notable series oncctnrec
under the management of George Dolby, formerly jnanaging
agent lor Charles Dickens. For two months Mafk Twain
lectured steadily to London audiences — the big Hanover
Square rooms always filled. He returned to his faHEi y in
January, 1874. f
Meantime, a home was being built for them in Hartford,
and in the autumn of 1874 they took up residence in it—
a happy residence, continued through seventeen years —
well-nigh perfect years. Their summers they spent in
Elmira, on Quarry Farm — a beautiful hilltop, the home
of Mrs. Clemens’s sister. It was in Elmira that much of
Mark Twain’s literary work was done. He had a special
study there, some distance from the house, where he loved
to work out his fancies and put them into visible form.
It was not so easy to work at Hartford ; there was too
much going on. The Clemens home was a sort of general
headquarters for literary folk, near and far, and for dis-
tinguished foreign visitors of every sort. Howells and
Aldrich used it as their half-way station between Boston
and New York, and every foreign notable who visited
America made a pilgrimage to Hartford to see Mark Twain.
Some even went as far as Elmira, among them Rudyard
Kjpling, who recorded his visit in a chapter of his American
Notes. Kipling declared he had come all the way from
India to see Mark Twain.
Hartford had its own literary group. Mrs. Harriet
Beecher Stowe lived near the Clemens home ; also Charles
Dudley Warner. The Clemens and Warner families were
constantly associated, and The Gilded Age , published in
1873, resulted^ from the friendship of Warner and Mark
Twain. The character of Colonel Sellers in that book
has become immortal, and it is a character that only Mark
Twain could create, for, though drawn from his mother’s
cousin, James Lampton, it embodies — and in no very
Exaggerated degree — characteristics that were his own.
The tendency to make millions was always imminent;
PUBLISHING AND LITERATURE
13
.tempt Alton was always hard to resist. Money-making
schemes are continually being placed before men of means
and prominence, and Mark Twain, to the day of his death,
found such schemes fatally attractive.
tit was because of the Sellers characteristics in him that
he invested in a typesetting-machine which cost him
nearly *£wo hundred thousand dollars and helped to
wreck his fortunes by and by. It was because of this
characteristic that he invested in numberless schemes of
lesser Importance, but no less disastrous in the end. His
one sucdfcssful commercial venture was his association with
Charles L. Webster in the publication of the Grant Memoirs,
of which enough copies were sold to pay a royalty of
more than four hundred thousand dollars to Grant’s
widow — the largest royalty ever paid from any single
publication. It saved the Grant family from poverty.
Yet even this triumph was a misfortune to Mark Twain,
for it led to scores of less profitable book ventures and
eventual disaster.
Meanwhile he had written and published a number of
books. Tom Sawyer , The Prince and the Pauper, Life on the
Mississippi , Huckleberry Finn, and A Connecticut Yankee
in King Arthur's Court -were among the volumes that had
entertained the world and inspired it with admiration
and love for their author. In 1878-79 he had taken his
family to Europe, where they spent their time in travelling
over the Continent. It was during this period that he was
joined by his intimate friend, the Rev. Joseph H. Twichell,
of Hartford, and the two made a journey, the story of
which is told in A Tramp Abroad.
In 1891 the Hartford house was again closed, this time
indefinitely, and the family, now five in number, took up
residence in Berlin. The typesetting-machine and the
unfortunate publishing venture were drawing heavily on
the family finances at this period, and the cost of the
Hartford establishment was too great to be maintained.
During the next three years he was distracted by the
14
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
financial struggle which ended in April, 1894, with the*
failure of Charles L. Webster & Co. Mark Twain now
found himself bankrupt, and nearly one hundred thousand
dollars in debt. It had been a losing fight, with this bitter
ending always in view ; yet during this period r i fidrd,
hopeless effort he had written a large portion of the book
which of all his works will perhaps survive the longest —
his tender and beautiful story of Joan of Arc. All his
life Joan had been his favourite character in the world’s
history, and during those trying months and years of the
early ’nineties— in Berlin, in Florence, in Paris — he was
conceiving and putting his picture of that gentle girl-
warrior into perfect literary form. It was published in
Harper's Magazine — anonymously, because, as he said,
it would not have been received seriously had it appeared
over his own name. The authorship was presently recog-
nized. Exquisitely, reverently, as the story was told, it
had in it the touch of quaint and gentle humour which
could only have been given to it by Mark Twain.
It was only now and then that Mark Twain lectured
during these years, lie had made a reading tour with
George W. Cable during the winter of 1884-85, but he
abominated the platlorm, and often vowed he would
never appear before an audience again. Yet, in 1895,
when he was sixty years old, he decided to rebuild his
fortunes by making a reading tour around the world. It
was not required of him to pay his debts in full. The
creditors were willing to accept fifty per cent, of the
liabilities, and had agreed to a settlement on that basis.
But this did not satisry Mrs. Clemens, and it did not
satisfy him. They decided to pay dollar for dollar. They
sailed for America, and in July, 1895, set out from Elmira
on the long trail across land and sea. Mrs. Clemens and
Clara Clemens joined this pilgrimage, Susy and Jean
Clemens remaining at Elmira with their aunt. Looking
out of the car windows, the travellers saw Susy waving
them an adieu. It was a picture they would long remember.
IN EUROPE
15
, The reading tour was one of triumph. High prices and
crowded houses prevailed everywhere. The author-
reader visited Australia, New Zealand, India, Ceylon,
South Africa, arriving in England, at last, with the money
and fnaterial which would pay off the heavy burden of
debt and make him once more free before the world. And
in thate.hour of triumph came the heavy blow. Susy
Clemens, never very strong, had been struck down. The
first cable announced her illness. The mother and Clara
sailed *at once. Before they were half-way across the
ocean a Second cable announced that Susy was dead. The
father had to meet and endure the heartbreak alone ; he
could not reach America in time for the burial. lie
remained in England, and was joined there by the sorrowing
family.
They passed that winter in London, where he worked
at the story of his travels, Following the Equator , the
proofs of which he read the next summer in Switzerland.
The returns from it, and from his reading venture, wiped
away Mark Twain’s indebtedness and made him free.
He could go back to America, as he said, able to look any
man in the face again.
Yet he did not go immediately. He could live more
economically abroad, and economy was still necessary.
The family spent two winters in Vienna, and their apart-
ments there constituted a veritable court where the world’s
notables gathered. Another winter in England followed,
and then, in the latter part of 1900, they went home —
that is, to America. Mrs. Clemens never could bring
herself to return to Hartford, and never saw their home
there again.
Mark Twain’s return to America was in*the nature of
a national event. Wherever he appeared throngs turned
out to bid him welcome. Mighty banquets were planned
in his honour.
In a house at 14, West Tenth Street, and in a beautiful
place at Riverdale, on the Hudson, most of the next three
16
letters of mark twain
years were passed. ' Then Mrs. Clemens’s health faifed,
and in the autumn of 1908 the family went to Florence
for her benefit. There, on the 5th of June, 1904,,shc died.
They brought her back and laid her beside Susy, at Elmira.
That winter the family took up residence at 21, oFifth
Avenue, New York, and remained there until the completion
of Stormfield, at Redding, Connecticut, in 1908.
In his later life Mark Twain was accorded high academic
honours. Already, in 1888, he had received from Yale
College the degree of Master of Arts, and the same college
made him a Doctor of Literature in 1901. A year later
the university of his own State, at Columbia, Missouri,
conferred the same degree, and then, in 1907, came the
crowning honour, when venerable Oxford tendered him
the doctor’s robe.
“ I don’t know why they should give me a degree like
that,” he said, quaintly. “ I never doctored any literature.
I wouldn’t know how.”
He had thought never to cross the ocean again, but he
declared he would travel to Mars and back, if necessary,
to get that Oxford degree. He appreciated its full mean-
ing — recognition by the world’s foremost institution of
learning of the achievements of one who had no learning
of the institutionary kind. He sailed in June, and his
sojourn in England was marked by a continuous ovation.
His hotel was besieged by callers. Two secretaries were
busy nearly twenty hours a day attending to visitors and
mail. When he appeared on the street his name went
echoing in every direction and the multitudes gathered.
On the day when he rose, in his scarlet robe and black
mortar-board, to receive his degree (be must have made
a splendid picture in that dress, with his erown of silver
hair), the vast assembly went wild. What a triumph,
indeed, for the little Missouri printer-boy ! It was the
climax of a great career.
Mark Twain’s work was always of a kind to make
people talk, always important, even when it was mere
LAST YEARS
17
.humour* Yet it was seldom that ; there was always wisdom
under it, and purpose, and these things gave it dynamic
force arid enduring life. Some 'of his aphorisms — so
quaint in form as to invite laughter — are yet fairly startling
in thfeir purport. His paraphrase, “ When in doubt, tell
the truth,” is of this sort. “ Frankness is a jewel ; only
the young can afford it,” he once said to the writer,
apropos of a little girl’s remark. His daily speech was
full of such things. The secret of his great charm was his
great humanity and the gentle quaintness and sincerity
6f his utterance.
His work did not cease when the pressing need of money
came to an end. He was full of ideas, and likely to begin
a new article or story at any time. He wrote and pub-
lished a number of notable sketches, articles, stories, even
books, during these later years, among them that marvellous
short story — ‘"The Man that Corrupted Hadleyburg.”
In that story, as in most of his later work, he proved to
the world that he was much more than a humorist — that
he was, in fact, a great teacher, moralist, philosopher —
the greatest, perhaps, of his age.
His life at Stormfield — he had never seen the place
until the day of his arrival, June 18, 1908 — was a peaceful
and serene old age. Not that he was really old ; he never
was that. His step, his manner, his point of view, were
all and always young. He was fond of children and fre-
quently had them about him. He delighted in games —
especially in billiards — and in building the house at
Stormfield the billiard-room was first considered. He
had a genuine passion for the sport ; without it his after-
noon was not complete. His mornings he was likely to
pass in bed, smoking — he was always smoking — and
attending to his correspondence and reading. History and
the sciences interested him, and his bed was strewn with
biographies and stories of astronomical and geological
research. The vastness of distances and periods always
impressed him. He had no head for figures, but he would
18
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
labour for hours over scientific calculations, trying*to com-,
pass them and to grasp their gigantic import. I remember
once finding him highly elated over the fact thtffc he had
figured out for himself the length in hours and minutes
of a “ light year.” He showed me the pages co^rccf with
figures, and was more proud of them than if they had been
the pages of an immortal story. Then we playcd.billiards,
but even his favourite game could not make him altogether
forget his splendid achievement.
It was on the day before Christmas, 1909, that heavy
bereavement once more came into the life of Mark Twain.
His daughter Jean, long subject to epileptic attacks, was
seized with a convulsion while in her bath and died before
assistance reached her. He was dazed by the suddenness
of the blow. His philosophy sustained him. He was glad,
deeply glad for the beautiful girl that had been released.
“ I never greatly envied anybody but' the dead,” he
said, when he had looked at her. “ I always envy the dead.”
The coveted estate of silence, time’s only absolute gift,
it was the one benefaction he had ever considered worth
while.
Yet the years were not unkindly to Mark Twain. They
brought him sorrow, but they brought him likewise the
capacity and opportunity for large enjoyment, and at the
last they laid upon him a kind of benediction. Naturally
impatient, lie grew always more gentle, more generous,
more tractable and considerate as the seasons passed.
His final days may be said to have been spent in the
tranquil light of a summer afternoon.
His own end followed by a few months that of his
daughter. Inhere were already indications that his heart
was seriously affected, and soon after Jean’s death he
sought the warm climate of Bermuda. But his malady
made rapid progress, and in April he returned to Stormfield.
He died there just a week later, April 21, 1910.
Any attempt to designate Mark Twain’s place in the
world’s literary history would be presumptuous now. Yet
PLACE IN LITERATURE 19
,1 cannot help thinking that he will maintain his supremacy
in the century that produced him. I think so because, of
all the Writers of that hundred yfars, his work was the
most human — his utterances went most surely to the
mark*. In the long analysis of the ages it is the truth that
counts, and he never approximated, never compromised,
but pronounced those absolute verities to which every
human being of whatever rank must instantly respond.
His understanding of subjective human nature — the
vast, unwritten life within — was simply amazing. Such
knowledge he acquired at the fountainhead — that is, from
himself. He recognized in himself an extreme example of
the human being with all the attributes of power and of
weakness, and he made his exposition complete.
The world will long -miss Mark Twain ; his example and
his teaching will be neither ignored nor forgotten. Genius
defies the laws <5f perspective and looms larger as it recedes.
The memory of Mark Twain remains to us a living
and intimate presence that to-day, even more than
in life, constitutes a stately moral bulwark reared against
hypocrisy and superstition — a mighty national menace to
sham.
20
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
THE LETTERS
We have no record of Mark Twain’s earliest letters. No
letter of his boyhood, no scrap of his earlier writing, has come
to light except his pencilled name, Sam Clemens, laboriously
inscribed on the inside of a small worn purse that once held
his meagre, almost non-existent wealth. •
It was not until he was seven! cen years old that Sam Clemens
wrote a letter any portion of which has survived. He wa6 no
longer in Hannibal. Orion’s unprosperous enterprise did not
satisfy him. His wish to earn money and to see the world had
carried him first to St. Louis, where his sister Pamela was living,
then to New York City, where a World’s Fair in a Crystal Palace
was in progress. The letter tells of a visit to this great exhibi-
tion. It is not complete, and the fragment bears no date, but it
was written during the summer of 1 853.
Fragment of a letter from Sam L. Clemens to his sister
Pamela Moffett, in St. Louis , summer of 1853 :
... It would take more than a week to examine
everything on exhibition ; and as 1 was only in a little
over two hours to-night, I only glanced at about one-
third of the articles ; and having a poor memory, I
have enumerated scarcely any of even the principal
objects. The visitors to the Palace average 6,000 daily —
double the population of Hannibal.
I am very sorry to learn that Ilenry has been sick. He
ought to go»to the country and take exercise ; for he is
not half so healthy as Ma thinks he is. If he had my
walking to do, he would be another boy entirely. Four
times every tiay I walk a little over one mile ; and work-
ing hard all day, and walking four miles, is exercise — I
am used to it, now, though, and it is no trouble. Where is
it Orion’s going to ? Tell Ma my promises are faithfully
NEW YORK
21
‘kept, and if I have my health I will take her to Ky. in
the spring — I shall save money for this. Tell Jim and
all the rest of them to write, and give me all the news.
I an^ sorry to hear such bad news from Will and Captain
Bowen. I shall write to Will soon. The Chathom-square
Post Office and the Broadway office too, are out of my
way, and I always go to the General Post Office ; so you
must write the direction of my letters plain, “ New York
City, N- Y.,” without giving the street or anything of
the kinc^ or they may go to some of the other offices. (It
has just struck 2 a.m. and I always get up at 6, and am
at work at 7.) You ask me where I spend my evenings.
Where would you suppose, with a free printers’ library
containing more than 4,000 volumes within a quarter of
a mile of me, and nobody at home to talk to ? I shall
write to Ella sqon. Write soon
Truly your Brother
Sam.
P.S. I have written this by a light so dim that you
nor Ma could not read by it.
He was lodging in a mechanics’ cheap boarding-house in
Duane Street, and wc may imagine the bareness of his room,
the feeble poverty of his lamp.
“ Tell Ma my promises are faithfully kept.” It was the
day when he had left Hannibal. His mother, Jane Clemens, a
resolute, wiry woman of forty-nine, had put together his few
belongings. Then, holding up a little Testament :
“ I want you to take hold of the end of this, Sam,” she said,
“ and make me a promise. I want you to repeat after me these
words : ‘ I do solemnly swear that I will not throw a card, or
drink a drop of liquor while I am gone.’ ” •
It was this oath, repeated after her, that he was keeping
faithfully. The Will Bowen mentioned is a former playmate,
one of Tom Sawyer's outlaw band. He had gone on the river
to learn piloting with an elder brother, the “ Captain.” What
the bad news was is no longer remembered, but it could not
have been very serious, for the Bowen boys remained on the
river for many years. “ Ella ” was Samuel Clemens’s cousin
n LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
* • ^
and one-time sweetheart, Ella Creel. “ Jim " was Jim Wolfe,
an apprentice in Orion’s office, and the hero of an adventure
which long after Mark Twain wrote under the title of
Wolfe and the Cats.” , , , . _ ,
He was working in the printing-office of John A. Gray ano
Green, on Cliff Street, and remained there through the summo,
He must have written more than once during this period, but
the next existing letter— also to Sister Pamela— was written in
October.
To Mrs. Moffett, in St. Louis :
New York . . . , Oct. Saturday 53.
My dear Sister, — I have not written to any of the
family for some time, from the fact, firstly , that I didn’t
know where they were, and secondly, because I have been
fooling myself with the idea that I was going to leave
New York every day for the last two weeks. I have
taken a liking to the abominable place, and every time
I get ready to leave, I put it off a day or so, from some
unaccountable cause. It is as hard on my conscience to
leave New York, as it was easy to leave Hannibal. I
think I shall get off Tuesday, though.
Edwin Forrest has been playing, for the last sixteen
days, at the Broadway Theatre, but I never went to see
him till last night. The play was the “ Gladiator.” I did
not like parts of it much, but other portions were
really splendid. In the latter part of the last act, where
the “ Gladiator ” (Forrest) dies at his brother’s feet, (in
all the fierce pleasure of gratified revenge,) the man’s
whole soul seems absorbed in the part he is playing ; and
it is really startling to see him. I am sorry I did not see
him play “Damon andPythias” — the former character being
his greatest. He appears in Philadelphia on Monday
night.
I have not received a letter from home lately, but got
a “ Journal ” the other day, in which I see the office has
been sold. I suppose Ma, Orion and Henry are in St.
Louis now. If Orion has no other project in his head,
AMERICAN SOLDIERY ' 88
. ne ougttt to take the contract for getting out some weekly
paper, if he cannot get a foremanship. Now, for such a
paper a# the “ Presbyterian ” (containing about 60,000,) 1
he could get $20 or $25 per week, and he and Henxy could
easil^ do the work ; nothing to do but set the type and
make up the forms. . . .
If toy betters do not come often, you need not bother
yourself about me; for if you have a brother nearly
eighteen years of age, who is not able to take care of
himseli a few miles from home, such a brother is not worth
one’s thoughts : and if I don’t manage to take care of
No. 1, be assured you will never know it. I am not afraid,
however ; I shall ask favors from no one, and endeavor to
be (and shall be) as “ independent as a wood-sawyer’s clerk.”
I never saw such a place for military companies as
New York. Go on the street when you will, you are sure
to meet a eoinpany in ‘full uniform, with all the usual
appendages of drums, fifes, &c. I saw a large company of
soldiers of 1812 the other day, with a ’76 veteran scattered
here and there in the ranks. And as I passed through one
of the parks lately, I came upon a company of boys on
parade. Their uniforms were neat, and their muskets
about half the common size. Some of them were not
more than seven or eight years of age ; but had evidently
been well-drilled.
Passage to Albany (160 miles) on the finest steamers
that ply the Hudson, is now 25 cents — cheap enough, but
is generally cheaper than that in the summer.
I want you to write as soon as I tell you where to direct
your letter. 1 would let you know now, if I knew myself.
I may perhaps be here a week longer ; but; I cannot tell.
When you write tell me the whereabouts of the family.
My love to Mr. Moffett and Ella. Tell Ella I intend to
write to her soon, whether she wants me to nor not
Truly your Brother,
Saml L. Clemens.
* Sixty thousand ems, type measurement.
24 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
He was in Philadelphia when he wrote the next letter. It .
is to Orion Clemens, who had disposed of his paper, but evidently
was still in Hannibal. An extended description of & trip to
Fairmount Park is omifted because of its length, its chief
interest being the tendency it shows to descriptive writing—
the field in which he would make his first great fame. Thkre is,
however, no hint of humour, and only a mild suggestion of
the author of the Innocents Jbroad in this early attempt. T l -
letter as here given is otherwise complete, the omissions being
indicated.
To Orion Clemens, in Hannibal :
Philadelphia, Pa. Oct. 26, 1853.
My dear Brother, — It was at least two weeks before
I left New York, that I received my last letter from home :
and since then, not a word have I heard from any of you.
And now, since I think of it, it wasn’t a letter, either, but
the last number of the “ Daily Journal,” saying that that
paper was sold, and I very naturally supposed from that,
that the family had disbanded, and taken up winter
quarters in St. Louis. Therefore, I have been writing to
Pamela, till I’ve tired of it, and have received no answer.
I have been writing for the last two or three weeks, to
send Ma some money, but devil take me if I knew where
she was, and so the money has slipped out of my pocket
somehow or other, but I have a dollar left, and a good
deal owing to me, which will be paid next Monday. I
shall enclose the dollar in this letter, and you can hand it
to her. 1 know it’s a small amount, but then it will buy
her a handkerchief, and at the same time serve as a specimen
of the kind of stuff we are paid with in Philadelphia,
ior you see it*s against the law, in Pennsylvania, to keep
or pass a bill of less denomination than $5. I have only
seen two or three bank bills since I have been in the State.
On Monday the hands are paid off in sparkling gold,
fresh from the Mint ; so your dreams are not troubled
with the fear of having doubtful money in your pocket.
25
SEEKING A LIVELIHOOD
I afh subbing at the Inquirer office. One man has
engaged me to work for him every Sunday till the first of
next Ajfril, (when I shall return home to take Ma to Ky. ;)
and another has engaged my services for the 24th of
nexl? month ; and if I want it, I can get subbing every
night of the week. 1 go to work at 7 o’clock in the evening,
and wdfck* till 8 o’clock the next morning. I con go to the
theatre and stay till 12 o’clock and then go to the office,
and get work from that till 8 the next morning ; when I
go to bed, and sleep till 11 o’clock, then get up and loaf
the rest* of the day. The type is mostly agate and minion,
with some bourgeois ; and when one gets a good agate
take, 1 he is sure to make money. I made $2.50 last
Sunday, and was laughed at by all the hands, the
poorest of whom sets 11,000 on Sunday ; and if I
don’t set 10,000, at least, next Sunday, I’ll give them
leave to laugh as much as they want to. Out of the
22 compositors in this office, 12 at least, set 15,000 on
Sunday.
Unlike New York, I like this Philadelphia amazingly,
and the people in it. There is only one thing that gets
my “ dander ” up — and that is the hands arc always en-
couraging me : telling me — “ it’s no use to get discouraged
— no use to be down-hearted, for there is more work here
than you can do ! ” “ Down-hearted,” the devil 1 I have
not had a particle of such a feeling since I left Hannibal,
more than four months ago. I fancy they'll have to wait
some time till they see me down-hearted or afraid of
starvi g while I have strength to work and am in a city
of 400,000 inhabitants. When I was in Hannibal, before
I had scarcely stepped out of the town ^limits, nothing
could have convinced me that I would starve as soon as
1 got a little way from home. . . .
The grave of Franklin is in Christ Chureh-yard, cor.
of Fifth and Arch streets. They keep the gates locked,
1 “ Agate,*' “minion,” etc., sizes of type; “take,” a piece of work,*
Type measurement is by ems, meaning the width of the letter m.
20 LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
and one can only see the flat slab that lies over his remains
and that of his wife ; but you cannot see the inscription
distinctly enough to read it. The inscription, 1 *believe,
reads thus :
6 Benjamin \
and >■ Franklin ”
Deborah J
I counted 27 cannons (6 pounders) planted in the edge
of the sidewalk in Water St. the other day. They are
driven into the ground, about a foot, with the month end
upwards. A ball is driven fast into the mouth of each,
to exclude the water ; they look like so many posts. They
were put there during the war. I have also seen them
planted in this manner, round the old churches, in N. Y. . . .
There is one fine custom observed in Phila. A gentle-
man is always expected to hand up a lady’s money for
her. Yesterday, I sat in the front end of the ’bus, directly
under the driver s box — a lady sat opposite me. She
handed me her money, which was right. But, Lord ! a
St. Louis lady would think herself ruined, if she should
be so familiar with a stranger. In St. Louis a man will
sit in the front end of the stage, and see a lady stagger
from the far end, to pay her fare. The Phila. ’bus drivers
cannot cheat. In front of the stage is a thing like an
office clock, with figures from 0 to 40, marked on its face.
When the stage starts, the hand of the clock is turned
towards the 0. When you get in and pay your fare, the
driver strikes a bell, and the hand moves to the figure 1
— that is, “ one fare, and paid for,” and there is your
receipt, as good as if you had it in your pocket. When a
passenger pays*his fare and the driver does not strike the
bell immediately, he is greeted “ Strike that bell ! will you ? ’
I must dose now. I intend visiting the Navy Yard,
Mint, etc., before I write again. You must write often*
You see 1 have nothing to write interesting to you, while
you can write nothing that will not interest me. Don’t
PRINTING AT KEOKUK
27
say my letters are not long enough. Tell Jim Wolfe to
write. Tell all the boys where I am, and to write. Jim
Robinson, particularly. I wrote lo him from N. Y. Tell
me gll that is going on in H — 1.
Truly your Brother
Sam.
0
“ if— l 99 is his abbreviation for Hannibal. The doubtful
money he mentions was the paper issued by private banks,
“ wild cat,” as it was called. He had been paid with it in New
York,' and found it usually at a discount — sometimes even
worthless.
Orion Clemens, on a trip to Keokuk, had casually married
there, and a little later removed his office to that city. He did
not move the paper ; perhaps it did not seem worth while, and
in Keokuk he confined himself to commercial printing. The
Ben Franklin Book and Job Office started with fair prospects.
Ilcnry Clemens and a boy named Dick Hingham were the
assistants, and somewhat later, when brother Sam came up
from St. Louis on a visit, an offer of five dollars a week and
board induced him to remain. Later, when it became in-
creasingly difficult to pay the five dollars, Orion took his brother
into partnership, which perhaps relieved the financial stress,
though the office methods would seem to have left something to
be desired.
To Mrs. Clemens and Mrs . Moffett , in St Louis :
Keokuk, Iowa. June 10th, 1850.
My dear Mother & Sister, — I have nothing to write.
Everything is going on well. The Directory is coming on
finely. I have to work on it occasionally, which I don’t
like a particle. I don’t like to work at too many things
at once. They take Henry and Dick away from me too.
Before we commenced the Directory, I could tell before
breakfast just how much work could be cjone during the
day, and manage accordingly — but now, they throw all
my plans into disorder by taking my hands away from
their work. I have nothing to do with the book — if I
did I would have the two book hands do more work than
they do, or else I would drop it. It is not a mere sup *
position that they do not work fast enough— I know it ;
28
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
4
for yesterday the two book hands were at work all day*
Henry and Dick all the afternoon, on the advertisements,
and they set up five pages and a half— and I set* up two
pages and a quarter of the same matter after supper, night
before last, and I don’t work fast on such things. They
are either excessively slow motioned or very lazy. T am
not getting along well with the job work. I can't work
blindly— without system. I gave Dick a job yesterday,
which I calculated he would set in two hours and I # could
work off in three, and therefore just finish it by supper
time, but he was transferred to the Directory, and the
job, promised this morning, remains untouched. Through
all the great pressure of job work lately, I never before
failed in a promise of the kind.
Your Son
Sam.
Excuse brevity— this is my 3rd letter to-night.
He seems, on the whole, to have been rather happy in
Keokuk. But he had grown dissatisfied, and when one day
some weeks later there fell into Ins hands an account of the
riches of the newly explored regions of the upper Amazon, he
promptly decided to find his fortune at the headwaters of the
great South-Amenean river. The second letter reports this
momentous decision. It was written to Henry Clemens, who
was temporarily abs nt — probably m Hannibal.
To Henry Clemens :
Keokuk, August 5th, ’50.
My dear Brother, — . , . Ward and I held a long con-
sultation, Sunday morning, and the result was that we
two have determined to start to Brazil, if possible, in
. h weeks from now, in order to look carefully into matters
there and report to Dr. Martin in time for him to follow
on the first of March. We propose going via New York.
Now, between you and J and the fence you must say
nothing about this to Orion, for he thinks that Ward is
to go clear through alone, and that I am to stop at New
York or New Orleans until he reports. But that don’t
AMAZON PROJECT 29
suit me! My confidence in human nature does not extend
quite that far. I won’t depend upon Ward’s judgment,
or anybody’s else — I want to see -with my own eyes, and
form my own opinion. But you know what Orion is.
When he gets a notion into his head, and more especially
if it is an erroneous one, the Devil can’t get it out again.
So I know better than to combat his arguments long, but
apparently yielded, inwardly determined to go clear
through. Ma knows my determination, but even she
counsels me to keep it from Orion. She says I can treat
him as T did her when I started to St. Louis and went to
New York — 1 can start to Now York and go to South
America 1 Although Orion talks grandly about furnishing
me with fifty or a hundred dollars in six weeks, I could
not depend upon him for ten dollars, so I have “ feelers ”
out in several directions, and have already asked for a
hundred dollars from one source (keep it to yourself.)
I will lay on my oars for awhile, and see how the wind
sets, when I may probably try to get more. Mrs. Creel
is a great friend of mine, and has some influence with
Ma and Orion, though 1 reckon they would not acknow-
ledge it. I am going up there tomorrow, to press her into
my service. I shall take care that Ma and Orion arc
plentifully supplied with South American books. They
have Herndon’s Report now. Ward and the Dr. and
myself will hold a grand consultation tonight at the office.
We have agreed that no more shall be admitted into our
company.
I believe the Guards went down to Quincy today to
escort our first locomotive home.
Write soon.
Your Brother,
Sam.
Readers familiar with the life of Mark Twain know that
none of the would-be adventurers found their way to the
Amazon. His two associates gave up the plan, probably for
lack of means. Young Clemens himself found a fifty-dollar bill
80
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
one bleak November day blowing along the streets of 4Ceokuk,
and after duly advertising his find without result, set out for
the Amazon, by way of Cincinnati and New Orleans .
“I advertised ihe find and left for the Amazon the same
day/* he onee declared, a statement which we may take with
a literary discount. *
He remained in Cincinnati that winter (1856-57) working at
his trade. In April he took up once more the journey toward
South America, but presently forgot the Amazon altogether in
the new career that opened to him. All through his boyhood
and youth Samuel Clemens had wanted to be a pilot. Now
came the long-deferred opportunity. On the little Cincinnati
steamer, the Paul Jones , there was a pilot named Horace Bixby.
Young Clemens idling in the pilot-house was one morning seized
with the old ambition, and laid siege to Bixby to teach him the
river. The terms finally agreed upon specified a fee to Bixby
of five hundred dollars, one hundred down, the balance when the
pupil had completed the course and was earning money. But
all this has been told in full elsewhere, and is only summarized
here because the letters fail to complete the story.
Bixby soon made some trips up the Missouri River, and in
his absence turned hi* apprentice, or “ cub,” over to other
pilots, such being the river custom. Young Clemens, in love
with the life, and a favourite with his superiors, had a happy
time until he came under a pilot named Brown. Brown was
illiterate and tyrannical, and from the beginning of their
association pilot and apprentice disliked each other cordially.
It is at this point that the letters begin once more — the first
having been written when young Clemens, now twenty-two
years old, had been on the river nearly a year.
To Orion Clemens and Wife , in Keokuk , Iowa :
Samt Louis, March 9th, 1858.
Dear Brother and Sister, — I must take advantage
of the opportunity now presented to write you, but I shall
necessarily be dull, as I feel uncommonly stupid. We
have had a hard trip this time. Left Saint Louis three
weeks ago on the Pennsylvania. The weather was very
cold, and the ice running densely. We got 15 miles below
town, landed the boat, and then one pilot. Second Mate
and four deck hands took the sounding boat and shoved
out in the ice to hunt the channel. They failed to find it.
FOOTING ON THE MISSISSIPPI
31
and th<? ice drifted them ashore, 'ftie pilot left the men
with the boat and walked back to us, a mile and a half.
Then the other pilot and myself, with a larger crew of men
started out and met with the same fate. We drifted
ashofe just below the other boat. Then the fun com-
menced. We made fast a line 20 fathoms long, to the
bow of *tl!e yawl, and put the men (both crews) to it like
horses, on the shore. Brown, the pilot, stood in the bow,
with an oar, to keep her head out, and I took the tiller.
We w'ould start the men, and all would go well till the
yawl would bring up on a heavy cake of ice, and then the
men would drop like so many ten-pins, while Brown
assumed the horizontal in the bottom of the boat. After
an hour’s hard work we got back, with ice half an inch
thick on the oars. Sent back and warped up the other
yawl, and then George (the first mentioned pilot,) and
myself, took a»double crew of fresh men and tried it again.
This time wc found the channel in less than half an hour,
and landed on an island till the Pennsylvania came along
and took us off. The next day was colder still. 1 was
out in the yawl twice, and then we got through, but
the infernal steamboat came near running over us. We
went ten miles further, landed, and George and I cleared
out again — found the channel first trial, but got caught
in the gorge and drifted helplessly down the river. The
Ocean Spray came along and started into the ice after
us, but although she didn’t succeed in her kind intention
of taking xis aboard, her waves washed us out, and that
was all we wanted. We landed on an island, built a
big fire and waited for the boat. She started, and ran
aground ! It commenced raining and sleeting, and a
very interesting time we had on that barren sandbar
for the next four hours, when the boat got off and took us
aboard. The next day was terribly cold. We sounded
Hat Island, warped up around a bar and sounded again —
but in order to understand our situation you will have
to read Dr. Kane. It would have been impossible to
32
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
get back to the boat. * But the Maria Denning was aground
at the head of the island — they hailed us — we ran along-
side and they hoisted us in and thawed us out. *We had
then been out in the yawl from 4 o’clock in the morning till
half past 9 without being near a fire. There was a 'ithick
coating of ice over men, yawl, ropes and everything else,
and we looked like rock-candy statuary. We got to
Saint Louis this morning, after an absence of 3 weeks —
that boat generally makes the trip in 2.
Henry was doing little or nothing here, and I sent him
to our clerk to work his way for a trip, by measuring
wood piles, counting coal boxes, and other clerkly duties,
whieh he performed satisfactorily. He may go down with
us again, for I expect he likes our bill of fare better than
that of his boarding house. . . .
I got here too late to see the funeral of the 10 victims
by the burning of the Pacific hotel in 7th street. Ma says
there were 10 hearses, with the fire companies (their
engines in mourning — firemen in uniform,) the various
benevolent societies in uniform and mourning, and a
multitude of citizens and strangers, forming, altogether,
a procession of 30,000 persons ! One steam fire engine was
drawn by four white horses, with crape festoons on their
heads.
Well, I am — just — about — asleep —
Your brother
Sam.
The Doctor Kane of this letter is, of course, Dr. Elisha Kent
Kane, the American Arctic explorer. Any book of exploration
always appealed to Mark Twain, and in those days Kane was a
fa\ ounte.
The paragrftph concerning Henry, and his employment on
the Pennsylvania, begins the story of a tragedy. Henry, a
gentle, faithful boy, shared with his brother the enmity of the
pilot Brown. Some two months following the date of the
fort going It ttcr, on a down trip of the Pennsylvania , an unpro-
voked attack made by Brown upon the boy brought his brother
Sam to the rescue. Brown received a good pummelling at the
DEATH OF HENRY CLEMENS
88
hands of the future humorist, who, though upheld by the
captain, decided to quit the Pennsylvania at New Orleans and
to come up the river by another boat. The Brown episode has
no special bearing on the main tragedy, though now in retro-
spect jt seems closely related to it. Samuel Clemens, coming
up the river on the A. T. Lacey, two days behind the Pennsyl-
vania, heard a voice shout as they approached the Greenville,
Mississippi, ‘landing :
“ The Pennsylvania is blown up just below Memphis, at Ship
Island ! One hundred and fifty lives lost 1 ”
It was a true report. At six o’clock of a warm, mid- June
morning, while loading wood, sixty miles below Memphis, the
Pennsylvania’s boilers had exploded with fearful results. Henry
Clemens was among the injured. lie was still alive when his
brother reached Memphis on the Lacey, but died a few days
later. Samuel Clemens had idolized the boy, and regarded
himself responsible for his death. The letter that follows shows
that he was overwrought by the scenes about him and the
strain of watching, yet the anguish of it is none the less real.
•
To Mrs. Orion Clemens :
Memphis, Term., Friday, June 18th, 1858.
Dear Sister Mollie, —Long before this reaches you,
my poor Henry — my darling, my pride, my glory, my
all, will have finished his blameless career, and the light
of my life will have gone out in utter darkness’. (O, God 1
this is hard to bear.) Hardened, hopeless, —aye, lost —
lost — lost and ruined sinner as I am — I, evtn I, have
humbled myself to the ground and prayed as never man
prayed before, that the great God might let this cup
pass from me — that he would strike me to the earth, but
spare my brother — that he would pour out the fulness of
his just wrath upon my wicked head, but have mercy,
mercy, mercy upon that unoffending boy. f The horrors
of three days have swept over me — they have blasted
my youth and left me an old man before my time. Mollie,
there are gray hairs in my head tonight. For forty-
eight hours I labored at the bedside of my poor burned
and bruised, but uncomplaining brother, and then the
star of my hope went out and left mo in the gloom of
84
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
despair. Men take me by the hand and congratulate me,
and call me “ lucky ” because I was not on the Pennsyl-
vania when she blew up 1 May God forgive them, for
they know not what they say.
Mollie you do not understand why I was not on that
boat — I will tell you. I left Saint Louis on her, but on
the way down, Mr. Brown, the pilot that was 'kill i J by
the explosion (poor fellow,) quarreled with Henry without
cause, while I was steering. Henry started out t of the
pilot-house — Brown jumped up and collared him — turned
him half way around and struck him in the face /—and him
nearly six feet high- -struck my little brother. I was wild
from that moment. I left the boat to steer herself, and
avenged the insult — and the Captain said I was right —
that he would discharge Brown in N. Orleans if he could
get another pilot, and would do it in St. Louis, anyhow.
Of course both of us could not return to St. Louis on the
same boat — -no pilot could be found, and the Captain
sent me to the A. T. Lacey, with orders to her Captain
to bring me to Saint Louis. Had another pilot been
found, poor Brown would have been the “ lucky ” man.
I was on the Pennsylvania five minutes before she left
N. Orleans, and I must tell you the truth, Mollie — three
hundred human beings perished by that fearful disaster.
Henry was asleep — was blown up — then fell back on the
hot boilers, and I suppose that rubbish fell on him, for
he is injured internally. He got into the water and swam
to shore, and got into the flatboat with the other sur-
vivors. 1 He had nothing on but his wet shirt, and he lay
there burning up with a southern sun and freezing in the
wind till th« Kate Frisbee came along. His wounds were
not dressed till he got to Memphis, 15 hours after the
explosion. He was senseless and motionless for 12 hours
after that. But may God bless Memphis, the noblest
city on the face of the earth. She has done her duty
1 Henry had returned once to the Pennsylvania to render assistance to
the passengers. Later he had -somehow made his way to the lifeboat.
FRATERNAL AFFECTION 85
*
by these poor afflicted creatures — especially Henry, for
he has had five — aye, ten, fifteen, twenty times the care
and attention that any one else has had. Dr. Peyton, the
best physician in Memphis (he is exactly like the portraits
of Webster,) sat by him for 80 hours. There are 82
scalded men in that room, and you would know I)r.
Peyton Hot ter than I can describe him, if you could follow
him around and hear each man murmur as he passes —
“ May t the God of Heaven bless you. Doctor ! ” The
ladies have done well, too. Our second Mate, a handsome,
noble hearted young fellow, will die. Yesterday a
beautiful girl of 15 stooped timidly down by his side and
handed him a pretty bouquet. The poor suffering boy’s
eyes kindled, his lips quivered out a gentle “ God bless
you, Miss,” and he burst into tears. lie made them
write her name on a card for him, that he might not
forget it.
Pray for me, Mollie, and pray for my poor sinless
brother.
Your unfortunate Brother,
Saml. L. Clemens.
P. S. 1 got here two days after Henry.
It is said that Mark Twain never really recovered from the
tragedy of his brother’s death. He went back to the river, and
in September of the same year, after an apprenticeship of less
than eighteen months, received his licence as a St. Louis and
New Orleans pilot, and was accepted by his old chief, Bixby,
as full partner on an important boat. In Life on the Mississippi
Mark Twain makes the period of his study from two t > two
and a half years, but this is merely an attempt to magnify his
dullness. He was, in fact, an apt pupil and a pilot of very high
class. •
Clemeus was now suddenly lifted to a position of importance.
The Mississippi River pilot of those days was a person of dis-
tinction, earning a salary then regarded as princely. Certainly
two hundred and fifty dollars a month was large for a boy of
twenty-three. At once, of course, he became t lie head of the
Clemens family. His brother Orion was ten years older, but
he had not the gift of success. By common consent the younger
36 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
brother assumed permanently the position of family eounsdloi
and financier. Wecxpecthim to feel the importance of his nev
position, and he is too human to disappoint US. Incidentally,
we notice an improvement in his English. lie no longer writes
“ between you and I.”
Fragment of a letter to Orion Clemens. Written at St.
Louis in 1859 :
... I am not talking nonsense, now — I am in earnest,
I want you to keep your troubles and your plans out of
the reach of meddlers, until the latter are consummated,
so that in case you fail, no one will know it but yourself.
Above all things (between you and me) never tell Ma
any of your troubles ; she never slept a wink the night
your last letter came, and she looks distressed yet. Write
only cheerful news to her. You know that she will not
be satisfied so long as she thinks anything is going on
that she is ignorant of — and she makes a little fuss about
it when her suspicions arc awakened ; but that makes
no difference — I know that it is better that she be kept
in the dark concerning all things of an unpleasant nature.
She upbraids me occasionally for giving her only the
bright side of my affairs (but unfortunately for her she
has to put up with it, for 1 know that troubles that I
curse awhile and forget, would disturb her slumbers for
some time.) (Parenthesis No. 2 — Possibly because she
is deprived of the soothing consolation of swearing.) Tell
her the good news and me the bad.
Putting all things together, I begin to think I am rather
lucky than otherwise — a notion which I was slow to take
up. The other night I was about to round to for a storm
—but concluded that 1 could find a smoother bank some-
where. I landed 5 miles below. The storm came — passed
away and did not injure us. Coming up, day before
yesterday, I looked at the spot I first chose, and half the
trees on the bank were tom to shreds. We couldn’t have
lived 5 minutes in such a tornado. And I am also lucky
A SUCCESSFUL PILOT
37
m having a berth, while all the young pilots are idle. This
is the luckiest circumstance that ever befell me. Not on
account of the wages — for that is a secondary considera-
tion— but from the fact that the City of Memphis is
the largest boat in the trade and the hardest to pilot,
and consequently I can get a reputation on her, which
is a thin£ I never could accomplish on a transient boat.
I can “ bank ” in the neighbourhood of $100 a month on
her, and that will satisfy me for the present (principally
because the other youngsters are sucking their fingers .)
Bless mcl what a pleasure there is in revenge ! and what
vast respect Prosperity commands ! Why, six months
ago I could enter the “ Rooms,” and receive only a cus-
tomary fraternal greeting — but now they say, “ Why,
how are you, old fellow — when did you get in ? ”
And the young pilots who used to tell me, patronizingly,
that I could never learn’ the river cannot keep from show-
ing a little of their chagrin at seeing me so far ahead of
them. Permit me to “ blow my horn,” for 1 derive a
living pleasure from these things, and I must confess that
when I go to pay my dues, I rather like to let the d— d
rascals get a glimpse of a hundred dollar bill peeping out
from amongst notes of smaller dimensions, whose face
I do not exhibit ! You will despise this egotism, but I
tell you there is a “ stern joy ” in it. . . .
The clairvoyant of the following letter was Madame Caprcll,
famous in her day. Clemens had been urged to consult her,
and one idle afternoon concluded to make the experiment.
The letter reporting the matter to his brother is fragmentary,
and is the last remaining to us of the piloting period.
Fragment of a letter to Orion Clemens, in Keokuk , Iowa:
Now Orleans February 6, 1861.
. . . She’s a very pleasant little lady — rather pretty
— about 28, — say 5 feet 2 and one quarter — would
38 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
t
weigh 116— has black eyes and hair— is polite and
intelligent— used good language, and talks much faster
than I do.
She invited me into the little back parlor, closed the
door; and we were alone. We sat down facing each
other. Then she asked my age. Then she put her hands
before her eyes a moment, and commenced talking as if
she had a good deal to say and not much time to say
it in. Something after this style :
Madame. Yours is a watery planet ; you gain your
livelihood on the water ; but you should have been a
lawyer — there is where your talents lie : you might have
distinguished yourself as an orator, or as an editor ;
you have written a great deal ; you write well — but you
are rather out of practice ; no matter — you will be in
practice some day ; you have a superb constitution, and
as excellent health as any man in the world ; you have
great power-, of endurance ; in your profession your
strength holds out against the longest sieges without
flagging ; still, the upper part of your lungs, the top of
them is slightly affected — you must take care of your-
self ; you do not drink, but you use entirely too much
tobacco ; and you must stop it ; mind, not moderate,
but stop the use of it totally ; then I can almost promise
you 86 when you will surely die ; otherwise look out for
28, 81, 84, 47, and 65 ; be careful — for you are not of a
long-lived race, that is on your father’s side ; you arc the
only healthy member of your family, and the only one
in it who has anything like the certainty of attaining to
a great age — so, stop using tobacco, and be careful of
yourself. . , 4 . In some respects you take after your father,
but you are much more like your mother, who belongs to
the long-lived, energetic side of the house. . . . You never
broughi all your energies to bear upon any subject but
what you accomplished it — for instance, you are self-
made, self-educated.
S. L. C. Which proves nothing.
A CLAIRVOYANT
89
Madame! Don’t interrupt. When you sought your
present occupation you found a thousand obstacles in the
way — obs*taclcs unknown — not even suspected by any
save you and me, since you keep such matters to your-
self — but you fought your way, and hid the long struggle
under a mask of cheerfulness, which saved your friends
anxiety bn your account. To do all this requires all the
qualities I have named.
S. L. C. You flatter well, Madame.
I
Madame. Don’t interrupt. Up to within a short time
you ha<f always lived from hand to mouth — now you
are in easy circumstances — for which you need give credit
to no one but yourself. The turning point in your life
occurred in 1840-7-8.
S. L. C. Which was ?
Madame. A death perhaps, and this threw you upon the
world and made you what you arc ; it was always in-
tended that you should make yourself ; therefore, it was
well that this calamity occurred as early as it did. You
will never die of water, although your career upon it in
the future seems well sprinkled with misfortune. You
will continue upon the w ater for some time yet ; you will
not retire finally until ten years from now. . . . What is
your brother’s age ? 35 — and a lawyer ? and in pursuit
of an office ? Well, he stands a better chance than the
other two, and he may get it ; he is too visionary — is
always flying off on a new hobby ; this will never do —
tell him 1 said so. He is a good lawyer— a very good lawyer
— and a fine speaker — is very popular and much respected,
and makes many friends ; but although he retains their
friendship, he loses their confidence by displaying his
instability of character. . . . The land he has now will be
very valuable after a while —
S. L. C. Say 250 years hence, or thereabouts. Madame —
Mad ame . No — less time — but never mind the land, that
is a secondary consideration — let him drop that for the
present, and devote himself to his business and politics
40 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
t
with all his might, for he must hold offices uhder the
Government. ...
After a while you will possess a good deal of property
— retire at the end of ten yearn — after which your pur-
suits will be literary — try the law — you will certainly
succeed. I am done now. If you have any questions to
ask — ask them freely — and if it be in my powcS.% I will
answer without reserve — without reserve.
I asked a few questions of minor importance — paid her
$2 — and left, under the decided impression that going to
the fortune teller’s was just as good as going to the opera,
and the cost scarcely a trifle more — ergo, 1 will disguise
myself and go again, one of these days, when other
amusements fail. Now isn’t she the devil ? That is to
say, isn’t she a right smart little woman ?
When you want money, let Ma know, and she will
send it. She and Pamela are always ' fussing about
change, so I sent them a hundred and twenty quarters
yesterday — fiddler’s change enough to last till 1 get back,
I reckon. Sam.
A little more than two months after the Caprell letter was
written Fort Sumter was fired upon. Mark Twain had made
his last trip as a pilot up the river to St. Louis — the nation was
plunged into a four years’ conflict.
There are no letters of this immediate period. Young
Clemens went to Hannibal, and enlisting in a private company,
composed mainly of old schoolmates, went soldiering for two
rainy, inglorious weeks, by the end of which he had had enough
of war, and furthermore had discovered that he was more of a
Union abolitionist than a slave-holding secessionist, as he had
at first supposed. Convictions were likely to be rather infirm
during those early days of the war, and subject to change
without notiea. Especially was this so in a border State.
Clemens went from the battle-front to Keokuk, where Orion
was preparing to accept the appointment prophesied by Madame
Caprell. Orion was a staunch Unionist, and a member of
Lincoln’.". Cabinet had offered him the secretaryship of the new
Territory of Nevada. Orion had accepted, and only needed
funds to carry him to his destination. Ilis pilot brother had
the funds, and upon being appointed “ private ” secretary,
NEVADA
41
agreed ttf pay both passages on the overland stage, which would
bear them across the great plains from St. Jo to Carson City.
Mark Twain, in Roughing It, has described that glorious journey
and the frontier life that followed it llis letters form a sup-
plement of realism to a talc that is more or less fictitious , though
marvellously true in colour and background,
■
Part of a letter to Mrs. Jane Clemens, in St. Louis:
(Date not given, but Sopt. or Oct., 1861.)
Mv Dear Mother, — I hope you will all come out here
someday. But I shan’t consent to invite you, until we
can receive you in style. But I guess we shall be able to
do that, one o£ these days. I intend that Pamela shall
live on Lake Bigler until she can knock a bull down with
her fist — say, about three months.
“ Tell everything as it is — no betti r, and no worse.”
Well, “ Gold Hill ” sells at $5,000 per foot, cash down ;
“ Wild cat ” isn’t worth ten ct nts. The country is fabu-
lously rich in gold, silver, copper, lead, coal, iron, quick-
silver, marble, granite, chalk, plaster of Paris, (gypsum,)
thieves, murderers, desperadoes, ladies, children, lawyers,
Christians, Indians, Chinamen, Spaniards, gamblers,
sharpers, coyotes (pronounced Ki-yo-ties,) poets, preachers,
and jackass rabbits. I overheard a gentleman say,
the other day, that it was “ the d — dcst country under
the sun ” — and that comprehensive conception I fully
subscribe to. It never rains here, and the dew never
falls. No flowers grow here, and no green thing gladdens
the eye. The birds that fly over the land carry their
provisions with them. Only the crow and the raven
tarry with us. Our city lies in the midst ^of a desert of
the purest — most unadulterated, and uncompromising sand
— in which infernal soil nothing but that fag-end of vege-
table creation, “ sage-brush,” ventures to grow. If you
will take a lilliputian cedar tree for a model, and build
a dozen imitations of it with the stiffest article of telegraph
wire— set them one foot apart and then try to walk
42
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
through them, you’ll understand (provided the 'floor is
covered 12 niches deep with sand,) what it is to wander
through a sage-brush desert. When crushed, sage-brush
emits an odor which isn’t exactly magnolia and equally
isn’t exactly polecat — but it a sort of compromise between
the two. It looks a good deal like grease-wood, and is the
ugliest plant that was ever conceived of. It is in
color. On the plains, sage-brush and grease-wood grow
about twice as large as the common geranium — and in
my opinion they arc a very good substitute for that use-
less vegetable. Grease-wood is a perfect — most perfect
imitation in miniature of a live oak tree — barring the color
of it. As to the other fruits and flowers of the countxy,
there ain’t any, except “ Pulu ” or “ Tuler,” or whatever
they call it, — a species of unpoetical willow that grows
on the banks of the Carson — a river, 20 yards wide, knee-
deep, and so villainously rapid and crooked, that it looks
like it had wandered into the country without intending
it, and had run about in a bewildered way and got lost,
in its hurry to get out again before sonic thirsty man came
along and drank it up. I said we are situated in a flat,
sandy desert — true. And surrounded on all sides by
such prodigious mountains, that when you gaze at them
awhile, — and begin to conceive of their grandeur — and
next to feel their vastness expanding your soul — and
ultimately find yourself growing and swelling and spreading
into a giant — I say when this point is reached, you look
disdainfully down upon the insignificant village of Carson,
and in that instant you are seized with a burning desire
to stretch forth your hand, put the city in your pocket,
and walk off with it.
As to churches, I believe they have got a Catholic one
here, but like that one the New York firemen spoke of,
I believe “ they don’t run her now.” Now, although wc
aie surrounded by sand, the greatest part of the town is
built upon what was once a very pretty grassy spot ;
and the streams of pure water that used to poke about it
A FOREST FIRE
4 3
in rural sloth and solitude, now pass through on dusty
streets and gladden the hearts of men by reminding them
that there is at least something here that hath its proto-
type^ among the homes they left behind them. And up
“ King’s Canon,” (please pronounce can-yon, after the
manner of the natives,) there are “ ranches,” or farms,
where they say hay grows, and grass, and beets and
onions, and turnips, and other “ truck ” which is suitable
for cows — yes, and even Irish potatoes ; also, cabbages,
peas and beans.
The houses arc mostly frame, unplastered, but
“ papered ” inside with flour-sacks sewed together, — and
the handsomer the “ brand ” upon the sacks is, the neater
the house looks. Occasionally, you stumble on a stone
house. On account of the dryness of the country, the
shingles on the houses war}) till they look like short joints
of stove pipe split lengthwise.
(Remainder missing.)
There had been no secretary work for him to do, and no pro-
vision for payment. lie found his profit in studying human
nature and in prospecting native resources. He was not in-
terested in mining — not yet. With a boy named John Kinney
he made an excursion to Lake Bigler — now Tahoe — and located
a timber claim, really of great value. They were supposed to
build a fence around it, but they were too full of the enjoyment
of camp-life to complete it. They pul in most of their time
wandering through the stately forest or drifting over the trans-
parent lake in a boat left there by lumbermen. They built
themselves a brush house, but they did not sleep in it. In
Roughing It he v rites, “ It never occurred to us, for one thing ;
and, besides, it was built to hold the ground., and that was
enough. We did not wish to strain it.”
They were having a glorious time, when their camp-fire got
away from them and burned up their claim. »llis next letter,
of which the beginning is missing, describes the fire.
Fragment of a letter to Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett,
in St. Louis :
. . . The level ranks of flame were relieved at intervals
by the standard-bearers, as we called the tall dead trees,
44
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
wrapped in fire, and waving their blazing banners a
hundred feet in the air. Then we could turn from this
scene to the Lake, and see every branch, and leaf, and
cataract of flame upon its bank perfectly reflected as < in a
gleaming, fiery mirror. The mighty roaring of the con-
flagration, together with our solitary and somewhat unsafe
position (for there was no one within six mile’s «of us,)
rendered the scene very impressive. Occasionally, one
of us would remove his pipe from his mouth and say, —
“ Superb ! magnificent ! Beautiful ! — but — by the Lord
God Almighty, if wc attempt to sleep in this little patch
tonight, we’ll never live till morning ! — for if wc don’t
burn up, we’ll certainly suffocate." But he was persuaded
to sit up until we fell pretty safe as far as the fire was
concerned, and then we turned in, with many misgivings.
When we got up in the morning, we found that the fire
had burned small pieces of drift wood within six feet of
our boat, and had made its way to within 4 or 5 steps of
us on the South side. We looked like lava men, covered
as we were with ashes, and begrimed with smoke. We
were very black in the face, but we soon washed ourselves
white again.
John D. Kinney, a Cincinnati boy, and a first-rate
fellow, too, who came out with Judge Turner, was my
comrade. We staid at the Lake four days — I had plenty
of fun, for John constantly reminded me of Sam Bowen
when we were on our campaign in Missouri. But first
and foremost, for Annie's, Mollic’s, and Pamela’s comfort,
be it known that I have never been guilty of profane
language since I have been in this Territory, and Kinney
hardly ever shears. — But sometimes human nature gets
the better of him. On the second day we started to go
by land to the lower camp, a distance of three miles,
over the mountains, each carrying an axe. I don’t think
wc got lost exactly, but we wandered four hours over the
steepest, rockiest and most dangerous piece of country
in the world. I couldn’t keep from laughing at Kinney’s
CAMP-LIFE
45
distress* so I kept behind, so that he could not see me.
After he would get over a dangerous place, with infinite
labor and constant apprehension, he would stop, lean on
his ajee, and look around, then behind, then ahead, and
then drop his head and ruminate awhile. Then he would
draw a long sigh, and say : “ Well — could any Billygoat
have settled that place without breaking his neck ? ”
And I would reply, “ No, — I don’t think he could.” “ No
— you, don’t think he could — ” (mimicking me,) “ Why
don’t you curse the infernal place ? You know you want to.
— I do, and will curse the thieving country as long
as I live.” Then we would toil on in silence for awhile.
Finally I told him — “ Well, John, what if we don't find
our way out of this today — we’ll know all about the
country when we do get out.” “ Oh stuff — I know enough
— and too much about the d — d villainous locality already.”
Finally, wc reached the camp. But as we brought no
provisions with us, the first subject that presented itself
to is was, how to get back. John swore he wouldn’t
walk back, so we rolled a drift log apiece into the Lake
and set about making paddles, intending to straddle the
logs and paddle ourselves back home sometime or other.
But the Lake objected — got stormy, and wc had to give
it up. So wc set out for the only house on this side of the
Lake — three miles from there, down the shore. We found
the way without any trouble, reached there before sun-
down, played three games of cribbage, borrowed a dug-out
and pulled back six miles to the upper camp. As we had
eaten nothing since sunrise, wc did not waste time in
cooking our supper or in eating it, cither. After supper
we got out our pipes — built a rousing capnp fire in the
open air — established a faro bank (an institution of this
country,) on our huge flat granite dining table, and bet
white beans till one o’clock, when John went to bed. We
were up before the sun the next morning, went out on the
Lake and caught a fine trout for breakfast. But unfor-
tunately, I spoilt part of the breakfast. Wc had coffee
40 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
t
and tea boiling on the fire in coffee-pots, and fearing they
might not be strong enough, I added more ground coffee,
and more tea, but — you know mistake? will Happen—
I put the tea in the coffee-pot, and the coffee in the tea-
pot — -and if you imagine that they wore not villainous
mixtures, just try the effect once. . . .
Remember me to all my St. Louis and Kcokuk«fnends,
and tell Challie and Hallie Renson that 1 heard a military
band play “ What are the Wild Waves Saying ? ” the other
night, and it reminded me very forcibly of them. It
brought Ella Creel and Belle across the Desert too in an
instant, for they sang the song in Orion’s yard the first
time I ever heard it. It was like meeting an old friend.
I tell you I could have swallowed that whole band, trom-
bone and all, if such a compliment would have been any
gratification to them.
Love to the young folks,
Sam.
He was beginning to be mildly interested in mining, and,
with his brother Orion, had acquired “ feet ” in an Esmeralda
camp. In his next letter he gives us the size- of this claim,
which he has visited. Ifis interest, however, still appears to
be chiefly in liis timber claim on Lake Bigler (Tahoe), though
we are never to hear of it again idler this letter.
To Mrs. Moffett , in St. Louis :
Carson City, Oct. 25, 1861.
My Dear Sister, — I have just finished reading your
letter and Ma’s of Sept. 8lh. IIow in the world could
they have beei} so long coming ? You ask me if I have for-
gotten my promise to lay a claim for Mr. Moffett. By no
means. I have already laid a timber claim on the borders
of a lake (Bigler) which throws Como in the shade —
and if we succeed in getting one Mr. Jones to move his
saw-mill up there, Mr. Moffett can fust consider that
claim better than bank stock. Jones says he will move
A MINING CLAIM
47
his mill*up next spring. In that claim I took tip about
two miles in length by one in width — and the names in
it arc as follows : “ Sam. L. CIcncns, Wm. A. Moffctl ,
Thos. f Nye ” and three others. It is situated on “ Sam
Clemens Bay ” — so named by Capt. Nye — and it goes
by that name among the inhabitants of that regiou. 1
had better stop about “ the Lake,” though, — for whenever
I think of it I want to go there and die, the place is so
beautiful. I’ll build a country seat there one of these
days that will make the Devil’s mouth water if he ever
visits tfie earth. Jim Lampton will never know whether
I laid a claim there for him or not until he eomes here
himself. We have now got about 1,650 feet of mining
ground — and if it proves good, Mr. Moffett’s name will
go in — if not, I can get “ feet ” for him in the Spring which
will be good. You see, Pamela, the trouble does not con-
sist in getting ‘mining" ground — for that is plenty enough
— but the money to work it with after you get it is the
mischief. When I was in Esmeralda, a young fellow
gave me fifty feet in the “ Black Warrior ” — an unpro-
spected claim. The other day he wrote me that he had
gone down eight feet on the ledge, and found it eight
feet thick — and pretty good rock, too. He said he could
take out rock now if there were a mill to crush it— but the
mills are all engaged (there arc only four of them) so,
if I were willing, he would suspend work until Spring. I
wrote him to let it alone at present — because, you see,
in the Spring I can go down myself and help him look
after it. There will then be twenty mills there. Orion
and I have confidence enough in this country to think
that if the war will let us alone we can make Mr. Moffett
rich without its ever costing him a cent of money or particle
of trouble. We shall lay plenty of claims for him, but if
they never pay him anything, they will never cost him
anything, Orion and I are not financiers. Therefore,
you must persuade*TJnele Jim to come out here and help
us in that line. I have written to him twice to come.
48 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
<
I wrote him today. In both letters I told hiA not to
let you or Ma know that we dealt in such romantic non-
sense as “ brilliant prospects,” because I always did
hate for any one to know what my plans or hopes or
prospects were — for, if I kept people in ignorance in these
matters, no one could be disappointed but myself, if they
were not realized. You know I never told you that I
went on the river under a promise to pay Bixby $500,
until I had paid the money and cleared my skirts of the
possibility of having my judgment criticised. I would
not say anything about our prospects now, if we were
nearer home. Rut 1 suppose at this distance you arc
more anxious than you would be if you saw us every
month — and therefore it is hardly fair to keep you in the
dark. However, keep these matters to yourselves, and
then if we fail, we’ll keep the laugh in the family.
What we want now is something that will commence
paying immediately. We have got a chance to get into
a claim where they say a tunnel has been run 150 feet,
and the ledge struck. I got a horse yesterday, and went
out with the Attorney-General and the claim-owner — and
we tried to go to the claim by a new route, and got lost
in the mountains — sunse t overtook us before we found the
claim — my horse got too lame to carry me, and I got down
and drove him ahead of me till within four miles of town
— then we sent Rice on ahead. Bunker, (whose horse
was in good condition,) undertook to lead mine, and I
followed after him. Darkness shut him out from my view
in less than a minute, and within the next minute I lost
the road and got to wandering in the sage brush. I would
find the road occasionally and then lose it again in a minute
or so. 1 got to Carson about nine o’clock, at night, but
not by the road I traveled when I left it. The General
says mj horse did very well for awhile, but soon refused
to kad. Then he dismounted, and had a jolly time driving
both horses ahead of him anil chasing them here and
there through the sage-brush (it does my soul good when
MINING FEVER
49
I think *of it) until he got to town, when both animals
deserted him, and he cursed them handsomely and
came hohae alone. Of course the horses went to their
stables.
Tell Sammy I will lay a claim for him, and he must
come out and attend to it. lie must get rid of that pro-
pensity fofr tumbling down, though, for when we get fairly
started here, I don’t think we shall have time to pick up
those who fall. . . .
That is Stougliter’s house, I expect, that Cousin Jim
has moVcd into. This is just the country for Cousin
Jim to live in. I don’t believe it would take him six
months to make $100,000 here, if he had 3,000 dollars
to commence with. 1 suppose ho can’t leave his family
though.
Tell Mrs. Benson I never intend to be a lawyer. I
have been a si five several times in my life, but I’ll never
be one again. I always intend to be so situated (unless
I marry,) that I can “ pull up stakes ” and clear out
whenever I feel like it.
We arc very thankful to you, Pamela, for the papers
you send. We have received half a dozen or more, and,
next to letters, they arc* the most welcome visitors we have.
Write ofiencr, Pamela.
Yr. Brother
Sam.
The “ Cousin Jim ” mint toned in this lcttir is the original of
the character of Coloiul Sillers. Whatever Mark Twain’s
later opinion of Cousin Jim Lampton’s financial genius may
have beui, he seenis to have respected it at this time.
More than three months puss until we have another letter,
and in that time the mining fever had bccom£ well seated.
Mark Twain himself was full of the Sellers optimism, and it was
bound to overflow, fortify as he would against it.
lie met with little enough encouragement. With three com-
panions, in midwinter, he made a mining excursion to the much
exploited Humboldt region, returning empty-handed after a
month or two of hard experience. This is the trip picturesquely
described in Chapters XXVII to XXXIII of Houghing It.
50 LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
t
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in St! Louis
Carson City, Fob. 8, 1862.
My dear Mother and Sister, — By George, Pamela, I
begin to fear that I have invoked a Spirit of some* kind
or other which I will find some difficulty in laying. I
wasn’t much terrified by your growing incUnatism, but
when you begin to call presentiments to your aid, I confess
that I “ weaken.” Mr. Moffett is right, as I said before
— and I am not much afraid of his going wrong. Men are
easily dealt with — but when you get the women ‘started,
you are in for it, you know. But I have decided on two
things, viz : Any of you, or all of you, may live in California,
for that is the Garden of Eden reproduced — but you shall
never live in Nevada; and secondly, none of you, save
Mr. Moffett, shall ever cross the Plains. If you were
only going to Pike’s Peak, a little mattdr of 700 miles
from St. Jo, you might take the coach, and I wouldn’t
say a word. But I consider it over 2,000 miles from
St. Jo to Carson, and the first 6 or 800 miles is mere
Fourth of July, compared to the balance of the route.
But Lord bless you, a man enjoys every foot of it. If
you ever come here or to California, it must be by sea.
Mr. Moffett must come by overland coach , though, by
all means. He would consider it the jolliest little trip he
ever took in his life. Either June, July, or August are
the proper months to make the journey in. He could
not suffer from heat, and three or four heavy army blankets
would make the cold nights comfortable. If the coach
were full of passengers, two good blankets would probably
he sufficient.. If he comes, and brings plenty of money,
and fails to invest it to his entire satisfaction, I will
prophesy no more.
But I will tell you a few things which you wouldn’t
have found out if I hadn’t got myself into this scrape. I
expect to return to St, Louis in July — per steamer. I
don’t say that I will return then, or that I shall be able
CASTLES IN SPAIN
51
to do it — but I expect to — you bet. I came down here
from Humboldt, in order to look after our Esmeralda
interests^ and my sore-backed horse and the bad roads
have prevented me from making the journey. Yesterday
one of my old. Esmeralda friends, Bob Howland, arrived
here, and I have had a talk with him. He owns with me
in the ‘^Horatio and Derby ” ledge. lie says our tunnel
is in 52 feet, and a small stream of water has been struck,
which bids fair to become a “ big thing ” by the time the
ledge is reached — sufficient to supply a mill. Now, if
you kntNv anything of the value of water, here, you would
perceive at a glance that if the water should amount to
50 or 100 inches, we wouldn’t care whether school kept
or not. If the ledge should prove to be worthless, we’d
sell the water for money enough to give us quite a lift. But
you set', the ledge will not prove to be worthless. We have
located, near by, a fine site for a mill ; and when we strike
the ledge, you know, we’ll have a mill-site, water power,
and pay-rock, all handy. Then we shan’t care whether
we have capital or not. Mill -folks will build us a mill,
and wait for their pay. If nothing goes wrong, we’ll
strike the ledge in June — and if we do, I’ll be home in
July, you know.
Pamela, don’t you know that undemonstrated human
calculations won’t do to bet on ? Don’t you know that
I have only talked, as yet, but proved nothing ? Don’t
you know that I have expended money in this country
but have made none myself ? Don’t you know that I have
never held in my hands a gold or silver bar that belonged
to me Y Don’t you know that it’s all talk and no cider
so far ? Don’t you know that people wh<j always feel
jolly, no matter where they are or what happens to them
— who have the organ of hope preposterously developed
— who are endowed with an uncongealable sanguine tem-
perament — who never feel concerned about the price of
corn — and who cannot, by any possibility, discover any
but the bright side of a picture — are very apt to go to
52
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
extremes, and exaggerate with 40-horse microscopic*power ?
Of course I never tried to raise these suspicions in your
mind, but then your knowledge of the fact that some
people’s poor frail human nature is a sort of crazy in-
stitution anyhow, ought to have suggested them to* you.
Now, if I hadn’t thoughtlessly got you into the notion
of coming out here, and thereby got myself into* % sc^pe,
I wouldn’t have given you that highly-coloured paragraph
about the mill, etc., because, you know, if that pretty
little picture should fail, and wash out, and go the' Devil
generally, it wouldn’t cost me the loss of an hour's sleep,
but you fellows would be so much distressed on my account
as I could possibly be if “ circumstances beyond my
control ” -were to prevent my being present at my own
funeral. But — but —
“ In the bright lexicon of youth,
There’s no such word as Fail — ”
and I’ll prove it
And look here. I came near forgetting it. Don’t you
say a word to me about “ trains ” across the plains.
Because I am down on that arrangement. That sort of
thing is “ played out,” you know. The Overland Coach
or the Mail Steamer is the thing.
You want to know something about the route between
California and Nevada Territory ? Suppose you take my
word for it, that it is exceedingly jolly. Or take, for a
winter view, J. Ross Brown’s picture, in Harper’s Monthly,
of pack mules tumbling fifteen hundred feet down the side
of a mountain. Why bless you, there’s scenery on that
route. You can stand on some of those noble peaks and
see Jerusalenj and the Holy Land. And you can start
a boulder, and send it tearing up the earth and crashing over
trees — down — down — down — to the very devil, Madam.
And you would probably stand up there and look, and
stare and wonder at the magnificence spread out before
you till you starved to death, if let alone. But you should
take someone along to keep you moving. . . .
NAMING BABIES 53
Since wo have been here there has not been a fire —
although the houses are built of wood. They “ holler ”
fire sometimes, though, but I am always too late to see
the dunoke before the fire is out, if they ever have any.
Now they raised a yell here in front of the office a moment
ago. I # put away my papers, and locked up everything
of value, and changed my boots, and pulled off my coat,
and went and got a bucket of water, and came back to
sec what the matter was, remarking to myself, “ I guess
I’ll be on hand this time, any way.” But I met a friend on
the pavement, and he said, “ Where you been ? Fire’s
out half an hour ago.”
Ma says Axtele was above “ suspition ” — but I have
searched through Webster’s Unabridged, and can’t find
the word. However, it’s of no consequence — J hope he
got down safely. I knew Axtele and his wife as well as I
know Dan Ilaines. Mrs. A. once tried to embarrass me
in the presence of company by asking me to name her
baby, when she was well aware that I didn’t know the
sex of that Phenomenon. But I told her to call it Frances,
and spell it to suit herself. That was about nine years
ago, and Axtele had no property, and could hardly sup-
port Iris family by his earnings, lie was a pious cuss,
though. Member of Margaret Sexton’s Church.
And Ma says “ it looks like a man can’t hold public
office and be honest.” Why, certainly not. Madam. A
man can't hold public office and be honest. Lord bless
you, it is a common practice with Orion to go about town
stealing little things that happen to be lying around
loose. And I don’t remember having heard him speak the
truth since we have been in Nevada. He even tries to
prevail upon me to do these things, Ma, but I wasn’t
brought up in that way, you know. You showed the
public what you eould do in that line when you raised me,
Madam. But then you ought to have raised me first,
so that Orion eould have had the benefit of my example.
Do you, know that he stole all the stamps out of an 8-stamp
5 4
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
4
quartz mill one night, and brought them home under his
over-coat and hid them in the back room ?
Yrs. etc.,
Sam.
A little later he had headed for the Esmeralda Ilills. Some
time in February he was established there in a effrry) with a
young man by the name of Horatio Phillips (Itaish). Later
he eamped with Bob Howland, who, as City Marshal of Aurora,
bceame known as the most fearless man in the Territory, and,
still later, with Calvin II. Iligbie (Cal), to whom Roughing It
would one day be dedieated. His own funds were exhausted
by this time, and Orion, with his rather slender salary, became
the financial partner of the firm.
There is too much of a sameness in the letters of this period
to use all of them. There are always new claims, and work done,
apparently without system or continuance, hoping to uncover
sudden boundless affluence.
In the next letter and the one following it we get a hint of an
episode, or rather of two incidents which he combined into an
episode in Roughing It. The story as told in that book is an
account of what might have happened, rather than history.
There was never really any money in the “ blind lead ” of the
Wide West claim, except that which was sunk in it by un-
fortunate* investors. Only extracts from these letters arc given.
The other portions are irrelevant and of slight value.
Extract from a letter to Orion Clemens, in Carson City :
18 C 2 .
Two or three of the old “ Salina ” company entered our
hole on the Monitor yesterday morning, before our men
got there, and took possession, armed with revolvers.
And according to the d — d laws of this forever d— -d
country, nothing but the District Court (and there ain’t
any) can touch the matter, unless it assumes the shape of
an infernal humbug which they call “ forcible entry and
detainer,” and in order to bring that about, you must
compel the jumpers to use personal violence toward you !
We went up and demanded possession, and they refused.
Said they were in the hole, armed and meant to die for it,
if necessary.
JUMPING A CLAIM
55
I got in with them, and again demanded possession.
They said I might stay in it as long as I pleased, and work
but they would do the same. I asked one of our company
to t^ce my place in the hole, while I went to consult a
lawyer. He did so. The lawyer said it was no go. They
must offer some “ force.”
Our* boys will try to be there first in the morning — in
which case they may get possession and keep it. Now
you understand the shooting scrape in which Gebhart
was killed the other day. The Clemens Company — all
of us — hate to resort to arms in this matter, and it will
not be done until it becomes a forced hand — but I think
that will be the end of it, never-the-less.
Sometimes, during idle days in the camp, the miner had
followed old literary impulses and written an occasional
burlesque sketch, which he had signed “ Josh,” and sent to
the Territorial Enterprise, at Virginia City. The rough, vigorous
humour of these had attracted some attention, and Orion,
pleased with any measure of sueeess that might come to his
brother, had allowed the authorship of them to become known.
When, in July, the fmancial situation became desperate, the
Esmeralda miner was moved to turn to literature for relief.
To Orion Clemens, in Carson City :
Esmeralda, July 23rd, 1862.
My dear Bro., — No, I don't own a foot in the “ John-
son ” ledge — I will tell the story some day in a more
intelligible manner than Tom has told it. You needn’t
take the trouble to deny Tom’s version, though. I own
‘25 feet (1-10) of the 1st east ex. on it— and Johnson
himself has contracted to find the ledgc^ for 100 feet.
Contract signed yesterday. But as the ledge will
be difficult to find he is allowed six months to find
it in. An eighteenth of the Ophir was a fortune to
John D. Winters— and the Ophir can’t beat the Johnson
flny« • * •
My debts are greater than I thought for; I bought
SO LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
4
$25 worth of clothing, and sent $25 to Higbic, in the
cement diggings. I owe about $45 or $50, and {lave got
about $45 in my pocket. But how in the h — 1 1 am going
to live on something over $100 until October or November,
is singular. The fact is, I must have something to do, and
that shortly, too. ... ,
Now write to the Sacramento Union folks, or to Marsh,
and tell them I’ll write as many letters a week as they
want, for $30 a week— my board must be paid. Tell them
T have corresponded with the N. Orleans Orescept, and
other papers — and the Enterprise. California is full of
people who have interests here, and it’s d — d seldom they
hear from this country. I can’t write a specimen letter
— now, at any rate — I’d rather undertake to write a
Greek poem. Tell ’em the mail and express leave three
limes a week, and it costs from 25 to 50 cents to send
letters by the blasted express. If they want letters from
here, who’ll run from morning till night collecting materials
cheaper ? I'll write a short letter twice a week, for the
present, for the “ Age,” for $5 per week. Now it has
been a long time since I couldn’t make my own living,
and it shall be a long time before I loaf another
year. . . .
If I gel the other 25 feet in the Johnson ex., T shan’t
care a d — n. I’ll be willing to curse awhile and wait.
And if I can’t move the bowels of those hills this fall, I
will come up and clerk for you until I get money enough
to go over the mountains for the winter.
Yr. Bro.
Sam.
•
The Territorial Enterprise at Virginia City was at this time
owned by Joseph T. Goodman, who had bought it on the eve
of the great Comstock silver-mining boom, and from a struggling,
starving sheet had converted it into one of the most important
— certainly the most picturesque — papers on the coast. The
sketches which the Esmeralda miner had written over the name
of Josh ” titled into xt exactly, and when a young man named
JOURNALISM
57
Barstow, m the business office, urged Goodman to invite 44 Josh ”
to join their staff, the Enterprise owner readily fell in with the
idea. Among a lot of mining matters of no special interest,
Clemens, July 30th, wrote his brother : 44 Barstow has offered
me thopost as local reporter for the Enterprise at $25 a week,
and I have written him that 1 will let him know next mail, if
possible.’ 5
It wa^about the c nd of August (1802) when the miner finally
abandoned the struggle, and with his pack on his shoulders
walked the one hundred and thirty miles over the mountains
to Virginia City, arriving dusty, lame, and travel-stained to
claim at last his rightful inheritance. At the Enterprise office
he was welcomed, and in a brief time entered into his own.
Goodman, the proprietor, himself a man of great ability, had
surrounded himself with a group of gay-hearted fellows, whose
fresh, wild way of writing delighted the Comstock pioneers far
more than any sober presentation of mere news. Samuel
Clemens fitted exactly into this group. By the end of the year
he had become a leader of it. When lie asked to be allowed
to report the coming Carson legislature, Goodman consented,
realizing that while Clemens knew nothing of parliamentary
procedure, he would at least make the letters picturesque.
It was in the midst of this work that he adopted the name
which he v as to make famous throughout the world. “ Mark
Twain ” was first signed to a Carson letter, February 2, 1863,
and (roni that time was attached to all of Samuel Clemens’s
work. The letters had already been widely copied, and the
name now which gave them personality quickly obtained vogue.
It was attached to himself as well as to the letters ; heretofore
he had been called Sam or Clemens, now he became almost
universally Mark Twain and Mark.
This early period of Mark Twain’s journalism is full of de-
licious history, but we are permitted here to retell only such
of it as will supply connection to the infrequent letters. He
wrote home brieily m February, but the letter contained nothing
worth preserving. Then two months later he gives us at least
a hint of his employment.
To Mrs . Jane Clemens and Mrs . Mojfett , in St. Louis :
Virginia, April 11, 1863.
My dear Mother and Sister, — It is very late at
night, and I am writing in my room, which is not quite
as large or as nice as the one I had at home. My boarb,
08 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
, *
washing and lodging cost me seventy-five dollars a
month.
I have just received your letter, Ma, from Carson —
the one in which you doubt my veracity about the state-
ments I made in a letter to you. That’s right, f don’t
reeollcct what the statements were, but I suppose they
were mining statistics. I have just finished witting up
my report for the morning paper, and giving the Unre-
liable a column of adviee about how to conduct himself
«
in church, and now I will tell you a few more lies, while
my hand is in. For instance, some of the boys made me
a present of fifty feet in the East India G. and S. M. Com-
pany ten days ago. I was offered ninety-five dollars a
fool for it, yesterday, in gold. I refused it — not because
1 think the claim is worth a cent for I don't but because I
had a curiosity to see how high it would go, before people
find out how worthless it is. Besides, what if one mining
claim docs fool me ? I have got plenty more. I am not
in a particular hurry to get rich. I suppose I couldn’t
well help getting rich here some time or other, whether I
wanted to or not. You folks do not believe in Nevada,
and I am glad you don’t. Just keep on thinking so. . . .
The “ Unreliable ” of this letter was a rival reporter on whom
Mark Twain had conferred this name during the legislative
session. His real name was Rice, and he had undertaken to
criticize Clemons’s reports. The brisk reply that Rice's letters
concealed with a show of parliamentary knowledge a “ festering
mass of misstatements the author of whom should be properly
termed the ‘ Unreliable,’ ” fixed that name upon him for life.
This burlesque warfare delighted the frontier and it did not
interfere with friendship. Clemens and Rice were constant
associates, though continually firing squibs at each other in
their respective papers — a form of personal journalism much in
vogue on the Comstock.
In thi next letter we find these two journalistic “ blades ”
enjoying themselves together in the coast metropolis. This
letter is labelled “ No. 2,” meaning, probably, the second from
San Francisco, but No, 1 has disappeared, and even No. 2 is
incomplete.
SAN FRANCISCO JUNKETINGS 59
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in St. Louis :
No. 2 — $20.00 Enclosed
• Liok Houso, S. F., June 1, ’63.
My dear Mother and Sister, — The Unreliable and
, myself are still here, and still enjoying ourselves. I
supposed know at least a thousand people here — a great
many of them citizens of San Francisco, but the majority
belonging in Washoe — and when I go down Montgomery
street, shaking hands with Tom, Dick and Harry, it is
just like being in Main street in Hannibal and meeting
the old familiar faces. I do hate to go back to Washoe.
We fag ourselves completely out every day, and go to
sleep without rocking, every night. We dine out and we
lunch out, and we cat, drink and are happy — as it were.
After breakfast, I don’t often see the hotel again until
midnight — or after. 1 am going to the Dickens mighty
fast. I know a regular village of families here in the
house, but I never have time to call on them. Thunder 1
we’ll know a little more about this town, before we leave,
than some of the people who live in it. We take trips
across the Bay to Oakland, and down to San Leandro,
and Alameda, and those places, and we go out to the
Willows, and Hayes Park, and- Fort Point, and up to
Benicia ; and yesterday we were invited out on a yachting
excursion, and had a sail in the fastest yacht on the Pacific
Coast. Rice says : “ Oh, no — we arc not having any fun,
Mark — Oh, no, I reckon not — it’s somebody else — it’s
probably the ‘ gentleman in the wagon ’ ! ” (popular slang
phrase.) When I invite Rice to the Lick House to dinner,
the proprietors send us champagne and elwret, and then
we do put on the most disgusting airs. Rice says our
calibre is too light — we can’t stand it to be noticed !
I rode down with a gentleman to the Ocean House, the
other day, to see the sea horses, and also to listen to the
roar of the surf, and watch the ships drifting about, here,
and there, and far away at sea. When I stood on the
60
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
beach and let the surf wet my feet, I recollected doing
the same thing on the shores of the Atlantic — and then
I had a proper appreciation of the vastness of this country —
for I had travelled from ocean to ocean across it.
(Remainder missing.)
Not far from Virginia City there are some warm springs that
constantly send up jets of steam through fissures in the mountain
side. The place was a health resort, and Clemens, always subject
to bronchial colds, now and again retired there for a cure.
A letter written in the late summer - a gay, jouthful docu-
ment — belongs to one of these periods of convalescence.
To Mrs , Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in St. Louis :
Steamboat Springs, August 19, 'G3.
No. 12 — $20 enclosed.
«
My dear Mother and Sister, — Ma, you have given
my vanity a deadly thrust. Behold, I am prone to boast
of having the widest reputation, as a local editor, of any
man on the Pacific coast, and you gravely come forward
and tell me “ if I work hard and attend closely to my
business, I may aspire to a place on a big San Francisco
daily, some day.” There’s a comment on human vanity
for you ! Why, blast it, I was under the impression that
I could get such a situation as that any time I asked for
it. But I don’t want it. No paper in the United States
can afford to pay me what my place on the “ Enterprise ”
is worth. If I were not naturally a lazy, idle, good-for-
nothing vagabond, I could make it pay me $20,000 a year.
But I don’t suppose I shall ever be any account. I lead
an easy life, though, and I don’t care a cent whether school
keeps or not. Everybody knows me, and I fare like a
prince wherever I go, be it on this side of the mountains
or the other. And I am proud to say I am the most
conceited ass in the Territory.
You think that picture looks old ? Well, I can’t help
it- -in reality I am not as old as I was when I was eighteen.
STEAMBOAT SPRINGS
61
l toon a desperate cold more than a week ago, and I
seduced Wilson (a Missouri boy, reporter of the Daily
Union), from his labours, and we went over to Lake Bigler.
But I failed to cure my cold. I found the “ Lake House ”
crowded with the wealth and fashion of Virginia, and I
could not resist the temptation to take a hand in all the
’ fun going.* Those Virginians — men and women both —
are a stirring set, and I found if I went with them on all
their eternal excursions, I should bring the consumption
home with me — so 1 left, day before yesterday, and came
back into the Territory again. A lot of them had pur-
chased a site for a town on the Lake shore, and they gave
me a lot. When you come out, I’ll build you a house on
it. The Lake seems more supernaturally beautiful now,
than ever. It is the masterpiece of the Creation.
The hotel here at the Springs is not so much crowded
as usual, and I-am having a very comfortable time of it.
The hot, white steam puffs up out of fissures in the earth
like the jets that come from a steam-boat’s ’scape pipes,
and it makes a boiling, surging noise like a steam-boat,
too — hence the name. We put eggs in a handkerchief
and dip them in the springs — they “ soft boil ” in 2
minutes, and boil as hard as a rock in 4 minutes. These
fissures extend more than a quarter of a mile, and the long
line of steam columns looks very pretty. A large bath
house is built over one of the springs, and we go in it and
steam ourselves as long as we can stand it, and then come
out and take a cold shower bath. You get baths, board
and lodging, all for $25 a week — cheaper than living in
Virginia without balhs. . . .
Yrs aft
Makk.
It was now the autumn of 1803. Mark Twain was twenty-
eight years old. On the Coast he had established a reputation
as a gaily original newspaper writer. Thus far, however, he
had absolutely no literary standing, nor is there any evidence
that he had literary ambitions ; his work was unformed and
uncultivated.
62 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
He was busy reporting the Legislature at Carson* City and
responding to social demands. From having been a scarcely
considered unit during the early days of his arrival in Car son
Mark Twain had attained a high degree of importance in the
little Nevada capital. In the Legislature he was a power; as
correspondent for the Enterprise he was feared and rcSpectcd
as well as admired. His humour, his satire, and his fearlessness
were dreaded weapons. ,
Also, he was of extraordinary popularity. Orion’s Vife, with
her little daughter, Jennie, had come out from the States. The
Governor of Nevada had no household in Carson City, and was
generally absent. Orion Clemens reigned in his stead, and
indeed was usually addressed as “ Governor ” Clemens. His
home became the social centre of the capital, and his brilliant
brother its chief ornament. From the roughest of miners of a
year before he had become, once more, almost a dandy in dress,
and no occasion was complete without him. When the two
Houses of the Legislature assembled, in January, 1864, a bur-
lesque Third House was organized, and proposed to hold a
session, as a church benefit. After very brief consideration it
was decided to select Mark Twain to preside at* this Third House
assembly under the title of “ Governor,” and a letter of invita-
tion was addressed to him. His reply to it follows :
To S. Pixlcy and G. A. Scars, Trustees :
Carson City, January 23, 1801.
Gentlemen, — Certainly. If the public can find any-
thing in a grave state paper worth paying a dollar for,
I am willing that they should pay that amount, or any
other; and although I am not a very dusty Christian
myself, I take an absorbing interest in religious affairs,
and would willingly inflict my annual message upon the
Church itself if it might derive benefit thereby. You can
charge what you please ; I promise the public no amuse-
ment, but I do promise a reasonable amount of instruction.
£ am responsible to the Third House only, and I hope to
he permitted to make it exceedingly warm for that body,
without earing whether the sympathies of the public and
the Church be enlisted in their favour, and against myself
or not.
Respectfully,
Mark Twain.
FIRST LITERARY SUCCESS
68
In 18(?4 Clemons was in San Francisco , working on the Call,
and contributing literary articles to the Californian, of which
Bret Harte, unknown to fame, was editor. Hartc had his
office just above the rooms of the Call, and he and Clemens were
good intends.
Relations with the Call ceased before the end of the year,
though not in the manner described in Roughing It. It had
been an important year ; the jumping frog story, published in
New York, had been reprinted East and West, and laughed over
in at least a million homes.
To Mm. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in St. Louis :
San Francisoo, Jan. 20, 1866
My dear Mother and Sister, — I do not know what
to write ; my life is so uneventful. I wish I was back
there piloting up and down the river again. Verily, all
is vanity and little worth. — save piloting.
To think thiat, after writing many an article a man
might be excused for thinking tolerably good, those New
York people should single out a villainous backwoods
sketch to compliment me on 1 — “ Jim Smiley and Ilis
Jumping Frog ” — a squib which would never have been
written but to please Artemus Ward, and then it reached
New York too late to appear in his book.
But no matter. His book was a wretchedly poor one,
generally speaking, and it could be no credit to either of
us to appear between its covers.
This paragraph is from the New York correspondence
of the San Francisco Alta :
(Clipping pasted in.)
“ Mark Twain’s story in the Saturday Press of
November 18th, called * Jini Smiley and Ilis Jumping Frog,’
has set all New York in a roar, and he may be said to have
made his mark. 1 have been asked fifty times about it
and its author, and the papers are copying it far and
near. It is voted the best thing of the day. Cannot the
Californian afford to keep Mark all to itself ? It should
M TVmniS rttl> MAPK" »TWATM
VJI OTunUtttlv JLYYAJUM
not let him scintillate so widely without first bei% filtered
through the California press.”
The New York publishing house of Carleton & Co. gave
the sketch to the Saturday Press when they found it was
too late for the book.
Though I am generally placed at the head of my Wed
of scribblers in this part of the country, the place properly
belongs to Bret Harte, I think, though he denies it, along
with the rest. He wants me to club a lot of old sketches
together with a lot of his, and publish a book. I Wouldn’t
do it, only he agrees to take all the trouble. But I want
to know whether we are going to make anything out of
it, first. However, he has written to a New York publisher,
and if we are offered a bargain that will pay for a month’s
labour we will go to work and prepare the volume for
the press.
Yours affy,
Sam.
Bret Harte and Clemens had by this time quit the Californian,
expecting to contribute to Eastern periodicals. Clemons, how-
ever, was not yet through with Coast journalism. There was
much interest just at this time in the Sandwich Islands, and lie
was selected by the foremost Sacramento paper to spy out the
islands and report aspects and conditions there.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in St. Louis :
Honolulu, Sandwich Islands, April 3, 18(K>.
My dear Mother and Sister, — I have been here two
or three weeks, and like the beautiful tropical climate
better and better. I have ridden on horseback all over tliis
island (Oahu) in the meantime, and have visited all the
ancient battle-fields and other places of interest. I have
got a lot of human bones which I took from one of those
battle-fields— I guqss I will bring you some of them. I
went with the American Minister and took dinner this
\ ouoir Ol' VlAKk J WAIN'S LAT.lv 11U1M>S
6$
SANDWICH ISLANDS
evening with the King’s Grand Chamberlain, who is related
to the royal family, and although darker than a mulatto,
he has an excellent English education and in manners is
an accomplished gentleman. The dinner was as cere-
monious as any I ever attended in California — five regular
courses, and five kinds of wine and one brandy. He is
to call f&r me in the morning with his carriage, and we
will visit the King at the palace-— both arc good Masons
— the King is a Royal Arch Mason. After dinner tonight
they called in the “singing girls,” andwc had somebeautiful
music, sung in the native tongue.
The steamer I came here in sails tomorrow, and as
soon as she is gone I shall sail for the other islands of the
group and visit the great volcano — the grand wonder of
the world. Be gone two months.
Yrs.
' ■ Sam.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in St. Louis :
Honolulu, Sandwich Islands,
June 21, 1866.
My dear Mother and Sister,- — I have just got back
from a hard trip through the Island of Hawaii, begun on
the 26th of May and finished on the 18th of June — only
six or seven days at sea — all the balance horse-back, and
the hardest mountain road in the world. I staid at the
volcano about a week and witnessed the greatest eruption
that has occurred for years. I lived well there. They
charge $4 a day for board, and a dollar or two extra for
guides and horses. I had a pretty good #time. They
didn’t charge me anything. I have got back sick went
to bed as soon as I arrived here — shall not be strong again
for several days yet, 1 rushed too fast. I ought to have
taken five or six weeks on that trip.
A week hence 1 start for the Island of Kauai, to he gone
three weeks and then I go back to California.
66 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
The Crown Princess is dead and thousands of natives
cry and wail and dance and dance for the dead, around
the King’s Palace all night and every night. . They will
keep it up for a month and then she will be buried. »
Hon. Anson Burlingame, U. S. Minister to China, and
Gen. Van Valkcnburgh, Minister to Japan, -jvith their
families and suites, have just arrived here cn routf 1 . They
were going to do me the honor to call on me this morning,
and that accounts for my being out of bed now. You
know what condition my room is always in when you
are not around— so I climbed out of bed and dressed and
shaved pretty quick and went up to the residence of the
American Minister and called on them. Mr. Burlingame
told me a good deal about Hon. Jere Clemens and that
Virginia Clemens who was wounded in a duel. He was
in Congress years with both of them. Mr. B. sent for his
son, to introduce him — said he could tell that frog story
of mine as well as anybody. I told him I was glad to hear
it for I never tried to tell it myself without making a
botch of it. At his request I have loaned Mr. Burlingame
pretty much everything I ever wrote. I guess he will be
an almighty wise man by the time he wades through that
lot.
If the New United States Minister to the Sandwich
Islands (Hon. Edwin McCook), were only here now, so
that I could get his views on this new condition of Sand-
wich Island politics, I would sail for California at
once. But he will not arrive for two weeks yet
and so I am going to spend that interval on the island
of Kauai.
I stopped three days with Hon. Mr. Cony, Deputy
Marshal of the Kingdom, at Hilo, Hawaii, last week and
by a funny circumstance he knew everybody that I ever
knew in Hannibal and Palmyra. We used to sit up all
night talking and then sleep all day. He lives like a
Prince. Confound that Island ! I had a streak of fat
and a streak of lean all over it— got lost several times and
AN AMERICAN DIPLOMAT
67
had to sleep in huts with the natives and live like a dog.
Of course I couldn’t speak fifty words of the language.
Take it altogether, though, it was a mighty hard trip.
Yours Affect.
Sam.
Burlingame and Van Valkonburgli were on their way to their
posts, and their coming to the islands just at this time proved
a most important circumstance to Mark Twain. We shall come
to this # prcsently, in a summary of the newspaper letters written
to the Union. June 27th he wrote to his mother and sister a
letter, only a fragment of which survives, in which he tells of the
arrival in Honolulu of the survivors of the ship Ilornel , burned
on the line, and of his securing the first news report of the lost
vessel.
Part of a letter to Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in
. . St. Louis :
Honolulu, Juno 27, I860.
. . . with a gill of water a day to each man. I got the
whole story from the third mate and two of the sailors.
If my account gets to the Sacramento Union first, it will
be published first all over the United States, France,
England, Russia and Germany — all over the world, I
may say. You will see it. Mr. Burlingame went with
me all the time, and helped me question the men— throw-
ing away invitations to dinner with the prinecs and
foreign dignitaries, and neglecting all sorts of things to
accommodate me. You know how I appreciate that kind
of thing — especially from such a man, who is acknowledged
to have no superior in the diplomatic circles of the world,
and obtained from China concessions in fav«r of America
which were refused to Sir Frederick Bruce and Envoys
of France and Russia until procured for them by Burlin-
game himself — which service was duly acknowledged
by those dignitaries. He hunted me up as soon as he
came here, and has done me a hundred favors since, and
says if I will come to China in the first trip of the great
68 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
<■
mail steamer next January and make his house in Pekin
my h6me, he will afford me facilities that few men can
have there for seeing and learning. He will give me letters
to the chiefs of the great Mail Steamship Company ivhich
will he oi service to me in this matter. I expect to do
all this, but I expect to go to the States first — and from
China to the Paris World’s Fair.
Don’t show this letter.
Yours affly
Sam.
P. S. The crown Princess of this Kingdom will be buried
tomorrow with great ceremony — after that I sail in two
weeks for California.
It was August 18th when he reached San Francisco and wrote
in his note-book, “ Home again. No — not home again— in
prison again, and all the wild sense of freedom gone. City scorns
so cramped and so dreary with toil and care and business
anxieties. God help me, I wish I were at sea again ! ”
lie wished to make a trip around the world, a project that
required money. He contemplated making a book of his island
letters and experiences, and the accept ance by Harper's Magazine
of the revised version of the Hornet Shipwreck story encouraged
this thought.
Friends urged him to embody in a lecture the picturesque
aspect of Hawaiian life. The thought frightened him, but it
also appealed to him strongly. He believed he could entertain
an audience, once he got started on the right track. As Governor
of the Third House at Carson City he had kept the audience in
hand. Men in whom he had the utmost confidence insisted that
he should follow up the lecture idea and engage' the largest house
in the city for his purpose. The possibility of failure appalled
him, but he finally agreed to the plan.
In Roughing It, and elsewhere, has been told the story of
this vent ire — the tale of its splendid success. lie was no longer
concerned, now, as to his immediate future. His audience
laughed and shouted, lie was learning the flavour of real
success and exulting in it. With Dennis McCarthy, formerly
one of the partners in the Enterprise , as manager, he made a
tour of Calitoinia and Nevada.
69
LECTURING IN THE WEST
To* Mrs. Jane Clemens and others, in St. Louis :
Virginia City, Nov, 1 , 1866 .
All tiie Folks, Affectionate Greeting, — You know
the flush times are past, and it has long been impossible
to more than half fill the Theatre here, with any sort of
attraction, but they filled it for me, night before last —
full — dollar all over the house. . . .
I have lectured in San Francisco, Sacramento, Marys-
ville, Grass Valley, Nevada, You 33cfc, lied Dog and Vir-
ginia. ,T am going to talk in Carson, Gold Hill, Silver
City, Dayton, Washoe, San Francisco again, and again
here if I have time to re-hash the lecture.
Then I am bound for New York — lecture on the
Steamer, maybe.
I’ll leave toward 1st December — but I’ll telegraph you.
Love to all.
Yrs.
Mark.
His keture tour continual from October until December, a
pc riod of picturesque incident.
Arriving in New York, after an adventurous voyage, lie
met a number of old Californians —men who believed in him —
and urged him to lecture. lie also received offers of newspaper
engagements, and from Charles Ik nry Webb, who had pub-
lished the Californian, which Bret Hartc had edited, came the
proposal to collect his published sketches, including the Jumping
Frog story, in book form. Webb finally declared, after vainly
approaching several publishers, that he would publish the book
himself, and Clemens, after a few weeks of New York, joined
his mother and family in St. Louis and gave himself up to a
considerable period of visiting, lecturing meantime in both
Hannibal and Keokuk.
Fate had great matters in preparation for him. The Quaker
City Mediterranean excursion, the first great o<*ean picnic, was
announced that spring, and Mark Twain realized that it offered
a possible opportunity for him to see something of the world.
He wrote at once to the proprietors of the AUa-Califomia and
proposed that they send him as their correspondent. To his
delight his proposition was accepted, the Alta agreeing to the
twelve hundred dollars passage money, and twenty dollars each
for letters.
70
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
The Quaker City was not to sail until the 8th of June, but the
Alia wished some preliminary letters from New York. Further-
more, Webb had the Frog book in press, and would issue it
May 1st. Clemens, therefore, returned to New York in April,
and now once more being urged by the Californians to lerture,
he did not refuse. Frank Fuller, formerly Governor of Utah,
took the matter in hand and engaged Cooper Union for the
venture. Ife timed it for May 6th, which would be a fcw days
after the appearance of Webb’s book. Clemens was even more
frightened at the prospect of this lecture than he had been in
San Francisco, and with more reason, for in New York his
friends were not many, and competition for public favour was
very great.
To Bret II arte, in San Francisco :
Westminster Hotel, May 1, 1867.
Deau Rbet, — I take my pen in hand to inform you
that I am well and hope these few lines, will find you
enjoying the same God’s blessing.
The book is out, and is handsome. It is full of damnable
errors of grammar and deadly inconsistencies of spelling
in the Frog sketch because I was away and did not read
the proofs ; but be a friend and say nothing about these
things. When my hurry is over, I will send you an auto-
graph copy to pisen the children with.
1 am to lecture in Cooper Institute next Monday night.
Pray for me.
We sail for the Iloly Land June 8. Try to write me
(to this hotel,) and it will be forwarded to Paris, where
we remain 10 or 15 days.
Regards and best wishes to Mrs. Bret and the family.
Truly Yr Friend
Mabk.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and family, in St. ljouis :
Westminster Hotel, May 1, 1867.
Deab Folks, — Don’t expect me to write for a while.
My hands are full of business on account of my lecture for
LECTURING IN NEW YORK 71
the 6th *inst., and everything looks shady, at least, if not
dark. I have got a good agent — but now after we have
hired Cooper Institute and gone to an expense in one way
or another of $500, it comes out that I have got to play
against Speaker Colfax at Irving Hall, Ristori, and also
the double troupe of Japanese Jugglers, the latter opening
at the great Academy of Music — and with all this against
me I have taken the largest house in New York and cannot
back water. Let her slide ! If nobody else cares I don’t.
I’ll send the book soon. I am awfully hurried now, but
not worried.
Yrs. Sam.
The Cooper Union lecture proved a failure, and a success.
When it became evident to Fuller that the venture was not
going to pay, he sent out a Hood of complimentarics to the
school-teachers of New York City and the surrounding dis-
tricts. No one seems to have declined them. Clemens lectured
to a jammed house and acquired much reputation.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and family, in St. Louis:
Westminster Hotel, New York, Juno 1, 1867.
Dear Folks, — I know I ought to write oftener (just
got your last,) and more fully, but I cannot overcome my
repugnance to telling what I am doing or what I expect
to do or propose to do. Then, what have I left to write
about ? Manifestly nothing.
It isn’t any use for me to talk about the voyage, because
I can have no faith in that voyage till the ship is under
way. IIow do I know she will ever sail ? My passage is
paid, and if the ship sails, I sail in her — but I make no
calculations, have bought no cigars, no sea-going clothing
— have made no preparation whatever — shall not pack
my trunk till the morning we sail. Yet my hands are
full of what 1 am going to do the day before we sail — and
what isn’t done that day will go undone.
All I do know or feel, is, that I am wild with impatience
to move — move — move ! Half a dozen times I have wished
72 , LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
I had sailed long ago in some ship that wasn’t f going to
keep me chained here to chafe for lagging ages while she
got ready to go. Curse the endless delays ! They always
kill me — they make me neglect every duty and then I
have a conscience that tears me like a wild beast. I wish
I never had to slop anywhere a month. I do more mean
things, the moment I get a chance to fold my hands and
sit down than ever I can get forgiveness for. . . .
I am resigned to Rev. Mr. Hutchinson’s or anybody
else’s supervision. I don’t mind it. I am fixed. I have
got a splendid, immoral, tobacco-smoking, wine-drinking,
godless room-mate who is as good and true and right-
minded a man as ever lived — a man whose blameless
conduct and example will always be an eloquent sermon
to all who shall come within their influence. But send on
the professional preachers- -there arc none I like better
to converse with. If they’re not narrotv minded and
bigoted they make good companions.
I asked them to send the N. Y. Weekly to you — no
charge. I am not going to write for it. Like all other
papers that pay one splendidly it circulates among stupid
people and the canaille. I have made no arrangement
with any New York paper — 1 will see about that Monday
or Tuesday.
Love to all
Good bye,
Yrs affy
Sam.
Mark Twain, now at sea, was writing many letters; not
personal letters, but l hose unique descriptive relations of travel
which would make him his first great fame — those fresh first
impressions preserved to us now as chapters of The Innocents
Abroad.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and family, in St. Louis:
\alta, Russia, Aug. 20, 1867.
L)eak Folks, — We have been representing the United
States all wo knew bow today. We went to Sebastopol,
A VISIT TO THE CZAR
78
after wo*got tired of Constantinople (got your letter there,
and one at Naples,) and there the Commandant and the
whole town came aboard and were as jolly and sociable
as old friends. They said the Emperor of Russia was at
Yalta, 30 miles or 40 away, and urged us to go there with
the ship and visit him— promised us a cordial welcome.
They insisted on sending a telegram to the Emperor,
and also a courier overland to announce our coming. But
we knc # w that a great English Excursion part} , and also the
Viceroy of Egypt, in his splendid yacht, had been refused
an audience within the last fortnight, so we thought it
not safe to try it. They said, no difference —the Emperor
would hardly visit our ship, because that would be a most
extraordinary favor, and one which he uniformly refuses to
accord under any circumstances, but he would certainly
receive us at his palace. We still declined. But we had
to go to Odessa, 250'miles away, and there the Governor
General urged us, and sent a telegram to the Emperor,
which we hardly expected to be answi red, but it was, and
promptly. So we sailed back to Yalta.
We all went to the palace at noon, today, (3 miles) in
carriages and on horses sent by the Emperor, and we had
a jolly time. Instead of the usual formal audience of 15
minutes, we staid 1 hours and were made a good deal
more at home than we could have been in a New York
drawing-room. The whole tribe turned out to receive
our party — Emperor, Empress, the oldest daughter
(Grand-Duchess Marie, a pretty girl of 14,) a little Grand
Duke, her brother, and a platoon of Admirals, Princes,
Peers of the Empire, etc., and in a little while an aide-
de-camp arrived with a request from the .Grand Duke
Michael, the Emperor’s brother, that we would visit his
palace and breakfast with him. The Emperor also invited
us, on behalf of his absent eldest son and heir (aged 22),
to visit his palace and consider it a visit to him. They
all talk English and they were all very neatly but
very plainly dressed. You all dress a good deal finer
74 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
than they were dressed. The Emperor and his family
threw off all reserve and showed us all over the palace
themselves. It is very rich and very elegant, but in no
way gaudy.
I had been appointed chairman of a committee to
draught an address to the Emperor in behalf of the pas-
sengers, and as I fully expected, and as they fully Intended,
I had to write the address myself. I didn’t mind
it, because I have no modi sty and would as soon write
to an Emperor as to anybody else — but considering that
there were 5 on the committee I thought they might
have contributed ont paragraph among them, anyway.
They wanted me to read it to him, too, but I declined that
honor — not because I hadn’t check enough (and some to
spare,) but because our Consul at Odessa was along, and
also the Secretary of our Legation at St. Petersburgh,
and of course one of those ought to read it* The Emperor
accepted the address — it was his business to do it — and so
many others have praised it warmly that I begin to
imagine it must be a wonderful soil of document and
herewith send you the original draught ol it to be put
into alcohol and preserved forever like a curious reptile.
They live right well at the Grand Duke Michael’s —
their breakfasts are not gorgeous but very excellent —
and if Mike were to say the word I would go there and
breakfast with him tomorrow.
Yi aff
Sam.
P. S. [Written across the face of the last page.] They
had told us jt would be polite to invite the Emperor to
visit the ship, though he would not be likely to do it.
But he didn’t give us a chance — he has requested per-
mission to come on board wutli his family and all his rela-
tions tomorrow and take a sail, in case it is calm weather.
J can entertain them. My hand is in, now, and if you
want any more Emperors feted in style, trot them out.
THE LEVANT
75
U. S. Consul’s Office,
Beirut, Syria, Sept. II. (1867)
Deab Folks, — Wc arc here, eight of us, making a con-
tract with a dragoman to take us to Baalbek, then to
Damascus, Nazareth; &c,, then to Lake Genassareth (Sea
of Tiberias,) then South through all the celebrated Scrip-
tural localities to Jerusalem — then to the Dead Sea, the
Cave of Macpclah and up to Joppa where the ship will
be. Wp shall be in the saddle three weeks — we have
horses, tents, provisions, arms, a dragoman and two other
servants, and we pay five dollars a day apiece, in gold.
Love to all, yrs.
Sam.
We leave tonight, at two o’clock in the morning.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and family, in St. Louis :
Cagliari, Sardinia, Oct. 12, 1867.
Dear Folks, — W e have just dropped anchor before
this handsome city and
Algiers, Africa, Oct. 16.
They would not let us land at Cagliari on account of
cholera. Nothing to write.
Malaga, Spain, Oct. 17.
The Captain and I are ashore here under guard, waiting
to know whether they will let the ship anchor or not.
Quarantine regulations arc very strict here on all vessels
coming from Egypt. I am a little anxioys because I
want to go inland to Granada and see the Alhambra.
I can go on down by Seville and Cordova, and be picked
up at Cadiz.
Later : We cannot anchor — must go on. We shall be
at Gibraltar before midnight and I think I will go horse-
back (52 long days) and thence by rail and diligence to
76
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Cadiz. I will not mail this till I sec the Gibraltar lights —
I begin to think they won’t let us in anywhere.
11.30 P. M. — Gibraltar.
At anchor and all right, but they won’t let us land till
morning — it is a waste of valuable time. We shall reach
New York middle of November.
Yours,
Sam.
Cadiz, Oct. 24, 1807.
Dear Folks, — We left Gibraltar at noon and rode to
Algeciras, (4 hours) thus dodging the quarantine, took
dinner and then rode horseback all night in a swinging
trot and at daylight took a calcchc (2-wheeled vehicle)
and rode 5 hours — then took ears and traveled till twelve
at night. That landed us at Seville and yre were over the
hard part of our trip, and somewhat tired. Since then
we have taken things comparatively easy, drifting around
from one town to another and attracting a good de al of
attention, for I guess strangers do not wander through
Andalusia and the other Southern provinces of Spain
often. The country is precisely as it w r as when Don
Quixote and Sancho Pauza were possible characters.
But I see now what the glory of Spain must have been
when it was under Moorish domination. No, I will not
say that, but then when one is’ carried away, infatuated,
entranced, with the wonders of the' Alhambra and the
supernatural beauty of the Alcazar, he is apt to overflow
with admiration for the splendid intellects that created
them.
I cannot ‘‘write now. I am only dropping a line to
let you know 1 am well. The ship will call for us here
tomorrow. We may stop at Lisbon, and shall at the
Bermudas, and will arrive in New York ten days after
this letter gets there.
Yr>.
Sam.
TRAVEL LITERATURE
77
He wrote fifty-three letters to the Alta-Califomia, six to the
New York Tribune, and at least two to the New York Herald —
more than sixty, all told, of an average length of three to four
thousand words each. They made him famous. Arriving in
New York, November 19, 18G7, Mark Twain found himself no
longer unknown to the metropolis, or to any portion of America.
Papers East and West had copied his Alta and Tribune letters'
and oarriqd*his name into every eorner of the Statens and Terri-
tories. He had preached a new gospel in travel literature, the
gospel of frankness and sincerity that Americans could under-
stand. .Also his literary powers had awakened at last. Ilis
work was no longer trivial, crude, and showy; it was full of
dignity, beauty, and powt r ; Jus humour was finer, worthier.
The difference in quality between the Quaker City Utters and
those written from the Sandwich Islands only a year before
can scarcely be measured.
He did not remain m New York, but went down to Washing-
ton, where he had arranged for a private secretaryship with
Senator William M. Stewart, whom he had known in Nevada.
Such a position he believed would make but little demand upon
his time, and would afford him an insight into Washington life,
which he could make valuable in the shape of newspaper
correspondence.
But fate had other plans for him. He presently received
the following letter :
From Elisha Bliss, Jr., in Hartford :
Office of the American Publishing Company.
Hartford, Conn, Nov. 21, 1867.
Samuel L. Clemens Esq.
Tribune Office, New York.
Dr. Sir, — W e take the liberty to address you this, in
place of a letter which we had recently written and was
about to forward to you, not knowing your arrival home
was expected so soon. We are desirous of obtaining from
you a work of some kind, perhaps compiled from your
letters from the East, &e., with such interesting additions
as may be proper. We are the publishers of A. 1>. Richard-
son’s works, and flatter ourselves that wc can give an
author as favorable terms and do as full justice to his
productions as any other house in the country. We are
78 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
perhaps the oldest subscription house in the country, and
have never failed to give a book an immense circulation.
We sold about 100,000 copies of Richardson’s F. D. & E.
(Field, Dungeon and Escape) and arc now printing 41,000
of “Beyond the Mississippi,” and large orders ahead.
If you have any thought of writing a book, or couJd be
induced to do so, wo should be pleased to see you, and will
do so. Will you do us the favor to reply at once, at your
earliest convenience.
Very truly, &c.,
E. Bliss, Jr.
Secty.
Clemens had already the idea of a book in mind and welcomed
this proposition.
To Elisha Bliss, Jr., in Hartford :
Washington, Doc. 2, 1867.
E. Bliss, Jr. Esq.
Secy American Publishing Co. —
Dear Sir, — I only received your favor of Nov. 21st
last night at the rooms of the Tribune Bureau here. It
was forwarded from the Tribune office, New York, where
it had lain eighi or ten days. This will be a sufficient
apology for the seeming discourtesy of my silence.
I wrote fifty-two (three) letters for the San Francisco
“ Alta California ” during the Quaker City excursion,
about half of which number have been printed, thus far.
The “ Alta ” has few exchanges in the East, and I suppose
scarcely any of these letters have been copied on this side
of the Rocky Mountains. I could weed them of their
chief faults of construction and inelegancies of expression
and make a volume that would be more acceptable in many
respects than any I could now write. When those letters
were written my impressions were fresh, but now they
have lost that freshness ; they were warm then — they are
cold, now. I could strike out certain letters, and write
new ones wherewith to supply their places. If you think
THE AMERICAN PUBLISHING COMPANY 79
such a Rook would suit your purpose, please drop me a
line, specifying the size and general style of the volume ;
when the matter ought to be ready ; whether it should
have pictures in it or not ; and particularly what your
terms with me would be, and what amount of money I
might possibly make out of it. The latter clause has a
degree oMmportance for me which is almost beyond my own
comprehension. But you understand that, of course.
I h^ve other propositions for a book, but have doubted
the propriety of interfering with good newspaper en-
gagements, except my way as an author could be demon-
strated to be plain before me. But I know Richardson,
and learned from him some months ago, something of an
idea of the subscription plan of publishing. If that is
your plan invariably, it looks safe.
I am on the N. Y. Tribune staff here as an “ occasional,”
among other things, "and a note from you addressed to
Very truly &e.
Sam L. Clemens,
New York Tribune Bureau, Washington, will find me,
without fail.
The exchange of these two letters marked the beginning of
one of the most notable publishing connections in American
literary history. The book, however, was not begun imme-
diately. Bliss was in poor health and final arrangements were
delayed ; it was not until late in January that Clemens went to
Hartford and concluded the arrangement.
Meantime, fate had disclosed another matter of even greater
importance; wc get the first hint of it in the following letter,
though to him its beginning had been earlier — on a day in the
blue harbour of Smyrna, when young Charles Langdon, a fellow-
passenger on the (junker City, had shown to J^Iark Twain a
miniature of young Langdon ’s sister at home :
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in St. Louis :
224 F. Street, Wash, Jan. 8, 1868.
Mv dear Mother and Sister, — And °o old Major
has been there, has he ? I would like mighty well to sec
80
letters of mark twain
him. I was a sort of benefactor to him once. *1 itidped
to snatch him out when he was about to ride into a
Mohammedan Mosque in that queer old Moorish town of
Tangier, in Africa. If he had got in, the Moors would
have knocked his venerable old head off, for his temerity.
I have just arrived from New York — been there -ver
since Christmas staying at the house of Darf Slotc —
my Quaker City room-mate, and having a splendid
time. Charley Langdon, Jack Van Nostrand, Dan and
I, (all Quaker City night-hawks,) had a blow-out at Dan’s
house and a lively talk over old times. We went through
the Holy Land together, and I just laughed till my sides
ached, at some of our reminiscences. It was the unholiest
gang that ever cavorted through Palestine, but those are
the best boys in the world. We needed Moulton badly.
I started to make calls. New Year’s Day, but 1 anchored
for the day at the first house I came to — Charlie Langdon’s
sister was there (beautiful girl,) and Miss Alice Hooker,
another beautiful girl, a niece of Henry Ward Beecher’s.
We sent the old folks home early, with instructions not
to send the carriage till midnight, and then 1 just staid
there and worried the life out of those girls. I am going
to spend a few days with the Langdons in Elmira, New
York, as soon as I get time, and a few days at Mrs. Hooker’s
in Hartford, Conn., shortly.
Henry Ward Beecher sent for me last Sunday to come
over and dine (he lives in Brooklyn, you know), and I
went. Harriet Beecher Stowe was there, and Mrs. and
Miss Beecher, Mrs. Hooker and my old Quaker City
favorite, Emma Beach.
We had a. very gay time, if it was Sunday. 1 expect
I told more lies than I have told before in a month.
I went back by invitation, after the evening service,
and finished the blow-out, and then staid all night at
Mr. Beach’s. Henry Ward is a brick.
I found out at 10 o’clock, last night, that I was to lecture
tomorrow evening and so you must be aware that I have
HENRY WARD BEECHER
81
been wonting like sin all night to get a lecture written.
I have finished it, I call it “ Frozen Truth.” It is a little
top-heavy, though, because there is more truth in the
title than there is in the lecture.
But thunder, I mustn’t sit here writing all day, with
so much business before me.
Goodly, and kind regards to all.
Yrs a fly
Sam L. Clemens.
Jack y.-tn Nostrand of this letter is “ Jack ” of the Innocents.
Emma Beach was the daughter of Moses S. Beach, of the New
York Sun. Later she became the wife of the well-known
painter, Abbot II. Thayer.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in Si. Louis :
. Hartford, Conn. Jan. 24 -G 8 .
Dear Mother and Sister, —This is a good week for
me. I stopped in the Herald office as I came through New
York, to see the boys on the staff, and young James
Gordon Bennett asked me to write twice a week, im-
personally, for the Herald, and said if I would I might
have full swing, and (write) about anybody and every-
body I wanted to. I said I must have the very fullest
possible swing, and ho said “ all right.” I said It’s a con-
tract — ” and that settled that matter.
I’ll make it a point to write one letter a week, any-
how.
But the best thing that has happened was here. This
great American Publishing Company kept on trying to
bargain with me for a book till I thought 1 would cut the
matter short by coming up for a talk. I mef Rev. Henry
Ward Beecher in Brooklyn, and with his usual whole-
souled way of dropping his own work to give other people
a lift when he gets a chance, he said, “ Now, here, you are
one of the talented men of the age — nobody is going to
deny that — but in matters of business, I don’t suppose
o
82
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
you know more than enough to come in whetf it rains.
I’ll tell you what to do, and how to do it.” And he did.
And I listened well, and then came up here and made a
splendid contract for a Quaker City Book of 5 or COO large
pages, with illustrations, the manuscript to be placed in
the publishers’ hands by the middle of July. My per-
centage is to be a fifth more than they have cvCnpail any
author, except Horace Greeley. Beecher will be surprised,
I guess, when he hears this.
But I had my mind made up to one thing — t wasn’t
going to touch a book unless i here was money in it, and a
good deal of it. I told them so. I had the misfortune to
“ bust out ” one author of standing. They had his manu-
script, with the understanding that they would publish his
book if they could not get a book from me, (they only pub-
lish two books at a time, and so my book and Richardson’s
Life of Grant will fill the bill for next fall and winter) — so
that manuscript was sent back to its author today. . . .
The Chicago Tribune wants letters, but I hope and pray
1 have charged them so much that they will not close the
contract. I am gradually getting out of debt, but these
trips to New York do cost hkt sin. I hope you have cut
out and forwarded my printed letters to Washington —
please continue to do so as they arrive.
I have had a tip-top time, here, for a few days (guest of
Mr. Jno. Hooker’s family — Beecher’s relatives — in a
general way of Mr. Bliss, also, who is head of the pub-
lishing firm.) Puritans are mighty straight-laced and
they won’t let me smoke in the parlor, but the Almighty
don’t make any better people.
Love to all — good-bye. I shall be in New York 8
days — then go on to the Capital.
Yrs aff’ly, especially Ma.,
Yr Sam.
No formal contract for the book had been made when this
letter was written. A verbal agreemt nt between Bliss and
Clemens had been reached, to be ratified by an exchange of
THE AGREEMENT WITH BLISS
83
letters in the near future. Bliss had made two propositions,
viz., ten thousand dollars, cash in hand, or a 5-per-cent, royalty
on the selling price of the book. The cash sum offered looked
very large to Mark Twain, and he was sorely tempted to accept
it lie had faith, however, in the book, mid in Bliss’s ability
to sell it. He agreed, therefore, io the* royalty proposition.
“ The best^ business judgment I ever displayed ” he often
declared ifi 'after years. Five per cent, royalty sounds rather
small in these days of more liberal contracts. But the American
Publishing Company sold its books only by subscription, and
the agents’ commissions and delivery expenses ate heavily into
the profits. Clemens was probably correct in saying that his
percentage was larger than had been paid to any previous author
except Horace Greeley, The John Hooker mentioned was the
husband of Ilenry Ward Beecher’s sister, Isabel. It was easy
to understand the Beecher family’s robust appreciation of Mark
Twain.
From the office of Han Side, his room-mate of the Quaker
City — u Han ” of the Innocents — Clemens wrote his letter that
closed the agreement with Bliss.
To Elisha Bliss , Jr., in Hartford :
Office of Slote & Woodman, Blank Book Manufacturers,
Koa. Ill) to 121 William St.
Kew Yoik, Januaiy 27, 18(>8.
Mr. E. Bliss, Jr.
Sec’y American Publishing Co.
Hartford Conn.
Dear Sir, — Your favor of Jan. 25th is received and
in reply, I will say that I accede to your several proposi-
tions, via ; That I furnish to the American Publishing
Company, through you, with MSS sufficient for a volume
of 500 to 000 pages, the subject to be the Quaker City,
the voyage, description of places, &c., and also embodying
the substance of the letters written by me during that
trip, said MSS to be ready about the first of August,
next, I 1o give all the usual and necessary attention in
preparing said MSS for the press, and m preparation of
illustrations, in correction of proofs — no use to be made by
me of the material for this work in any way which will
84 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
conflict with its interest— the book to be soli \v the
American Publishing Co., by subscription— and for said
MS and labor on my part said Company to pay me a
copyright of 5 percent, upon the subscription price of
the book for all copies sold.
As further proposed by you, this understanding, herein
sot forth shall be considered a binding contract upon nil
parties concerned, all minor details to be arranged between
us hereafter.
Very truly yours,
Sam. L. Clemens.
(Private and (Jim ml.)
1 was to have gone to Washington tonight, but have
held over a day, to attend a dinner given by a lot of news-
paper Editors and literary sealliwags, at the Westminster,
Hotel. Shall go down to-morrow, if I survive the banquet.
Yrs truly
Sam. ('lumens.
Mark Twain, in Washington, was in line for political pre-
ferment. IIis wide acquaintance on the Pacific slope, his new
fame and growing popularity, his powerful and dreaded pen,
all gave him special distinction at t he capital. From lime to
time the offer of one oilice or another tempted him, but he
wisely, or luckily, resisted. In his letters home are presented
some of his problems.
To Mrs, Jane Clcnuns and Mrs, Moffett, in Si. Louis ;
224 F, St reel Washington Feb. 0. 1868.
My deai* Mother and Sister, — For two months there
have been some fifty applications before the government
for the postmast cr&hip of San Francisco, which is the
heaviest concentration of political power on the coast
and consequently is a post which is much coveted.
When I found that a personal friend of mine, the
Chief Editi r of the Alta, was an applicant I said I didn’t
A SCRAMBLE FOR A JOB 85
want it— I would not take $10,000 a year out of a friend’s
pocket.
The two months have passed. I heard day before
yesterday that a new and almost unknown candidate had
suddenly turned up on the inside traek, and was to be
appointed at once. I didn’t like that, and went after his
case in a* fine passion. I hunted up all our Senators and
representatives and found that his name was actually to
come faom the President early in the morning.
Then Judge Field said if I wanted the place he could
pledge me the President’s appointment — and Senator Con-
ness said he would guarantee me the Senate’s confirmation.
It was a great tempi alien, but it would render it impossible
to fill my book contract, and I had to drop the idea.
I have to spend August and September in Hartford
— which isn’t San Francisco. Mr. C’onncss offers me any
choice out of five mlluential California offices. Now,
some day or other I shall want an office and then, just my
luck, I can’t get it, I suppose.
They want to send me abroad, as a Consul or a Minister.
I said I didn’t want any of the pic. Cod knows I am
mean enough and lazy enough, now, without being a
foreign consul.
Sometime in the eoursc of the present century I think
they will create a Commissioner of Patents, and then I
hope to get a berth for Orion.
I published 0 or 7 letters in the Tribune while I was
gone — now I cannot get them. I suppose I must have them
copied.
Love to all
Yrs
* Saw.
Orion Clemens was once more a candidate for office. Nevada
had become a Slate, with regularly eleetedfofficials, and Orion
had somehow missed being chosen, llis day of authority had
passed, and the law having failed to support him, he was again
back at his old occupation, setting type in St. Louis. He was,
86 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
as ever, full of dreams and inventions that would somfe day lead
to fortune. With the gift of the Sellers imagination, inherited
by all the family, he lacked the driving power which means
achievement. Mure and more as the years went by he would
lean upon his brother for moral and physical support. The
chance s for him in Washington do not appear to have been
bright. The political situation under Andrew Johnson was not
a happy one.
To Orion Clemens, in St. Louis :
22 i F. Street, Wash.. Feb. 21. (1868)
My dear Bro., — I am glad you do not want t'he clerk-
ship, for that Patent Office is in such a muddle that there
would be no security for the permanency of a place in it.
The same remark will apply to all offices here, now, and
no doubt will, till the close of the present administration.
Any man who holds a place here, now, stands prepared
at all times to vacate it. You are doing, now, exactly
what I wanted you to do a year ago.
We chase phantoms half the dajs of our lives.
It is well if we learn wisdom even then, and save the
other half.
I am in for it. I must go on chasing them —until I
marry — then I am done with literature and all other
bosh, — that is, literature w herewith to please the general
public.
I shall write to please myself, then. 1 hope you will
set type till you complete that invention, for surely
government pap must be nauseating food for a man — a
man whom God has enabled to saw wood and be inde-
pendent. It really seemed to me a falling from grace,
the idea of going back to San Francisco nothing better
than a mere* postmaster, albeit the public would have
thought I came with gilded honors, and in great
glory.
1 only retain correspondence enough, now, to make a
living for myself, and have discarded all else, so that I
may have time to spare for the book. Drat the thing,
SECRETARIAL WORK 87
I wish it were done, or that I had no other writing
to do.
This is the place to get a poor opinion of everybody in.
There isn’t one man in Washington, in civil office, who
has the brains of Anson Burlingame — and I suppose if
China hfyi, not seized and saved his great talents to the
world, this government would have discarded him when
his time was up.
There are more pitiful intellects in this Congress !
Oh, geerpiny ! There are few of them that I find pleasant
enough company to visit.
I am most infernally 1 ired of Wash, and its “ attrac-
tions.” To be busy is a man’s only happiness — and I
am — otherwise I should die
Yrs. aff
Sam.
The secretarial position with Senator Stewart was short-
lived. They parted without friction, though in later years,
when Stewart had become old and irascible, he used to recount
a list of grievances and declare* that he had been obliged to
threaten violence in order to bring Mark to terms ; but this
was because the author of Roughing It had in that book taken
liberties with the Senator, to the extent of an anecdote and
portrait which, though certainly harmless enough, had for some
reason given deep offence.
Mark Twain re ally had no time for secretary w'ork. For one
thing he was associated with John Swinton in supplying a
Washington letter to a list e>f newspapers, and then he was busy
collecting liis Quaker City letters, and preparing the copy for
his book. Matters were going well enough, when trouble
developed from an unexpected quarter. The AHa-Catifornia
had copyrighted the letters and proposed to issue them in book
form. There had been no contract which woukj prevent this,
and the correspondence which Clemens undertook with the Alta
management led to nothing. He knew that he had powerful
friendb among the owners, if he could reach them personally,
and he presently concluded to return to San Francisco,
make what arrangement he could, and finish his book
there.
The San Francisco trip proved successful. Once on the
ground Clemens had little difficulty in convincing the Alta
88
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
publishers that they had received full value in the newspaper
use of the letters, and that the book rights remained with the
author. A letter to Bliss conveys the situation.
To Elisha Bliss, Jr., in Hartford :
San Franoisco, May G, ’io.
E. Bliss, Jr. Esq.
Dr. Sir, — The Alta people, after some hesitation, have
given me permission to use my printed letters, and have
ceased to think of publishing them themselves ‘in book
form. I am steadily at work, and shall start East with the
completed Manuscript, about the middle of June.
I lectured here, on the trip, the other night— over
sixteen hundred dollars in gold in the house — every scat
taken and paid for before night.
Yrs truly,
Mark Twain.
But he did not sail in June. His friends persuaded him to
cover his lecture circuit of two years before, telling the story
of his travels. This he did with considerable profit, being
everywhere received with great honours. He ended this tour
with a second lecture in San Francisco, announced in a droll
and characteristic fashion which delighted his Pacific admirers,
and ensured him a crowded house.
His agreement had been to deliver his MS. about August 1st.
Returning by the Cliauncey, July 28th, he was two days later
m Hartford, and had placed the copy for the new book in
Blns’s hands.
The story of Mark Twain’s courtship need only be briefly
sketched here as a setting for the letters of this period.
Through young Charles Langdon, his Quaker City ship-
mate, he was pivited to Elmira. The invitation was given for
a week, but through a subterfuge — unpremeditated, and cer-
tainly fair enough in a matter of Jove — he was enabled con-
siderably to prolong his visit. By the end of his stay he had
become really “like one of the family,” though certainly not
yet accepted as such. The fragmentary letter that follows
reflects something of his pleasant situation. The Mrs. Fairbanks
m< n tinned in this letter had been something more than a
“ ship-mot Lee ” to Mark Twain. She was a woman of fine
MRS. FAIRBANKS
89
literary taste, and Quaker City correspondent for her husband’s
paper, the Cleveland Herald. She had given Mark Twain
sound advice as to his letters, which he had usually read to her,
and had in no small degree modified his early natural tendency
to exaggeration and outlandish humour.
Part oft i letter to Mrs. Jane Clemens and family, in St.
Louis :
• Elmira, N.Y. Aug. 24, 18(58.
Df.aji Folks, — You see I am progressing— though
slowly. I shall be here a week yet — maybe two — for
Charlie Langdon cannot get away until his father’s chief
business man returns from a journey — and a visit to
Mrs. Fairbanks, at Cleveland, would lose half its pleasure
if Charlie were not along. Moulton of St. Louis ought
to be there too. We. three were Mrs. F’s “ cubs,” in the
Quaker City. She took good care that we were at church
regularly on Sundays ; at the 8-bclls prayer meeting
every night ; and she kept our buttons sewed on and our
clothing in order — and in a word was as busy and con-
siderate, and as watchful over her family of uncouth and
unruly cubs, and as patient and as long-suffering, withal,
as a natural mother. So we expect. . . .
Aug. 25th.
Didn’t finish yesterday. Something called me away.
T am most comfortably situated here. This is the pleasant-
est family I ever knew. 1 only have one trouble, and
that is they give me too much thought and too much time
and invention to the object of making my visit pass
delightfully. It needs 9
He had a standing invitation now to the Langdon home, and
the end of the week often found him there. Yet when at last
he proposed for the hand of Livy Langdon the acceptance was
by no means prompt. He was a favourite in the Langdon
household, but his suitability as a husband for the frail and
gentle daughter was questioned.
However, he was carrying everything, just then, by storm.
90
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
The largest houses everywhere were crowded to hear him.
Papers spoke of him as the coming man of the age, people came
to their doors to see him pass.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and family, in St. Louis :
Cleveland, Nov. 20,
Dear Folks, — I played against the Eastern favorite,
Fanny Kemble, in Pittsburgh, last night. She had 200
in her house, and I had upwards of 1,500. All the scats
were sold (in a driving rain storm, 3 days ago,) as reserved
seats at 25 cents extra, even those in the second and third
tiers — and when the last scat was gone the box office had
not been open more than 2 hours. When I reached the
theatre they were turning people away and the house
was crammed. 150 or 200 stood up, all the evening.
I go to Elmira tonight. I am simply lecturing for
•societies, at $100 a pop.
Yrs
Sam.
It would be difficult for any family to refuse rilationship
with one whose star was so clearly ascending, « specially when
every inclination was in his favour, and the young lady herself
encouraged his suit. A provisional engagement was presently
made, but it was not finally ratified until February of the
following year. Then in a letter from one of his lecture points
he tells Ins people something of his happiness.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and family , in St. Louis:
Lockport, N. Y. Fob. 27, 1809.
Dear Foljcs, — I enclose $20 for Ma. I thought I
was getting ahead of her little assessments of $35 a month,
but find I am falling behind with her instead, and have
let her go without money. Well, I did not mean to do
it. But jou see when people have been getting ready
lor months in a quiet way to got married, they are bound
to gxow stingy, and go to saving up money against that
OLIVIA LANGDON
91
awful day when it is sure to be needed. I am particularly
anxious to place myself in a position where I con carry
on my married life in good shape on my own hook, because
I have paddled my own canoe so long that I could not
be satisfied now to let anybody help me — and my pro-
posed father-in-law is naturally so liberal that it would
be just Jllce him to want to give us a start in life. But 1
don’t want it that way. I can start myself. I don’t want
any htjlp. I can run this institution without any outside
assistance, and I shall have a wife who will stand by me
like a soldier through thick and thin, and never complain.
She is only a little body, but she hasn’t her peer in Christen-
dom. I gave her only a plain gold engagement ring,
when fashion imperatively demands a two-hundred dollar
diamond one, and told her it was typical of her future
lot — namely, that she would have to flourish on sub-
stantial rather than luxuries. (But you see 1 know the
girl — she don’t care anything about luxuries.) She is a
splendid girl. She spends no money hut her usual year’s
allowance, and she spends nearly every cent of that on
other people. She will be a good sensible little wife,
without any airs about her. I don’t make intercession
for her beforehand and ask you to love her, for there
isn’t any use in that — you couldn’t help it if you were
to try.
I warn you that whoever comes within the fatal in-
fluence of her beautiful nature* is her willing slave for
evermore. I take my affidavit on that statement. Her
father and mother and brother embrace' and pe't her con-
stantly, precisely as if she were a sweetheart, inste ad of a
blood relation. She has unlimited power o>jer her father,
and yet she never uses it except to make him help people
who stanel in need of help. . . .
But if I get fairly started on the subject of my bride,
I never shall get through — and so I will quit right here.
I went to Elmira a little over a week ago, and staid four
days and then had to go to New York on business. . . .
92
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and family, in St. Louis :
Elmira, June 4. (1869)
Dear Folks, — Livy sends you her love and loving good
wishes, and I send you mine. The last 3 chapters of the
book came tonight — we shall read it in the morning and
then thank goodness, we are done. *
In twelve months (or rather I believe it is fourteen,)
I have earned just i ighfy dollars by my pen — twa little
magazine squibs and one newspaper letter — altogether
the idlest, laziest 14 months I ever spent in my life. And
m that time my absolute and necessary expenses have been
scorchingly heavy — for I have now less than three thousand
six hundred dollars in bank out of the eight or nine
thousand I have made during those months, lecturing.
My expenses were something frightful during the winter.
I feel ashamed of my idleness, and yet I have had really
no inclination to do anything but court Livy. I haven’t
any other inclination yet. I have determined not to work
as hard traveling, any more, as I did last winter, and so
I have resolved not io lecture outside of the G New England
States next winter. My Western course would easily
amount to $10,000, but 1 would rather make 2 or 8
thousand in New England than submit again to so much
wearing travel. (I have promised to talk ten nights for a
thousand dollars in the State of New York, provided the
places arc close together.) But after all if I git located
in a newspaper in a way to suit me. in the meantime, I
don’t want to lecture at all next winter, and probably
shan’t. I most cordially hate the lecture field. And
after all, I shudder to think that 1 may never get out of it.
In all conversations with Gough, and Anna Dickinson,
Nasby, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Wendell Phillips and the
other old stagers, I could not observe that they ever ex-
pected or hoped to get out of the business. I don’t want
to get wedded to it as they arc. Livy thinks we can live
on a very moderate sum and that we’ll not need to
JOURNALISTIC PLANS
08
lecture. I know very well that she can live on a small
allowance, but I am not so sure about myself. I can’t
scare her by reminding her that her father’s family ex-
penses are forty thousand dollars a year, because she
produces the documents at once to show that precious
little of tliis outlay is on her account. But I must not
commence writing about Livy, else 1 shall never stop.
There isn’t such another little piece of perfection in the
world /is she is.
My time is become so short, now, that 1 doubt if I get
to California this summer If I manage to buy into a
paper, I think I will visit you a while and not go to Cal.
at all. I shall know something about it after my next
trip to Hartford. We all go there on the 10th- the whole
family— to attend a wedding, on the 17th. I am offered
an interest in a Cleveland paper which would pay me
$2,800 to $2,500 a year, and a salary added of $3,000.
The salary is fair enough, but the interest is not large
enough, and so I must look a little further. The Cleve-
land folks say they can be induced to do a little better
by me, and urge me to come out and talk business. But
it don’t strike me-— I feel little or no inclination to go.
I believe I haven’t anything else to write, and it is
bed-time. I want to write to Orion, but I keep putting
it off —I keep putting cvcryi hing off. Day after day
Livy and I are together all day long and until 10 at night,
and then I feel dreadfully sleepy. If Orion will bear with
me and forgive me £ will square up with him yet. I
will even let him kiss Livy.
My love to Mollie and Annie and Sammie and all.
Good-bye. »
Affectionately ,
Sam.
The new book was issued in July. In spite of its immediate
success — a success the like of which had scarcely been known
in America — Mark Twain hold himself to be, not a literary man,
but a journalist. lie had no plans for another book ; as a
newspaper owner and editor he expected, with his marriage,
64
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
to settle down and devote the rest of his life to journalism.
The paper was the Buffalo Express ; his interest in it was one-
tliird — the purchase price, twenty-live thousand dollars, of
which ho had paid a part, Jervis Lungdon, his future father-in-
law, having furnished cash and security for the remainder,
lie was already in possession in August, hut he was not regularly
in Buffalo that autumn, for he had agreed with Redpath to
deliver his Quaker City lecture, and the tour would* not emi
until a short time before his wedding-day, February 2, 1870.
Our next letter was sent in response to an invitation from
the New York Society of California Pioneers to attend a banquet
given in New York City, October 13, 1809, and was, of course,
read to the assembled diners.
To the New York Society of California Pioneers, in
New York City :
Elmira, October 11, 1809.
Gentlemen, — Circumstances render it out of my power
to take advantage of the invitation extended to me through
Mr. Simonton, and be present at your dinner at New York.
I regret this very much, for there are several among you
whom I would have a right to join hands with on the score
of old friendship, and I suppose I would have a sublime
general right to shake hands with the rest of you on the
score of kinship in California ups and downs in search of
fortune.
Tf I were to tell some of my experience, you would
recognize California blood in me ; I fancy the old, old story
would sound familiar, no doubt. 1 have the usual stock
of reminiscences. For instance : I went to Esmeralda
early. I purchased largely in the “ Wide West,” “ Winne-
mucca,” and other fine claims, and was very wealthy.
I fared sumptuously on bread when flour was $200 a
barrel and had beans for dinner (‘very Sunday, when none
but bloated aristocrats could afford such grandeur. But
I finished Ly feeding batteries in a quartz mill at $15 a
week, and wishing I was a battery myself and had some-
body to feed me. My claims in Esmeralda arc there
yet. 1 suppose I could be persuaded to sell.
CALIFORNIAN EXPERIENCES
95
I weift to Humboldt District when it was new ; I became
largely interested in the “ Alba Nucva ” and other claims
with gorgeous names, and was rich again — in prospect.
I owned a vast mining property there. I would not
have sold out for less than $400,000 at that time. But
I will now. Finally I walked home — 200 miles — partly
for cxcrdse, and partly because stage fare was expensive.
Next I entered upon an affluent career in Virginia City,
and by a judicious investment of labor and the capital
of friends, became the owner of about all the worthless
wild caf mines there were in that part of the country.
Assessments did the business for me there. There were
a hundred and seventeen assessments to one dividend,
and the proportion of income to outlay was a little against
me. My financial barometer went down to 32 Fahrenheit,
and the subscriber was frozen out.
1 took up extensions on the main lead — extensions that
reached to British America in one direction, and to the
Isthmus of Panama in the other — and I verily believe
I would have been a rich man if I had ever found those
infernal extensions. But I didn’t. I ran tunnels till I
tapped the Arctic Ocean, and I sunk shafts till I broke
through the roof of perdition ; but those extensions turned
up missing every time. I am willing to sell all that property
and throw in the improvements.
Perhaps you remember that celebrated “ North Ophir ” ?
I bought that mine. It was very rich in pure silver.
You could take it out in lumps as large as a filbert. But
when it was discovered that those lumps were melted half
dollars, and hardly melted at that, a painful ease of
“ salting ” was apparent, and the undersign* 1 adjourned
to the poorhousc again.
I paid assessments on “ Hale and Norcross ” until they
sold me out, and I had to take in washing for a living—
and the next month that infamous stock went up to
$7,000 a foot.
I own millions and millions of feet of affluent silver
96 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
leads in Nevada — in fact the entire undercrust ' of that
country nearly, and if Congress would move that State
off my property so that I could get at it, I would be
wealthy yet. But no, there she squats — and here am I.
Failing health persuades ine to sell. If you know of any
one desiring a permanent investment, I can furnish one
that will have the virtue of being eternal. * *
I have been through the California mill, with all its
“ dips, spurs and angles, variations and sinuosities.” I
have worked there at all the different trades and pro-
fessions known to the catalogues. I have bccil every-
thing, from a newspaper editor down to a eow-eateher
on a locomotive, and I am encouraged to believe that if
there had been a few more occupations to experiment on,
I might have made a dazzling success at last, and found
out what mysterious designs Providence had in creating
me.
But you perceive that although I am not a Pioneer,
I have had a sufficient ly variegated Lime of it to enable
me to talk Pioneer like a native, and feel like a Forty-
Niner. Therefore, I cordially welcome you to your old-
remembered homes and your long deserted firesides, and
close this screed with the sincere hope that your visit
here will be a happy one, and not embittered by the sorrow-
ful surprises that absence and lapse of years are wont
to prepare for wanderers ; surprises which come in the
form of old friends missed from their places ; silence where
familiar voices should be ; the young grown old : change and
decay everywhere : home a delusion and a disappointment ;
strangers at hearthstone ; sorrow where gladness was ;
• ears for laughter; the melancholy pomp of death where
the grace of life had been !
With all good wishes for the Returned Prodigals, and
regrets tht 1 1 cannot partake of a small piece of the fatted
calf (rare and no gravy,)
I am yours, cordially,
Mark Twain.
“THE INNOCENTS ABROAD”
97
By tills end of January, 1870, more than thirty thousand
copies of the Innocents had been sold, and in a letter to his
publisher the author expressed his satisfaction.
To Elisha Bliss , in Hartford :
* * Elmira, Jan. 28 '70.
Friend Buss, — . . Yes, I am satisfied with the way
you art* running the ’ You are running it in staving,
tip-top, first-class style ’ never wander into any corner
of the country but I find that an agent has been there
before me, and many of that community have read the
book. And on an average about ten people a day come
and hunt n.t- up to thank me and tell me I’m a benefactor !
1 guess tin-, is a part of tin programme we didn’t expect
in the fi. ,t place.
I think v r arc rushing this book m a manner to be
prone of » ou will mo' * * nest success of it that
h?« eve , h v uh a ,u»" ption book, I believe.
‘Vhnt * ' \ .uu, rstab’ mg agencies, &e., you
>v° got an < lot of machinery under way and
,ud J ’ :> adcrfull ,hw space of time. It is
- i <s , » ir,n n.l that one must be
* looAeo . i . fi »ew‘ialship m order to
. -xuvr ’ is. line ot battle stretohis
m end to , . „ . ' ontinent, and whose forage j <=
skimushevo m.-st v <\ry hamlet and besiege every
u lage hidden aw a,* ‘he ..si space hoi ween.
i’ll back you tigai r > publisher in America, Bliss
— or elsewhere.
Yrs as ever
Cm. MENS
Samuel L. Clemens and Olivia Lnngdon v<n married in
‘he Lungdon home at Elmira, February i?, lt»70 ..ml .ook up
Their residence in Buffalo in a beautiful home, a wedding present
bum the bride’s father.
H
98 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To James Redpath, in Boston :
Elmira, N. Y. May 10, 1870.
Friend Redpath, — I guess I am out of the field per-
manently.
Have got a lovely wife ; a lovely house, bcwitchingly
furnished ; a lovely carriage, and a coachman 'whose '.lyle
and dignity are simply awe-inspiring — nothing less — and
I am making more money than necessary — by considerable,
and therefore why crucify myself nightly on the platform ¥
The subscriber will have to be excused from the present
season at least.
Remember me to Nasby, Billings and Fall. 1 Luck to
you ! I am going to print your menagerie, Parton and all,
and make comments.
In next Galaxy I give Nasby’s friend and mine from
Philadelphia (John Quill, a literary thief) a “ hyste.”
Yours always and after.
Mark.
The reference to the Galaxy in the foregoing letter has to do
with a department called Memoranda, which he had undertaken
to conduct for the new magazine. His mother and sister were
no longer far away in St. Louis. Soon after his marriage they
had, by his advice, taken up residence at Fredonia, New York,
where they could be easily visited from Buffalo.
Altogether, the outlook seemed bright to Mark Twain and
his wife, during the first months of their marriage. Then there
came a change. In a letter which Clemens wrote to his mother
and sister we get the first chapter of disaster.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens, and Mrs. Moffett, in Fredonia, N. Y . :
Elmira, N. Y. Jane 25, 1870.
My Dear Mother and Sister, — We were called here
suddenly by telegram, 8 days ago. Mr. Langdon is very
low. We have well-nigh lost hope — all of us except Livy.
Mr. Langdon, whose hope is one of his most prominent
characteristics, says himself, this morning, that his
1 Redpath 's partner in the lecture lyceum.
ILLNESS OF MR. LANGDON
recovery is only a possibility, not a probability. He made
his will this morning — that is, appointed executors —
nothing else was necessary. The household is sad enough.
Charley is in Bavaria. We telegraphed Munroc & Co.,
Paris, to notify Charley to come home — they sent the
message to Munich. Our message left here at 8 in the
morning and Charley’s answer arrived less than eight
hours afterward. He sailed immediately.
He will reach home two weeks from now. The whole
city is # troubled. As I write (at the office), a dispatch
arrives from Charley who has reached London, and will
sail thence on 28tli. He wants news. We cannot send
him any.
Affectionately
Sam.
P. S. I sent $300 to Fredonia Bank for Ma — It is in
her name.
To Orion Clemens, in St. Louis :
Elmira, July 15, 1870.
My Dear Bro., — P er contract I must have another
600-page book ready for my publisher Jan. 1, and 1 only
began it today. The subject of it is a secret, because I
may possibly change it. But as it stands, I propose to
do up Nevada and Cal., beginning with the trip across
the country in the stage. Have you a memorandum of
the route we took — or the names of any of the Stations
we stopped at ? Do you remember any of the scenes,
names, incidents or adventures of the coach trip ?— for I
remember next to nothing about the matte « Jot down a
foolscap page of items for me. I wish l could have two
days’ talk with you.
I suppose I am to get the biggest copyright, this time,
ever paid on a subscription book in this country.
Give our love to Mollie. — Mr. Langdon is very low.
Yr Bro Sam,
100
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
The “ biggest copyright,” mentioned in this IcttA, was a
royalty of 7| per cent., which Bliss had agreed to pay, on the
retail price of the book. The book was Roughing It, though
this title was not decided upon until considerably later. Orion
Clemens eagerly furnished a detailed memorandum of the route
of their overland journey, which brought this enthusiastic
acknowledgment :
To Orion Clemens , in St. Louis :
Bnf., *1870.
Dear Bro., — I find that your little memorandum book
is going to be ever so much use to me, and will enable me
to make quite a coherent narrative of the Plains journey
instead of slurring it over and jumping 2,000 miles at a
stride. The book I am writing will sell. In return for
the use of the little memorandum book I shall take the
greatest pleasure in forwarding to you the third $1,000
which the publisher of the forthcoming work sends me
— or the first $1,000, I am not particular — they will both
be in the first quarterly statement of account from the
publisher.
In great haste,
Yr Obliged Bro.
Sam.
Love to Mollie. We are all getting along tolerably
well.
Mr. Langdon died early in August, and Mrs. Clemens
returned to Buffalo, exhausted in mind and body. If she hoped
for rest now, in the quiet of her own home, she was disappointed,
as the two brief letters that follow clearly show.
To Mrs. Moffett, in Fredonia, N. Y. :
Buffalo, Aug. 31, '70.
My dear Sister,— I know I ought to be thrashed for
not writing you, but I have kept putting it off. We get
DOMESTIC TROUBLES
101
heaps of letters every day ; it is a comfort to have some-
body like you that will let us shirk and be patient over it.
We got the book and I did think I wrote a line thanking
you for it — but I suppose f neglected it.
We are getting along tolerably well. Mother [Mrs.
Langdouj.is here, and Miss Emma Nye. Livy cannot
sleep since her father’s death — but I give her a narcotic
every night and make her. I am just as busy as I can be
— am fctill writing for the Galaxy and also writing a book
like the Innocents ” in size and style. I have got my
work ciphered down to days, and I haven't a single day to
spare between this and the date which, by written contract
I am to deliver the M.S. of the book to the publisher.
In a hurry
Affectionately
Sam.
To Orion Clemens, in St. Louis :
Buf„ Sept. 9th, 1870.
My Dear Bro, — O here ! I don’t want to be consulted
at all about Tenn. I don’t want it even mentioned to me.
When I make a suggestion it is for you to act upon it or
throw it aside, but I beseech you never to ask my advice,
opinion or consent about that hated property. If it was
because I felt the slightest personal interest in the infernal
land that I ever made a suggestion, the suggestion would
never be made.
Do exactly as you please with the land — always
remember this — that so trivial a percentage as ten per cent,
will never sell it.
It is only a bid for a somnambulist.
I have no time to turn round, a young lady visitor
(schoolmate of Livy’s) is dying in the house of typhoid
fever (parents are in South Carolina) and the premises
are full of nurses and doctors and we are all fagged out.
Yrs. Sam.
102
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
Miss Nyc, who had conic to chccr her old schoolmate, had
been prostrated with the deadly fiver soon after her arrival.
Another period of anxiety and nursing followed. A little more
than a month later, November 7th, Langdon Clemens was
prematurely born. To the Itev. Joseph II. Twichell and wife,
of Hartford, Mark Twain characteristically announced the new
arrival.
To Rev. Joseph H. Twichell and wife, in Hartford, Conn. :
Builalo, Nov. 12, ’70.
C
Dear Uncle and Aunt, — I came into the world on
the 7th inst., and consequently am about five days old,
now. I have had wretched health ever since I made my
appearance. First one thing and then another has kept
me under the weather, and as a general thing I have been
chilly and uncomfortable.
I am not corpulent, nor am 1 robust in any way. At
birth I only weighed pounds with my clothes on — and
the clothes were the chiel feature of the weight, too, I
am obliged to confess. But I am doing finely, all things
considered. I was at a standstill for 3 days and a hall',
but during the last 21 hours I have gained nearly an ounce,
avoirdupois.
They all say I look very old and venerable — and I am
aware, myself, that 1 never smile. Life seems a serious
thing, what I have seen of it — and my observation teaches
me that it is made up mainly of hiccups, unnecessary
washings, and colic. But no doubt you, who are old,
have long since grown accustomed and reconciled to wliat
seems to me such a disagreeable novelty.
My father *said, this morning, when my face was in
repose and thoughtful, that I looked precisely as young
Edward Twichell of Hartford used to look some 12 months
ago— chin, mouth, forehead, expression — everything.
My little mother is very bright and cheery, and I
guess she is pretty happy, but I don’t know what about.
She laughs a great deal, notwithstanding she is sick abed.
THE NEW BABY
108
And she eats a great deal, though .she says that is because
the nurse desires it. And when she has had all the nurse
desires her to have, she asks for more. She is getting
along very well indeed.
My aunt Susie Crane has been here some ten days or
two weeks, but goes home to-day, and Granny Fairbanks
of Cleveland arrives to take her place . 1
Very lovingly,
. Langdon Clemen s.
P. S. Father said I had better write because you
would be more interested in me, just now, than in the
rest of the family.
Clemens had made the acquaintance of the Rev. Joseph
llopkins Twiehell and liis wife during his several sojourns in
Hartford, in connection with his book publication, and the
two men had immediately become firm friends. Twiehell had
come to Elmira in February to the wedding to assist Rev. Thos.
K. Beecher in the marriage ceremony. Joseph Twiehell was a
devout Christian, while Mark Twain was a doubter, even a
scoffer, where orthodoxy was concerned, yet the sincerity and
humanity of the two men drew them together j their friendship
was lifelong.
A second letter to Twiehell, something more than a month
later, shows a somewhat improved condition in the Clemens
household.
To Rev. Twiehell, in Hartford:
Buf., Doo. 19th, 1870.
Dear J. H., — All is well with us, I believe- -though
for some days the baby was quite ill. We consider him
nearly restored to health now, however. Ask my brother
about us — you will find him at Bliss’s publishing office,
where he is gone to edit Bliss’s new paper — left here last
Monday. Make his and his wife’s acquaintance. Take
Mrs. T. to see them as soon as they arc fixed.
Livy is up, and the prince keeps her busy and anxious
1 Mrs. Fairbanks, of the Quaker City excursion
104
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
these latter days and nights, but I am a bachelor up stairs
and don’t have to jump up and get the soothing syrup
— though I would as soon do it as not, I assure you.
(Livy will be certain to read this letter.)
Tell Harmony (Mrs. T.) that I do hold the baby, and
do it pretty handily, too, although with occasio^n^l appre-
hensions that his loose head will fall off. I don’t have
to quiet him — he hardly ever utters a cry. He is always
thinking about something. He is a patient, good little
baby. ,
Smoke ? 1 always smoke from 3 till 5 Sunday after-
noons — and in New York the other day I smoked a week,
day and night. But when Livy is well I smoke only
those two hours on Sunday. I’m “ boss ” of the habit,
now, and shall never let it boss me any more. Originally,
I quit solely on Livy’s account, (not that I believed there
was the faintest reason in the matter, but just as I would
deprive myself of sugar in my coffee if she wished it,
or quit wearing socks if she thought them immoral.) and
I stick to it yet on Livy’s account, and shall always con-
tinue to do so, without a pang. But somehow it seems a
pity that you quit, for Mrs. T. didn’t mind it if I remember
rightly. Ah, it is turning one’s back upon a kindly
Providence to spurn away from us the good creature he
sent to make the breath of life a luxury as well as a neces-
sity, enjoyable as well as useful, to go and quit smoking
when there ain’t any sufficient excuse for it 1 Why, my
old boy, when they use to tell me I would shorten my
life ten years by smoking, they little knew the devotee
they were wasting their puerile word upon - they little
knew how trivial and valueless I would regard a decade
that had no smoking in it ! But I won’t persuade you,
Twichell — I won’t until I see you again— but then we’ll
smoke for n week together, and then shut off again.
1 would have gone to Hartford from New York last
Saturday, but I got so homesick I couldn’t. But maybe
I’ll come sooa.
THOMAS BAILEY ALDRICH 105
No, Sir, catch me in the metropolis again, to get home-
sick.
I didn’t know Warner had a book out.
We send oceans and continents of love — I have worked
myself down, today.
Yrs always
Mark.
Thc.Buffalo Express, under Mark Twain's management, had
become a sort of repository for humorous efforts, often of an
indifferent order. Some of these things, signed by nom dc
plumes , were charged to Mark Twain. When Bret Hartc’s
“ Heathen Chinee devastated the country, and was so widely
parodied, an imitation of it entitled, “ Three Aces,” and signed
“ Carl Bvng,” was printed in the Express. Thomas Bailey
Aldrich, then editor of Every Saturday , had not met Mark
Twain, and, noticing the ursrs printed in the exchanges over
his signature, wa. one -of those w ho accepted them as Mark
Twain’s work, lie wrote rather an uncomplimentary note in
Every Saturday concerning the poem and its authorship,
characterizing it as a feeble imitation of Bret Ilarte’s “ Heathen
Chinee.” Clemens promptly protested to Aldrich, then as
promptly regretted having done so, feeling that he was making
too much of a small matter. Hurriedly he sent a second brief
note.
To Thomas Bailey Aldrich , editor of “ Every Saturday ,”
Boston, Massachusetts :
Buffalo, Jan. 22, 1871.
Dear Sir, — Please do not publish the note I sent you
the other day about “ Ily. Slocum’s ” plagiarism entitled
“ Three Aces ” — it is not important enough for such a
long paragraph. Webb writes me that he iias put in a
paragraph about it, too — and I have requested him to
suppress it. If you would simply state, in a line and a half
under “ Literary Notes,” that you mistook one “ Hy.
Slocum ” (no, it was one “■ Carl Byng ,” I perceive) “ Carl
Byng ” for Mark Twain, and that it was the former who
wrote the plagiarism entitled “ Three Accs,” I think that
106
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
would do a fair justice without any unseemly display. But
it is hard to be accused of plagiarism— a crime I never
have committed in my life.
Yrs. Truly
Mask Twain.
But t his came t oo late. Aldrich replied 1 hat he chifld not be
prevented from doing him justice, as forty-two thousand copies
of the first note, with the editor’s apology duly appended, were
already in press. He would withdraw his apology in the next
number of Every Saturday, if Mark Twain said so. Mark
Twain’s response this time assumed Ihc proportions of‘a letter.
To Thomas Bailey Aldrich, in Boston :
472 Delaware St., Buffalo, Jan. 28.
Dear Mr. Aldrich, — No indeed, don’t take back the
apology ! Hang it, I don’t want to abuse a man’s civility
merely because be gives me the chance.
I hear a good deal about doing things on the “ spur of
the moment ” — I invariably regret the things I do on the
spur of the moment. That disclaimer of mine was a case
in point. I am ashamed every time I think of my burst-
ing out before an unconcerned public with that bombastic
pow-wow about burning publisher’s letters, and all that
sort of imbecility, and about my not being an imitator,
etc. Who would find out that I am a natural fool if I
kept always cool and never let nature come to the surface ?
Nobody.
Hut I did hate to be accused of plagiarizing Bret Ilarte,
who trimmed and trained and schooled me patiently
until he changed me from an awkward utterer of coarse
grotesqucncsses to a writer of paragraphs and chapters that
have found a certain favor in the eyes of even some of
the very decentest people in the land — and this grateful
remembrance of mine ought to be worth its face, seeing
that Bret broke our long friendship a year ago without
any cause or provocation that I am aware of.
A SYMPOSIUM
107
Well, it is funny, the reminiscences that glare out from
murky comers of one’s memory, now and then, without
warning. Just at this moment a picture flits before me :
Scene — private room in Barnum’s Restaurant, Virginia,
Nevada ; present, Artemus Ward, Joseph T. Goodman,
(editor and proprietor Daily “ Enterprise ”), and “ Dan de
Quillc ” ana myself, reporters for same ; remnants of the
feast thin and scattering, but such tautology and repetition
of empty bottles everywhere visible as to be offensive to
the sensitive eye; time, 2.30 a.m. ; Artemus thickly
reciting a poem about a certain infant you wot of, and
interrupting himself and being interrupted every few lines
by poundings of the table and shouts of “ Splendid, by
Shorzhe ! ” Finally, a long, vociferous, poundiferous and
vitreous jingling of applause announces the conclusion,
and then Artemus : 1,4 Let every man ’at loves his fellow
man and ’predates a poet ’at loves his fellow man. stan’
up ! — stan’ up and drink health and long life to Thomas
Bailey Aldrich ! — and drink it stunning ! ” (On all hands
fervent, enthusiastic, and sincerely honest attempts to
comply.) Then Artemus : “ Well — consider it stanning,
and drink it just as ye are ! ” Which was done.
You must excuse all this stuff from a stranger, for the
present , and when I see you 1 will apologize in full.
Do you know the prettiest fancy and the neatest that
ever shot through Ilarte’s brain ? It was this : When
they were trying to decide upon a vignette for the cover
of the Overland, a grizzly bear (of the arms of the State of
California) was chosen. Nahl Bras, carved him and the
page was printed, with him in it, looking thus : [Rude
sketch of a grizzly bear.]
As a bear, he was a success — he was a good bear. —
But then, it was objected, that he was an objectless bear
— a bear that meant nothing in particular, signified nothing,
— simply stood there snarling over his shoulder at nothing —
and was painfully and manifestly a boorish and ill-natured
intruder upon the fair page. All hands said that — none
108
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
were satisfied. They hated badly to give him up, and
yet they hated as much to have him there when there was
no point to him. But presently Harte took a pencil and
drew these two simple lines under his feet and behold he
was a magnificent success ! — the ancient symbol of
California savagery snarling at the approaching type of
high and progressive Civilisation, the first Overland
locomotive ! : [Sketch of a small section of railway track.]
I just think that was nothing less than inspiration
itself. ,
Once more I apologize, and this time I do it “ stanning ” !
Yrs. Truly
Saml. L. Clemens.
The “ two simple lines,” of course, were the train rails under
the bear’s feet, and completed the striking cover design of the
Overland monthly.
The brief controversy over the “ Three Aces ” was the
beginning of a long and happy friendship between Aldrich and
Mark Twain.
In his reply to Clemens’s letter, Aldrich declared that he was
glad now that, for the sake of such a letter, he had accused him
falsely, and added :
“ Mem. Always abuse people.
“ When you come to Boston, if you do not make your
presence manifest to me, I’ll put in a ^ in Every Saturday to the
effect that though you are generally known as Mark Twain your
favourite nom de plume is ‘ Barry Gray.' ”
Buffalo agreed with neither Mrs. Clemens nor the baby.
What with nursing and anguish of mind, Mark Twain found
that he could do nothing on the new book, and that he must
give up his magazine department. lie had lost interest in his
paper and his surroundings in general. Journalism and author-
ship are poor yoke-mates. To Orion Clemens, at this time
editing Bliss’s«paper at Hartford, he explained the situation.
To Orion Clemens, in Hartford :
Buffalo, 4th 1871.
My jjeah Bro, — What I wanted of the “ Liar ” Sketch,
was to worl it into the California book — which 1 shall do.
LITERARY WORK
109
But day "before yesterday I concluded to go out of the
Galaxy on the strength of it, so I have turned it into the
last Memoranda I shall ever write, and published it as a
“ specimen chapter ” of my forthcoming book. —
I have written the Galaxy people that I will never
furnish them another article long or short, for any price
but $500!W> cash — and have requested them not to ask
me for contributions any more, even at that price.
I hope that lets them out, for I will stick to that. Now
dp try and leave me clear out of the Publisher for the
present, for I am endangering my reputation by writing
too much — I want to get out of the public view for
awhile.
I am still nursing Livy night and day and cannot write
anything. I am nearly worn out. We shall go to Elmira
ten days hence (if Livy can travel on a mattress then)
and stay there till I have finished the California book —
say three months. But I can’t begin work right away
when I get there— must have a week’s rest, for I have been
through 30 days’ terrific siege.
That makes it after the middle of March before I can
go fairly to work — and then I’ll have to hump myself
and not lose a moment. You and Bliss just put yourselves
in my place and you will see that my hands are full and
more than full.
When I told Bliss in N. Y. that I would write something
for the Publisher I could not know that I was just about
to lose fifty days. Do you see the difference it makes ?
Just as soon as ever I can, I will send some of the book
M.S., but right in the first chapter I have got to alter the
whole style of one of my characters and *ic- write him
clear through to where I am now. It is no fool of a job,
I can tell you, but the book will be greatly bettered by
it. Hold on a few days — four or five — and I will see if I
can get a few chapters fixed to send to Bliss.
I have offered this dwelling house and the Express for
sale, and when we go to Elmira we leave here for good. I
no
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
shall not select a new home till the book is finished, but
we have little doubt that Hartford will be the place.
We are almost certain of that. Ask Bliss how it would
be to ship our furniture to Hartford, rent an upper room
in a building and unbox it and store it there where s - me- ,
body can frequently look after it. Is not Urn idea good ?
The furniture is worth $10,000 or $12,000 and must not
be jammed into any kind of a place and left unattended
to for a year. • <
The first man that offers $25,000 for our house can take
it — it cost that. What are taxes there ? Here, all bunched
together — of all kinds, they are 7 per cent — simply ruin.
The things you have written in the Publisher are tip-
top. In haste, Yr Bro —
Sam.
There arc no further letters until the end of April, by which
time the situation had improved. Clemens liad sold his interest
in the Express (though at a loss), had severed his magazine
connection, and was located at Quarry Farm, on a beautiful
hilltop above Elmira, the home of Mrs. Clemens's sister, Mrs.
Theodore Crane. The pure air and rest of that happy place,
where they were to spend so many idyllic summers, had proved
beneficial to the sick ones, and work on the new book progressed
in consequence. „
To Elisha Bliss, in Hartford:
Elmira, Monday, May 15th 1871.
Feiend Bliss, — Yrs rec’d enclosing check for $703.35.
The old “ Innocents ” holds out handsomely.
I have MS. enough on hand now, to make (allowing for
engravings) <about 400 pages of the book — consequently
am two-thirds done. I intended to run up to Hartford
about the middle of the week and take it along ; because
it has chapters in it that ought by all means to be in the
prospectus ; but I find myself so thoroughly interested in
my work now (a thing I have not experienced for months)
that 1 can’t bear to lose a single moment of the inspiration.
METHOD OF COMPOSITION 111
So I wilf stay here and peg away as long as it lasts. My
present idea is to write as much more as I have already
written, and then cull from the mass the very best
chapters and discard the rest. I am not half as well
satisfied with the first part of the book as I am with what
I am writing now. When I get it done I want to see the
man who will begin to read it and not finish it. If it falls
short of the “ Innocents ” in any respect I shall lose my
guess. •
When I was writing the “ Innocents ” my daily stunt
was 30 pages of MS and 1 hardly ever got beyond it;
but I have gone over that nearly every day for the last
ten. That shows that I am writing with a red-hot interest.
Nothing grieves me now — nothing troubles me, nothing
bothers me or gets my attention — I don’t think ot
anything but the book,, and I don’t have an hour’s unhappi-
ness about anything, and don’t care two cents whether
school keeps or not. It will be a bully book. If I keep
up my present lick three weeks more I shall be able and
willing to scratch out half of the chapters of the Overland
narrative — and shall do it.
You do not mention having received my second batch
of MS, sent a week or two ago — about 100 pages.
If you want to issue a prospectus and go right to can-
vassing, say the word and I will forward some more MS
— or send it by hand — special messenger. Whatever
chapters you think are unquestionably good, we will
retain of course, so they can go into a prospectus as well one
time as another. The book will be done soon, now. I
have 1200 pages of MS already written and am now writing
200 a week — more than that, in fact; during the past
week wrote 23 one day, then 30, 83, 35, 52, and 05. — How’s
that ?
It will be a starchy book, and should be full of snappy
pictures — especially pictures worked in with the letter-
press. The dedication will be worth the price of the
volume — thus :
112
letters op mark twain
To tke hale Cain,
This Book is Dedicated :
Not on account of respect for his memory, for it merits
little respect ; not on account of sympathy with him, for
his bloody deed placed him without the pale of symp *thy,
strictly speaking : but out of a mere human commiseration
for him that it was his misfortune to live in a dark age
that knew not the beneficent Insanity Plea.
I think it will do.
Yrs. Clemens.
P. S. — The reaction is beginning and my stock is look-
ing up. I am getting the bulliest offers for books and
almanacs ; am flooded with lecture invitations, and one
periodical offers me $0,000 cash for 12 articles, of any
length and on any subject, treated humorously or other-
wise.
Clemens’s enthusiasm for work was now such that he agreed
with Redpath to return to the platform that autumn, and he
began at once writing lectures.
Letters to James Redpath, in Boston :
Elmira, June 27, 1871.
Dear Red, — Wrote another lecture — a third one — to-
day. It is the one I am going to deliver. I think I shall
call it “ Reminiscences of Some Pleasant Characters Whom
I Have Met,” (or should the “ whom ” be left out ?) It
covers my whole acquaintance — kings, lunatics, idiots
and all. Suppose you give the item a start in the Boston
papers. If I write fifty lectures I shall only choose one
and talk that one only.
No sir : Don’t you put that scarecrow (portrait) from
the Galaxy in, I won’t stand that nightmare.
Yours,
Maw
A BIG PRICE
118
Elmira, July 10, 1871.
Bear Red path,— I never made a success of a lecture
delivered in a church yet. People arc afraid to laugh in
a church. They can't be made to do it in any possible way.
Success to Fall’s carbuncle and many happy returns.
Yours,
Mark.
To Mr. Fall, in Boston :
Elmira, N. Y. July 20, 1871.
Friend Fall, — Rcdpath tells me to blow up. Here
goes ! I wanted you to scare Rondout off with a big
price. $125 ain’t big. I got $100 the first time I ever
talked there and now they have a much larger hall. It
is a hard town to get to— 1 run a chance of getting caught
by the ice and missing next engagement. Make the price
$150 and let them draw out.
Yours,
Mark.
Letters to James Rcdpath, in Boston :
Hartford, Tuesday Aug. 8, 1871.
Dear Red, — I am different from other women ; my
mind changes oftener. People who have no mind can
easily be steadfast and firm, but when a man is loaded
down to the guards with it, as 1 am, every heavy sea
of foreboding or inclination, maybe of indolence, shifts
the cargo. See ? Therefore, if you will notice, one week
I am likely to give rigid instructions to coj fine me to
New England ; next week, send me to Arizona ; the next
week withdraw my name ; the next week give you full
untrammelled swing ; and the week following modify it.
You must try to keep the run of my mind, Redpath, it
is your business being the agent, and it always was too
many for me. It appears to me to be one of the finest
114
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
pieces of mechanism I have ever met with. Nbw about
the West, this week, I am willing that you shall retain
all the Western engagements. But what I shall want
next week is still with God.
Let us not profane the mysteries with soiled hands and
prying eyes of sin.
Yours,
Mask.
P. S. Shall be here 2 weeks, will run up there when <
Nasby comes. .
Elmira, N. Y. Sept. 15, 1871.
Dear Redpatii, — I wish you would get me released
from the lecture at Buffalo. I mortally hate that society
there, and I don’t doubt they hired me. I once gave them
a packed house free of charge, and they never even had
the common politeness to thank me. They left me to
shift for myself, too, k la Bret Harte at Harvard. Get me
rid of Buffalo ! Otherwise I’ll have no recourse left but
to get sick the day I lecture there. I can get sick easy
enough, by the simple process of saying the word — well
never mind what word — I am not going to lecture there.
Yours,
Mark.
The house they had taken in Hartford was the Hooker
property on Forest Street, a handsome place in a distinctly
literary neighbourhood. Harriet Beecher Stowe, Charles Dudley
Warner, and other well-known writers were witliin easy walking
distance ; Twichell was perhaps half a mile away. But a
lecture circuit cannot be restricted to the radius of Boston.
Clemens was presently writing to Itcdpath from Washington
and points farther west.
To James Kedpath, in Boston :
Washington, Tuesday, Oot. 28, 1871.
Dear Red, — I have come square out, thrown “ Remi-
niscences ” overboard, and taken “ Artemus Ward,
CHOICE OF LECTURING SUBJECTS 115
Humorist,*’ for my subject. Wrote it here on Friday and
Saturday, and read it from MS last night to an enormous
house. It suits me and I’ll never deliver the nasty,
nauseous “ Reminiscences ” any more.
Yours,
Mark.
The Arlcmus Ward lecture lasted eleven days, then he wrote :
To Rcdpath and Fait, in Boston :
Buffalo Depot, Deo. 8, 1871.
Redpath & Fall, Boston, — Notify all hands that from
this time I shall talk nothing but selections from my forth-
coming book “ Roughing It.” Tried it last night. Suits
me tip-top.
Sam’l L. Clemens.
The Roughing It chapters proved a success, and continued
in high favour through the rest of the season.
To James Redpath, in Boston :
Logansport, Ind. Jan. 2, 1872.
Friend Redpath, — Had a splendid time with a splendid
audience in Indianapolis last night — a perfectly jammed
house, just as I have had all the time out here. I like the
new lecture but I hate the “ Artemus Ward ” talk and
won’t talk it. any more. No man ever approved that
choice of subject in my hearing, I think.
Give me some comfort. If I am to talk in New York,
am I going to have a good house ? I don’t care now to have
any appointments cancelled. I’ll even “ fetch ” those
Dutch Pennsylvanians with this lecture.
Have paid up $4000 indebtedness. You are the last
on my list. Shall begin to pay you in a few days and then
I shall be a free man again.
Yours,
Mark.
116
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
With his debts paid, Clemens was anxious to be getting home.
Two weeks following the above he wrote Rcdpath that he would
accept no more engagements at any price, outside of New
England, and added, “ The fewer engagements I have from
this time forth the better I shall be pleased.” By the end of
February he was back in Hartford, refusing an engagement in
Boston, and announcing to Redpath, “ If I had another engage- *
ment I’d rot before I’d fill it.” From which w£ gather that *
he was not entirely happy in the lecture field.
Meantime, Roughing It had appeared and was selling abun-
dantly. Mark Twain, free of debt, and in pleasai\t circum-
stances, felt that the outlook was bright. It became even more so*
when, in March, the second child, a little girl, Susy* was bom,
with no attending misfortunes. But, then, in the early summer
little Langdon died. It was seldom, during all of Mark Twain’s
life, that he enjoyed more than a brief period of unmixed
happiness.
It was in June of that year that Clemens wrote his first
letter to William Dean Howells — the first of several hundred
that would follow in the years to come, and has in it something
that is characteristic of nearly all the Clcmcns-Howclls letters —
a kind of tender playfulness that answered to something in
Ilowells’s make-up, his sense of humour, his wide knowledge of
a humanity which he pictured so amusingly to the world.
To William Dean Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, June 15, 1872.
Friend Howells, — Could you tell me how 1 could get
a copy of your portrait as published in Hearth and Home ?
I hear so much talk about it as being among the finest
works of art which have yet appeared in that journal, that
I feel a strong desire to see it. Is it suitable for framing ?
I have written the publishers of H & II time and again,
but they say that the demand for the portrait immediately
exhausted the edition and now a copy cannot be had, even
for the European demand, which has now begun. Bret
Harte has been here, and says his family would not be
without that portrait for any consideration. He says his
children get up in the night and yell for it. I would give
anything for a copy of that portrait to put up in my
A PORTRAIT OF W. D. HOWELLS 117
parlor. I have Oliver Wendell Holmes’s and Bret Harte’s,
as published in Every Saturday, and of all the swarms
that come every day to gaze upon them none go away
that are not softened and humbled and made more resigned
*to the will of God. Tf I had yours to put up alongside
of them, I “believe the combination would bring more
souls to earnest reflection and ultimate conviction of their
lost condition, than any other kind of warning would.
Where in the nation can I get that portrait ? Here are
heaps of people that want it, — that need it. There is my
uncle, lie wants a copy. He is lying at the point of
death. He has been lying at the point of death for two
years. He wants a copy — and I want him to have a copy.
And I want you to send a copy to the man that shot
my dog. I want to see if he is dead to every human
instinct.
Now you send me that portrait. I am sending you
mine, in this letter ; and am glad to do it, for it has been
greatly admired. People who are judges of art, find in
the execution a grandeur which has not been equalled
in this country, and an expression which has not been
approached in any.
Yrs truly,
S. L. Clemens.
\
P. S. 62,000 copies of “ Roughing It ” sold and
delivered in 4 months.
The Clemens family did not spend the summer at Quarry
Farm that year. The sea air was prescribed for Mrs. Clemens
and the baby, and they went to Say brook, Connecticut, to
Fenwick Hall. Clemens wrote very little, though die seems to
have planned Tom Sawyer, and perhaps made its earliest
beginning, which was in dramatic form.
His mind, however, was otherwise aeiive. He was always
more or less given to inventions, and in his next letter we find
a description of one which he brought to comparative per-
fection.
He had also conceived the idea of another book of travel, and
this was his purpose of a projected trip to England,
138 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To Orion Clemens, in Hartford :
Fenwick Hall, Saybrook, Conn. Aug. 11, 1872.
My dear Bro, — I shall sail for England in the Scotia,
Aug. 21. t
But what I wish to put on record now, is my new ,
invention — hence this note, which you will preserve. It
is this — a self -'pasting scrap-book — good enough idea if
some juggling tailor does not come along and ante-date,
me a couple of months, as in the case of the elastic
vest-strap.
The nuisance of keeping a scrap-book is : 1. One never
has paste or gum tragacanth handy ; 2. Mucilage won’t
stick, or stay, 4 weeks ; 3. Mucilage sucks out the ink
and makes the scraps unreadable ; 4. To daub and paste
8 or 4 pages of scraps is tedious, slow, nasty and tiresome.
My idea is this : Make a scrap-book with leaves veneered
or coated with gurn-stickum of some kind ; wet the page
with sponge, brush, rag or tongue, and dab on your scraps
like postage stamps.
Lay on the gum in columns of stripes.
Each stripe of gum the length of say 20 ems, small pica,
and as broad as your finger ; a blank about as broad as
your finger between each 2 stripes — so in wetting the
paper you need not wet any more of the gum than your
scrap or scraps will cover — then you may shut up the book
and the leaves won’t stick together.
Preserve, also, the envelope of this letter — postmark
ought to be good evidence of the date of this great humaniz-
ing and civilizing invention.
I’ll put jt into Dan Slote’s hands and tell him he must
send you all over America to urge its use upon stationers
and booksellers — so don’t buy into a newspaper. The name
of this thing is “ Mark Twain’s Self-Pasting Scrap-book.”
All well here. Shall be up 2 p. m. Tuesday. Send the
carriage.
Yr Bro.
S. L. Oilmens.
RECEPTION IN LONDON
119
Clemens did, in fact, sail for England on the given date,
and was lavishly received there. All literary London joined
in giving him a good time. He had not as yet been received
seriously by the older American men of letters, but England
made no question as to his title to first rank. Already, too,
they classified him as of the human type of Lincoln, and revelled
in him without stint. Howells writes : “ In England, rank,
fashion, and* culture rejoiced in him. Lord Mayors, Lord Chief
Justices, and magnates of many kinds were his hosts.”
He was treated so well and enjoyed it all so much that he
could not write a book — the kind of book he had planned.
One could not poke fun at a country or a people that had
welcomed him with open arms. He made plenty of notes, at
first, but presently gave up the book idea and devoted himself
altogether to having a good time.
To Mrs. Clemens, in Hartford :
London, Sep. 15, 1872.
Livy, darling, everybody says lecture — lecture— lecture
— but I have not the least idea of doing it — certainly not
at present. Mr. Dolby, who took Dickens to America,
is coming to talk business to me tomorrow, though I
have sent him word once before, that I can’t be hired to
talk here, because I have no time to spare.
There is too much sociability — I do not get along fast
enough with work. Tomorrow I lunch with Mr. Toole
and a Member of Parliament — Toole is the most able
Comedian of the day. And then I am done for a while.
On Tuesday I mean to hang a card to my keybox, in-
scribed — “ Gone out of the City for a week ” — and then I
shall go to work and work hard. One can’t be caught in
a hive of 4,000,000 people, like this.
I have got such a perfectly delightful razor. I have a
notion to buy some for Charley, Theodore and Slee —
for I know they have no such razors there. I have got a
neat little watch-chain for Annie — $20.
I love you my darling. My love to all of you.
Saml.
120
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
To Elisha Bliss, in Hartford:
tondon, Sept 28, 1872.
Friend Bliss, — I have been received in a sort of
mendous way, tonight, by the brains of London, assembl d
nt the annual dinner of the Sheriffs of London — mine
being (between you and me) a name which w&s* received
with a flattering outburst of spontaneous applause when
the long list of guests was called.
I might have perished on the spot but for the friendly
support and assistance of my excellent friend Sir John
Bennett — and I want you to paste the enclosed in a
couple of the handsomest copies of the “ Innocents ”
and “ Roughing It,” and send them to him. His address
is —
“ Sir John Bennett,
Cheapside,
London.”
Yrs Truly
S. L. Clemf.ns.
The “ relating circumstances ” were* these : At the above-
mentioned dinner there had been a roll-call of the distinguished
guests present, and each name had been duly applauded.
Clemens, conversing in a whisper with his neighbour, Sir John
Bennett, did not give very elose attention to the names, ap-
plauding meehanically with the others.
Finally, a name was read that brought out a vehement
hand-clapping. Mark Twain, not to be outdone in cordiality,
joined vigorously, and kept his hands going even after the
others finished. Then, remarking the general laughter, he
wliispered to Sir John : “ Whose name was that we were just
applauding ? ”
“ Murk Twain’s.”
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett :
London, Nov. 0, 1872.
My dear Mother and Sister, — I have been so ever-
lasting busy that I couldn't^-writc — and moreover I have
SECOND LONDON VISIT
121
been so unceasingly lazy that I couldn’t have written any-
how. I came here to take notes for a book, but I haven’t
done much but attend dinners and make speeches. But
have had a jolly good time and I do hate to go away from
these English folks ; they make a stranger feel entirely
at home— and they laugh so easily that it is a comfort
to make after-dmner speeches here. I have made hundreds
of friends ; and last night in the crush of the opening
of the 'New Guild-hall Library and Museum, I was sur-
prised meet a familiar face every few steps. Nearly
4,000 people, of both sexes, came and went during the
evening, so I had a good opportunity to make a great
many new acquaintances.
Livy is willing to come here with me next April and
stay several months — so I am going home next Tuesday.
I would sail on Saturday, but that is the day of the Lord
Mayor’s annual grand state dinner, when they say 900
of the great men of the city sit down to table, a great many
of them in their fine oflicial and court paraphernalia, so
I must not miss it. However, I may yet change my mind
and sail Saturday. I am looking at a fine Magic lantern
which will cost a deal of money, and if I buy it Sammy
may come and learn to make the gas and work the
machinery, and paint pictures for it on glass. I mean to
give exhibitions for charitable purposes in Hartford, and
charge a dollar a head.
In a hurry, Yrs aflly
Sam.
On his second visit to London Mark Twain was literally over-
whelmed with honours and entertainment, his rooms at the
Langham were like a court. Such men as ltdoert Browning,
Turgenieff, Sir John Millais, and Charles Kingsley hastened to
call. Kingslc y and others gave him dinners. Mrs. Clemens to
her sister wrote : “It is perfectly discouraging to try to write
you.”
The continuous excitement presently told on her. In July
all further engagements were cancelled, and Clemens took his
little family to Scotland, for quiet and rest. They broke the
122
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
journey at York, and it was there that Mark Twain wrote the
only letter remaining from this time.
Part oj a letter to Mrs. Jervis Langdon, of Elmira, N. Y. :
For the present we shall remain in this queer oljl walled
town, with its crooked, narrow lanes, that tell us of their
old day that knew no wheeled vehicles ; its plaster-and-
tiinbcr dwellings, with upper stories far overhanging the
street, and thus marking their date, say three hundred
years ago; the stately city walls, the castellated gates,
the ivy-grown, foliage-sheltered most noble and picturesque
ruin of St. Mary’s Abbey, suggesting their date, say five
hundred years ago, in the heart of Crusading times and
the glory of English chivalry and romance; the vast
Cathedral of York, with its worn carvings and quaintly
pictured windows, preaching of still remoter days ; the
outlandish names of streets and courts and byways that
stand as a record and a memorial, all these centuries,
of Danish dominion here in still earlier times ; the hint
here and there of King Arthur and his knights and their
bloody fights with Saxon oppressors round about this
old city more than thirteen hundred years gone by ; and,
last of all, the melancholy old stone coflins and sculptured
inscriptions, a venerable arch and a hoary tower of stone
that still remain and are kissed by the sun and caressed
by the shadows every day, just as the sun and the shadows
have kissed and caressed them every lagging day since
the Roman Emperor’s soldiers placed them here in the
times when Jesus the Son of Mary walked the streets
of Nazareth a* youth, with no more name or fame than
the Yorkshire boy who is loitering down this street this
moment.
Their destination was Edinburgh, where they remained a
month. Mrs. Clemens’s health gave way on their arrival there,
and her husband, knowing the name of no other physician in
the plucc, looked up Dr. John Brown, author of Rob and Uis
A STOWAWAY
123
Friends, and found in him not only a skilful practitioner, but a
lovable companion, to whom they all became deeply attached.
Little Susy, now seventeen months old, became his special
favourite. He named her Megalops, because of her great eyes.
Mrs. Clemens regained her strength and they returned to
London. Clemens, still urged to lecture, finally agreed with
George ^Dolby to a week’s engagement, and added a promise
that after taking his wife and daughter back to America be
would return immediately for a more ( x tended course. Dolby
announced him to app< ar at the Queen’s Concert Rooms, Han-
o\ cr Square, for the week of October 13-18, his lecture to be the
old Sapdwich Islands talk that seven years before had brought
him his first suecc ss. The great hall, the largest in London, was
thronged at each appearance, and the papers declared that
Mark Twain had no more than “ whetted the public appetite ”
for his humour. Three days later, October 21, 1873, Clemens,
with his little party, sailed for home. Halfway across the
ocean he wrote the iriend they had left in Scotland :
To Dr. John Brown, in Edinburgh :
Mid-Atlantic, Oct. 30, 1873.
Our dear friend the doctor, — We have plowed a
long way over the sea, and there’s twenty-two hundred
miles of restless water between us, now, besides the railway
stretch. And yet you are so present with us, so close to
us that a span and a whisper would bridge the distance.
The first three days were stormy, and wife, child, maid,
and Miss Spaulding were all sea-sick 25 hours out of the
24, and I was sorry I ever started. However, it has been
smooth, and balmy, and sunny and altogether lovely for
a day or two now, and at night there is a broad luminous
highway stretching over the sea to the moon, over which
the spirits of the sea are traveling up and down all through
the secret night and having a genuine good time, I make
no doubt.
Today they discovered a “ collie ” on board ! I find
(as per advertisement which I sent you) that they won’t
carry dogs in these ships at any price. This one has been
concealed up to this time. Now his owner has to pay
i n
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
£10 or heave him overboard. Fortunately the doggie is
a performing doggie and the money will be paid. So
after all it was just as well you didn’t intrust your collie
to us.
A poor little child died at midnight and was buried at
dawn this morning — sheeted and shotted, and sunk- in the
middle of the lonely ocean in water three thousand fathoms
deep. Pity the poor mother.
With our love.
S. L. Clemens.
Mark Twain was back in London, lecturing again at the
Queen’s Concert Rooms, after barely a month’s absence.
Charles Waricn Stoddard, whom he had known in California,
shared his apartment at the Langham, and acted as his secretary.
He remained in London two months, lecturing steadily at
Hanover Square to full houses.
To Dr. John Brown, in Edinburgh :
Farmington Avenue, Hartford,
Feby. 28, 1874.
My dear Friend, — We are all delighted with your com-
mendations of the “ Gilded Age ” — and the more so because
some of our newspapers have set forth the opinion that
Wai-ner really wrote the book and I only added my name
to the title page in order to give it a larger sale. I wrote
the first eleven chapters, every word and every line. I
also wrote chapters 24, 25, 27, 28, 30, 32, 83, 34, 36, 37,
VI, 43, 45, 51, 52, 53, 57, 59, CO, 61, 62, and portions of 85,
49 and 56. So I wrote 32 of the 63 chapters entirely and
part of 3 others beside.
The fearful financial panic hit the book heavily, for we
published it in the midst of it. But nevertheless in the 8
weeks that have now elapsed since the day we published,
we have sold 40,000 copies ; which gives £8,000 royalty to
be divided between the authors. This is really the largest
two-months’ sale which any American book has ever
achieved (unless one excepts the cheaper editions of Uncle
MARRIED LIFE
125
♦
Tom’s Cabin). The average price of our book is 16 shillings
a copy — Uncle Tom was 2 shillings a copy. But for
the panic our sale would have been doubled, I verily
believe. I do not believe the sale will ultimately go over
100,000 copies.
I shipped to you, from Liverpool, Darley’s Illustrations
of Judfl’s “ Margaret ” (the waiter at the Adelphi Hotel
agreeing to ship it securely per parcel delivery,) and I do
hope it did not miscarry, for we in America think a deal of
Darley’s 1 work. I shipped the novel (“ Margaret ”) to
you frbm here a week ago.
Indeed I am thankful for the wife and the child — and if
there is one individual creature on all this footstool who
is more thoroughly and uniformly and unceasingly happy
than I am I defy the world to produce him and prove him.
In my opinion, he doesn’t exist. I was a mighty rough,
coarse, unpromising subject when Livy took charge of me
4 years ago, and I may still be, to the rest of the world,
but not to her. She has made a very creditable job
of me.
Success to the Mark Twain Club ! — and the novel
shibboleth of the Whistle. Of course any member rising to
speak would be required to preface his remark with a keen
respectful whistle at the chair — the chair recognizing the
speaker with an answering shriek, and then as the speech
proceeded, its gravity and force would be emphasized and
its impressiveness augmented by the continual interjection
of whistles in place of punctuation-pauses ; and the
applause of the audience would be manifested in the same
way. . . .
They’ve gone to luncheon, and I must follow. With
strong love from us both.
your friend,
Saml. L. Clemens.
1 Felix Ootavius Carr Dsfrley, 1822-1888, illustrator of the works
of Irving, Cooper, etc. Probably tho most distinguished American
illustrator of his time.
126 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To Dr. John Brown, in Edinburgh:
Elmira, N. Y., April 27, '74.
Dear Doctor, — This town is in the interior of the State
of New York — and was my wife’s birth-place. We are
here to spend the whole summer. Although it is so near
summer, we had a great snow-storm yesterday,, and one
the day before. This is rather breaking in upon our plans,
as it may keep us down here in the valley a trifle longer
than wc desired. It gets fearfully hot here in the summer,
so we spend our summers on top of a hill 6 or 700 feet high,
about two or three miles from here — it never gets hot Tip
there.
Mrs. Clemens is pretty .strong, and so is the “ little
wifie ” barring a desperate cold in the head — the child
grows in grace and beauty marvellously. I wish the
nations of the earth would combine in a baby show and
give us a chance to compete. I must try to find one of her
latest photographs to enclose in this. And this reminds
me that Mrs. Clemens keeps urging me to ask you for your
photograph and last night she said, “ and be sure to ask
him for a photograph of his sister, and Jock — but say
Master Jock — do not be headless and forget that courtesy ;
he is Jock in our memories ami our talk, but he has a right
to his title when a body uses his name in a letter.” Now
I have got it all in. — I can’t have made any mistake this
time. Miss Clara Spaulding looked in, a moment, yester-
day morning, as bright and good as ever. She would like
to lay her love at your feet if she knew I was writing — as
would also fifty friends of ours whom you have never seen,
and whose homage is as fervent as if the cold and clouds
and darkness bf a mighty sea did not lie between their
hearts and you. Poor old Rab had not many “ friends ”
at first, but if all his friends of today could gather to his
grave from the four corners of the earth what a procession
there would be 1 And Rab’s friends are your friends.
I am going to work when we get on the hill — till then
THE FAMILY
127
I’ve got’ to He fallow, albeit against my will. We join in
love to you and yours.
Your friend ever,
Saml. L. Clemens.
P. S. I enclose a specimen of villainy. A man pre-
tends to be my brother and my lecture agent — gathers
a great audience together in a city more than a thousand
miles from here, and then pockets the money and elopes,
leaving the audience to wait for the imaginary lecturer ! I
am after him with the law.
It was a historic summer at the Farm. A new baby arrived
in June ; a new study was built for Mark Twain by Mrs. Crane,
on the hillside near the old quarry ; a new book was begun in
it — The Adventures of Tom Sawyer — and a play, the first that
Mark Twain had really attempted, was completed — the drama-
tization of The Gilded Age.
An early word went to Hartford of conditions at the Farm.
To Rev. and Mrs. Twichell, in Hartford :
Elmira, Juno 11, '74
My dear old Joe and Harmony, — The baby is here
and is the great American Giantess — weighing 7f pounds.
We had to wait a good long time for her, but she was full
compensation when she did come.
The Modoc was delighted with it, and gave it her doll at
once. There is nothing selfish about the Modoc. She is
fascinated with the new baby. The Modoc rips and tears
around out doors, most of the lime, and consequently is as
hard as a pine knot and as brown as an Indian. She is
bosom friend to all the ducks, chickens, turkevs and guinea
hens on the place. Yesterday as she marched along the
winding path that leads up the hill through the red clover
beds to the summer-house, there was a long procession of
these fowls stringing contentedly after her, led by a stately
rooster who can look over the Modoc’s head. The devotion
of these vassals has been purchased with daily largess of
128 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Indian meal, and so the Modoc, attended by her body-
guard, moves in state wherever she goes.
Susie Crane has built the loveliest study for me, you
ever saw. It is octagonal, with a peaked roof, each
octagon filled with a spacious window, and it sits perched
in complete isolation on top of an elevation that com-
mands leagues of valley and city and retreating ranges of
distant blue hills. It is a cosy nest, with just room in it
for a sofa and a table and three or four chairs — and when
the storms sweep down the remote valley and the lightning
flashes above the hills beyond, and the rain beats upon
the roof over my head, imagine the luxury of it 1 It
stands 500 feet above the valley and 2 \ miles from it.
{ However one must not write all day. We send con-
tinents of love to you and yours.
Affectionately
Mark.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Elmira, Aug. 22, 1874.
Dear Howells, — I have just finished reading the
‘ Foregone Conclusion ’ to Mrs. Clemens and we think you
have even outdone yourself. I should think that this
must be the daintiest, truest, most admirable workman-
ship that was ever put on a story. The creatures of
God do not act out their natures more unerringly than
yours do. If your genuine stories can die, I wonder
by what right old Walter Scott’s artificialities shall continue
to live.
I brought Mrs. Clemens back from her tnp in a dread-
fully broken-down condition — so by the doctor’s orders we
unpacked the trunks sorrowfully to lie idle here another
month instead of going at once to Hartford and proceeding
to furnish the new house which is now finished. We hate
to have it go longer desolate and tenantless, but cannot
help it.
“A TRUE StfORY”
126
By and by, if the madam gets strong again, we are
hoping to have the Grays there, and you and the Aldrich
households, and Osgood, down to engage in an orgy with
them.
Ys Ever
Mark.
Howells was editor of the Atlantic by this time, and had been
urging Clemens to write something suitable for that magazine.
He had* done nothing, however, until tliis summer at Quarry
Farm. There, one night in the moonlight, Mrs. Crane’s coloured
cook, who had been a slave, was induced to 1 ell him her story.
It was exactly the story to appeal to Mark Twain, and the kind
of thing he could write. He set it down next morning, as nearly
in her own words and manner as possible, without departing
too far from literary requirements.
To W. D . Howells , in Boston :
Elmira, Sept. 2, ’74.
My dear Howells, — . . . 1 enclose also a “ True
Story ” which has no humor in it. You can pay as lightly
as you choose for that, if you want it, for it is rather out of
my line, I have not altered the old colored woman’s
story except to begin at the beginning, instead of the
middle, as she did —and traveled both ways. . ,
Yrs Ever
Mark.
Along with the “ True Story ” Mark Twain had sent the
1,1 Fable for Good Old Boys and Girls ” ; but this Howells
returned, not, as he said, because lie didn’t like it, but because
the Atlantic on matters of religion was just in that Good Lord,
Good Devil condition when a little fable like yours wouldn’t
leave it a single Presbyterian, Baptist, Unitarian' Episcopalian,
Methodist, or Millerite paying subscriber, while all the dead-
heads would stick to it and abuse it in the denominational
newspapers ! ”
But the shorter MS. had been only a brief diversion.
Clemens had all along intended to dramatize the story of Colonel
Sellers, and was one day thunderstruck to receive word from
California that a San Francisco dramat ist had appropriated his
• K
E
180
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
character in a play written for John T. Raymond. Clemens
hod taken out dramatic copyright on The Gilded Age, and
immediately stopped the performance by telegraph. A corre-
spondence between the author and the dramatist followed,
leading to a friendly arrangement by which the latter agreed
to dispose of his version to Mark Twain.
To Mrs. Clemens — intended for Howells, Aldrich, etc.
Boston, Nov. 16, 1936. {1874]
Dear Livy, — You observe I still call this beloved old
place by the name it had when 1 was young. Limerick !
It is enough to make a body sick.
The gcntlemen-in-waiting stare to see me sit here
telegraphing this letter to you, and no doubt they are
smiling in their sleeves. But let them ! The slow old
fashions are good enough for me, thank God, and I will none
other. When I see one of these modern fools sit absorbed,
holding the end of a telegraph wire in his hand, and reflect
that a thousand miles away there is another fool hitched to
the other end of it, it makes me frantic with rage ; and then
am I more implacably fixed and resolved than ever, to
continue taking twenty minutes to telegraph you what I
communicate in ten seconds by the new way if I would
so debase myself. And when I see a whole silent, solemn
drawing-room full of idiots sitting with their hands on
each other’s foreheads “ communing,” I tug the white
hairs from my head and curse till my asthma brings me
the blessed relief of suffocation. In our old day such a
gathering talked pure drivel and “ rot,” mostly, but better
that, a thousand times, than these dreary conversational
funerals that«oppress our spirits in this mad generation.
It is sixty years since I was here before. I walked
hither, then, with my precious old friend. It seems in-
credible, now, that we did it in two days, but such is my
recollection. I no longer mention that we walked back
in a single day, it makes me so furious to see the doubt in
face of the hearer. Men were men in those old times.
AN EXTRAVAGANZA
131
Think of one of the puerile organisms in this effeminate age
attempting such a feat.
My air-ship was delayed by a collision with a fellow
from China loaded with the usual cargo of jabbering,
copper-colored missionaries, and so I was nearly an hour on
my jourijey. But by the goodness of God thirteen of the
missionaries were crippled and several killed, so I was con-
tent to lose the time. I love to lose time, anyway, because
it brings soothing reminiscences of the creeping railroad
days of pld, now lost to us forever.
Our game was neatly played, and successfully. — None
expected us, of course. You should have seen the guards
at the ducal palace stare when I said, “ Announce his grace
the Archbishop of Dublin and the Rt. Hon. the Earl of
Hartford.” Arrived within, we were all eyes to see the
Duke of Cambridge and his Duchess, wondering if we
might remember their faces, and they ours. In a moment,
they came tottering in ; he, bent and withered and bald ;
she blooming with wholesome old age. He peered through
his glasses a moment, then screeched in a reedy voice :
“ Come to my arms 1 Away with titles — I’ll know ye by
no names but Twain and Twichell ! ” Then fell he on our
necks and jammed his trumpet in his ear, the which we
filled with shoutings to this effect : “ God bless you, old
Howells, what is left of you I ”
We talked late that night — none of your silent idiot
“ communings ” for us — of the olden time. We rolled a
stream of ancient anecdotes over our tongues and drank
till the lord Archbishop grew so mellow in the mellow past
that Dublin ceased to be Dublin to him and resumed its
sweeter forgotten name of New York. In truth he almost
got back into his ancient religion, too, good Jesuit as he
has always been since O’Mulligan the First established
that faith in the Empire.
And we canvassed everybody. Bailey Aldrich, Marquis
of Ponkapog, came in, got nobly drunk, and told us all
about how poor Osgood lost his earldom and was hanged
182 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
for conspiring against the second Emperor— but lie
mention how near he himself came to being hanged, too,
for engaging in the same enterprise. He was as chaffy as
he was sixty years ago, too, and swore the Archbishop
and I never walked to Boston— but there was never a day
that Ponkapog wouldn’t lie, so be it by the grace of Gcu
he got the opportunity.
The Lord High Admiral came in, a hale gentleman close
upon seventy and bronzed by the suns and storms of many
climes and scarred with the wounds got in many battles,
and I told him how I had seen him sit in a high clhair and
cat fruit and cakes and answer to the name of Johnny.
His granddaughter (the eldest) is but lately married to the
youngest of the Grand Dukes, and so who knows but a day
may come when the blood of the Howells’s may reign in
the land ? 1 must not forget to say, while I think of it,
that your new false teeth are done, my dear, and your
wig. Keep your head well bundled with a shawl till the
latter comes, and so cheat your persecuting neuralgias and
rheumatisms. Would you believe it ? — the Duchess of
Cambridge is deafer than you — deafer than her husband
They call her to breakfast with a salvo of artillery ; and
usually when it thunders she looks up expectantly and
says “ come in. . . .”
The monument to the author of “ Gloverson and His
Silent Partners ” is finished. It is the stateliest and the
costliest ever erected to the memory of any man. This
noble classic has now been translated into all the languages
of the earth and is adored by all nations and known to all
creatures. Yet I have conversed as familiarly with the
author of it as 1 do with my own great-grandchildren.
I wish you could sec old Cambridge and Ponkapog. I
love them as dearly as ever, but privately, my dear, they
are not much improvement on idiots. It is melancholy
to hear them jabber over the same pointless anecdotes
three and four limes of an evening, forgetting that they
had jabbered them over three or four times the evening
A TITLE
183
before. Ponkapog still writes poetry, but the old-time
fire has mostly gone out of it. Perhaps his best effort of
late years is this :
“0 soul, soul, soul of mine.
Soul, soul, soul of thine !
Thy soul, my soul, two souls entwine,
And sing thy lauds in crystal wine ! ”
Thi3 he goes about repeating to everybody, daily and
nightly, .insomuch that he is become a sore affliction to all
that know him.
But I must desist. There are drafts here, everywhere,
and my gout is something frightful. My left foot hath
resemblance to a snuff- bladder.
God be with you.
Hartford.
These to Lady Hartford, in the earldom of Hartford, in
the upper portion of the city of Dublin.
To If. D. Howells, in Boston :
Dec. 3, 1874.
My dear Howells, — Let us change the heading to
“ Piloting on the Miss in the Old Times ” — or to “ Steam-
boating on the M. in Old Times ” — or to “ Personal Old
Times on the Miss.” — We could change it for Feb. if now
too late for Jan. — I suggest it because the present heading
is too pretentious, too broad and general. It seems to
command me to deliver a Second Book of Revelation to the
world, and cover all the Old Times the Mississippi (dang
that word, it is worse than “ type ” or “ Egypt ”) ever saw
— whereas here I have finished Article No. Ill and am
about to start on No. 4 and yet I have spoken of nothing
but of Piloting as a science so far ; and I doubt if I ever
get beyond that portion of my subject. And I don’t care
to. Any muggins can write about Old Times on the Miss.
184
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
of 500 different kinds, but I am the only man alive that
can scribble about the piloting of that day — and no man
ever has tried to scribble about it yet. Its newness pleases
me all the time — and it is about the only new subject I
know of. If I were to write fifty articles they would all be
about pilots and piloting — therefore let’s get the word
Piloting into the heading. There’s a sort of freshness
about that, too.
Ys ever, *
Mark.
t
But Howells thought the title satisfactory, and indeed it was
the best that could have been selected for the scries. He wrote
every few days of his delight in the papers, and cautioned the
author not to make an attempt to please any “ supposed Atlantic
audience,” adding, “ Yarn it off into my sympathetic ear.”
Clemens replied :
To W. D Ilowells, in Boston :
H’tf’cL Dec. 8, 1874
My dear Howells, — It isn’t the Atlantic audience that
distresses me ; for it is the only audience that I sit down
before in perfect serenity (for the simple reason that it
doesn’t require a “ humorist ” to paint himself striped and
stand on his head every fifteen minutes.) The trouble
was, that I was only bent on “ working up an atmosphere ”
and that is to me a most fidgety and irksome thing, some-
times. I avoid it, usually, but in this case it was absolutely
necessary, else every reader would be applying the atmo-
sphere of his own or sea experiences, and that shirt wouldn’t
fd, you know*
I could have sent this Article II a week ago, or more, but
I couldn’t bring myself to the drudgery of revising and
correcting it. I have been at that tedious work 3 hours,
now, and by George but I am glad it is over.
Say — I am as prompt as a clock, if I only know the day
a thing is wanted — otherwise I am a natural procrasti-
TYPEWRITERS
185
naturalist. Tell me what day and date you want Nos. 3
and 4, and I will tackle and revise them and they’ll be
there to the minute.
I could wind up with No. 4, but there are some things
more which I am powerfully moved to write. Which is
natural enough, since I am a person who would quit
authorizing in a minute to go to piloting, if the madam
would stand it. I would rather sink a steamboat than
eat, any time.
My wife was afraid to write you — so I said with sim-
plicity,* “/ will give you the language — and ideas.”
Through the infinite grace of God there has not been such
another insurrection in the family before as followed this.
However, the letter was written, and promptly, too —
whereas, heretofore she has remained afraid to do such
things.
With kind regards 'to Mrs. Howells,
Yrs ever,
Mark.
The “ Old Times ” papers appeared each month in the
Atlantic until July, 1875.
These were the days when the typewriter was new. Clemens
and Twichell, during their stay in Boston, had seen the marvel
in operation, and Clemens had been unable to resist owning
one. It was far from being t he perfect machine of to-day ;
the letters were all capitals, and one was never quite certain,
even of those. Mark Twain, however, began with enthusiasm
and practised faithfully. On the day of its arrival he wrote two
letters that have survived, the first to lus brother, the other to
Howells.
Typewritten letter to W. D. Howells, iy Boston :
Hartford, Deo. 9, 1874.
My dear Howells, — I want to add a short paragraph to
article No. 1, when the proof comes. Merely a line or
two, however.
I don’t know whether I am going to make this type-
186
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
writing machine go or nto,: that last word was intended
for n -not ; but I guess I shall make some sort of a succss of
it before I run it very long. I am so thick-fingered that
I miss the keys.
You neednt a swer this ; I am only practicing to get
three ; another slip-up there ; only practicing to get the
hang of the thing. I notice I miss fire & get *in a good
many unnecessary letters and punctuation marks. I am
simply using you for a target to bang at. Blame my cats
but this thing requires genius in order to work it just
right.
Yours ever,
(M)ark.
Orion Clemens had kept his job with Bliss only a short
time. His mental make-up was such that it was difficult for
him to hold any position long. On the whole, Samuel Clemens
was surprisingly patient and considerate with Orion, and there
was never a time that he was not willing to help. Yet there
were bound to be moments of exasperation ; and once, when
his mother, or sister, had written, suggesting that he encourage
his brother’s efforts, he felt moved to write at considerable
freedom.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens and Mrs. Moffett, in Frcdonia, N.Y. :
Hartford, Sundaj, 1874.
My dear Mother and Sister, — I saw Gov. Jewell to-
day and he said he was still moving in the matter of
Sammy’s appointment 1 and would stick to it till lie got a
result of a positive nature one way or the other, but thus
far he did not know whether to expect success or defeat.
Ma, whenever you need money I hope you won’t be
backward about saying so — you can always have it. We
stint ourselves in some ways, but we have no desire to
stint you. And we don’t intend to, either.
I can't “ encourage ” Orion. Nobody can do that, con-
scientiously, for the reason that before one’s letter has
1 As a West Point cadet.
ORION CLEMENS
187
time to reach him he is off on some new wild-goose chase. —
Would you encourage in literature a man who, the older
he grows, the worse he writes ? Would you encourage
Orion in the glaring insanity of studying law ? If he were
, packed and crammed full of law, it would be worthless
lumber t<j him, for his is such a capricious and ill-regulated
mind that lie would apply the principles of the law with
no more judgment than a child of ten years. I know what
I am saying. 1 laid one of the plainest and simplest of
legal questions before Orion once, and the helpless and
hopeless mess he made of it was absolutely astonishing.
Nothing aggravates me so much as to have Orion mention
law or literature to me.
Well, I cannot encourage him to try the ministry, because
he would change his religion so fast that he would have to
keep a travelling agent .under wages to go ahead of him
to engage pulpits and board for him.
I cannot conscientiously encourage him to do anything
but potter around his little farm and put in his odd hours
contriving new and impossible projects at the rate of 365
a year — which is his customary average, lie says he did
well in Hannibal ! Now there is a man who ought to be
entirely satisfied with the grandeurs, emoluments and
activities of a hen farm —
Tf you ask me to pity Orion, I can do that. I can do it
every day and all day long. But one can’t “ encourage ”
quick-silver, because the instant you put your finger on it
it isn’t there. No, I am saying too much — he does stick
to his literary and legal aspirations ; and he naturally
zvould select the very two things which he is wholly and
preposterously unfitted for. If I ever become able, I
mean to put Orion on a regular pension without revealing
the fact that it is a pension. That is best for him. Let
him consider it a periodical loan, and pay interest out of
the principal. Within a year’s time he would be looking
upon himself as a benefactor of mine, in the way of furnish-
ing me a good permanent investment for money, and that
188 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
would make him happy and satisfied with himself. If he
had money he would share with me in a moment and I
have no disposition to be stingy with him.
Affly
Sam.
Livy sends love.
The New Orleans plan was not wholly dead at this time.
Howells wrote near the end of January that the matter was
still being debated, now and then, but was far from being
decided upon. He hoped to go somewhere with Mrs. Howells
for a brief time in March, he said. Clemens, in haste,* replied :
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, Jan. 26, 1876.
My dear Howells, — When Mrs. Clemens read your
letter she said : “ Well, then, wherever they go, in March,
the direction will be southward and so they must give us a
visit on the way.” I do not know what sort of control
you may be under, but when my wife speaks as positively
as that, I am not in the habit of talking back and getting
into trouble. Situated as 3 am, I would not be able to
understand, now, how you could pass by this town ■without
feeling that you were running a wanton risk and doing a
daredevil thing. I consider it settled that you are to
coine in March, and I would be sincerely sorry to learn
that you and Mrs. Howells feel differently about it.
The piloting material has been uncovering itself by
degrees, until it has exposed such a huge hoard to my view
that a whole book will be required to contain it if I use it.
So I have agreed to write the book for Bliss. 1 I won’t be
able to run the articles in the Atlantic later than the
September number, for the reason that a subscription book
issued in the fall has a much larger sale than if issued at
any other season of the year. It is funny when I reflect
that when I originally wrote you and proposed to do from
1 The took idea was later given np for the time being.
A FAMILY GROUP
189
6 to 9 articles for the magazine, the vague thought in my
mind was that 6 might exhaust the material and 9 would
be pretty sure to do it. Or rather it seems to me that that
was my thought — can’t tell at this distance. But in
truth 9 chapters don’t now seem to more than open up the
subject ^irly and start the yarn to wagging.
I have been sick a-bed several day s, for the first time in
21 years. IIow little confirmed invalids appreciate their
advantages. I was able to read the English edition of the
Greville Memoirs through without interruption, take my
meals in bed, neglect all business without a pang, and
smoke 18 cigars a day. I try not to look back upon these
21 years with a feeling of resentment, and yet the partiali-
ties of Providence do seem to me to be slathered around
(as one may say) without that gravity and attention to
detail which the real importance of the matter would seem
to suggest.
Yrs ever
Mark.
To Mrs. W.D. Howells, in Boston :
1875.
Dear Mrs. Howells, — Mrs. Clemens is delighted to
get the pictures, and so am I. I can perceive in the group,
that Mr. Howells is feeling as I so often feel, viz : — “ Well,
no doubt I am in the wrong, though I do not know how or
where or why — but anyway it will be safest to look meek,
and walk circumspectly for a while, and not discuss the
thing.” And you look exactly as Mrs. Clemens does after
she has said, “ Indeed I do not wonder that you can frame
no reply : for you know only too well that your conduct
admits of no excuse, palliation or argument — none ! ”
I shall just delight in that group on account of the good
old human domestic spirit that pervades it — bother these
family groups that put on a state aspect to get their pictures
taken in
140
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
We want a heliotype made of our eldest daughter.
How soft and rich and lovely the picture is. Mr. Howells
must tell me how to proceed in the matter.
Truly yours
Sam. L. Clemens.
In the next letter wc have a picture of Susy A Siemens’s
third birthday. The letter is to her unde Charles Langdon, the
“ Charlie ” of the Quaker City. “ Atwater ” was associated
with the Langdon coal interests in Elmira. “ The play ” is, of
course, “ The Gilded Age.”
To Charles Langdon, in Elmira :
Mch. 19, 1876.
Dear Charlie, — Livy, after reading your letter, used
her severest form of expression about Mr. Atwater — to
wit : She did not “ approve ” of his conduct. This made
me shudder; for it was equivalent to Allic Spaulding’s
saying “ Mr. Atwater is a mean thing ; ” or Rev. Thomas
Beecher’s saying “Damn that Atwater,” or my saying
“ I wish Atwater was three hundred million miles in 1 ”
However, Livy does not often get into one of these
furies, God be thanked.
In Brooklyn, Baltimore, Washington, Cincinnati, St.
Louis and Chicago, the play paid me an average of nine
hundred dollars a week. In smaller towns the average is
$400 to $500.
This is Susie’s birth-day. Lizzie brought her in at 8.30
this morning (before we were up) hooded with a blanket,
red curl-papers in her hair, a great red japonica in one
hand (for Livy) and a yellow rose-bud nestled in violets
(l'or my buttonhole) in the other — and she looked wonder-
fully pretty. She delivered her memorials and received
her birth-day kisses. Livy laid her japonica down to get
a better “ holt ” for kissing — which Susie presently per-
1 This spoiling of the name was adopted somewhat later and much
preferred. It appears as “ Susie " in most of the earlier lettere.
SUSIE’S BIRTHDAY
141
ceived, and became thoughtful : and then said sorrowfully,
turning the great deeps of her eyes upon her mother,
“ Don’t you care for you wow ? ”
Right after breakfast we got up a rousing wood fire in
the main hall (it is a cold morning), illuminated the place
with a rjph glow from all the globes of the newell chande-
lier, spread a bright rug before the fire, set a circling row
of chairs (pink ones and dove-colored) and in the midst a
low invalid-table covered with a fanciful cloth and laden
with tfye presents — a pink azalea in lavish bloom from
Rosa ; a gold inscribed Russia-leather bible from Patrick
and Mary ; a gold ring (inscribed) from “ Maggy Cook ; ”
a silver thimble (inscribed with motto and initials) from
Lizzie ; a rattling mob of Sunday clad dolls from Livy and
Annie, and a Noah’s Ark from me, containing 200 wooden
animals such as only a human being could create and only
God call by name without referring to the passenger list.
Then the family and the seven servants assembled there,
and Susie and the “ Bay ” arrived in state from above, the
Bay’s head being fearfully and wonderfully decorated with
a profusion of blazing red flowers and overflowing cataracts
of lycopodium. Wee congratulatory notes accompanied
the presents of the servants. I tell you it was a great
occasion and a striking and cheery group, taking all the
surroundings into account and the wintry aspect outside.
(Remainder missing.)
There was to bo a centennial celebration that year of the
battles of Lexington and Concord, and Howells wrote, urging
Clemens and his wife to visit them and attend it. Mrs. Clemens
did not go, and Clemens and Ilowells did not go, either — to
the celebration. They had their own ideas about gettiug there,
but found themselves unable to board the thronged train at
Concord, and went tramping about in the cold and mud,
hunting a conveyance, only to return at length to the cheer of
the home, defeated and rather low in spirits.
Twiehell, who wen! on his own hook, had no such difficulties.
To Howells, Mark Twain wrote the adventures of this athletic
and strenuous exponent of the gospel.
142 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
The “Winnie” mentioned in this letter was Ilowells’s
daughter Winifred. She had unusual gifts, but did not live to
develop them.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Farmington Avenue, Hartford. Apt 23, 1876.
My dear Howells, — I’ve got Mrs. Clemens’s picture
before me, and hope I shall not forget to send it with this.
Joe Twiehell preached morning and evening here last
Sunday ; took midnight train for Boston ; got an early
breakfast and started by rail at 7.30 a. m. for Concord ;
swelled around there until 1 p. m., seeing everything ;
then traveled on top of a train to Lexington ; saw every-
thing there ; traveled on top of a train to Boston, (with
hundreds in company) deluged with dust, smoke and
cinders ; yelled and hurrahed all the way like a school-
boy ; lay fiat down to dodge numerous bridges, and sailed
into the depot, howling with excitement and as black as a
chimney-sweep ; got to Young’s Hotel at 7 p. m. ; sat
down in reading-room and immediately feel asleep ; was
promptly awakened by a porter who supposed he was
drunk ; wandered around an hour and a hall' ; then took
9 p. m. train, sat down in smoking car and remembered
nothing more until awakened by conductor as the train
came into Hartford at 1.30 a. m. Thinks he had simply
a glorious time — and wouldn’t have missed the Centennial
for the world. He would have run out to see us a moment
at Cambridge, but was too dirty. I wouldn’t have wanted
him there — his appalling energy would have been an in-
sufferable reproach to mild adventurers like you and me.
Well, he is welcome to the good time he had — I had a
deal belter one. My narrative has made Mrs. Clemens
wish she could have been there. — When 1 think over what
a splendid good sociable time I had in your house I feel
ever so thankful to the wise providence that thwarted our
several ably-planned and ingenious attempts to get to
148
“TOM SAWYER”
Lexington. I am coming again before long, and then she
shall be of the party.
Now you said that you and Mrs. Howells could run
down here nearly any Saturday. Very well then, let us
call it next Saturday, for a “ starter.” Can you do that ?
By that time it will really be spring and you won’t freeze.
The birds are already out ; a small one paid us a visit
yesterday. We entertained it and let it go again, Susie
protesting.
The ijpring laziness is already upon me — insomuch that
the spirit begins to move me to eease from Mississippi
articles and everything else and give myself over to idle-
ness until we go to New Orleans. I have one article al-
ready finished, but somehow it doesn’t seem as proper a
chapter to close with as the one already in your hands.
1 hope to get in a mood and rattle off a good one to finish
with — but just now all my moods are lazy ones.
Winnie’s literature sings through me yet ! Surely that
child has one of these “ futures ” before her.
Now try to come — will you ?
With the warmest regards of the two of us —
Yrs ever,
S. L. Clemens.
The Clemens family remained in Hartford that summer, with
the exception of a brief season at Baleman’s Point, R. 1., near
Newport. By this time Mark Twain had taken up and finished
the Tom Sawyer story begun two years before. Naturally he
wished Howells to consider the MS.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, July 6th, 1876.
My dear Howells, — I have finished the story and
didn’t take the chap beyond boyhood. I believe it would
be fatal to do it in any shape but autobiographically —
like Gil Bias. I perhaps made a mistake in not writing
it in the first person. If I went on, now, and took him
144
LETTERS OR MARK fWW
into manhood , he would just lie like all the one-horse
men in literature and the reader would conceive a hearty
contempt for him. It is not a boy’s book, at all. It will
only be read by adults. It is only written for adults.
Moreover the book is plenty long enough as it stands.
It is about 900 pages of MS, and may be 10QP when I
shall have finished “ working up ” vague places ; so it
would make from 180 to 150 pages of the Atlantic —
about what the Foregone Conclusion made, isn’t it ?
I would dearly like to see it in the Atlantic, but I doubt
if it would pay the publishers to buy the privilege, or me
to sell it. Bret Harte has sold his novel (same size as
mine, I should say) to Scribner’s Monthly for $6,500
(publication to begin in September, I think) and he gets
a royalty of per cent from Bliss in book form after-
wards. He gets a royalty of ten per cent on it in England
(issued in serial numbers) and the same royalty on it in
book form afterwards, and is to receive an advance pay-
ment of five hundred pounds the day the first No. of the
serial appears. If I could do as well, here, and there, with
mine, it might possibly pay me, but I seriously doubt it
— though it is likely I could do better in England than
Bret, who is not widely known there.
You see I take a vile, mercenary view of things — but
then my household expenses are something almost ghastly.
By and by I shall take a boy of twelve and run him on
through life (in the first person) but not Tom Sawyer —
he would not be a good character for it.
I wish you would promise to read the MS of Tom Sawyer
some time, and see if you don’t really decide that I am
right in closing with him as a boy — and point out the
most glaring defects for me. It is a tremendous favor to
ask, and I expect you to refuse and would be ashamed to
expect you to do otherwise. But the thing has been so
many months in my mind that it seems a relief to snake
it out. I don’t know any other person whose judgment
I could venture to take fully and entirely. Don’t hesitate
DRAMATIZATION 14*
about saying no, for I know how your time is taxed, and
I would have honest need to blush if you said yes.
Osgood and I are “ going for ” the puppy G— — on
infringement of trademark. To win one or two suits of
this kind will set literary folks on a firmer bottom. I
wish Osgood would sue for stealing Holmes’s poem.
Wouldn’t it be gorgeous to sue R for petty larceny?
I will promise to go into court and swear I think him
capable *of stealing pea-nuts from a blind pedlar.
Yrs ever,
Clemens.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
July 13, 1875.
My dear Howells, — Just as soon as you consented
I realized all the atrocity of my request, and straightway
blushed and weakened. I telegraphed my theatrical
agent to come here and carry off the MS and copy it.
But I will gladly send it to you if you will do as follows :
dramatize it, if you perceive that you can, and take, for
your remuneration, half of the first $6000 which I receive
for its representation on the stage. You could alter the
plot entirely, if you choose. I could help in the work, most
cheerfully, after you had arranged the plot, I have my
eye upon two young girls who can play “Tom” and
“ Huck.” I believe a good deal of a drama can be made of
it. Come — can’t you tackle this in the odd hours of your
vacation ? or later, if you prefer ?
I do wish you could come down once more before your
holiday. I’d give anything 1
Yrs ever,
Mark.
Howells wrote that he had no time for the dramatization
and urged Clemens to undertake it himself. He was ready to
read the story, whenever it should arrive. Clemens did not
hurry, however. The publication of Tom Sawyer could wait.
146 letters op MARK twain
He already had a book in press — the volume of Sketches New
and Old, which he had prepared for Bliss several years
^Considered among Mark Twain’s books to-day, the collection
of sketches docs not seem especially important. Clemens him-
self confessed to Howells that he wished, when it was too late, #
that he had destroyed a number of them. The book, however,
was distinguished in a special way : it contains Mafck Tvain’s
first utterance in print on the subject of copyright, a matter
in which he never again lost interest. The absurdity and
injustice of the copyright laws both amused and irritaled him,
and in the course of time he would be largely instrumental in
their improvement. In the book hi*- open petition to Congress
that all property rights, as well as literary ownership, should
be put on the copyright basis and limited to a 44 beneficent
term of forty-two years,” was more or less of a joke, but, like
so many of Mark Twain’s jokes, it was founded on reason and
justice.
He had another idea, that was not a joke : an early plan in
the direction of international copyright. It was to be a petition
signed by the leading American authors, asking the United
States to declare itself to be the first to stand for right and
justice by enacting laws against the piracy of foreign books. It
was a rather utopian scheme, as most schemes for moral progress
arc, in their beginning. It would not be likely ever to reach
Congress, but it would appeal to Howells and his Cambridge
friends. Clemens wrote, outlining his plan of action.
To W. D . Howells , in Boston :
Hartford, Sept. 18, 1875.
My dear Howells, — My plan is this — you are to get
Mr. Lowell and Mr. Longfellow to be the first signers of
my copyright petition ; you must sign it yourself and get
Mr. Whittier to do likewise. Then Holmes will sign —
he said he would if he didn’t have to stand at the head.
Then I’m fixed. 1 will then put a gentlemanly chap under
wages and send him personally to every author of distinc-
tion in the country, and corral the rest of the signatures.
Then 1T1 have the whole thing lithographed (about a
thousand copies) and move upon the President and Con-
gress in person , but in the subordinate capacity of a
COPYRIGHT
147
party who is merely the agent of better and wiser men
— men whom the country cannot venture to laugh at.
I will ask the President to recommend the thing in his
message (and if he should ask me to sit down and frame
„ the paragraph for him I should blush — but still 1 would
frame it)..
Next I would get a prime leader in’ Congress ; I would
also see that votes enough to carry the measure were
privately secured before the bill was offered. This I
would try through my leader and my friends there.
And then if Europe chose to go on stealing from us,
we would say with noble enthusiasm, “ American law-
makers do steal — but not from foreign authors — not from
foreign authors ! ”
You see, what I want to drive into the Congressional
mind is the simple fact that the moral law is “ Thou shalt
not steal ” — no matter what Europe may do.
I swear I can’t see any use in robbing European authors
for the benefit of American booksellers, anyway.
If we can ever get this thing through Congress, we can
try making copyright perpetual, some day. There would
be no sort of use in it, since only one book in a hundred
millions outlives the present copyright term — no sort of
use except that the writer of that one book have his
rights — which is something.
If we only had some God in the country’s laws, instead
of being in such a sweat to get Him into the Constitution,
it would be better all around.
The only man who ever signed my petition with alac-
rity, and said that the fact that a thing was right was all-
sufficient, was Rev. Dr. Bushnell. •
I have lost my old petition, (which was brief) but will
draft and enclose another — not in the words it ought to
be, but in the substance. I want Mr. Lowell to furnish
the words (and the ideas too,) if he will do it.
Say Redpath beseeches me to lecture in Boston ip
November — telegraphs that Beecher’s and Nast’s with-
148
letters of mark twain
drawal has put him in the tightest kind of a place. So
I guess 1*11 do that old “ Roughing It ’’ lecture over again
in November and repeat it 2 or 8 times in New York while
I am at it.
Can I take a carriage after the lecture and go out and
stay with you that night, provide you find ah that dis-
tant time that it will not inconvenience you ? Is Aldrich
home yet ?
With love to you all — -
Yrs ever, t
S. L. C.
To W, D. Howells, in Boston :
Oot. 4, ’75.
My oear Howells, — Wc had a royal good time at
your house, and have had a royal good time ever since,
talking about it, both privately and with the neighbors.
Mrs. Clemens’s bodily strength came up handsomely
under that cheery respite from household and nursery
cares. I do hope that Mrs. IIowclls’s didn’t go corre-
spondingly down, under the added burden to her cares and
responsibilities. Of course I didn’t expect to get through
without committing some crimes and hearing of them
afterwards, so I have taken the inevitable* lashings and
been able to hum a tune while the punishment went on.
I “ caught it ” for letting Mrs. Ilowells bother and bother
about her coffee when it was “ a good deal better than we
get at home.” I “ caught it ” for interrupting Mrs. C.
at the last moment and losing her the opportunity to
urge you n»t to forget to send her that MS when the
printers are done with it. I “ caught it ” once more lor
personating that drunken Col. James. I “ caught it ”
for mentioning that Mr. Longfellow’s picture was slightly
damaged ; and when, after a lull in the storm, I confessed
shame-facedly, that I had privately suggested to you that
we hadn’t any frames, aud that if you wouldn’t mind
SLOVENLY WRITING
149
hinting to Mr. Houghton, &c., &c., &c., the Madam was
simply speechless for the space of a minute. Then she
said :
“ IIow could, you, Youth ! The idea of sending Mr.
• Howells, with his sensitive nature, upon such a repulsive
er-
“ Oh, Ilowclh won’t mind it I You don’t know Howells.
Howells is a man who ” She was gone. But George
was the 'first person she stumbled on in the hall, so she
took it out of George. I was glad of that, because it
saved the babies.
I’ve got another rattling good character for my novel I
That great work is mulling itself into shape gradually.
Mrs. Clemens sends love to Mrs. Howells — meantime
she is diligently laying up material for a letter to her.
Yrs ever, Mark.
The “ George ” of this letter was Mark Twain’s coloured
butler, a valued and even beloved member of the household —
a most picturesque character, who “one day came to wash
windows,” as Clemens used to say, “ and remained eighteen
years.” The fiction of Mrs. Clemens's severity he always found
amusing, because of its entire contrast with the reality of her
gentle heart.
To W, D, Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, Nov. 23, ’75.
My dear Howells, — Herewith is the proof. In spite
of myself, how awkwardly I do jumble words together ;
and how often I do use three words where one would
answer — a thing I am always trying to guard against.
I shall become as slovenly a ■writer as Charles Francis
Adams, if I don’t look out. (That is said in jest ; because
of course I do not seriously fear getting so bad as that.
I never shall drop so far toward his and Bret Harte’s
level as to catch myself saying “ It must have been wiser
to have believed that he might have accomplished it if
he could have felt that he would have been supported by
160 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
those who would have See. See. See”) The reference to
Bret Harte reminds me that I often accuse him of being a
deliberate imitator of Diekens ; and this in turn reminds
me that I have charged unconscious plagiarism upon
Charley Warner ; and this in turn reminds me that I have *
been delighting my soul for two weeks over bran-ne^'
and ingenious way of beginning a novel — and behold,
all at once is flashes upon me that Charley Warner origi-
nated the idea 3 years ago and told me about it ! Aha !
So much for self-righteousness ! I am well repaid. Here
are 108 pages of MS, new and clean, lying disgraced in
the waste paper basket, and I am beginning the novel
over again in an uustolen way. 1 would not wonder if I
am the worst literary thief in the world, without knowing it.
It is glorious news that you like Tom Sawyer so well.
I mean to see to it that your review of it shall have plenty
of time to appear before the other notices. Mrs. Clemens
decides with you that the book should issue as a book for
boys, pure and simple — and so do I. It is surely the cor-
rect idea. As to that last chapter, I think of just leaving
it off and adding nothing in its place. Something told
me that the book was done when I got to that point —
and so the strong temptation to put Huck’s life at the
Widow’s into detail, instead of generalizing it in a para-
graph was resisted. Just send Sawyer to me* by express —
I enclose money for it. If it should get lost it will be no
great matter.
Company interfered last night, and so “ Private The-
atricals ” goes over till this evening, to be read aloud.
Mrs. Clemens is mad, but the story will take that all out.
This is goiifg to be a splendid winter night for fireside
reading, anyway.
I am almost at a dead stand-still with my new story,
on account of the misery of having to do it all over again.
We-all send love to you-all.
Yrs ever
Mark.
A BIRTHDAY LETTER 151
To Mrs. Clemens on her Thirtieth Birthday :
Hartford, November 27, 1875*
Livy darling, six years have gone by since I made my
first great success in life and won you, and tliirty years
have passed since Providence made preparation for that
happy success by sending you into the world. Every day
we live together adds to the security of my confidence
that we can never any more wish to be separated than
that wc can ever imagine a regret that we were ever
joined. , You are dearer to me to-day, iny child, than you
were upon the last anniversary of this birth-day ; you
were dearer then than you were a year before — you have
grown more and more dear from the first of those anni-
versaries, and I do not doubt that this precious progression
will continue on to the end.
Let us look forward- to the coming anniversaries, with
their age and their gray hairs without fear and without
depression, trusting and believing that the love we bear
each other will be sufficient to make them blessed.
So, with abounding affection for you and our babies,
I hail this day that brings you the matronly grace and
dignity of three decades !
Always Yours
S. L. C.
To IF. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, Jan. 18, '76.
My dear Howells, — Thanks and ever so many, for
the good opinion of Tom Sawyer. Williams has made
about 300 rattling pictures for it — some, of them very
dainty. Poor devil, what a genius he has and how he
does murder it with rum. He takes a book of mine, and
without suggestion from anybody builds no end of pictures
just from his reading of it.
There was never a man in the world so grateful to an-
other as I was to you day before yesterday, when 1 sat
252
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
down (in still rather wretched health) to set myself to the
dreary and hateful task of making final revision of Tom
Sawyer, and discovered, upon opening the package of MS
that your pencil marks were scattered all along. This
was splendid, and swept away all labor. Instead of reading
the MS, I simply hunted out the pencil marks fynd made
the emendations which they suggested. I re'duced the
boy battle to a curt paragraph ; I finally concluded to
cut the Sunday school speech down to the first two sen-
tences, leaving no suggestion of satire, since the book is
to be for boys and girls ; I tamed the various obscenities
until I judged that they no longer carried offense. So,
at a single sitting I began and finished a revision which
I had supposed would occupy 3 or 4 days and leave me
mentally and physically fagged out at the end. I was
careful not to inflict the MS upon you until I had
thoroughly and painstakingly revised it. Therefore,
the only faults left were those that would discover
themselves to others, not me — and these you had pointed
out.
There was one expression which perhaps you overlooked.
When Huck is complaining to Tom of the rigorous system
in vogue at the widow’s, he says the servants harass him
with all manner of compulsory decencies, and he winds up
by saying : “ and they comb me all to hell.” (No exclama-
tion point.) Long ago, when I read that to Mrs. Clemens,
she made no comment ; another time I created occasion
to read that chapter to her aunt and her mother (both
sensitive and loyal subjects of the kingdom of heaven,
so to speak) and they Jet it pass. I was glad, for it was the
most natural remark in the world for that boy to make
(and he had been allowed few privileges of speech in the
book ;) when I saw that you, too, had let it go without
protest, I was glad, and afraid, too — afraid you hadn’t
observed it Did you ? And did you question the pro-
priety of it ? Since the book is now professedly and con-
fessedly a boy’s and girl’s book, that dam word bothers
REVISION
153
me> some, nights, but it never did until I had ceased to
regard the volume as being for adults.
Don’t bother to answer now, (for you’ve writing enough
to do without allowing me to add to the burden,) but tell
me when you see me again ?
Which we do hope will be next Saturday or Sunday or
Monday. Couldn’t you come now and mull over the
alterations which you are going to make in your MS,
and make them after you go back ? Wouldn’t it assist
the work if you dropped out of harness and routine for
a day or two and have that sort of revivification which
comes of a holiday — forgetfulness of the work-shop ? I
can always work after I’ve been to your house ; and if
you will come to mine, now, and hear the club toot their
various horns over the exasperating metaphysical ques-
tion which I mean to lay before them in the disguise of a
literary extravaganza, it would just brace you up like a
cordial.
(I feci sort of mean trying to persuade a man to put
down a critical piece of work at a critical time, but yet
I am honest in thinking it would not hurt the work nor
impair your interest in it to come under the circum-
stances.) Mrs. Clemens says, “ Maybe the Howellscs
could come Monday if they cannot come Saturday ; ask
them ; it is worth trying.” Well, how’s that ? Could you ?
It would be splendid if you could. Drop me a postal
card — I should have a twinge of conscience if I forced
you to write a letter, (I am honest about that,) — and if
you find you can’t make out to come, tell me that you
bodies will come the next Saturday if the thing is possible,
and stay over Sunday.
Yrs ever
Mark.
Howells, however, did not come to the club meeting but
promised to come soon when they could have a quiet time to
themselves together. As to Huek’s language, he declared :
“ I’d have that swearing out in an instant. 1 suppose I didn’t
154
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
notice it beeause the locution was so familiar to my Western
sense, and so exactly the thing that Huck would say.” Clemens
changed the phrase to, “ They comb me all to thunder,” and
so it stands to-day. Meantime Howells had written his Atlantic
notice of Tom Sawyer, and now enclosed Clemens a proof of it.
We may judge from the reply that it was satisfactory.
To W. D. Howells , in Boston :
ApL“3, ’76.
My dear Howells, — It is a splendid notice and will
embolden weak-kneed journalistic admirers to speak out,
and will modify or shut up the unfriendly. To “ fear God
and dread the Sunday school ” exactly described that old
feeling which I used to have, but I couldn’t have formu-
lated it. I want to enclose one of the illustrations in this
letter, if I do not forget it. Of course the book is to be
elaborately illustrated, and I think that many of the
pictures are considerably above the American average,
in conception if not in execution.
I do not re-enclose your review to you, for you have
evidently read and corrected it, and so I judge you do not
need it. About two days after the Atlantic issues I mean
to begin to send books to principal journals and maga-
zines. . . .
Mrs. Clemens has returned from New York with dread-
ful sore throat, and bones racked with rheumatism. She
kee ps her bed. “ Aloha nui 1 ” as the Kanakas say.
Mark.
Henry Irving once said to Mark Twain : “ You made a mis-
take by not adopting the stage as a profession. You would
have made evfn a greater actor than a writer.”
Mark Twain would have made an actor, certainly, but not
a very tract able one. His appearance in Hartford in “ The Loan
of a Lover ” was a distinguished event, and liis success complete,
though he made so many extemporaneous improvements on
the lines of thick-headed Peter Spuyk, that he kept the other
actors guessing as to their cues, and nearly broke up the per-
formance. It was, of course, an amateur benefit, though
CARLTON AND “THE JUMPING FROG” 155
Augustin Daly promptly wrote, offering to put it on for a
long run.
The “ skeleton novelette ” mentioned in the next letter refers
to a plan coneoeted by Howells and Clemens, by which each of
twelve authors was to write a story, using the same plot,
“ blindfolded ” as to what the others had written. It was a
regular “ Mark Twain ” notion, and it is hard to-day to imagine
HowcJls’s Continued enthusiasm in it. Neither he nor Clemens
gave up the idea for a long time.
To W. 2). Howells , in Boston :
Apl. 22, 1876,
My dear Howells, — You’ll see per enclosed slip that
I appear for the first time on the stage next Wednesday.
You and Mrs. II. come down and you shall skip in free.
I wrote my skeleton novelette yesterday and today.
It will make a little under 12 pages.
Please tell Aldrich I’ve got a photographer engaged,
and tri-weekly issue is about to begin. Show him the
canvassing specimens and beseech him to subscribe.
Ever yours,
S. L. C.
In his next letter Mark Twain explains why Tom Sawyer is
not to appear as soon ns planned. The reference to “ The
Literary Nightmare ” refers to the “ Punch, Conductor, Punch
with Care 55 sketch, which had recently appeared in the Atlantic .
Many other versiliers had had their turn at horse-ear poetry,
and now a publisher was anxious to collect it in a book, pro-
vided he could use the Atlantic sketch. Clemens does not tell
us here the nature of Carlton’s insult, forgiveness of which he
was not yet qualified to grant, but there arc at least two stories
about it, or two halves of the same incident, as jcKtcd afterward
by Clemens and Carlton. Clemens said that when he took the
Jumping Frog book to Carlton, in 1807, the latter, pointing to
his stock, said, rather scornfully : u Books ? I don’t want your
book ; my shelves are full of books now,” though the reader
may remember that it was Carlton himself who had given the
frog story to the Saturday Press and had seen it become famous.
Carlton’s half of the story was that he did not accept Mark
Twain's book because the author looked so disreputable. Long
156
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
afterwards, when the two men met in Europe, the publisher
said to the now rich and famous author : “ Mr. Clemens, my
one claim on immortality is that I declined your first book.”
To W. D. Howells , in Boston :
t
Hartford, Apl.'25, 1876.
My dear Howells, — T hanks for giving me the place
of honor. *
Bliss made a failure in the matter of getting Tom Sawyer
ready on time — the engravers assisting, as usual. I went
down to see how much of a delay there was going to be,
and found that the man had not even put a convasser
on, or issued an advertisement yet — in fact, that the
electrotypes would not all be done for a month ! But of
course the main fact was that no canvassing had been
done — because a subscription harvest is before publica-
tion, (not after, when people have discovered how bad
one’s book is.)
Well, yesterday I put in the Courant an editorial para-
graph stating that Tom Sawyer is “ ready to issue, but
publication is put off in order to secure English copy-
right by simultaneous publication there and here. The
English edition is unavoidably delayed.”
You see, part of that is true. Very well. When I ob-
served that my “ Sketches ” had dropped from a sale of
6 or 7000 a month down to 1 200 a month, I said “ this
ain’t no time to be publishing books ; therefore, let Tom
lie still till Autumn, Mr. Bliss, and make a holiday book
of him to beguile the young people withal.”
I shall print items occasionally, still further delaying
Tom, till I ease him down to Autumn without shock to the
waiting world.
As to that “ Literary Nightmare ” proposition. I’m
obliged to withhold consent, for what seems a good reason
to wit : A single page of horse-car poetry is all that
the average reader can stand, without nausea ; now, to
HORSE-CAR POETRY
157
stack together all of it that has been written, and then
add it to my article would be to enrage and disgust each
and every reader and win the deathless enmity of the lot.
Even if that reason were insufficient, there would still
be a sufficient reason left, in the fact that Mr. Carlton
seems to be the publisher of the magazine in which it is
proposed to publish this horse-car matter. Carlton in-
sulted me in Feb. 1867, and so when the day arrives that
sees mb doing him a civility I shall feel that I am ready
for Paradise, since my list of possible and impossible
forgivenesses will then be complete.
Mrs. Clemens says my version of the blindfold novelette
“ A Murder and A Marriage ” is “ good.” Pretty strong
language — for her.
The Fieldses arc coming down to the play tomorrow,
and they promise to get you and Mrs. Howells to come
too, but I hope you’ll do nothing of the kind if it will in-
convenience you, for I’m not going to play either strik-
ingly bad enough or well enough to make the journey pay
you.
My wife and I think of going to Boston May 7th to see
Anna Dickinson’s debut on the 8th. If I find we can go.
I’ll try to get a stage box and then you and Mrs. Ilowells
must come to Parker’s and go with us to the crucifixion.
(Is that<spelt right 't — somehow it doesn’t look right.)
With our very kindest regards to the whole family.
Yrs ever,
Mark.
The mention of Anna Dickinson, at the end of tins letter,
recalls a prominent reformer and lecturer of the Civil War
period. She had begun her crusades against temperance and
slavery in 1857, when she was but fifteen years old, when her
success as a speaker had been immediate and extraordinary.
Now, in this later period, at the age of thirty-four, she aspired
to the stage — unfortunately for her, as her gifts lay elsewhere.
From May until August no letters appear to have passed
between Clemens and Howells ; the latter finally wrote, com-
plaining of the lack of news. He was in the midst of campaign
158
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
activities, he said, writing a life of Hayes, and gaily added :
“ You know I wrote the life of Lincoln, which elected him.”
He further reported a comedy he had completed, and gave
Clemens a general stirring up as to his own work.
Mark Twain, in his hillside study, was busy enough. Summer
was his time for work, and he had tried his hand in various
directions. His mention of Huek Finn in his reply to Howells is
interesting, in that it shows the measure of his enthusiasm, c.
lack of it, as a gauge of his ultimate achievement.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
*
Elmira, Ang. 9, 1876.
My dear Howells, — I was just about to write you
when your letter came — and not one of those obscene
postal cards, cither, but reverently, upon paper.
I shall read that biography, though the letter of accept-
ance was amply sufficient to corral my vote without any
further knowledge of the man. Which reminds me that
a campaign club m Jersey City wrote a few days ago and
invited me to be present at the raising of a Tildcn and
Hendricks flag there, and to take the stand and give them
some “ counsel.” Well, I could not go, but gave them
counsel and advice by letter, and in the kindliest terms
as to the raising of the flag— advised them “ not to raise it.”
Get your book out quick, for this is a momentous time.
If Tildcn is elected I think the entire country will go
pretty straight to — Mrs. Ilowells’s bad place.
I am infringing on your patent- -I started a record of
our children’s sayings, last night. Which reminds me that
last week I sent down and got Susie a vast pair of shoes of
a most villainous pattern, for I discovered that her feet
were being twisted and cramped out of shape by a smaller
and prettier article. She did not complain, but looked
degraded and injured. At night her mamma gave her
the usual admonition when she was about to say her
prayers —to wit :
“ Now, Susie— think about God.”
A SUNSET
150
“ Mamma, I can’t, with those shoes.”
The farm is perfectly delightful this season. It is as
quiet and peaceful as a South Sea Island. Some of the
sunsets which we have witnessed from this commanding
eminence were marvelous. One evening a rainbow spanned
an entire range of hills with its mighty arch, and from a
black hub ‘resting upon the hill-top in the exact centre,
black rays diverged upward in perfect regularity to the
rainbow’s arch and created a very strongly defined and
altogether the most majestic, magnificent and startling
half-sunlc wagon wheel you can imagine. After that, a
world of tumbling and prodigious clouds came drifting
up out of the West and took to themselves a wonderfully
rich and brilliant green color — the decided green of new
spring foliage. Close by them we saw the intense blue
of the skies, through rents in the cloud-rack, and away
off in another quarter were drifting clouds of a delicate
pink color. In one place hung a pall of dense black clouds,
like compacted pitch-smoke. And the stupendous wagon
wheel was still in the supremacy of its unspeakable
grandeur. So you see, the colors present in the sky at
one and the same time were blue, green, pink, black, and
the vari-colored splendors of the rainbow. All strong and
decided colors, too. I don’t know whether this weird
and astounding spectacle most suggested heaven, or hell.
The wonder, with its constant, stately, and always sur-
prising changes, lasted upwards of two hours, and we
all stood on the top of the hill by my study till the final
miracle was complete and the greatest day ended that we
ever saw.
Our farmer, who is a grave man, watehed.tl at spectacle
to the end, and then observed that it was “ dam funny.”
The double-barreled novel lies torpid. I found I could
not go on with it. The chapters I had written were still
too new and familiar to me. 1 may take it up next winter,
but cannot tell yet ; I waited and waited to sec if my in-
terest in it would not revive, but gave it up a month
160
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
ago and began another boys’ book — more to be at work
than anything else. I have written 400 pages on it —
therefore it is very nearly half done. It is Huck Finn’s
Autobiography. I like it only tolerably well, as far as I
have got, and may possibly pigeonhole or burn the MS
when it is done.
»
So the eomedy is done, and with a “ fair degree of satis-
faction.” That rejoices me, and makes me mad, too — for
I can’t plan a comedy, and what have you done that God
should be so good to you ? I have racked myself bald-
headed trying to plan a comedy harness for some prom-
ising characters of mine to work in, and had to give it
up. It is a noble lot of blooded stock and worth no end
of money, but they must stand in the stable and be profit-
less. I want to be present when the comedy is produced
and help enjoy the success.
Warner’s book is mighty readable, I think.
Love to yez.
Yrs. ever
Mark.
Howells promptly wrote again, urging him to enter the
campaign for Hayes. “ There is not another man in this
country,” he said, “ who could help him so much as you.”
The “ farce *’ which Clemens refers to in his reply, was “ The
Parlour Car,” which seems to have been about the first venture
of Howells in that field.
To IF. D. Ilowells , in Boston :
Elmira, August 23, 1876.
C*
My ijear Howells, — I am glad you think I could do
Hayes any good, for I have been wanting to write a letter
or make a speech to that end. I’ll be careful not to do
either, however, until the opportunity comes in a natural,
justifiable and unlugged way ; and shall not then do any-
thing unless I’ve got it all digested and worded just right.
“THE CANVASSER’S TALE” 161
Iu which case I might do some good — in any other I
should do harm. When a humorist ventures upon the
grave concerns of life he must do his job better than
another man or he works harm to his cause.
* The farce is wonderfully bright and delicious, and must
make a hit.., You read it to me, and it was mighty good ;
I read it last night and it was better ; I read it aloud to
the household this morning and it was better than ever.
So i* would be worth going a long way to see it well
played ; for with ou °ny question an actor of genius always
adds a subtle si thing to any man’s woik that none
but the writer knew was there before. Even if he knew
it. I have heard of readers convulsing audience 1 with
my “ Aurcha’s Unfortunate Young Man.” If there is
anything really funny in the piece, the author is not
aware of it.
All right — advertise me for the new volume. I send
ou herewith a sketch which will make 3| pages of the
Mlantic. If you like it and accept it, you should get it
into the December No. because I shall read it in public
.•I Boston the 13th and 11th of Nov. If it went in a
month earlier it would be too old for me to read except
as old matter ; and if it went in a month later it would bt
too old for the Atlantic- do you sec ? And if you wish
to use it, will you set it up now, and send me three proofs ?
--one to correct for Atlantic, one to send to Temple Bar
(shall I tell them to use it not earlier than their November
No ?) and one to use in practising for my Boston readings.
We must get up a less elaborate and a much belter
>keleton-plan for the Blindfold Novels and make a success
>t tnat idea. David Gray spent Sunday here and said
ite could but little comprehend what a rattling stir that
hing would make in the country. He thought it w T ould
oake a mighty strike. So do 1. But with only 8 pages
o tell the tale in, *he plot must be less elaborate, doubt-
ess. What do you think ?
When we exchange visits I’ll show you an unfinished
M
162
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
sketch of Elizabeth’s time which shook David Gray’s
system up pretty exhaustively.
Yrs ever, Mark.
The MS. sketch mentioned in the foregoing letter was “ Thq
Canvasser's Talc,” later included in the volume, Tom Sawyer,
Abroad , and Other Stories. David Gray was an uble journalist
and editor whom Mark Twain had known in Buffalo. The
“ sketch of Elizabeth’s time ” is a brilliant piece of writing —
an imaginary record of conversation and court manners in the
good old days of free speech and performance, phrased in the
language of the period. *
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Sept. 14, 1876.
My dear Howells, — I will not, and do not, believe
that there is a possibility of Hayes’s defeat, but I want the
victory to be sweeping. . . .
It seems odd to find myself interested in an election.
I never was before. And L can’t seem to get over my
repugnance to reading or thinking about polities, yet.
But in truth I care little about any party’s politics— the
man behind it is the important thing.
You may well know that Mrs. Clemens liked the Parlor
Car — enjoyed it ever so much, and was indignant at you
all through, and kept exploding into rages at you for
pretending that such a woman ever existed — closing each
and every explosion with “ But it is just what such a
woman would do.” — “ It is just what such a woman
would say.” They all voted the Parlor Car perfection —
except me. I said they wouldn’t have been allowed to
court and quarrel there so long, unintcri upted ; but at
each critical moment the odious train-boy would come in
and pile foul literature all over them four or five inches
deep, and the lover would turn his head aside and curse
— and presently that train-boy would be back again (as
on all those Western roads) to take up the literature and
leave prize candy.
Of course the thing is perfect, in the magazine, without
A STORY BY HOWELLS
163
tlic train-boy ; but I was thinking of the stage and the
groundlings. If the dainty touches wont over their heads,
the train-boy and other possible interruptions would
fetch them every time. Would it mar the flow of the thing
„too much to insert that devil ? I thought it over a couple
. of hours and concluded it wouldn’t, and that he ought to
be in for the’sake of l he groundlings (and to get new copy-
right on the piece.)
And ft seemed to me that now that the fourth act is
so successfully written, why nol go ahead and write the
3 preceding acts ? And then after it is finished, let me
put into it a low-comedy character (the girl’s or the
lover’s father or uncle) and gobble a big pecuniary interest
in your work for myself. Do not let this generous pro-
position disturb your rest- -but do write the other 3 acts,
and then it will be valuable to managers. And don’t go
and sell it to anybody, lilo '•to, but keep it for yourself.
Harte’s play can be < *ed till it will be entirely
acceptable and then it \ 1 great sum every year
lam out of all patience v, ' r soiling it- The play
entertained mo hugely «*' ci 'stale.
Love to you all.
v Mvrk.
Following the Seller* -.w.c'*-, sleeve, bud made many
attempts at drainat i* writ in r Suit* limb rt.ikmgs hail uni-
formly tailed, b* \ <1 i.lv. bet n willing to try again. In
u< -iter get lie Ik ginning ( f what plow'd Ins first
a. id i< i eet literary aw v non, that is to say, collaboration,
with l Harte f ' mois had gnat admiration for Uaite’s
ability a* 11 bo ‘ btl.utn them they could turn out a
sucec < ! i ,
It( s’*- i lv of Hayes, meanwhile, X. >i not gone
will. hat only two thousand copies had been
sold ui \\ u the' height of the campaign. “ There’s
succe*''- 1 ’ he said ; “ it makes me despair of the
itepvbh * ” v l< i..cns, on his part, had made u speech for llayes
i hal How ( !U di clared had put civil-service reform in a nutshell ;
tic addi d : “ You are the only Republican orator, quoted without
distinction of parly by all the newspapers.”
164 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, Oct. 11, 1876.
My dear Howells, — This is a secret, to be known to
nobody but you (of course I comprehend that Mrs.
Howells is part of you) that Bret Hartc came up here the,
other day and asked me to help him write a play and
divide the swag, and I agreed. I am to put in Scotty
Briggs (See Buck Fanshaw’s Funeral, in “ Roughing It.”)
and he is to put in a Chinaman (a wonderfully funny
creature, as Bret presents him — tor 5 minuttes — in his
Sandy Bar play.) This Chinaman is to be the character
of the play, and both of us will work on him and develop
him. Bret is to draw a plot, and I am to do the same ;
wc shall use the best of the two, or gouge from both
and build a third. My plot is built — finished it yesterday
— six days’ work, 8 or 9 hours a day, and has nearly
killed me.
Now the favor I ask of you is that you will have the
words “ Ah Sin, a Drama,” printed in the middle of a
note-paper page and send the same to me, with Bill. We
don’t want anybody to know that we are building this
play. I can’t get this title page printed here without
having to lie so much that the thought of it is disagreeable
to one reared as I have been. And yet the tjile of the play
must be printed— the rest of the application for copyright
is allowable in penmanship.
We have got the very best gang of servants in America,
now. When George first came he was one of the most
religious of men. He had but one fault — young George
Washington’s. But I have trained him ; and now it
fairly breaks Mrs. Clemens’s heart to hear George stand
at lhat front door and lie to the unwelcome visitor. But
your time is valuable ; I must not dwell upon these
things. . . .
I’ll ask Warner and Ilarte if they’ll do Blindfold Novel-
ettes. Some time I’ll simplify that plot. All it needs is
BRET HARTE
165
that the hanging and the marriage shall not be appointed
for the same clay. I got over that difficulty, but it re-
quired too much MS to reconcile the thing — so the move-
ment of the story was clogged.
* I came near agreeing to make political speeches with
our candidate for Governor the 16th and 23 inst., but I
had to give up the idea, for Harte and I will be here at
work then.
Yrs ever,
Mark.
Mark Twain must have been too busy to write letters that
winter. Those that have survived are few and unimportant.
As a matter of fact, he was writing the play, u Ah Sin,” with
Bret llartc, and getting it ready for production, llarte was a
guest in the Clemens home while the play was being written,
and not always a pleasant one. He was full of requirements,
critical as to the menage , to the point of sarcasm. The long
friendship between Clemens and Harte weakened under the
strain of collaboration and intimate daily intercourse, never to
renew its old fibre. It was an unhappy outcome of an enter-
prise which in itself was to prove of little profit. The play,
“ Ah Sin,” had many good features, and with Charles T. Parsloe
in an amusing Chinese' part might have been made a success,
if the two authors could have harmoniously undertaken the
needed repairs. It drew some good houses m Washington, but
could not hold them for a run.
Meantime, Rjntherford II. Hayes had been elected President,
and Clemens one day called with a letter of introduction from
Ilowelis, thinking to meet the Chief Executive. Ilis own letter
to Howells, later, probably does not give the real reason of his
failure, but it will be amusing to those who recall the erratic
personality of George Francis Train. Train and Twain were
sometimes confused by the very unlettered ; or, prctendcdly,
by Mark Twain’s friends.
To W. I). Howells , in Boston :
Baltimore, May 1 '77.
My dear Howells, — Found I was not absolutely
needed in Washington so I only staid 24 hours, and am
on my way home, now. I called at the White House, and
166
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN ,
got admission to Col. Rodgers, because I wanted to in-
quire what was the right hour to go and infest the Presi-
dent. It was my luck to strike the place in the dead
waste and middle of the day, the very busiest time. I
perceived that Mr. Rodgers took me for George Francis*.
Train and had made up his mind not to let me gel at the
President ; so at the end of half an hour I took my letter
of introduction from the tabic and went away? It was
a great pity all round, and a great loss to the nation, for
1 was brim full of the Eastern question. I didn’t get to
see the President or the Chief Magistrate cither, though
I had sort of a glimpse of a lady at a window who resembled
her portraits.
Yrs ever,
Mark.
Later, in May, Clemens took Twichell for an excursion to
Bermuda. lie had begged IlowtIIs to go with than, but
Howells, as usual, was full ol literary affairs. Twichcil unit
Clemens spent four glorious days tramping the length and
breadth of the beautiful island, and rcnicmbtreel it always as'
one of the'ir happiest adventure's, (lemem would naturally
write something about .Bermuda, and began at ones', “ Random
Note's of an idle Excursion,” and presently completed four
papers, which Ilowells e'agc rly accepted for the Atlantic. Then
we iinel him plunging into another play, this time alone.
To W. D. Ilowells, in Boston :
Elmira, July 4, 1877.
My dear Howells,— It is splendid of you to say those
pleasant things. But I am still plague'el with doubts
about Part's 1 and 2. If you have any, don’t print. If
otherwise, please* make some cold villain like Latlirop
read and pass sentence on them. Mind, I thought they
were good, at first — it was the second reading that accom-
plished its hellish purpose on me. Put them up for a new
verdict. Part 4 has lain in my pigeon-hole a good while,
and whe;n I put it there I had a Christian’s confidence in
“AH SIN”
167
4 accs in it ; and you can be sure it will skip toward
Connecticut tomorrow before any fatal fresh reading
makes me draw my bet.
I’ve piled up 151 MS pages on my comedy. The first,
second and fourth acts are done, and done to my satis-
faction, too. Tomorrow and next day will finish the 3rd
act and tlio play. I have not written less than 30 pages
any day since I began. Never had so much fun over any-
thing in my life — never such consuming interest and de-
light. (But Lord bless you the second reading will fetch
it!) Alfd just think! — I had Sol Smith Russell in my
mind’s eye for the old detective’s part, and hang it he
has gone off pottering with Oliver Optic, or else the papers
lie.
I read everything about the President's doings there
with exultation.
I wish that old ass of a private secretary hadn’t taken
me for George Francis Train. If ignorance wore a means
of grace I wouldn’t trade that gorilla’s chances for the
Archbishop of Canterbury’s.
I shall call on the President again, by and by. I shall
go in my war paint ; and if I am obstructed the nation
will have the unusual spectacle of a private secretary with
a pen over one car, a tomahawk over the other.
I read the entire Atlantic this time. Wonderful num-
ber. Mrs. Rose Terry Cooke’s story was a ten-strike.
I wish she would write 12 old-time New England tales a
year.
Good times to you all ! Mind if you don’t run here for
a few days you will go to hence without having had a
fore-glimpse of heaven.
• Makk.
The play, “ Ah Sin,” that had done little enough in Washing-
ton. was that summer given another trial by Augustin Daly, at
the Fifth Avenue Theatre, New York, with a line company.
Clemens had undertaken to doctor the play, and it would seem
to have had an enthusiastic reception on the opening night.
168 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
But it was a summer audience, unspoiled by many attractions.
“ Ah Sin ” was never a success in the New York season— never
a money-maker on the road.
The reference in the first paragraph of the letter that follows
is to the Bermuda chapters which Mark Twain was publishing
simultaneously in England and America.
Elmira, Atfg. 3, 1877.
My dear Howells, — I have mailed one set of the slips
to London, and told Bentley you would print Sept. 15,
in October Atlantic, and lie must not print earlier in
Temple Bar. Have I got the dates and things right ?
I am powerful glad to see that No. 1 reads a nation sight
better in print than it did in MS. I told Bentley we’d
send him the slips, each time, G weeks before day of pub-
lication. We can do that can’t we ? Two months ahead
would be still better I suppose, but I don’t know.
“ Ah Sin ” went a-booming at the Fifth Avenue. The
reception of Col. Sellers was calm compared to it.
* The criticisms were just ; the criticisms of the great
New York dailies are always just, intelligent, and square
and honest — notwithstanding, by a blunder which nobody
was seriously to blame for, I was made to say exactly
the opposite of this in a newspaper some time ago. Never
said it at all, and moreover I never thought it. I could
not publicly correct it before the play appeared in New
York, because that would look as if I had really said that
thing and then was moved by fears for my pocket and
my reputation to take it back. But I can correct it now,
and shall do it ; for now my motives cannot be impugned.
When I began this letter, it had not occurred to me to
u .<_ you in this,connection, but it occurs to me now. Your
opinion and mine, uttered a year ago, and repeated more
than once i ince, that the candor and ability of the New
York critics were beyond question, is a matter which
makes it proper enough that I should speak through you
at this time. Therefore if you will print this paragraph
NEWSPAPER CRITICISM
169
somewhere, it may remove the impression that I say unjust
tilings which I do not think, merely for the pleasure of
talking.
There, now, Can’t you say
“ In a letter to Mr. Howells of the Atlantic Monthly,
Mark Twain describes the reception of the new comedy
‘ Ah Sin,’ a*)id then goes on to say : ” etc.
Beginning at the star with the words, “ The criticisms
wctc Mrs. Clemens says, “ Don’t ask that oY Mr.
Ilowells — it will be disagreeable to him.” I hadn’t thought
of it, bift I will bet two to one on the correctness of her
instinct. Wc shall see.
Will you cut that paragraph out of this letter and pre-
cede it with the remarks suggested (or with better ones,)
and send it to the Globe or some other paper ? You
can’t do me a bigger favor ; and yet if it is in the least
disagreeable, you mustn't think of it. But let me know,
right away, for 1 want to correct this thing before it grows
stale again. I explained myself to only one critic (the
World) — the consequence was a noble notice of the play.
This one called on me, else I shouldn’t have explained
myself to him.
I have been putting in a deal of hard work on that play
in New York, but it is full of incurable defects.
My old Plunkett family seemed wonderfully coarse and
vulgar on the stage, but it was because they were played
in such an outrageously and inexcusably coarse way.
The Chinaman is killingly funny. 1 don’t know when I
have enjoyed anything as much as I did him. The people
say there isn’t enough of him in the piece. That’s a
triumph — there’ll never be any more of him in it.
John Brougham said, “ Read the list of things which the
critics have condemned in the piece, and you have un-
assailable proofs that the play contains all the requirements
of success and a long life.”
That is true. Nearly every time the audience roared
I knew it was over something that would be condemned
170
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
in the morning (justly, too) buj, must be left in — for low
comedies are written for the drawing-room, the kitehcn
and the stable, and if you cut out the kitchen and the
stable the drawing-room can’t support the play by itself.
There was as much money in the house the first two
nights as in the first ten of Sellers. Haven’t heard from
the third — I came away.
Yrs ever.
Ma’rk.
The Clemens family was still at Quarry Farm at the end of
August, and one afternoon there occurred a startling incident
which Mark Twain thought worth setiing down in practically
duplicate letter* to Howells and to Dr. John ltrown. It may be
of interest to the reader to know that John T. Lewis, the
coloured man mentioned, lived to a good old age —a pensioner
of the Clemens family and, in the course of time, of II. H. Rogers,
llowclls’s letter follows.
To W. D. Howells and wife, in Boston :
Elmira, Aug. 25 ’77.
My pear Howellses, — I thought I ought to make a
sort of record of it for further reference ; the pleasantest
way to do that would be to write it to somebody ; but
that somebody would let it leak into print and that we
wish to avoid. The Howellses would be safe — so let us
tell the Howellses about it.
Day before yesterday was a fine summer day away up
here on the summit. Aunt Marsh and Cousin May
Marsh were here visiting Susie Crane and Livy at our
farmhouse. By and by mother Langdon came up the
lull in the “ high carriage ” with Nora the nurse and little
Jervis (Charley Langdon’s little boy) — Timothy the coach-
man driving. Behind these came Charley's wife and
little girl in the buggy, with the new, young, spry, gray
horse — a high stepper. Theodore Crane arrived a little
later.
The Bay and Susy were on hand with their nurse,
A RUNAWAY HORSE
171
Rosa. I was on hand, too. Susy Crane’s trio of colored
servants ditto — these being Josie, house-maid ; Aunty
Cord, cook, aged 02, turbaned, very tall, very broad,
very fine every way (see her portrait in “ A True Story
Just as I Heard It ” in my Sketches ;) Chocklate (the
laundress^ (as the llay calls her — she can’t say Charlotte,)
still taller, still more majestic of proportions, turbaned,
very .black, straight as an Indian — age 21. Then there
was the farmer’s wife (colored) and lier little girl, Susy.
Wasn’t it a good audience to get up an excitement be-
fore ? Good excitable, inflammable material ?
Lewis was still down town, three miles away, with his
two-horse wagon, to get a load of manure. Lewis is the
farmer (eolored). He is of mighty frame and muscle,
stocky, stooping, ungainly, has a good manly face and a
clear eye. Age about 15 — and the most picturesque of
men. when he sits in his fluttering work-day rags, humped
forward into a buneh, w th lus aged slouch hat mashed
down over his ears and neck. It is a spectacle to make
the broken-hearted smile. Lewis has worked mighty hard
and remained mighty poor. At the end of each whole
year’s toil he can’t show a gain of fifty dollars. He had
borrowed money of the Cranes till he owed them $700
— and he being conscientious and honest, imagine what
it was to* him to have to carry this stubborn, helpless
load year in and year out.
Well, sunset came, and Ida the young and comely
(Charley Langdon’s wife) and her little Julia and the nurse
Nora, drove out at the gate behind the new gray horse
and started down the long hill — the high carriage re-
ceiving its load under the porte coeh^rt*. Ida was seen
to turn her face toward us across the fence and inter-
vening lawn — Theodore waved good-bye to her, for he did
not know that her sign was a speechless appeal for help.
The next moment Livy said, “ Ida’s driving too fast
down hill ! ” She followed it with a sort of scream, “ Her
horse is running away ! ”
172 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
We could sec two hundred yards down that descent.
The buggy seemed to fly. It would strike obstructions
and apparently spring the height of a man from the
ground.
Theodore and I left the shrieking crowd behind and
ran down the hill bare-headed and shouting. A neighbor
appeared at his gate — a tenth of a second too late ! —
the buggy vanished past him like a thought. My last
glimpse showed it for one instant, far down the descent,
springing high in the air out of a cloud of dust, anjl then
it disappeared. As I flew down the road my impulse was
to shut my eyes as I turned them to the right or left, and
so delay for a moment the ghastly spectacle of mutilation
and death I was expecting.
I ran on and on, still spared this spectacle, but saying
to myself : “ I shall see it at the turn of the road ; they
never can pass that turn alive.” When I came in sight
of that turn I saw two wagons there bunched together
—one of them full of people. I said, “ Just so— they are
staring petrified at the remains.”
But when I got amongst that bunch, there sat Ida
in her buggy and nobody hurt, not even the horse or
the vehicle. Ida was pale but serene. As I came tearing
down, she smiled back over her shoulder at me and said,
“ Well, we’re alive yet, aren't we ? ” A miracld had been
performed— nothing else.
You see Lewis, the prodigious, humped upon his front
seat, had been toiling up, on his load of manure ; he saw
the frantic horse plunging down the hill toward him, on a
full gallop, throwing his heels as high as a man’s head
at every jump.* So Lewis turned his team diagonally
across the road just at the “ turn ” thus making a V with
the fence the running horse could not escape that, but
must enter it. Then Lewis sprang to the ground and stood
in this V. He gathered his vast strength, and with a
perfect Creedmoor aim he seized the gray horse’s bit as
lie plunged by and fetched him up standing !
THE RESCUE
ITS
It was down hill, mind you. Ten feet further down
hill neither Lewis nor any other man could have saved
them, for they would have been on the abrupt “ turn,”
then. But how this miracle was ever accomplished at
all, by human strength, generalship and accuracy, is
clean beyond my comprehension — and grows more so the
more I go and examine the ground and try to believe it
was actually done. I know one thing, well ; if Lewis had
missetl his aim he would have been killed on the spot
in the trap he had made for himself, and we should have
found the rest of the remains away down at the bottom
of the steep ravine.
Ten minutes later Theodore and I arrived opposite
the house, with the servants straggling after us, and
shouted to the distracted group on the porch, “ Every-
body safe ! ”
Believe it ? Why how could they ? They knew the
road perfectly. We might as well have said it to people
who had seen their friends go over Niagara.
However, we convinced them ; and then, instead of
saying something, or going on crying, they grew very
still — words could not express it, I suppose.
Nobody could do anything that night, or sleep, either ;
but there was a deal of moving talk, with long pauses
between — pictures of that flying carriage, these pauses
represented — this picture intruded itself all the time and
disjointed the talk.
But yesterday evening late, when Lewis arrived from
down town he found his supper spread, and some presents
of books there, with very complimentary writings on the
fly-leaves, and certain very complimentary letters, and
more or less greenbacks of dignified denomination pinned
to these letters and fly-leaves, — and one said, among
other things, (signed by the Cranes) “ We cancel $400 of
your indebtedness to us,” &c. &c.
(The end thereof is not yet, of course, for Charley Langdon
is West and will arrive ignorant of all these things, today.)
174
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
The supper-room had been kept locked and imposingly
secret and mysterious until Lewis should arrive ; but
around that part of the house were gathered Lewis’s
wife and child, Chocklate, Josic, Aunty Cord and our
Rosa, canvassing things and waiting impatiently. They
were all on hand when the curtain rose.
Now, Aunty Cord is a violent Methodist and Lewis
an implacable Dunkcr-Baptist. Those two are inveterate
religious disputants. The revealments having' been
made Aunty Cord said with effusion —
“ Now, let folks go on saying there ain’t nd God !
Lewis, the Lord sent you there to stop that horse.”
Says Lewis —
“ Then who sent the horse there in sich a shape ? ”
But I want to call your attention to one thing. When
Lewis arrived the other evening, after saving those lives
by a feat which I think is the most marvelous of any I
can call to mind — when he arrived, hunched up on his
manure wagon and as grotesquely picturesque as usual,
everybody wanted to go and see how he looked. They
came back and said he was beautiful. It was so, too —
and yet he would have photographed, exactly as he would
have done any day these past 7 years that he has occupied
this farm.
Aug. 27.
P. S. Our little romance in real life is happily and
satisfactorily completed. Charley has come, listened,
acted — and now John T. Lewis has ceased to consider
1. nisclf as belonging to that class called “ the poor.”
It has been known, during some years, that it was
Lewis’s purpose to buy a thirty dollar silver watch some
day, if he ever got where he could afford it. Today Ida
has given him a new, sumptuous gold Swiss stem- winding
stop-watch ; and if any scoffer shall say, “ Behold this
is out of cnaractcr,” there is an inscription within,
TESTIMONIALS
175
which will silence him ; for it will teach him that this
wearer aggrandizes the watch, not the watch the wearer.
I was asked beforehand, if this would be a wise gift,
and I said “ Yes, the very wisest of all ; I know the
colored race, and I know that in Lewis’s eyes this fine toy
will throw the other more valuable testimonials far away
into the shade. If he lived in England the Humane
Society would give him a gold medal as costly as this
watch, and nobody would say : “ It is out of character.”
If Lewjs chose to wear a town clock, who would become it
better ? ”
Lewis has sound common sense, and is not going to be
spoiled. The instant he found himself possessed of money,
lie forgot himself in a plan to make his old father comfort-
able, who is wretchedly poor and lives down in Maryland.
His next act, on the spot, was the proffer to the Cranes
of the $300 of his remaining indebtedness to them. This
was put off by them to the indefinite future, for he is not
going to be allowed to pay that at all, though he doesn’t
know it.
A letter of acknowledgment from Lewis contains a
sentence which raises it to the dignity of literature :
“ But I beg to say, humbly, that inasmuch as divine
providence saw lit to use me as a instrument for the saving
of those ptesshious lives, the honnor conferd upon me was
greater than the feat performed.”
That is well said. Yrs ever Mark.
Howells was moved to use the story in the “ Contributors’
Club,” and warned Clemens against letting it get into the
newspapers. He declared he thought it one of the most im-
pressive things he had ever read. But Cleqier . seems never
to have allowed it to be used in any form. In its entirety,
therefore, it is quite new matter.
To W. D. Ilowclls , in Boston :
Hartford, Sept. 19, 1877.
My dear Howells, — I don’t really see how the
story of the runaway horse could read well with the little
176
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
details of names and places and things left out. They
are the true life of all narrative. It wouldn’t quite do
to print them at this time. We’ll talk about it when
you come. Delicacy — a sad, sad false delicacy— robs
literature of the best two things among its belongings.
Family-circle narrative and obscene stories. But i.o
matter ; in that better world which I trust we are all
going to I have the hope and belief that they will not be
denied us.
g a y — Twichell and I had an adventure at sea, 4g
months ago, which I did not put in my Bermuda articles,
because there was not enough to it. But the press dis-
patches bring the sequel today, and now there’s plenty
to it. A sailless, wasteless, chartless, compassless, grub-
less old condemned tub that has been drifting helpless
about the ocean for 4 months and a half, begging bread
and water like any other tramp, flying a signal of distress,
permanently, and with 13 innocent, marveling chuckle-
headed Bermuda niggers on board, taking a Pleasure
Excursion ! Our ship fed the poor devils on the 25th of
last May, far out at sea and left them to bullrag their
way to New York — and now they ain’t as near New York
as they were then by 250 miles ! They have drifted 750
miles and are still drifting in the relentless Gulf Stream !
What a delicious magazine chapter it would ‘make— but
l had to deny myself. 1 had to come right out in the
papers at once, with my details, so as to try to raise the
government’s sympathy sufficiently to have better succor
sent them than the cutter Colfax, which went a little way
in search of them the other day and then struck a fog
and gave it up. *
If the President were in Washington I would telegraph
him.
When I hear that the “ Jonas Smith ” has been found
again, I mean to send for one of those darkies, to come to
Halt fnnl, and give me his adventures for an Atlantic
article*.
177
ANOTHER TRIP TO EUROPE
Likely you will
papers.
sec my today’s article in the news-
Yrs ever,
Mask.
The revenue cutter Colfax, went after the Jonas Smith,
thinking there was mutiny or other crime on hoard. It
occurs to mo now that, since there is only mere suffering
and mjsery and nobody to punish, it ceases to be a matter
which (a republican form of) government will leel autho-
rized tq interfere in further. Dam a republican form of
government.
To Mrs. Jane Clemens, in Keokuk, Iowa :
Hartford, Fob. 17, 1878.
My dear Mother, — I suppose I am the worst corre-
spondent in the whole world ; and yet I grow worse and
worse all the time. My conscience blisters me for not
writing you, but it has ceased to abuse me for not writing
other folks.
Life has come to be a very serious matter with me. I
have a badgered, harassed feeling, a good part of my time.
It comes mainly of business responsibilities and annoy-
ances, and the persecution of kindly letters from well
meaning strangers — to whom I must be rudely silent or
else put in the biggest half of my time bothering over
answers. There arc other things also that help to consume
my time and defeat my projects. Well, the consequence
is, I cannot write a book at home. This cuts my income
down. Therefore, I have about made up, my mind to
take my tribe and fly to some little corner of Europe and
budge no more until I shall have completed one of the
half dozen books that lie begun, up stairs. Please say
nothing about this at present.
We propose to sail the 11th of April. I shall go to
Fredonia to meet you, but it will not be well for Livy
„ N
178
LETTERS OF MARK TWATN
to make that trip I am afraid. However, we shall see. I
will hope she can go.
Mr. Twichcll has just come in, so I must go to him.
We are all well, and send love to you all.
Affly,
Sam.
%
Hr was writing few letters at this time, and doing but little
work. There were always many social events during t he. winter,
and what with his European plans and a diligent study of the
German language, which the entire family undertook, his days
and evenings were full enough. Ilowells wrote piotesting
against the European travel. Clemens replied promptly, urging
a visit to Hartford, addiug a postscript for Mrs. Howells,
characteristic enough to warrant preservation.
P. S. to Mrs. Howells, in Boston :
Fob. ’78.
Dear Mrs. Howells. — Mrs. Clemens wrote you n
letter, and handed it to me half an hour ago, while I was
folding mine to Mr. Howells. 1 laid that letter on this
table before me while I added 1 he paragraph about
R ’s application. Since then 1 have been hunting
and sw’earing, and swearing and hunting, but I can’t
find a sign of that letter. It is the most astonishing dis-
appearance I ever heard of. Mrs. Clemens has gone off
driving — so 1 will have to try and give you an idea of her
communication from memory. Mainly it consisted of an
urgent desire that you come to see us next week, if you
can possibly manage it, for that will be a reposeful time,
the turmoil of breaking up beginning the week after.
She wants you to tell her about Italy, and advise her in
that connection, if you will. Then she spoke of her
plans — hers, mind you, for I never have anything quite
so definite as a plan. She proposes to stop a fortnight
in (confound the place, I’ve forgotten what it was,) then
go and live in Dresden till sometime in the summer ; then
retire to Switzerland for the hottest season, then stay
EUROPE
179
a while in Venice and put in the winter in Munich —
This program subject to modifications according to cir-
cumstances. She said something about some little by-
trips here and there, but they didn’t stick in my memory
because the idea didn’t charm me.
(They £ave just telephoned me from the Courant office
that Bayard Taylor and family have taken rooms in our
ship, tjje Ilolsatia, for the 11th April.)
Do come, if you possibly can ! — and remember and don’t
forget tp avoid letting Mrs. Clemens find out I lost her
letter. Just answer her the same as if you had got it.
Sincerely yours
S. L. Clemens.
The first European letter came from Frankfort, a rest on
their way to Heidelberg.
To W. D. Ho’oells, in Boston :
Frankfort on the Main, May 4 , 1878.
My dear IIowejls, - I only propose to write a single
line to say we arc still around. Ah, I have such a deep,
grateful, unutterable sense of being “ out of it all.” I
think I foretaste some of the advantages of being dead.
Some of the joy of it. I don’t read any newspapers or
care for them. When people tell me England has declared
war, I drop the subject, feeling that it is none of my busi-
ness ; when they tell me Mrs. Tilton has confessed and
Mr. B. denied, 1 say both of them have done that before,
therefore let the worn stub of the Plymouth white-wash
brush be brought out once more, and let the faithful spit
on their hands and get to work again regardless of me —
for I am out of it all.
We had 2 almost devilish weeks at sea (and I tell you
Bayard Taylor is a really lovable man — which you already
knew) then we staid a week in the beautiful, the very
beautiful city of Hamburg ; and since then we have been
fooling {fclong, 4 hours per day by rail, with a courier*
180
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
spending the other 20 in hotels whose enormous bed-
chambers and private parlors arc an overpowering marvel
to me. Day before yesterday, in Cassel, we had a love of
a bedroom 31 feet long, and a parlor with 2 sofas, 12 chairs,
a writing desk and 4 tables scattered around, here and
there in it. Made of red silk, too, by George.
The times and times I wish you were along ! You
could throw some fun into the journey ; whereas I go on,
day by day, in a smilcless state of solemn admiration.
What a paradise this is ! What clean clothes, what
good faces, what tranquil contentment, what prosperity,
what genuine freedom, what superb government. And
1 am so happy, for I am responsible for none of it. I am
only here to enjoy. How charmed I am when I overhear
a German word which I understand. With love from us
2 to you 2.
Mark.
P.S. . . . Poor Susy ! From the day we reached
German soil, we have required Rosa to speak German to
the children — which they hate with all their souls. The
other morning in Hanover, Susy came to us (from Rosa,
in the nursery) and said, in halting syllables, “ Papa, vie
viel uhr ist es ? ” — then turned with pathos in her big
eyes, and said, “ Mamma, I wish Rosa was made in
English.” ...
Part of letter to W. D. Howells , in Boston :
Scliloss-Hotel Heidelberg, Sunday, a.m., May 26, 1878.
My dear Howells, — . . . divinely located. From
this airy porah among the shining groves we look down
upon Heidelberg Castle, and upon the swift Neckar, and
the town, and out over the wide green level of the Rhine
valley — a marvelous prospect. We are in a cul-de-sac
formed of hill-ranges and river ; we are on the side of a
steep mountain ; the river at our feet is walled, on its
other side, (yes, on both sides,) by a steep and wooded
181
A RHINE LANDSCAPE
mountain-range which rises abruptly aloft from the water’s
edge ; portions of these mountains are densely wooded ;
the plain of the Rhine, seen through the mouth of this
pocket, has many and peculiar charms for the eye.
Out bedroom has two great glass bird-cages (enclosed
balconies) one looking toward the Rhine valley and sun-
set, the other looking up the Neckar cul-de-sac, and
naturally we spend nearly all our time in these — when
one is sunny the other is shady. We have tables and
chairs in them ; wc do our reading, writing, studying,
smoking and suppering in them.
The view from these bird-cages is my despair. The
pictures change from one enchanting aspect to another in
ceaseless procession, never keeping one form half an hour,
and never taking on an unlovely one.
And then Heidelberg on a dark night ! It is massed,
away down there, almost right under us, you know, and
stretches off toward the valley. Its curved and interlacing
streets are a cobweb, beaded thick with lights — a wonderful
thing to see ; then the rows of lights on the arched bridges,
and their glinting reflections in the water ; and away at
the far end, the Eisenbahnhof, with its twenty solid acres
of glittering gas-jets, a huge garden, as one may say,
whose every plant is a flame.
These balconies are the darlingest things. I have spent
all the morning in this north one. Counting big and
little, it has 25G panes of glass in it ; so one is in effect
right out in the free sunshine, and yet sheltered from
wind and rain — and likewise doored and curtained from
whatever may be going on in the bedroom. It must have
been a noble genius who devised this hotel. Lord, how
blessed is the repose, the tranquillity of this place ! Only
two sounds ; the happy clamor of the birds in the groves»
and the muffled music of the Neckar, tumbling over the
opposing dykes. It is no hardship to lie awake awhile,
nights, for this subdued roar has exactly the sound of a
steady rain beating upon a roof. It is so healing to the
182
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
spirit ; and it bears up the thread of one’s imaginings^
the accompaniment bears up a song.
While Livy and Miss Spaulding have been writing at
this table, I have sat tilted back, near by, with a pipe
and the last Atlantic, and read Charley Warner’s article
with prodigious enjoyment. I think it is exquisite. *
think it must be the roundest and broadest ‘and com-
pletest short essay he has ever written. It is elear, and
compact, and charmingly done.
The hotel grounds join and communicate with the.
Castle grounds ; so we and the children loaf in tlic wind-
ing paths of those leafy vastnesses a great deal, and drink
beer and listen to excellent music.
When we first came to this hotel, a couple of weeks ago,
I pointed to a house across the river, and said I meant to
rent the centre room on the 3d floor for a work-room.
Jokingly we got to speaking of it as my office ; and amused
ourselves with watcliing “ my people ” daily in their small
grounds and trying to make out what we could of their
dress, &c., without a glass. Well, I loafed along there one
day and found on that house the only sign of the kind
on that side of the river : Moblirte Wohnung zu Ver-
miethen 1 ” 1 went in and rented that very room which
I had long ago selected. There was only one other room
in the whole double-house unrented. •
(It occurs to me that I made a great mistake in not
thinking to deliver a very bad German speech, every
other sentence pieced out with English, at the Bayard
Taylor banquet in New York. I think I could have made
it one of the features of the occasion.) 1
Wc left Hartford before the end of March, and I have
been idle ever since. I have waited for a call to go to
work — I knew it would come. Well, it began to come a
week ago ; my note-book comes out more and more fre-
quently every day since ; 3 days ago I concluded to move
1 Ho used this plan at a gathering of tho American students in
Heidelberg, on July 1th, with great eflect ; so his idea was not wasted.
THE MONTHS
188
my manuscript over to my den. Now the call is loud and
decided at last. So tomorrow I shall begin regular, steady
work, and stick to it till middle of July or 1st August,
when 1 look for Twiehell ; we will then walk about Ger-
many 2 or 8 weeks, and then I’ll go to work again — (per-
haps in Munich.)
We both send a power of love to the IIowcllscs, and we
do with you were here. Are you in tjie new house ? Tell
us about it. Yrs Ever
, Mark.
August 1st brought Twiehell, and the friends set out without
delay on a tramp through the Black Forest, making short
excursions at lirst, but presently extending them in the direction
of Switzerland. Mrs. Clemens and the others remained in
Heidelberg, to follow at their leisure. To Mrs. Clemens her
husband sent frequent reports of their wanderings.
Over the Gemmi Pass.
4.30 p.m. Saturday, Aug. 24, 1878.
Livy darling, Joe and I have had a most noble day.
Started to climb (on foot) at 8.30 this morning among
the grandest peaks ! Every half hour carried us back a
mouth in the season. We left them harvesting 2d crop
of bay. At 0 we wore in July and found ripe strawberries ;
at 9.30 we were in June and gathered flowers belonging to
that month ; at 10 we were in May and gathered a flower
which appeared in Heidelberg the 17th of that month ;
also forget-me-nots, which disappeared from Heidelberg
about mid-May ; at 11.30 wc were in April (by the flowers ;)
at noon wc had rain and hail mixed, and wind and envelop-
ing fogs, and eonsidered it March ; at* 12.30 we had
snowbanks above us and snowbanks below us, and con-
sidered it February. Not good February, though, because
in the midst of the wild desolation the forget-me-not still
bloomed, lovely as ever.
What a flower garden the Gemmi Pass is ! After I had
got my hands full Joe made me a paper bag, which I pinned
184 LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
to my lapel and filled with choice specimens. I gathered
no flowers which I had ever gathered before except 4 or
5 kinds. We took it leisurely and I picked all I wanted to.
I mailed my harvest to you a while ago. Don’t send it
to Mrs. Brooks until you have looked it over, flower by
flower. It will pay. t
Among the clouds and everlasting snows I found a
brave and bright little forget-me-not growing in th<i very
midst of a smashed and tumbled stone-debris, just as
cheerful as if the barren and awful domes and ramparts
that towered around were the blessed walls of heaven.
I thought how Lilly Warner would be touched by such
a gracious surprise, if she, instead of I, had seen it. So
I plucked it, and have mailed it to her with a note.
Our walk was 7 hours — the last 2 down a path as steep
as a ladder, almost, cut in the face of a mighty precipice.
People are not allowed to ride down it. This part of the
day’s work taxed our knees, I tell you. We have been
loafing about this village (Leukerbad) for an hour, now
— we stay here over Sunday. Not tired at all. (Joe’s
hat fell over the precipice — so he came here bareheaded.)
I love you, my darling. Saml.
Twichcll also made his reports home, some of which give
us interesting pictures of his walking partner. In one place he
wrote : “ Mark is a queer fellow. There is nothing he so
d< lights in as a swift, strong stream. You can hardly get
him to leave one when once he is within the inlluenee of its
fascinations.”
Twichcll tells how at Kandcrsteg they were out together one
evening where a brook comes plunging down from Gasternthal
and how he pirjiul in a drift to see it go racing along the
current. “ When I got back to the path Mark was running
down stream after it as hard as he could go, throwing up his
hands and shouting in the wildest ecstasy, and when a piece
went over a fall and emerged to view in the foam below he
would jump up and down and yell. He said afterward that
he had not been so excited in three months.”
In other pieces Twichcll refers to his companion’s considera-
tion for the feeling of others, and for animals. “ When we are
A BAD DREAM
185
driving, his concern is all about the horse. He can’t bear to
see the whip used, or to sec a horse pull hard.”
The tramp really ended at Lausanne, where Clemens joined
his party. *
hr orev Switzerland the Clemens party worked down into
*Italy, sight-seeing, a diversion in which Mark Twain found
• little enough of interest.
From Italy the Clemens party went to Munich, where they
had arranged in advance for winter quarters. Clemens claims,
in his report of the matter to Howells, that he took the party
through without the aid of a courier, though thirty years later,
in some comment which he set down on being shown the letter,
he wrote ebneerning this paragraph : “ Probably a lie.”
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
No 1 a, Karlstrasse, 2 e Stock.
Care Frauloin Dahlwcmer.
Munich, Nov. 17, 1878.
. . . While it occurs to nv, I must tell you Susie’s last.
She is sorely badgered with dreams ; and her stock dream
is that she is being eaten up by bears. She is a grave and
thoughtful child, as you will remember. Last night she
had the usual dream. This morning she stood apart
(after telling it,) for some time, looking vacantly at the
floor, and absorbed in meditation. At last she looked
up, and with Ihe pathos of one wdio feels he has not been
dealt by with even-handed fairness, said “ But Mamma,
the trouble is, that I am never the bear, but always the
person.”
It would not have occurred to me that there might be
an advantage, even in a dream, in occasionally being the
eater, instead of always the party eaten, •but I easily
perceived that her point was w r ell taken.
I’m sending to Heidelberg for your letter and Winnie’s,
and I do hope they haven’t been lost.
My wife and I send love to you all.
Yrs ever,
Mark.
186
LETTERS 05 MARK TWAIN
The “ detective ” chapter mentioned below was not in-
cluded in A Tramp Abroad. It was published separately,
as The Stolen White Elephant in a volume bearing that title.
The play, which he had now found “ dreadfully witless and
Hat,” was no other than “ Simon Wheeler, Detective,” which
he had once regarded so highly. The “ Stewart ” referred to was <
the millionaire merchant, A. T. Stewart, whose body was stcien
in the expectation of reward. •
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Munich, Jan. 2*1, (1879)
My dear Howells, — It’s no use, — your letter mis-
carried m some way and is lost. The consul has made a
thorough search and says he has not been able to trace it.
It is unaccountable, for all the letters I did not want arrived
without a single grateful failure. Well, I have read-up,
now, as far as vou have got, — that is, to where there’s a
storm at sea approaching, — and we three think you are
clear out-Howellsing Howells. If your literature lias not
struck perfection now we are not able to see what is
lacking. It is all such truth — truth to the life ; every-
where your pen falls it lea\ os a photograph. I did imagine
that everything hail been said about life at sea that could
be said, — but no matter, it was all a failure and lies,
nothing but lies with a thin varnish of fttet, — only you
have stated it as it absolutely is. And only you see people
and their ways, and their insides and outsides as they
are, and make them talk as the y do talk. I think you are
the very greatest artist in these tremendous mysteries
that ever lived. There doesn’t seem to be anything that
can be concealed from your awful all-seeing eye. It must
be a cheerful thing for one to live with you and be aware
that you are going up and down in him like another con-
sek nee all the time. Possibly you will not be a fully ac-
cepted classic until you have been dead a hundred years,
~-il is the fate ot the Shakespeares and of all genuine
prophets, but then your books will be as common as
ORION CLEMENS
187
Bibles, I believe. You’re not a weed, but an oak ; not
a summer-house, but a cathedral. In that day 1 shall
still be in the Cyclopedias, too,— thus : “ Mark Twain ;
history and occupation unknown — but he was personally
acquainted with Howells.” There— J could sing your
praises all day , and feel and believe every bit of it.
My bobft is half finished ; I wish to heaven it was done.
I have given up writing a detective novel — can’t write a
novel, for I lack the faculty ; but when the detectives were
nosing around after Stewart’s loud remains, I threw a
chapter into my present book in which I have very ex-
travagantly burlesqued the detective business — if it is
possible to burlesque that business extravagantly. You
know I was going to send you that detective play, so
that you could re-write it. Well I didn’t do it because I
couldn’t find a single idea in it that could be useful to
you. It was dreadfully witless and Hat. I knew it would
sadden you and unfit you for work.
I have always been sorry we threw up that play em-
bodying Orion which you began. It was a mistake to
do that. Do keep that MS and tackle it again. It will
work out all right ; you will sec. I don’t believe that that
character exists in literature in so well-developed a con-
dition as it exists in Orion’s person. Now won’t you put
Orion in a stetry ? Then he will go handsomely into a play
afterwards. How deliciously you could paint him — it
would make fascinating reading — the sort that makes a
reader laugh and ery at the same time, for Orion is as good
and ridiculous a soul as ever was.
Ah, to think of Bayard Taylor ! It is too sad to talk
about I was so glad there was not a single sting and
so many good praiseful words in the Atlantic’s criticism
of Dcukalion.
Love to you all
Yrs Ever
Mark.
We remain here till middle of March.
188
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
In A Tramp Abroad there is an incident, in which the author
describes himself as hunting for a lost sock in the dark, in a
vast hotel bedroom at Heilbronn. The account of the real
incident, as written to Twichell, seems even more amusing.
“The Yarn About the Limburgcr Cheese and the Box of
Guns,” like “ The Stolen White Elephant,” did not find place
in the travel-book, but was published in the same volume with
the elephant story, added to the rambling notes of “ An Idle
Excursion.”
To Rev. J. II. Twichell , in Hartford :
Munich, Jan. 26 ’79.
Dear old Joe. — Sunday. Your delicious letter arrived
exactly at the right time. It was laid by my plate as I
was finishing breakfast at 12 noon. Livy and Clara
(Spaulding) arrived from church 5 minutes later ; I took
a pipe and spread myself out on the sofa, and Livy sat by
and read, and I warmed to that butcher the moment
he began to swear. There is more than one w ay of praying,
and I like the butcher’s way because the petitioner is so
apt to be in earnest. I was peculiarly alive to his perform-
ance just at this time, for another reason, to wit : Last
night I awoke at 8 this morning, and after raging to my-
self for 2 interminable hours, J gave it up. 1 rose, as-
sumed a catlike stealthiness, to keep from waking Livy,
and proceeded to dress in the pitch dark.' Slowly but
surely I got on garment after garment — all down to one
sock ; I had one slipper on and the other in my hand.
Well, on my hands and knees I crept softly around, paw-
ing and feeling and scooping along the carpet, and among
cliair-legs lor that missing sock ; 1 kept that up ; — and still
Kept it up ami kepi it up. At first I only said to myself
“ Blame lhat sock,” but that soon ceased to answer ; my
expletives grew steadily stronger and stronger, — and at
last, when J found I was lost , I had to sit flat down on the
floor and take hold of something to keep from lifting the
roof off with the profane explosion that was trying to get
out of me I could see the dim blur of the window, but
A LOST SOCK
189
of course it was in the wrong place and could give me no
information as to where 1 was. But 1 had one comfort
— I had not waked Livy ; I believed 1 could find that
sock in silence if the night lasted long enough. So J
started again and softly pawed all over the place, — and
sure enough at the end of half an hour I laid my hand on
the missing article. 1 rose joyfully up and butted the
wash-bowl and pitcher oft the stand and simply raised
SO to speak. Livy screamed, then said, “ Who is
that ? what is the matter ? ” I said “ There ain’t anything
the matter — I’m hunting for my sock.” She said, “ Are
you hunting for it with a club ? ”
I went in the parlor and lit the lamp, and gradually
the fury subsided and the ridiculous features of the thing
began to suggest themselves. So I lay on the sofa, with
note-book and pencil, and transferred the adventure to
our big room in the hotel at Ileilbronn, and got it on
paper a good deal to my satisfaction.
I found the Swiss note-book, some time ago. When it
was first lost I was glad of it, for I was getting an idea
that I had lost my faculty of writing sketches of travel ;
therefore the loss of that note-book would render the
writing of this one simply impossible, and let me grace-
fully out ; I was about to v\ rite to Bliss and propose some
other book, when the confounded thing turned up, and
down went my heart into my boots. But there was now
no excuse, so I went solidly to work — tore up a great part
of the MS written in Heidelberg, — wrote and tore up, —
continued to write and tear up, — and at last, reward of
patient and noble persistence, my pen got the old swing
again ! •
Since then I'm glad Providence knew better what to
do with the Swiss note-book than I did, for I like my work,
now, exceedingly, and often turn out over 80 MS pages
a day and then quit sorry that Heaven makes the days
so short.
One of my discouragements had been the belief that
190 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN t
my interest in this tour had been so slender that I eouldn’t
gouge matter enough out of it to make a book. What a
mistake. I’ve got 900 pages written (not a word in it
about the sea voyage) yet I stepped my foot out of
Heidelberg for the first time yesterday, — and then only
to take our party of four on our first pedestrian tou* -
to Heilbronn. I’ve got them dressed elaborately in walk-
ing costume — knapsacks, canteens, field-glasses, , leather
leggings, patent walking shoes, muslin folds around their
hats, with long tails hanging down behind, sun umbrellas,
and Alpenstocks. They go all the way to Wimpfen by
rail — thence to Ilcilbronn in a chance vegetable cart drawn
by a donkey and a cow ; I shall fetch them home on a
raft ; and if other people shall perceive that that was no
pedestrian excursion, they themselves shall not be conscious
of it.— This trip will take 100 pages or more, — oh, good-
ness knows how many ! for the mood is everything, not
the material, and I already seem to see 300 pages rising
before me on that trip. Then, I propose to leave Heidel-
berg for good. Don’t you see, the book (1800 MS pages,)
may really be finished before I ever get to Switzerland ?
But there’s one thing ; l want to tell Frank Bliss and
his father to be charitable toward me in, — that is, let me
tear up all the MS I want to, and give me time to write
more. I shan’t waste the time — I haven’t ‘the slightest
desire to loaf, but a consuming desire to work, ever since
I got back my swing. And you see this book is either
going to be compared with the Innocents Abroad, or
contrasted with it, to my disadvantage. I think 1 can make
a book that will be no dead corpse of a thing and I mean
vo do my level best to accomplish that.
My crude plans are crystalizing. As the thing stands
now, I went to Europe for three purposes. The first you
know, and must keep secret, even from the Blisses ; the
second is to study Art ; and the third to acquire a critical
knowledge of the German language. My MS already
shows that the two latter objects are accomplished. It
SWITZERLAND
191
shows that I am moving about as an Artist and a Philo-
logist, and unaware that there is any immodesty in as-
suming these titles. Having three definite objects has
had the cllect of seeming to enlarge my domain and give
# mc the freedom of a loose costume. It is three strings to
• my bow, too.
Well, your butcher is magnificent. He won’t stay out
of my mind. — I keep trying to think of some way of
getting your account of him into my book without his
being offendid -and yet confound him there isn’t any-
thing you have said which he would sec any offense in,
— I’m only thinking of his friends — they are the parties
who busy themselves with seeing things for people. But
I’m bound to have him in. I'm putting in the yarn about
the Limburger cheese and the box of guns, too — mighty
glad Howells declined it. -It seems to gather richness and
flavor with age. I have very nearly killed several com-
panies with that narrative,— the American Artists’ Club,
here, for instance, and Smith and wife and Miss Griffith
(they were here in this house a week or two.) I’ve got 3
other chapters that pretty nearly destroyed the same
parties, too. —
O, Switzerland ! llu* further it recedes into the enrich-
ing haze of time, the more intolerably delicious the charm
of it and the cheer of it and the glory and majesty and
solemnity and pathos of it grow. Those mountains had a
soul ; they thought ; they spoke,— one couldn’t hear it
with the ears of the body, but what a voice it was ! — and
how real. Deep down in my memory it is sounding yet.
Alp calleth unto Alp !- that stately old Scriptural word-
ing is the right one lor God’s Alps and God’s ocean. How
puny we were in that awful presence— and how painless
it was to be so ; how fitting and right it seemed, and how
stingless was the sense of our unspeakable insignificance.
And Lord how pervading were the repose and peace and
blessedness that poured out of the heart of the invisible
Great Spirit of the Mountains.
192
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Now what is it ? There arc mountains and mountains
and mountains in this world — but only these take you
by the heart-strings. I wonder what the secret of it is.
Well, time and time again it has seemed to me that I
must drop everything and flee to Switzerland once more.^
It is a longing — a deep, strong, tugging longing — that is •
the word. We must go again, Joe. — October days, let
us get up at dawn and breakfast at the tower. I should
like that first rate.
Livy and all of us send deluges of love to you and
Harmony and all the children. 1 dreamed last nfght that 1
woke up in the library at home and your children were
frolicing around me and Julia was sitting in my lap ; you
and Harmony and both families of Warners had finished
their welcomes and were filing out through the conserva-
tory door, wrecking Patrick’s flower pots with their
dress skirts as they went. Peace and plenty abide with
you all !
Mabk.
I want the Blisses to know their part of this letter, if
possible. They will see that my delay was not from
choice.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Munich, Feb. 9. (1879)
My deab Howells, — I have just received this letter
from Orion — take care of it, for it is worth preserving.
I got as far as 9 pages in my answer to it, when Mrs.
Clemens shu£ down on it, and said it was cruel, and made
me send the money and simply wish his lecture success.
I said I couldn’t lose my 9 pages—so she said send them
to you. Hut I will acknowledge that I thought I was
writing a very kind letter.
Now just look at this letter of Orion’s. Did you ever
THE CAREER OF ORION CLEMENS LMJ
see the grotesquely absurd and the he&rt-breakingfy
pathetic more closely joined together ? Mrs. Clemens said
“ Raise his monthly pension.” So I wrote to Perkins to
raise it a trifle.
Now only think of it ! He still has 100 pages to write
on his lecture, yet in one inking of his pen he has already
swooped around the United States and invested the result I
You must put him in a book or a play right away. You
are the only man capable of doing it. You might die at
any moment, and your very greatest work would be lost
to the World. I could write Orion’s simple biography,
and make it effective, too, by merely stating the bald
facts — -and this I will do if he dies before I do ; but you
must put him into romance. This was the understanding
you and I had the day I sailed.
. Observe Orion’s career — that is, a little of it : (1) He has
belonged to as many as five different religious denomina-
tions ; last March he withdrew from the deaconship in
a Congregational Church and the Superintendency of its
Sunday School, in a speech in which he said that for many
months (it runs in my mind that he said 18 years,) he
had been a confirmed infidel, and so felt it to be his duty
to retire from the flock.
2. After being a republican for years, he wanted me
to buy him &, democratic newspaper. A few days before
the Presidential election, he came out in a speech and
publicly went over to the democrats ; he prudently
“ hedged ” by voting for 6 state republicans, also.
The new convert was made one of the secretaries of
the democratic meeting, and placed in the list of speakers.
He wrote me jubilantly of what a ten-strik^ he was going
to make with that speech. All right — but think of his
innocent and pathetic candor in writing me something
like this, a week later :
“ I was more diffident than I had expected to be, and
this was increased by the silence with which I was re-
ceived when I came forward ; so 1 seemed unable to get
. o
194
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
€
the fire into my speech which I had calculated upon, and
presently they began to get up and go out; and in a
few minutes they all rose up and went away. w
How could a man uncover such a sore as that and show
it to another ? Not a word of complaint, you see — only
a patient, sad surprise.
3. His next project was to write a burlesque upon
Paradise Lost.
4. Then, learning that the Times was paying Hartc
$100 a column for stories, he concluded to write some for
the same price. I read his first one and persucided him
not to write any more.
5. Then he read proof on the N. Y. Eve. Post at $10
a week and meekly observed that the foreman swore at
him and ordered him around “ like a steamboat mate.”
6. Being discharged from that post, he wanted to try
agriculture — was sure he could make a fortune out of a
chicken farm. I gave him $900 and he went to a ten-house
village 2 miles above Keokuk on the river bank — this
place was a railway station. He soon asked for money to
buy a horse and light wagon, — because the trains did not
run at church time on Sunday and his wife found it rather
far to walk.
For a long time I answered demands for “ loans ” and
by next mail always received his check for the interest
due me to date. In the most guileless way he let it leak
out that he did not underestimate the value of his custom
to me, since it was not likely that any other customer of
mine paid his interest quarterly, and this enabled me to
use my capital twice in 6 months instead of only once.
But alas, when the debt at last reached $1800 or $2500
(I have forgotten which) the interest ate too formidably
into his borrowings, and so he quietly ceased to pay it
or speak of it. At the end of two years I found that the
chicken farm had long ago been abandoned, and he had
moved into Keokuk. Later in one of his casual moments,
he observed that there was no money in fattening a
. ORION’S CAREER CONTINUED 195
chicken on 65 cents worth of corn and then selling it
for 50.
7. Finally, if I would lend him $500 a year for two
years, (this was 4 or 5 years ago,) he knew he could make
a success as a lawyer, and would prove it. This is the
pension which we have just increased to $600. The first
year his legal business brought him $5. It also brought
him an unremunerative case where some villains were try-
ing to chouse some negro orphans out of $700. He still
has this* ease. He has waggled it around through various
courts and made some booming speeches on it. The
negro children have grown up and married off, now, I
believe, and their litigated town-lot has been dug up and
carted off by somebody — but Orion still infests the courts
with his documents and makes the welkin ring with his
venerable case. The -second year, he didn’t make any-
thing. The third he made $6, and I made Bliss put a
case in his hands — about half an hour’s work. Orion
charged $50 for it — Bliss paid him $15. Thus four or
five years of lawing has brought him $26, but this will
doubtless be increased when he gets done lecturing and
buys that “ law library.” Meantime his office rent has
been $60 a year, and he has stuck to that lair day by
day as patiently as a spider.
8. Then lie by and by conceived the idea of lecturing
around America as “ Mark Twain’s Brother ” — that to
be on the bills. Subject of proposed lecture, “ On the
Formation of Character.”
9. I protested, and he got on his warpaint, couched
his lance, and ran a bold tilt against total abstinence and
the Red Ribbon fanatics. It raised a fine row among the
virtuous Keokukians.
10. I wrote to encourage him in his good work, but I
had let a mail intervene ; so by the time my letter reached
him he was already winning laurels as a Red Ribbon
Howler.
11. ^.fterward he took a rabid part in a prayer-meeting
196
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
epidemic ; dropped that to travesty Jules Verne ; dropped
that, in the middle of the last chapter, last March, to
digest the matter of an infidel book which he proposed to
write ; and now he comes to the surface to rescue our
“ noble and beautiful religion ” from the sacrilegious talons
of Bob Ingersoll.
Now come ! Don’t fool away this treasure which
Providence has laid at your feet, but take it up apd use
it. One can let his imagination run riot in portraying
Orion, for there is nothing so extravagant as to bj out of
character with him.
Well — good-bye, and a short life and a merry one be
yours. Poor old Methusaleh, how did he manage to
stand it so long ?
Yrs ever,
Mark. •
To Orion Clemens
(Unsent and inclosed with the foregoing, to W. D. Howells) :
Munich, Feb. 9, (1879)
My dear Bro., — Yours has just arrived. I enclose a
draft on Hartford for $25. You will have abandoned the
project you wanted it for, by the time it arrives, — but
no matter, apply it to your newer and present project,
whatever it is. You see I have an ineradicable faith in
your unsteadfastness, — but mind you, I didn’t invent
that faith, you conferred it on me yourself. But fire
away, fire away! I don’t see why a changeable man
shouldn’t get as much enjoyment out of his changes, and
transformations and transfigurations as a steadfast man
gets out of standing still and pegging at the same old
monotonous thing all the time. That is to say, I don’t
see why a kaleidoscope shouldn’t enjoy itself as much as
a telescope, nor a grindstone have as good a time as a
whetstone, nor a barometer as good a time as a yardstick.
I don’t feel like girding at you any more about fickleness
of purpose, because I recognize and realize at last that it
AN UNSENT LETTER
197
is incurable; but before I learned to accept this truth,
each new weekly project of yours possessed the power of
throwing me into the most exhausting and helpless con-
vulsions of profanity. But fire away, now I Your magic
has lost its might. I am able to view your inspirations
dispassionately and judicially, now, and say “This one
or that one or the other one is not up to your average
flight, or is above it, or below it.”
And so, without passion, or prejudice, or bias of any
kind, L sit in judgment upon your lecture project, and say
it was up to your average, it was indeed above it, for it
had possibilities in it, and even 'practical ones. While I
was not sorry you abandoned it, I should not be sorry
if you had stuck to it and given it a trial. But on the
whole you did the wise thing to lay it aside, I think, be-
cause a lecture is a most easy thing to fail in ; and at your
time of life, and in your own town, such a failure would
make a deep and cruel wound in your heart and in your
pride. It was decidedly unwise in you to think for a
moment of coming before a community who knew you,
with such a course of lectures ; because Keokuk is not
unaware that you have been a Swedenborgian, a Presby-
terian, a Congregationalist, and a Methodist (on proba-
tion), and that just a year ago you were an infidel. If
Keokuk had gone to your lecture course, it would have
gone to be amused, not instructed, — for when a man is
known to have no settled convictions of his own he can’t
convince other people. They would have gone to be
amused and that would have been a deep humiliation to
you. It could have been safe for you to appear only
where you were unknown — then many of your hearers
would think you were in earnest. And they would be
right. You are in earnest while your convictions are new.
But taking it by and large, you probably did best to dis-
card that project altogether. But I leave you to judge of
that, for you are the worst judge I know of.
(Unfisiahed.)
198
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
In Paris Mark Twain and his family found pleasant quarters
at the Hotel Normandy, but it was a chilly, rainy spring, and
they gained a rather poor impression of the French capital.
It was September 8, 1879, that Mark Twain returned to
America by the steamer Gallia. In the seventeen months of
his absence he had taken on a “ travelled look ” and had added
grey hairs.
To W. D. Howells , in Boston :
Elmira, Sept. 15, 1879.
. . . Say — a friend of mine wants to write a play with
me, I to furnish the broad-comedy cuss. I don’t know
anything about his ability, but his letter serves to remind
me of our old projects. If you haven’t used Orion or Old
Wakeman, don’t you think you and I can get together
and grind out a play with one of those fellows in it,?
Orion is a field which grows richer and richer the more he
mulches it with each new topdressing of religion or other
guano. Drop me an immediate line about this, won’t
you ? I imagine I see Orion on the stage, always gentle,
always melancholy, always changing his politics and re-
ligion, and trying to reform the world, always inventing
something, and losing a limb by a new kind of explosion
at the end of each of the four acts. Poor old chap, he
is good material. I can imagine his wife or hie sweetheart
reluctantly adopting each of his new religions in turn,
just in time to see him waltz into the next one and leave
her isolated once more.
(Mem. Orion’s wife has followed him into the outer
darkness, after 80 years’ rabid membership in the Pres-
byterian Churcfc.)
Well, with the sincerest and most abounding love to
you and yours, from all this family, I am,
Yrs ever
Mark.
The idea of the play interested Ilowells, but he had twinges
of conscience in the matter of using Orion as material. As a
ORION
199
matter of fact, Orion Clemens had a keen appreciation of his
own shortcomings, and would have enjoyed himself in a play
as much as any observer of it. Indeed, it is more than likely
that he would have been pleased at the thought of such dis-
tinguished dramatization.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Elmira, Oot. 9 ’79.
My dear Howells, — Since my return, the mail facili-
ties haw enabled Orion to keep me informed as to his
intentions. Twenty-eight days ago it was his purpose to
complete a work aimed at religion, the preface to which
he had already written. Afterward he began to sell off
his furniture, with the idea of hurrying to Leadville and
tackling silver-mining — threw up his law den and took
in his sign. Then he wrote to Chicago and St. Louis
newspapers asking for a situation as “ paragrapher ”■ —
enclosing a taste of his quality in the shape of two stanzas
of “ humorous rhymes.” By a later mail on the same day
he applied to New York and Hartford insurance com-
panies for copying to do.
However, it would take too long to detail all his pro-
jects. They comprise a removal to south-west Missouri ;
application for a reporter’s berth on a Keokuk paper;
application for a compositor’s berth on a St. Louis paper ;
a re-hanging of his attorney’s sign, “ though it only creaks
and catches no flies ; ” but last night’s letter informs me
that he has re-tackled the religious question, hired a
distant den to write in, applied to my mother for $50 to
re-buy his furniture, which has advanced in value since
the sale — purposes buying $25 worth of broks necessary
to his labors which he had previously been borrowing,
and his first chapter is already on its way to me for my
decision as to whether it has enough ungodliness in it or
not. Poor Orion ! . . .
The reader may remember Mark Twain’s Whittier dinner
200
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
speech of 1877, and its disastrous effects. Now, in 1879, there
was to be another Atlantic gathering : a breakfast to Dr. Oliver
Wendell Holmes, to which Clemens was invited. He was not
eager to accept ; it would naturally recall memories of two
years before, but being urged by both Howells and Warner, he
agreed to attend if they would permit him to speak. Mark
Twain never lacked courage and he wanted to redeem himself.
To Howells he wrote ; •
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, Nov. 28, 1879.
My deae Howells, — If anybody talks, there, I shall
claim the right to say a word myself, and be heard among
the very earliest — else it would be confoundedly awkward
for me— and for the rest, too. But you may read what^ I
say, beforehand, and strike out whatever you choose.
Of course I thought it wisest not to be there at all ;
but Warner took the opposite view, and most strenuously.
Speaking of Johnny’s conclusion to become an outlaw,
reminds me of Susie’s newest and very earnest longing —
to have crooked teeth and glasses — “ like Mamma.”
I would like to look into a child’s head, once, and see
what its processes are.
Yrs ever, ,
S. L. Clemens.
The matter turned out well. Clemens, once more introduced
by Howells — this time conservatively, it may be said — delivered
a delicate and fitting tribute to Doctor Holmes, full of graceful
humour and grateful acknowledgment, the kind of speech he
should have given at the Whittier dinner of two years before.
No reference was made to his former disaster, and this time he
came away covered with glory, and fully restored in his self-
respect.
A Tramp Abroad, which Mark Twain had hoped to finish
in Paris, and later in Elmira, for some reason would not come
to an end. In December, in Hartford, he was still working
on it, and he would seem to have finished it, at last, rather
by a decree than by any natural process of authorship.
“A TRAMP ABROAD ” 201
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, Jan* 8, '80.
My dear Howells, — Am waiting for Patrick to come
with the carriage. Mrs. Clemens and I are starting
(without the children) to stay indefinitely in Elmira.
The wear and tear of settling the house broke her down,
and she has been growing weaker and weaker for a fort-
night. All that time — in fact ever since I saw you — 1
have been fighting a life-and-death battle with this in-
fernal book and hoping to get done some day. I required
300 pages of MS, and I have written near 600 since I
saw you — and tore it all up except 288. This I was about
to tear up yesterday and begin again, when Mrs. Perkins
came up to the billiard room and said, “You will never
g<A any woman to do the thing necessary to save her
life by mere persuasion ; you sec you have wasted your
words for three weeks ; it is time to use force ; she must
have a change ; take her home and leave the children
here.”
I said, “If there is one death that is painfuller than
another, may I get it if I don’t do that thing.”
So I took the 288 pages to Bliss and told him that was
the very last line I should ever write on this book. (A
book which inquired 2600 pages of MS, and I have written
nearer four thousand, first and last.)
I am as soary (and flighty) as a rocket, to-day, with the
unutterable joy of getting that Old Man of the Sea off
my back, where he has been roosting for more than a
year and a half. Next time I make a contract before
writing the book, may I suffer the righteoifc penalty and
be burnt, like the injudicious believer.
I am mighty glad you are done your book (this is from
a man who, above all others, feels how much that sentence
means) and am also mighty glad you have begun the
next (this is also from a man who knows the felicity of
that, and means straightway to enjoy it.) The Undis-
m LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
covered starts off delightfully — I have read it aloud to
Mrs. C. and we vastly enjoyed it.
Well, time’s about up— must drop a line to Aldrich.
Yrs ever,
Mare
In a letter which Mark Twain wrote to his Mother Orion
at this period we get the first hint of a venture which was to
play an increasingly important part in the Hartford hdme and
fortunes during the next ten or a dozen years. This was the
type-setting machine investment, which, in the end, nil but
wrecked Mark Twain’s finances. There is but a brief mention
of it in the letter to Orion, and the letter itself is not worth
preserving, but as references to the “ machine ” appear with
increasing frequency, it seems proper to record here its first
mention. In the same letter he suggests to his brother that he
undertake an absolutely truthful autobiography, a confession in
which nothing is to be withheld. He cites the value of Casa-
nova’s memories, and the confessions of Rousseau. Of course,
any literary suggestion from “ Brother Sam ” was gospel to
Orion, who began at once piling up manuscript at u great rate.
Meantime, Mark Twain himself, having got A Tramp
Abroad on the presses, was at work with enthusiasm on a story
begun nearly three years before at Quarry Farm — a story for
children — its name, as he called it then, “ The Little Prince and
The Little Pauper.”
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, Moh. 11, '80.
My sear Howells, — ... I take so much pleasure in
my story that I am loth to hurry, not wanting to get it
done. Did I ever tell you the plot of it ? It begins at
9 a.m., Jan. 97, 1547, seventeen and a half hours before
Henry VIII’s death, by the swapping of clothes and
places, between the prince of Wales and a pauper boy of
the same age and countenance (and half as much learning
and still more genius and imagination) and after that, the
rightful small King has a rough time among tramps and
ruffians in the country parts of Kent, whilst the small bogus
“'£HE PRINCE AND THE PAUPER ** 208
King has a gilded and worshipped and dreary and re-
strained and cussed time of it on the throne— and this
all goes on for three weeks — till the midst of the coronation
grandeurs in Westminster Abbey, Feb. 20, when the ragged
?true King forces his way in but cannot prove his genuine-
* ness — until the bogus King, by a remembered incident
of the first *day is able to prove it for him — whereupon
clothes jarc changed and the coronation proceeds under
the new and rightful conditions.
My idpa is to afford a realizing sense of the exceeding
severity of the laws of that day by inflicting some of their
penalties upon the King himself and allowing him a
chance to see the rest of them applied to others — all of
which is to account for certain mildnesses which distin-
guished Edward Vi’s reign from those that preceded and
followed it.
Imagine this fact — I have even fascinated Mrs. Clemens
with this yam for youth. My stuff generally gets con-
siderable damning with faint praise out of her, but this
time it is all the other way. She is become the horse-
leech’s daughter and my mill doesn’t grind fast enough to
suit her. This is no mean triumph, my dear sir. . . .
Yrs ever,
Mark.
Orion Clemens, meantime, was forwarding his manuscript,
and for once seems to have won his brother’s approval, so much
so that Mark Twain was willing, indeed anxious, that Howells
should run the “ autobiography ” in the Atlantic.
To Orion Clemens :
May 0, '80.
My dear Brother, — It is a model autobiography.
Continue to develop your character in the same gradual
inconspicuous and apparently unconscious way. The
reader, up to this time, may have his doubts, perhaps,
but he can’t say decidedly, “ This writer is not such a
204 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN ,
simpleton as he has been letting on to be.” Keep him in
that state of mind. If, when you shall have finished, the
reader shall say, “ The man is an ass, but I really don’t
know whether he knows it or not,” your work will be a
triumph. *•
Stop re-writing. I saw places in your last batch wh p "e *
re-writing had done formidable injury. Do* not try to
find those places, else you will mar them furthei; by try-
ing to better them. It is perilous to revise a book while
it is under way. All of us have injured our boqks in that
foolish way.
Keep in mind what I told you — when you recollect
something which belonged in an earlier chapter, do not
go back, but jam it in where you are. Discursiveness
does not hurt an autobiography in the least.
I have penciled the MS here and there, but have*not
needed to make any criticisms or to knock out anything.
The elder Bliss has heart disease badly, and thence-
forth his life hangs upon a thread.
Yr Bro
Sam.
But Howells could not bring himself to print so frank a con-
fession as Orion had been willing to make. “ It wrung my
heart,” he said, “ and I felt haggard after I had finished it.
The writer’s soul is laid bare ; it is shocking.” Howells added
that the best touches in it were those which made one acquainted
with the writer’s brother ; that is to say, Mark Twain, and that
these would prove valuable material hereafter — a true prophecy,
for Mark Twain’s early biography would have lacked most of its
vital incident, and at least half of its background, without those
faithful chapters, fortunately preserved. Had Orion continued,
as he began, the work might have proved an important contri-
bution to literature, but he went trailing off into by-paths of
theology and discussion where the interest was lost. There
were, perhaps, as many as two thousand pages of it, which few
could undertake to read.
Mark Twain’s mind was always busy with plans and inven-
tions, many of them of serious intent, some semi-serious, others
of a purely whimsical character. Once he proposed a “ Modest
THE MODEST CLUB
205
«
Club/* of which the first and main qualification for membership
was modesty. “At present,” he wrote, “I am the only
member; and as the modesty required must be of a quite
aggravated type, the enterprise did seem for a time doomed to
stop dead still with myself, for lack of further material ; but
jupon reflection I have come to the conclusion that you are
• eligible. Therefore, I have held a meeting and voted to offer
you the distinction of membership. I do not know that we
can find any others, though I have had some thought of Hay,
Warner, . Twichtll, Aldrich, Osgood, Fields, Iligginson, and a
few more — together with Mrs. Howells, Mrs. Clemens, and
certain others of the sex.”
Howellk replied that the only reason he had for not joining
the Modest Club was that he was too modest — too modest to
confess his modesty. “ If I could get over this difficulty I
should like to join, for I approve highly of the Club and its
object. ... It ought to be given an annual dinner at the public
expense. If you think I am not too modest you may put my
naqje down and I will try to think the same of you. Mrs.
Howells applauded the notion of the club from the very first.
She said that she knew one thing : that she was modest enough,
anyway. Her manner of saying it implied that the other persons
you had named were not, and created a painful impression in
my mind. I have sent your letter and the rules to Hay, but
I doubt his modesty. He will think he has a right to belong
to it as much as you or I ; whereas, other people ought only
to be admitted on sufferance.”
Our next letter to Howells is, in the main, pure foolery, but
we get in it a hint of what was to become in time one of Mark
Twain’s strongest interests, the matter of copyright. He had
both a personal and general interest in the subject. His own
books were constantly pirated in Canada, and the rights of
foreign authors were not respected in America. We have already
seen how he had drawn a petition which Holmes, Lowell, Long-
fellow, and others were to sign, and while nothing had come of
this plan he had never ceased to formulate others. ITet he
hesitated when he found that the proposed protection was likely
to work a hardship to readers of the poorer ejass. Once he
wrote : “ My notions have mightily changed lately. ... I can
buy a lot of the copyright classics, in paper, at from three to
thirty cents apiece. These things must find their way into the
very kitchens and hovels of the country. . . , And even if the
treaty will kill Canadian piracy, and thus save me an average
of $5,000 a year, I am down on it anyway, and I’d hke cussed
well to write an article opposing the treaty.”
206 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN .
To W. D. Howells, in Belmont , Mass. :
Thursday, June 6th, 1880.
My dear Howells,— There you stick, at Belmont,
and now I’m going to Washington for a few days; and,
of course, between you and Providence that visit is going '
to get mixed, and you’ll have been here and* gone again
just about the time I get back. Bother it all, I wanted to
astonish you with a chapter or two from Orion’s latest
book — not the seventeen which he has begun ip the last
four months, but the one which he began last week.
Last night, when I went to bed, Mrs. Clemens said,
“ George didn’t take the cat down to the cellar — Rosa
says he has left it shut up in the conservatory.” So I
went down to attend to Abner (the cat). About 8 in the
morning Mrs. C. woke me and said, “ I do believe I hear
that cat in the drawing-room — what did you do with
him ? ” I answered up with the confidence of a man who
has managed to do the right thing for once, and said
“ I opened the conservatory doors, took the library off
the alarm, and spread everything open, so that there
wasn’t any obstruction between him and the cellar.”
Language wasn’t capable of conveying this woman’s
disgust. But the sense of what she said, was, “ He couldn’t
have done any harm in the conservatory— so you must
go and make the entire house free to him and the burglars,
imagining that he will prefer the coal-bins to the drawing-
room. If you had had Mr. Howells to help you, I should
have admired but not been astonished, because I should
know that together you would be equal to it ; but how
you managed to contrive such a stately blunder all by
yourself, is what I cannot understand.”
So, you see, even she knows how to appreciate our gifts.
Brisk times here. — Saturday, these things happened :
Our neighbor Chas. Smith was stricken with heart disease,
and came near joining the majority; my publisher,
Bliss, ditto, ditto ; a neighbor’s child died ; neighbor
A STRING OP CALAMITIES 20*
Whitmore’s sixth child added to his five other cases of
measles; neighbor Niles sent for, and responded; Susie
Warner down, abed ; Mrs. George Warner threatened
with death during several hours ; her son Frank, whilst
, imitating the marvels in Barnum’s circus bills, thrown
• from his aged horse and brought home insensible : Warner’s
friend Max ’Yortzburgh, shot in the back by a locomotive
and broken into 82 distinct pieces and his life threatened ;
and Mrs. Clemens, after writing all these cheerful things
to Clara Spaulding, taken at midnight, and if the doctor
had not \>een pretty prompt the contemplated Clemens
would have called before his apartments were ready.
However, everybody is all right now, except Yortzburgh,
and he is mending — that is, he is being mended. I knocked
off, during these stirring times, and don’t intend to go to
woi!k again till we go away for the Summer, 3 or C weeks
hence. So I am writing to you not because I have any-
thing to say, but because you don’t have to answer and
I need something to do this afternoon. . . .
I have a letter from a Congressman this morning, and
he says Congress couldn’t be persuaded to bother about
Canadian pirates at a time like this when all legislation
must have a political and Presidential bearing, else Con-
gress won’t look at it. So have changed my mind and my
course ; I go north, to kill a pirate. I must procure repose
some way, else I cannot get down to work again.
Pray offer my most sincere and respectful approval to
the President — is approval the proper word ? I find it is the
one I most value here in the household and seldomest get.
With our affection to you both.
Yrs ever •
Mare.
It was always dangerous to send strangers with letters of
introduction to Mark Twain. They were so apt to arrive at
the wrong time, or to find him in the wrong mood. Howells
was willing to risk it, and that the result was only amus ing
instead of tragic is the best proof of their friendship.
208
letters of mark: twain
To W. D. Hoivells, in Belmont , Mass. :
June 9, '80.
Well, old practical joker, the corpse of Mr. X — - has
been here, and I have bedded it and fed it, and put own
my work during 24 hours and tried my level best to make •
it do something, or say something, or appreciate some-
thing — but no, it was worse than Lazarus. A kind-hearted,
well-meaning corpse was the Boston young n$an, but lawsy
bless me, horribly dull company. Now, old man, unless
you have great confidence in Mr. X’s judgment, you ought
to make him submit his article to you before he prints it.
For only think how true 1 was to you : Every hour that
he was here I was saying, gloatingly, “ O G — — d you,
when you are in bed and your light out, I will fix you ”
(meaning to kill him) . . . but then the thought would fol-
low — “ No, Howells sent him — he shall be spared, he shall
be respected — he shall travel hell-wards by his own route.”
Breakfast is frozen by this time, and Mrs. Clemens corre-
spondingly hot. Good bye.
Yrs ever,
Mabk.
“ I did not expect you to ask that man to live with you,” '
Howells answered. “ What I was afraid of was that you would
turn him out of doors, on sight, and so I tried to put in a good
word for him. After this when 1 want you to board people.
I’ll ask you. I am sorry for your suffering. I suppose I have
mostly lost my smell for bores ; but yours is preternaturally
keen.”
To Rev. Twichell, in Hartford :
Quarry Farm, Aug. 29 [’80].
Deae old Joe, — Concerning Jean Clemens, if anybody
said he “ didn’t sec no p’ints about that frog that’s any
better’n any other frog,” I should think he was convicting
himself of being a pretty poor sort of observer. ... I will
not go into details ; it is not necessary ; you will soon be
CATS
209
in Hartford, where I have already hired a hall ; the
admission fee will be but a trifle.
It is curious to note the change in the stock-quotation
of the Affection Board brought about by throwing this
^new security on the market. Four weeks ago the children
• still put Mamma at the head of the list right along, where
she had always been. But now :
Jean
Mamma
Motley
„ , . cats.
Fraulein
Papa
That is the way it stands, now. Mamma is become
No. 2 ; I have dropped from No. 4, and am become No.
5. !Some time ago it used to be nip and tuck between me
and the cats, but after the cats “ developed ” I didn’t
stand any more show.
I’ve got a swollen ear ; so I take advantage of it to lie
abed most of the day, and read and smoke and scribble
and have a good time. Last evening Livy said with deep
concern, “ O dear, I believe an abscess is forming in your
ear.”
I responded as the poet would have done if he had had
a cold in the head —
“ Tis said that abscess conquers love,
But O believe it not.”
This made a coolness.
Been reading Daniel Webster’s Private Correspondence.
Have read a hundred of his diffuse, conceited,* eloquent,”
bathotic (or bathostic) letters written in that dim (no,
vanished) Past when he was a student ; and Lord, to think
that this boy who is so real to me now, and so booming
with fresh young blood and bountiful life, and sappy
cynicisms about girls, has since climbed the Alps of fame
and stood against the sun one brief tremendous moment
SI0 LETTERS OF MASK TWAIN
with the world’s eyes upon him, and then — f-z-t- 1 where
is he ? Why the only long thing, the only real thing about
the whole shadowy business is the sense of the lagging
dull and hoary lapse of time that has drifted by since then ;
a vast empty level, it seems, with a formless spectre glimpsed f
fitfully through the smoke and mist that lie along its *
remote verge.
Well, we are all getting along here fir, st -rate ,* Livy
gains strength daily, and sits up a deal ; the baby is five
weeks old and — but no more of this ; somebody may be
reading this letter 80 years lienee. And so, my friend
(you pitying snob, I moan, who are holding this yellow
paper in your hand in I960,) save yourself the trouble of
looking further ; I know how pathetically trivial our small
concerns will seem to you, and I will not let your eye pro-
fane them. No, I keep my news ; you keep your compas-
sion. Suffice it you to know, scoffer and ribald, that the
little child is old and blind, now, and once more toothless ;
and the rest of us are shadows, these many, many years.
Yes, and your time cometh !
Mark.
At the Farm that year Mark Twain was working on The
Prince and the Pauper, and, according to a letter to Aldrich,
brought it to an end September 14th. The book by Aldrich
here mentioned was The Stillwater Tragedy.
To T. B. Aldrich, in Ponkapog, Mass. :
Elmira, Sept. 16, '80.
My deai\ Aldrich, — Thank you ever so much for the
book — I had already finished it, and prodigiously enjoyed
it, in the periodical of the notorious Howells, but it hits
Mrs. Clemens just right, for she is having a reading holi-
day, now, for the first time in some months ; so between-
times, when the new baby is asleep and strengthening up
for another attempt to take possession of this place, she
A SCOTCHMAN
2X1
is going to read it. Her strong friendship for you makes
her think she is going to like it.
I finished a story yesterday, myself. I counted up and
found it between sixty and eighty thousand words — about
the size of your book. It is for boys and girls — been at
• work at it several years, off and on.
I hope Howells is enjoying his journey to the Pacific.
He wrote me, that you and Osgood were going, also, but
I doubfed it, believing he was in liquor when he wrote it.
In my opinion, this universal applause over his book is
going to land that man in a Retreat inside of two months.
I notice the papers say mighty fine things about your
book, too. You ought to try to get into the same estab-
► lishment with Howells. Rut applause does not affect
me — I am always calm-— this is because I am used
to «t.
Well, good-bye, my boy, and good luck to you. Mrs.
Clemens asks me to send her warmest regards to you and
Mrs. Aldrich — which I do, and add those of
Yrs ever
Mark.
To W. D. Ilowells, in Boston :
. Sunday, Oot. 24 ’80.
. . . I’m laying for that Encyclopedical Scotchman —
and he’ll need to lock the door behind him, when he comes
in ; otherwise when he hears my proposed tariff his skin
will probably crawl away with him. He is accustom ’d to
seeing the publisher impoverish the author — that spec-
tacle must be getting stale to him — if he contracts with
the undersigned he will experience a change m that pro-
gramme that will make the enamel peel off his teeth for
very surprise — and joy. No, that last is what Mrs.
Clemens thinks — but it’s not so. The proposed work is
growing, mightily, in my estimation, day by day ; and
1’ip not going to throw it away for any mere trifle. If I
letters of
myself ; I think . Why should we assist our fellowman for
mere love of God ?
Yrs ever
* Mark.
The “ Encyclopedical Scotchman ” mentioned in the pre-
ceding letter was the publisher Gebbie, who had a plan to engage
Howells and Clemens to prepare some sort of anthology of the
world’s literature. The idea came to nothing, though the other
plan mentioned — for a library of humour — in time grew into
a book.
Mark Twain’s contracts with Bliss for the publication of his
books on the subscription plan had been made on a royalty
basis, beginning with 5 per cent, on The Innocents Abroad ,
increasing to 7| per cent, on Houghing It, and to 10 per cent.
on later books. Bliss had held that these later percentages
fairly represented one half the profits. Clemens, however, had
never been fully satisfied, and his brother Orion had more than
once urged him to demand a specific contract on the half-profit
basis. The agreement for the publication of A Tramp Abroad
was made on these terms. Bliss died before Clemens received
his first statement of sales. Whatever may have been the facts
under earlier conditions, the statement proved to Mark Twain’s
satisfaction, at least, that the half-profit arrangement was to
his advantage. It produced another result ,* it gave Samuel
Clemens an excuse to place his brother Orion in a position of
independence.
To Orion Clemens , in Keokuk , Iowa :
Sunday, Oct. 24 ’SO.
My dear Bro., — Bliss is dead. The aspect of the
balance-sheet *is enlightening. It reveals the fact, through
my present contract, (which is for half the profits on the
book above actual cost of paper, printing and binding,) *
that I have lost considerably by all this nonsense 1 — sixty
thousand dollars, I should say — and if Bliss were alive
1 Percentage contracts on his former books.
JOEL CHANDLER HARRIS
218
I would stay with the concern and get it all back ; for
on each new book I would require a portion of that back
pay ; but as it is (this in the very strictest confidence,) I
shall probably go to a new publisher C or 8 months hence,
for I am afraid Frank, with his poor health, will lack
push and drive.
Out of the suspicions you bred in me years ago, has
grown this rcSult, — to wit, that I shall within the twelve-
month get $40,000 out of this “ Tramp ” instead of $20,000.
Twenty thousand dollars, after taxes and other expenses
are stripped away, is worth to the investor about $75 a
month — so I shall tell Mr. Perkins to make your check
that amount per month, hereafter, while our income is
able to afford it. This ends the loan business ; and here-
after you can reflect that you are living not on borrowed
money but on money -which you have squarely earned,
and which has no taint or savor of charity about it — and
you can also reflect that the money you have been re-
ceiving of me all these years is interest charged against
the heavy bill which the next publisher will have to stand
who gets a book of mine. . . .
With love from us
Yaff
$25 enclosed. Sam.
The Uncle Remus talcs of Joel Chandler Harris gave Mark
Twain great pleasure. He frequently read them aloud, not only
at home but in public. Finally, he wrote Harris, expressing
his warm appreciation, and mentioning one of the negro stories
of his own childhood, “ The Golden Arm,” which he urged
Harris to look up and add to his collection. “ You have pinned
a proud feather in Uncle Remus’s cap,” replied Jlm-ris. “ I do
not know what higher honour he could have than to appear
before the Hartford public arm in arm with Mark Twain.”
Ho disclaimed any originality for the stories, adding, “ I under-
stand that my relations toward Uncle Remus are similar to
those that exist between an almanac maker and the calendar.”
He had not heard the “ Golden Arm ” story and asked for the
outlines ; also for some publishing advice, out of Mark Twain’s
long experience.
214
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To. Joel Chandler Earns , in Atlanta :
Elmira, N* Y., Aug. 10.
My dear Mr. Harris, — You can argue yourself into
the delusion that the principle of life is in the stories
themselves and not in their setting; but you will save
labor by stopping with that solitary convert, for he is the
only intelligent one you will bag. In reality the. stories
are only alligator pears — one merely eats them for the
sake of the salad-dressing. Uncle Remus is most deftly
drawn, and is a lovable and delightful creation ; he, and
the little boy, and their relations with each other, are
high and fine literature, and worthy to live, for their own
sakes ; and certainly the stories arc not to be credited
with them. But enough of this ; I seem to be provin^to
the man that made the multiplication table that twice
one are two.
I have been thinking, yesterday and to-day (plenty of
chance to think, as I am abed with lumbago at our little
summering farm among the solitudes of the Mountain-
tops,) and I have concluded that I can answer one of
your questions with full confidence — thus : Make it a
subscription book. Mighty few books that come strictly
under the head of literature will sell by subscription ; but
if Uncle Remus won’t, the gift of prophecy *has departed
out of me. When a book will sell by subscription, it will
sell two or three times as many copies as it would in the
trade ; and the profit is bulkier because the retail price
is greater. . . .
You didn’t ask me for a subscription-publisher. If
you had, I should have recommended Osgood to you.
He inaugurates his subscription department with my new
book in the fall. . .
Now the doctor has been here and tried to interrupt
my yarn about “ The Golden Arm,” but I’ve got through,
anyway.
Of course I tell it m the negro dialect — that is necessary ;
NEGRO TALES
2 15
but I have not written it so, for I can’t spell it in your
matchless way. It is marvelous the way you and Cable
spell the negro and creole dialects.
Two grand features arc lost in print : the weird wailing,
the rising and falling cadences of the wind, so easily
mimicked with one’s mouth ; and the impressive pauses
and eloquent silences, and subdued utterances, toward
the end of the yarn (which chain the attention of the
children hand and foot, and they sit with parted lips and
breathlegs, to be wrenched limb from limb with the sudden
and appalling “ You got it ”).
Old Uncle Dan’l, a slave of my uncle’s 1 aged 60, used
to tell us children yarns every night by the kitchen fire
(no other light) ; and the last yarn demanded, every
night, was this one. By this time there was but a ghastly
blhze or two flickering about the back-log. We would
huddle close about the old man, and begin to shudder
with the first familiar words ; and under the spell of his
impressive delivery we always fell a prey to that climax
at the end when the rigid black shape in the twilight
sprang at us with a shout.
When you come to glance at the tale you will recollect
it — it is as common and familiar as the Tar Baby. Work
up the atmosphere with your customary skill and it will
“ go ” in prfnt.
Lumbago seems to make a body garrulous — but you’ll
forgive it. Truly yours S. L. Clemens.
Harris, receiving the outlines of the old Missouri tale,
presently announced that he had dug up its Georgia relative,
an interesting variant, as we gather from Mark Twain’s reply.
•
To Joel Chandler Harris, in Atlanta :
Hartford, '81.
My dear Mr. Harris, — I was very sure you would
run across that Story somewhere, and am glad you have.
1 Aooording to Orion Clemons, ten years older, it was their own
man-of -all-work, “ Uncle Nod."
210 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
A Drummond light — no, I mean a Brush light — is thrown
upon the negro estimate of values by his willingness to
risk his soul and his mighty peace forever for the sake of
a silver sev’m-punce. And this form of the story seems
rather nearer the true field-hand standard than that
achieved by my Florida, Mo., negroes with their sump-
tuous arm of solid gold.
I judge you haven’t received my new book yet — how-
ever, you will in a day or two. Meantime you must not
take it ill if I drop Osgood a hint about your proposed
story of slave life. . . .
When you come north I wish you would drop me a line
and then follow it in person and give me a day or two at
our house in Hartford. If you will, I will snatch Osgood
down from Boston, and you won’t have to go there at all
unless you want to. Please to bear this strictly in mind,
and don’t forget it.
Sincerely yours
S. L. Clemens.
Clemens now and then found it necessary to pay a visit to
Canada in the effort to protect his copyright. He usually had
a grand time on these trips, being lavishly entertained by the
Canadian literary fraternity. In November, 1881, he made one
of these journeys in the interest of The Prince and the Pauper,
this time with Osgood, who was now his publisher. In letters
written home we get a hint of his diversions. The Monsieur
Frechette mentioned was a Canadian poet of considerable dis-
tinction. “ Clara ” was Miss Clara Spaulding, of Elmira, who
had accompanied Mr. and Mrs. Clemens to Europe in 1878,
and again in 1878. Later she became Mrs. Jolm B. Stanchfield,
of New York City.
To Mrs. Clemens, in Hartford, :
Montreal, Nov. 28 ’81.
Livy darling, you and Clara ought to have been at
breakfast in the great dining room this morning. English
female faces, distinctive English costumes, strange and
marvelous English gaits — and yet such honest, honorable,
CANADA
217
clean-souled countenances, just as these English women
almost always have, you know. Right away —
But they’ve come to take me to the top of Mount
Royal, it being a cold, dry, sunny, magnificent day.
Going in a sleigh.
Yours lovingly,
Sami..
To Mrs. Clemens, in Hartford, :
Montreal, Sunday, November 27, 1881.
Livy dear, a mouse kept me awake last night till 3 or 4
o’clock — so I am lying abed this morning. I would not
give sixpence to be out yonder in the storm, although it
is # only snow.
[The above paragraph is written in the form of a rebus
illustrated with various sketches.]
There — that’s for the children — was not sure that they
could read writing ; especially Jean, who is strangely
ignorant in some things.
I can only look out upon the beautiful snow-storm,
past the vigorous blaze of my fire ; and upon the snow-
veiled buildings which I have sketched ; and upon the
churchward drifting umbrellas ; and upon the buffalo-
clad cabmen stamping their feet and thrashing their
arms on the corner yonder : but 1 also look out upon
the spot where the first white men stood, in the neighbor-
hood of four hundred years ago, admiring the mighty
stretch of leafy solitudes, and being admired and marveled
at by an eager multitude of naked savages. The dis-
coverer of this region, and namer of it, Jacques Cartier,
has a square named for him in the city. I wish you were
here ; you would enjoy your birthday, I think.
I hoped for a letter, and thought I had one when the
mail was handed in, a minute ago, but it was only that
218
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
note from Sylvester Baxter. You must write — do you
hear ? — or I will be remiss myself.
Give my love and a kiss to the children, and ask them
to give you my love and a kiss from
Saml.
To Mrs. Clemens, in Hartford :
Quebeo, Sunday. *81.
Livy darling, I received a letter from Monsieur Frechette
this morning, in which certain citizens of Montreal ten-
dered me a public dinner next Thursday, and by Osgood’s
advice I accepted it. I would have accepted anyway, and
very cheerfully but for the delay of two days — for I was
purposing to go to Boston Tuesday and home Wednes-
day ; whereas, now I go to Boston Friday and home
Saturday. I have to go by Boston on account of business.
We drove about the steep hills and narrow, crooked
streets of this old town during three hours, yesterday,
in a sleigh, in a driving snow-storm. The people here
don’t mind snow ; they were all out, plodding around on
their affairs — especially the children, who were wallowing
around everywhere, like snow images, and having a mighty
good time. I wish I could describe the winter costume of
the young girls, but I can’t. It is grave and simple, but
graceful and pretty — the top of it is a brimless fur cap.
Maybe it is the costume that makes pretty girls seem so
monotonously plenty here. It was a kind of relief to
strike a homely face occasionally.
You descend into some of the streets by long, deep
stairways ; anti in the strong moonlight, last night, these
were very picturesque. I did wish you were here to see
these things. You couldn’t by any possibility sleep in
these beds, though, or enjoy the food.
Good night, sweetheart, and give my respects to the
cubs.
Saml.
REV. JOE TWICHELL
219
It had been hoped that W. D. Howells would join the
Canadian excursion, but Howells was not very well that autumn.
He wrote that he had been in bed five weeks, “ most of the time
recovering ; so you see how bad I must have been to begin with.
But now I am out of any first-class pain ; 1 have a good appetite,
and I am as abusive and peremptory as Guiteau.”
JFo W. D. Howells , in Boston :
Hartford, Dee. 10 ’81.
My »eak Howells, — It was a sharp disappointment —
your inability to connect, on the Canadian raid. What a
gaudy good time we should have had !
Disappointed, again, when I got back to Boston ; for
I was promising myself half an hour’s look at you, in
Balmont ; but your note to Osgood showed that that
could not be allowed out -yet.
The Atlantic arrived an hour ago, and your faultless
and delicious Police Report brought that blamed Joe
Twichell powerfully before me. There's a man who can
tell such things himself (by word of mouth,) and has as
sure an eye for detecting a thing that is before his eyes,
as any man in the world, perhaps — then why in the nation
doesn’t he report himself with a pen ?
One of those drenching days last week, he slopped down
town with his cubs, and visited a poor little beggarly shed
where were a dwarf, a fat woman, and a giant of honest
eight feet, on exhibition behind tawdry show-canvascs,
but with nobody to exhibit to. The giant had a broom,
and was cleaning up and fixing around, diligently. Joe
conceived the idea of getting some talk out of him. Now
that never would have occurred to me. Sd he dropped in
under the man’s elbow, dogged him patiently around,
prodding him with questions and getting irritated snarls
in return which would have finished me early — but at
last one of Joe’s random shafts drove the centre of that
giant’s sympathies somehow, and fetched him. The
fountains of his great deep were broken up, and he
220 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
rained a flood of personal history that was unspeakably
entertaining.
Among other things it turned out that he had been a
Turkish (native) colonel, and had fought all through the
Crimean war — and so, for the first time, Joe got a picture
of the Charge of the Six Hundred that made him see the
living spectacle, the flash of flag and tongue-flame, the
rolling smoke, and hear the booming of the guns ; and for
the first time also, he heard the reasons for that wild
charge delivered from the mouth of a master, and-realized
that nobody had “ blundered,” but that a cold, logical,
military brain had perceived this one and sole way to win
an already lost battle, and so gave the command and did
achieve the victory.
And mind you Joe was able to come up here, days
afterwards, and reproduce that giant’s picturesque and
admirable history. But dern him, he can’t write it — which
is all wrong, and not as it should be. . . .
But, by jings ! the postman will be here in a minute ;
so, congratulations upon your mending health, and grati-
tude that it is mending ; — and love to you all.
Yrs Ever
Mark.
Don’t answer — I spare the sick.
To W. D. Howells , in Boston :
Hartford, Jan. 28 '82.
My dear Howells, — Nobody knows better than I,
that there are times when swearing cannot meet the
emergency. Bow sharply I feel that, at this moment.
Not a single profane word has issued from my lips this
morning — I have not even had the impulse to swear, so
wholly ineffectual would swearing have manifestly been,
in the circumstances. But I will tell you about it.
About three weeks ago, a sensitive friend, approaching
his revelation cautiously, intimated that the N. Y. Tribune
RESENTMENT
221
was engaged in a kind of crusade against me. This seemed
a higher compliment than I deserved ; but no matter, it
made me very angry. I asked many questions, and
gathered, in substance, this : Since lteid’s return from
Europe, the Tribune had been flinging sneers and brutalities
at me with such persistent frequency “ as to attract general
remark.” • I was an angered — which is just as good an
expression, \ take it, as an hungered. Next, I learned
that Osgood, among the rest of the “ general,” was worry-
ing over these constant and pitiless attacks. Next came
the testimony of another friend, that the attacks were
not merely “ frequent,” but “ almost daily” Reflect upon
that : “ Almost daily ” insults, for two months on a stretch.
What would you have done ?
As for me, I did the thing which was the natural thing
‘ fot me to do, that is, I set about contriving a plan to
accomplish one or the other of two things : 1. Force a
peace ; or 2. Get revenge. When I got my plan finished,
it pleased me marvelously. It was in six or seven sections,
each section to be used in its turn and by itself ; the
assault to begin at once with No. 1, and the rest to follow,
one after the other, to keep the communication open while
I wrote my biography of Reid. I meant to wind up with
this latter great work, and then dismiss the subject for
good. •
Well, ever since then I have worked day and night
m aki ng notes and collecting and classifying material. I’ve
got collectors at work in England. I went to New York
and sat three hours taking evidence while a stenographer
set it down. As my labors grew, so also grew my fascination.
Malice and malignity faded out of me— or*maybe I drove
them out of me, knowing that a malignant book would
hurt nobody but the fool who wrote it. I got thoroughly
in love with this work ; for 1 saw that I was going to
write a book which the very devils and angels themselves
would delight to read, and which would draw disapproval
from nobody but the hero of it, (and Mrs. Clemens, who
222 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
*
was bitter against the whole thing.) One part of my plan
was so delicious that I had to try my hand on it right
away, just for the luxury of it. I set about it, and sure
enough it panned out to admiration. I wrote that chapter
most carefully, and I couldn’t find a fault with it. (It
was not for the biography — no, it belonged to an imme-
diate and deadlier project.)
Well, five days ago, this thought came intp my mind —
(from Mrs. Clemens’s) : “ Wouldn’t it be well to* make
sure that the attacks have been ‘ almost daily ’ ? — and to
also make sure that their number and character will
justify me in doing what I am proposing to do ? ”
I at once set a man to work in New York to seek out
and copy every unpleasant reference which had been made
to me in the Tribune from Nov. 1st to date. On my own
part I began to watch the current numbers, for I bud
subscribed for the paper.
The result arrived from my New York man this morn-
ing. O, what a pitiable wreck of high hopes 1 The
“ almost daily ” assaults, for two months, consist of — 1.
Adverse criticism of P. & P. from an enraged idiot in the
London Athenaeum ; 2, Paragraph from some indignant
Englishman in the Pail Mall Gazette who pays me the vast
compliment of gravely rebuking some imaginary ass who
has set me up in the neighborhood of Rabelais ; 8, A
remark of the Tribune’s about the Montreal dinner,
touched with an almost invisible satire ; 4, A remark of
the Tribune’s about refusal of Canadian copyright, not
complimentary, but not necessarily malicious — and of
course adverse criticism which is not malicious is a thing
which none buf fools irritate themselves about.
There— that is the prodigious bugaboo, in its entirety I
Can you coneeive of a man’s getting himself into a sweat
over so diminutive a provocation ? I am sure I can’t.
What the devil can those friends of mine have been think-
ing about, to spread these 8 or 4 harmless things out into
two months of daily sneers and affronts ? The whole
A MARE’S NEST
22 #
offense, boiled down, amounts to just this : one uncour-
tcous remark of the Tribune about my book — not me —
between Nov. 1 and Dec. 20 ; and a couple of foreign
criticisms (of my writings, not me,) between Nov. 1 and
Jan. 261 If I can’t stand that amount of friction, I cer-
tainly need reconstruction. Further boiled down, this
vast outpouring of malice amounts to simply this : one
jest from the^ Tribune (one can make nothing more serious
than that out of it.) One jest — and that is all ; for the
foreign criticisms do not count, they being matters of
news, and proper for publication in anybody’s newspaper.
And to offset that one jest, the Tribune paid me one
compliment Dec. 23, by publishing my note declining
the New York New England dinner, while merely (in the
same breath,) mentioning that similar letters were read
fr'Mn General Sherman and other men whom we all know
to be persons of real consequence.
Well, my mountain has brought forth its mouse, and
a sufficiently small mouse it is, God knows. And my
three weeks’ hard work have got to go into the ignomini-
ous pigeon-hole. Confound it, I could have earned ten
thousand dollars with infinitely less trouble. However,
I shouldn’t have done it, for I am too lazy, now, in my
sere and yellow leaf, to be willing to work for anything
but love. . * . I kind of envy you people who are per-
mitted for your righteousness’ sake to dwell in a board-
ing house ; not that I should always want to live in one,
but I should like the change occasionally from this house-
keeping slavery to that wild independence. A life of
don’t-carc-a-damn in a boarding house is what I have
asked for in many a secret prayer. 1 shall come by and
by and require of you what you have offered me there.
Yours ever,
Mark.
Howells, who had already known something of the gathering
Storm, replied : “ Your letter was an immense relief to me, for
224
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
although I had an abiding faith that you would get sick of
your enterprise, I wasn’t easy until I knew that you had given
it up.”
Joel Chandler Harris appears again in the letters of this
period. Twichcll, during a trip South about this time, had
called on Harris with some sort of proposition or suggestion
from Clemens that Harris appear with him in public, and tell,
or read, the Remus stories from the platform. But Harris was
abnormally diffident. Clemens later pronounced him “ the
shyest full-grown man ” he had ever met, and the word i which
Twichell brought home evidently did not encourage the platform
idea.
To Joel Chandler Harris , in Atlanta :
Hartford, ApL 2, ’82.
Private.
My dear Mr. Harris, — Jo Twichell brought me yotlr
note and told me of liis talk with you. lie said you didn’t
believe you would ever be able to maste*. a suflicicncy
of reckless daring to make you comfortable aiu at ease
before an audience. Well, I have thought out a device
whereby I believe we can get around th t difficulty. I
will explain when I see you.
Jo says you want to go to Canada within a month or
six weeks — I forget just exactly what he did say ; but he
intimated that that trip could be delayed * a while, if
necessary. If this is so, suppose you meet °-good and
me in New Orleans early in May — say somewhere between
the 1st and 6th ?
It will be well worth your while to do this, because the
author who goes to Canada unposted, will not know what
course to pursue [to secure copyright] when he gets
there ; he will find himself in a hopeless confusion as to
what is the correct tiling to do. Now Osgood is the
only man in America who can lay out your course for
you and tell you exactly what to do. Therefore, you
just come to New Orleans and have a talk with him.
Our idea is to strike across lots and reach St. Louis the
NEW ORLEANS
225
20th of April — thence we propose to drift southward,
stopping at some town a few hours or a night, every day,
and making notes.
To escape the interviewers, I shall follow my usual
course and use a fictitious name ( C . L. Samuel, of New
York.) I don’t know what Osgood’s name will be, but
he can’t use his own.
If you see»your way to meet us in New Orleans, drop
me a line, now, and as we approach that city I will tele-
graph you what day we shall arrive there.
I would go to Atlanta if I could, but shan’t be able. We
shall go back up the river to St. Paul, and thence by rail
X-lots home.
(I am making this letter so dreadfully private and con-
fidential because ray movements must be kept secret,
else 1 1 shan’t be able to pick up the kind of book-material
T want.)
If you a-c difi l . "peet that you ought to let
Osgood 1' } your ' -a, nt. He makes those people
?'• three or Jr ii ’ m. h as an article is worth,
vhercas I neve* l ' 4 • he >»ek in make them pay more
than double.
rs Sincerely
S. L. Clf.mens.
“ My ' a^kw. . ic'ion,” wrote Harris. . . .
“ fh. ord< V >f a 1Jt .hi stage would be a terrible one,
b my < xpei i me . * . - 1» n a diffident man does become
familiar with his urron..din f .;.s he has more impudence than his
neighbours. Extrori. ei.”
He was sorely tempted, but his courage became as water at
the thought of footlights and assembled listeners. Once in New
York he appears to have been caught unawares? at a Tile Club
dinner and made to tell a sfc-y, but his agony was such that at
the prospect of a similar oidcal in Boston he avoided that city
and headed straight for Georgia and safety.
The New Orleans excursion with Osgood, as planned by
Clemens, proved a great success. The little party took the
steamer Gold Dust from St. Louis down river toward New
Orleans. Clemens was quickly recognized, of course, and his
• Q
226 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
assumed name laid aside. The author of “ Uncle Remus ” made
the trip to New Orleans. George W. Cable was there at the
time, and we may believe that in the company of Mark Twir.in
and Osgood those Southern authors passed two or three deligi
ful days. Clemens also met his old teacher Bixby in Ni
Orleans, and came back up the river with him, spending me .1
of his time in the pilot-house, as in the old days. It was a
glorious trip, and, reaching St. Louis, he continued it northward,
stopping off at Ilannibol and Quincy.
To Mrs. Clemens, in Hartford : •
Quincy, 111. May 17, '82.
Livy darling, I am desperately homesick. But I have
promised Osgood, and must stick it out ; otherwise I
would take the train at once and break for home.
I have spent three delightful days in Hannibal, loitering
around all day long, examining the old localities and talk-
ing with the grey-heads who were boys and girls with me
30 or 40 years ago. It has been a moving time. I spent
my nights with John and Helen Garth, three miles from
town, in their spacious and beautiful house. They were
children with me, and afterwards schoolmates. Now they
have a daughter 19 or 20 years old. Spent an hour, yester-
day, with A. W. Lamb, who was not married when I saw
him last. He married a young lady whom I knew. And
now I have been talking with their grown-up sons and
daughters. Lieutenant Hickman, the spruce young hand-
somely-uniformed volunteer of 1846, called on me — a grisly
elephantine patriarch of 65 now, his grace all vanished.
That world which I knew in its blossoming youth is
old and bowed and melancholy, now ; its soft cheeks are
leathery and wrinkled, the fire is gone out in its eyes, and
the spring from its step. It will be dust and ashes when
I come again. I have been clasping hands with the mori-
bund — and usually they said, “ It is for the last time.”
Now 1 am under way again, upon this hideous trip to
St. Paul, with a heart brimming full of thoughts and
W. D. HOWELLS 287
images of you and Susie and Bay and the peerless Jean.
And so good night, my love.
Saml.
William Dean Howells, at the age of forty-live, reached what
many still regard his highest point of achievement in American
realism. novel, The Rise of Silas Lapham , which was
running as a Century serial during the summer of 1882, attracted
wide attention, and upon its issue in book form took first place
among ’his published novels.
To W. D. Howells, in Belmont, Mass. :
My dear Howells, — I am in a state of wild enthusiasm
over this July instalment of your story. It’s perfectly
dazzling — it’s masterly— incomparable. Yet I heard you
rc5.d it — without losing my balance. Well, the difference
between your reading and your writing is — remarkable.
I mean, in the effects produced and the impression left
behind. Why, the one is to the other as is one of Joe
Twichell’s yarns repeated by a somnambulist. Goodness
gracious, you read me a chapter, and it is a gentle, pearly
dawn, with a sprinkle of faint stars in it ; but by and by I
strike it in print, and shout to myself, “ God bless us, how
has that pallid former spectacle been turned into these
gorgeous sunket splendors 1 ”
Well, I don’t care how much you read your truck to
me, you can’t permanently damage it for me that way. It
is always perfectly fresh and dazzling when I come on it
in the magazine. Of course I recognize the form of it as
being familiar — but that is all. That is, I remember it
as pyrotechnic figures which you set up before me, dead
and cold, but ready for the match — and now I see them
touched off and all ablaze with blinding fires. You can
read, if you want to, but you don’t read worth a damn. I
know you can read, because your readings of Cable and
your repeatings of the German doctor’s remarks prove
that.
228
letters of mark twain
That’s the best drunk scene — -because the truest— -that
T ever read. There are touches in it that I never saw any
writer take note of before. And they are set before the
reader with amazing accuracy. How very drunk, and
how recently drunk, and how altogether admirably drunk
you must have been to enable you to contrive that
masterpiece 1
Why I didn’t notice that that religious interview be-
tween Marcia and Mrs. Hallcck was so deliciously humor-
ous when you read it to me — but dear me, it’s ,iust too
lovely for anything. (Wrote Clark to collar it for the
“ Library.”)
Hang it, I know where the mystery is, now : When you
are reading, you glide right along, and I don’t get a chance
to let the things soak home ; but when I catch it in the
magazine, I give a page 20 or 80 minutes in which to
gently and thoroughly filter into me. Your humor is so
very subtle, and elusive — (well, often it’s just a vanishing
breath of perfume which a body isn’t certain he smelt till
he stops and takes another smell) whereas you can smell
other.
(Remainder obliterated.)
By the end of summer Howells was in Europe, and Clemens,
in Elmira, was trying to finish his Mississippi bodk, which was
giving him a great deal of trouble. It was usually so with his
non-fiction books ; his interest in them was not cumulative ;
he was prone to grow weary of them, while the menace of his
publisher’s contract was maddening. Howells’s letters, meant
to be comforting, or at least entertaining, did not always con-
• ribute to his peace of mind. The Library of American Humour
which they had .planned was an added burden.
In a letter from London, Howells writes of the good times he
is having over there with Osgood, Hutton, John Hay, Aldrich,
and Alma Tadema, excursioning to Oxford, feasting, especially
“ at the Mitre Tavern, where they let you choose your dinner
from the joints hanging from the rafter, and have passages that
you lose yourself in every time you try to go to your room. . . .
Couldn’t you and Mrs. Clemens step over for a little while ? . . .
We have seen lots of nice people and have been most pleasantly
WORK
229
made of ; but I would rather have you smoke in my face and,
talk for half a day just for pleasure, than to go to the best house
or club in London.”
To W. D. Howells, in London :
Hartford, Conn. Oct. 30, 1882.
Mx dka» Howells, — I do not expect to find you, so I
shan’t spend many words on you to wind up in the perdi-
tion of* some European dead-letter office. I only just
want to say that the closing installments of the story
are prodigious. All along I was afraid it would be im-
possible for you to keep up so splendidly to the end ; but
you were only, I see now, striking eleven. It is in these
last chapters that you struck twelve. Go on and write ;
you can write good books yet, but you can never match
this one. And speaking of the book, I inclose something
which has been happening here lately.
We have only just arrived at home, and I have not seen
Clark on our matters. I cannot see him or any one else,
until I get m> book finished. The weather turned cold,
and we had to rush home, while I still lacked thirty
thousand words. I had been sick and got delayed. I am
going to write all day and two thirds of the night, until
the thing is’ done, or break down at it. The spur and
burden of the contract are intolerable to me. I can endure
the irritation of it no longer. I went to work at nine
o’clock yesterday morning, and went to bed an hour after
midnight. Result of the day, (mainly stolen from books,
tho* credit given,) 9500 words, so I reduced my burden
by one third in one day. It was five days Work m one, I
have nothing more to borrow or steal ; the rest must all
be written. It is ten days work, and unless something
breaks, it will be finished in five. We all send love to you
and Mrs. Howells, and all the family.
Yours as ever.
Mark.
230
letters of mark twain
Again. from Villeneuve, on Lake Geneva, Howells wrote
ursine him flii** time to spend the winter with them in Florenl
where they would write their great American Comedy of Orme's
Motor, “ which is to enrich us beyond the dreams of avarice. . .
We could have a lot of fun writing it, and you could go home
with some of the good old Etruscan malaria in your bones ,
instead of the wretched pinch-beck Hartford article that you
arc suffering from now . . . it’s a great opportunity for you.
Besides, nobody over there likes you half as well as I do.”
It should be added that Orme’s Motor was the provisional
title that Clemens and Howells had selected for their comedy,
which was to be built, in some measure, at least, around the
character, or rather from the peculiarities, of Orion ‘Clemens.
The Cable mentioned in Mark Twain’s reply is, of course,
George W. Cable, who only a little while before had come up
from New Orleans to conquer the North with his wonderful
talcs and readings.
To W. D. Howells in Switzerland :
Hartford, Nov. 4th, 1882.
My dear Howells, — Yes, it would be profitable for
me to do that, because with your society to help me, I
should swiftly finish this now apparently interminable
book. But I cannot come, because I am not Boss here,
and nothing but dynamite can move Mrs. Clemens away
from home in the winter season.
I never had such a fight over a book in my life before.
And the foolishest part of the whole business is, that I
started Osgood to editing it before I had finished writing
it. As a consequence, large areas of it are condemned
here and there and yonder, and I have the burden of
these unfilled gaps harassing me and the thought of the
broken continuity of the work, while I am at the same
time trying to build the last quarter of the book. How-
ever, at last I have said with sufficient positiveness that
I will finish the book at no particular date ; that I will
not hurry it ; that I will not hurry myself ; that I will
take things easy and comfortably, write when I choose
to write, leave it alone when I so prefer. The printers
“ORME’S MOTOR”
231
must wait, the artists, the canvassers, and all the rest.
I have got everything at a dead standstill, and that is
where it ought to be, and that is where it must remain ;
to follow any other policy would be to make the book
worse than it already is. I ought to have finished it
before showing to anybody, and then sent it across the
ocean to you to be edited, as usual ; for you seem to be a
great many shades happier than you deserve to be, and
if I had thought of this thing earlier, I would have acted
upon it and taken the tuck somewhat out of your
joyousness.
In the same mail with your letter, arrived the enclosed
from Orme the motor man. You will observe that he
has an office. I will explain that this is a law office and I
think it probably docs him as much good to have a law
office without anything to do in it, as it would another
man to have one with an active business attached. You
see he is on the electric light lay now. Going to light the
city and allow me to take all the stock if I want to. And
he will manage it free of charge. It nfever would occur to
this simple soul how much less costly it would be to me,
to hire him on a good salary not to manage it. Do you
observe the same old eagerness, the same old hurry,
springing from the fear that if he does not move with
the utmost swiftness, that colossal opportunity will escape
him ? Now just fancy this same frantic plunging after
vast opportunities, going on week after week with this
same man, during fifty entire years, and he has not yet
learned, in the slightest degree, that there isn’t any occa-
sion to hurry ; that his vast opportunity will always wait ;
and that whether it waits or flies, he certainly will never
catch it. This immortal hopefulness, fortified by its
immortal and unteachable misjudgment, is the immortal
feature of this character, for a play ; and we will write
that play. We should be fools else. That staccato post-
script reads as if some new and mighty business were
imminent, for it is slung on the paper telegraphically, all
282
letters of mark twain
the small words left out. I am afraid something newer
and bigger than the electric light is swinging across his
orbit. Save this letter for an inspiration. I have got a
hundred more.
Cable has been here, creating worshippers on all hands.
lie is a marvelous talker on a deep subject. I do not see
how even Spencer could unwind a thought mor'e smoothly
or orderly, and do it in a cleaner, clearer, cnisper English.
He astounded Twichell with his faculty. You know when
it comes down to moral honesty, limpid innocence, and
utterly blemishless piety, l lie Apostles were mere police-
men to Cable ; so with this in mind you must imagine
him at a midnight dinner in Boston the other night,
where we gathered around the board of the Summerset
Club ; Osgood, full, Boyle O’Reilly, full, Fairchild respon-
sively loaded, and Aldrich and myself possessing the floor,
and properly fortified. Cable told Mrs. Clemens when he
returned here, that he seemed to have been entertaining
himself with horses, and had a dreamy idea that he must
have gone to Boston in a cattle-car. It was a very large
time. He called it an orgy. And no doubt it was, viewed
from his standpoint.
I wish I were in Switzerland, and I wish we could go to
Florence ; but we have to leave these delights to you ;
there is no helping it. We all join in love tb you and all
the family.
Yours as ever
Mark.
Mark Twrin, in due season, finished the Mississippi book
and placed it in Osgood’s hands for publication. It was a sort
of partnership Arrangement in winch Clemens was to furnish
the money to make the book, and pay Osgood a percentage
for handling it. It was, in fact, the beginning of Mark Twain’s
adventures as a publisher.
Howells was not as happy in Florence as he had hoped to be.
The social life there overwhelmed him. Clemens, now free
from the burden of his own book, was light of heart and full of
idea® and news ; also of sympathy and appreciation. Howells’s
DUTCH IDYLLS
233
story of this time was “ A Woman’s Reason.” Governor Jewell,
of this letter, was Marshall Jewell, Governor of Connecticut
from 1871 to 1873. Later, he was Minister to Russia, and in
1874 was United States Postmaster-General.
To W, D. Ilowells, in Florence :
Hartford, Maroh 1st, 1883.
Mv, dear* Howells, — We got ourselves ground up in
that same mill, once, in London, and another time in
Paris. It is a kind of foretaste of hell. There is no
way to avoid it except by the method which you have
now chosen. One must live secretly and cut himself
utterly off from the human race, or life in Europe
becomes an unbearable burden and work an impossi-
bility. I learned something last night, and maybe it
may reconcile me to go to Europe again sometime. 1
attended one of the astonishingly popular lectures of a
man by the name of Stoddard, who exhibits interesting
stereopticon pictures and then knocks the interest all
out of them with his comments upon them. But all
the world go there to look and listen, and are apparently
well satisfied. And they ought to be fully satisfied, if
the lecturer would only keep still, or die in the first act.
But he described how retired tradesmen and farmers in
Holland loacf a lazy scow with the family and the house-
hold effects, and then loaf along the waterways of the
low countries all the summer long, paying no visits,
receiving none, and just lazying a heavenly life out in
their own private unpestcred society, and doing their
literary w r ork, if they have any, wholly uninterrupted.
If you had hired such a boat and sent for us we should
have a couple of satisfactory books ready for the press
now with no marks of interruption, vexatious wearinesses,
and other hellishnesses visible upon them anywhere.
We shall have to do this another time. We have lost
an opportunity for the present. Do you forget that
Heaven ^s packed with a multitude of all nations and
234
letters of mark twain
that these people are all on the most familiar how-the-
hell-arc-you looting with Talmage swinging around the
circle to all eternity hugging the saints and patriarchs
and archangels, and forcing you to do the same unless
you choose to make yourself an object of remark if you
refrain ? Then why do you try to get to Heaven ? Be
warned in time.
We have all read your two opening numbers > in the
Century, and consider them almost beyond praise. I hear
no dissent from this verdict. 1 did not know theije was an
untouched personage in American life, hut I had forgotten
the auctioneer. You have photographed him aeeuratcly.
I have been an utterly free person for a month or two ;
and I do not believe I ever so greatly appreciated and
enjoyed and realized the absence of the chains of slavery
as I do this time. Usually my first waking thought*in
the morning is, “ 1 have nothing to do to-day, I belong to
nobody, I have ceased from being a slave.” Of course
the highest pleasure to be got out of freedom, and having
nothing to do, is labor. Therefore I labor. But I take
my time about it. I work one hour or four as happens to
suit my mind, and quit when I please. And so these days
are days of entire enjoyment. 1 told Clark the other day
to jog along comfortable and not get in a sweat. I said
I believed you would not be able to enjoy* editing that
library over there, where you have your own legiti-
mate work to do and be pestered to death by society
besides ; therefore I thought if he got it ready for
you against your return, that that would be best and
pleasantest.
You remember Governor Jewell, and the night he told
about Russia, down in the library. He was taken with a
cold about three weeks ago, and I stepped over one
evening, proposing to beguile an idle hour for him with
a yarn or two, but was received at the door with whispers,
and the information that he was dying. His case had been
dangerous during that day only and he died that night,
A CHAPTER OF DISASTERS 235
two hours after I left. His taking off was a prodigious
surprise, and his death has been most widely and sin-
cerely regretted. Wm. E. Dodge, the father-in-law of
one of Jewell’s daughters, dropped suddenly dead the day
before Jewell died, but Jewell died without knowing that.
Jewell’s widow went down to New York, to Dodge’s
house, the* day after Jewell’s funeral, and was to return
here day before yesterday, and she did — in a coffin. She
fell dead, of heart disease, while her trunks were being
packed for her return home Florence Strong, one of
Jewell’s daughters, who lives in Detroit, started East on
an urgent telegram, but missed a connection somewhere,
and did not arrive here in time to see her father alive.
She was his favorite child, and they had always been like
lovers together. He always sent her a box of fresh flowers
onfe a week to the day of-his death ; a custom which he
never suspended even when he was in Russia. Mrs. Strong
had only just reached her Western home again when she
was summoned to Hartford to attend her mother’s funeral.
I have had the impulse to write you several times. I
shall try to remember better henceforth.
With sincerest regards to all of you,
Yours as ever,
Mark.
*
Mark Twain made another trip to Canada in the interest of
copyright — this time to protect the Mississippi book. When
his journey was announced by the press, the Marquis of Lome
telegraphed an invitation inviting him to be his guest at Rideau
Hall, in Ottawa. Clemens accepted, of course, and was hand-
somely entertained by the daughter of Queen Victoria and her
husband, then Governor-General of Canada.
On his return to Hartford he found that Osgood had issued
a curious little book, for which Clemens had prepared an intro-
duction. It was an absurd volume, though originally issued
with serious intent, its title being The New Guide of the Con-
versation in Portuguese and English Evidently the “ New
1 The New Guide of the Conversation in Portuguese and English , by
Podro Carolino, with an introduction by Mark Twain. Osgood, Boston,
1883. See, also, Mark Twain: A Biography , chap cxliii.
236
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Guide ” was prepared by some simple Portuguese soul with
but slight knowledge of English beyond that which could be
obtained from a dictionary, and his literal translations of English
idioms are often startling, as, for instance, this one, taken at
random :
“ A little leameds are happies enough for to may to satisfy ,
their fancies on the literature.”
Mark Twain thought this quaint book might amuse his royal
hostess, and forwarded a copy in what he considered to be the
safe and proper form. "
To Col. De Winton, in Ottawa, Canada . r
Hartford, June 4, ’83.
Deab Colonel De Winton, — I very much want to
send a little book to her Royal Highness — the famous
Portuguese phrase book ; but I do not know the etiquette
of the matter, and I would not wittingly infringe ftny
rule of propriety. It is a book which I perfectly well
know will amuse her “ some at most ” if she has not seen
it before, and will still amuse her “ some at least,” even
if she has inspected it a hundred times already. So I will
send the book to you, and you who know all about the
proper observances will protect me from indiscretion, in
case of need, by putting the said book in the fire, and
remaining as dumb as I generally was when I was up there.
I do not rebind the thing, because that would look as if
1 thought it worth keeping, whereas it is only worth
glancing at and casting aside.
Will you please present my compliments to Mrs. De
Winton and Mrs. Mackenzie ? — and I beg to make my
sincere compliments to you, also, for your infinite kind-
nesses to met I did have a delightful time up there,
most certainly.
Truly yours
S. L. Clemens.
P. S. Although the introduction dates a year hack,
the book is only just now issued. A good long delay.
S L. C.
“HUCKLEBERRY FINN”
287
Howells, writing from Venice, in April, manifested special
interest in the play project. lie relumed to America in July.
Clemens sent him word of welcome, with glowing reports of
his own undertakings. The story on which he was piling up
MS. was The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, begun seven years
^ before at Quarry Farm. He had no great faith in it then, and
1 though he had taken it up again in 1880, his interest had not
lasted to its conclusion. This time, however, he was in the
proper spirit, and the story would be finished.
* To W. D. Howells , in Boston :
Elmira, July 20, ’83.
My dear Howells, — We are desperately glad you and
your gang are home again — may you never travel again,
till you go aloft or alow. Charley Clark has gone to the
other side for a run — will be- back in August. He has been
sick, and needed the trip very much.
Mrs. Clemens had a long and wasting spell of sickness
last Spring, but she is pulling up, now. The children are
booming, and my health is ridiculous, it’s so robust, not-
withstanding the newspaper mis-reports.
I haven’t piled up MS so in years as I have done since
we came here to the farm three weeks and a half ago.
Why, it’s like old times, to step right into the study, damp
from the breakfast table, and sail right in and sail right on,
the whole day long, without thought of running short of
stuff or words.
I wrote 4000 words to-day and I touch 3000 and upwards
pretty often, and don’t fall below 2600 any working day.
And when I get fagged out I lie abed a couple of days and
read and smoke and then go it again for 6t>r 7 uays. I
have finished one small book, and am away along in a big
one that I half-finished two or three j^ears ago. I expect
to complete it in a month or six weeks or two months
more. And I shall like it, whethei anybody else does or
not.
It’s a kind of companion to Tom Sawyer. There’s a
238
LETTERS of mark twain
raft episode from it in second or third chapter of Life on
the Mississippi. ...
I’m booming these days— got health and spirits to
waste — got an overplus ; and if I were at home we
would write a play. But we must do it anyhow by t
and by.
We stay here till Sep. 10 ; then maybe a week at Indian
Neck for sea air, then home. *
We are powerful glad you are all back ; and send love
according. *
Yrs Ever
Mark.
To Orion Clemens and family in Keokuk, la. :
Elmira, July 21, '83;
Private.
Dear Ma and Orion and Mollie — J don’t know that
I have anything new to report. . . .
. . . Day before yesterday I felt slightly warned to
knock off work for one day. So I did it, and took the open
air. Then I struck an idea for the instruction of the children,
and went to work and carried it out. It took me all day.
I measured off 817 feet of the road -way in our farm
grounds, with a foot-rule, and then divided it up among
the English reigns, from the Conqueror down to 1883,
allowing one foot to the year. I whittled out a basket of
little pegs and drove one in the ground at the beginning
of each reign, and gave it that King’s name.
I measured all the reigns exactly — as many feet to the
reign as therd were years in it. You can look out over the
grounds and see the little pegs from the front door — some
of them close together, like Richard II, Richard Cromwell,
James II, &c ; and some prodigiously wide apart, like
Henry III, Edward III, George III, &c. It gives the
children a realizing sense of the length or brevity of a
reign. Shall invent a violent game to go with it.
WRITING A PLAY
289
And in bed, last night, I invented a way to play it
indoors — in a far more voluminous way, as to multi-
plicity of dates and events — on a cribbagc board
Hello, supper’s ready. Love to all. Good bye .
Saml.
Orion Clemens would naturally get excited over the idea of
the game and its commercial possibilities. Not more so than
his brother, hdwever, who presently employed him to arrange
a quantity of historical data which the game was to teach*
For a season, indeed, interest in the game became a sort of mid-
summer madness which pervaded the two households, at
Keokuk and at Quarry Farm. Howells wrote his approval of
the idea of “ learning history by the running foot,” which was
a pun, even if unintentional, for in its out-door form it was a
game of speed as well as knowledge.
There had been some delay and postponement in the matter
of ^he play which Howells and Clemons agreed to write. They
did not put in the entire month of October as they had planned,
but they did put in a portion of that month, the latter half,
working out their old idea. In the end it became a revival of
Colonel Sellers, or rather a caricature of that extravagant,
gentle-hearted old visionary. Clemens had always complained
that the actor Raymond had never brought out the finer shades
of Colonel Sellers’s character, but Raymond in his worst per-
formance never belied his original as did Howells and Clemens
in his dramatic revival. These two, working together, let their
imaginations run riot with disastrous results. The reader can
judge something of this himself, from The American Claimant ,
the book which Mark Twain would later build from the play*
But at this time they thought it a great triumph. They had
“ cracked their sides ” laughing over its construction, as Howells
once said, and they thought the world would do the same over
its performance. They decided to offtr it to Raymond, but
rather haughtily, indifferently, because any number of other
actors would be waiting for it.
But this was a miscalculation. Raymond ijow turned the
tables. Though favourable to the idea of a new play, he declared
this one did not present his old Sellers at all, but a lunatic. In
the end he returned the MS. with a brief note. Attempts had
already been made to interest other actors, and these efforts
would continue for some time.
The type-setting machine docs not appear in the letters of
this period, but it was an important factor, nevertheless. It
was costing several thousand dollars a month for construction
m LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
and becoming a heavy drain on Mark Twain’s finances. It was
necessary to recuperate, and the anxiety for a profitable play,
or some other adventure that would bring a quick and generous
return, grew out of this need.
Clemens had established Charles L. Webster, his nephew by
marriage, in a New York office, as selling agent for the Mississippi
book and for his plays. He was also planning to let Webster
publish the new book, Huck Finn.
George W. Cable had proved his ability as a reader, and
Clemens saw possibilities in a reading combination, which was
first planned to include Aldrich, and Howells, and a private car.
But Aldrich and Howells did not warm to the idea, and the car
was eliminated from the plan. Cable came to visit. Clemens
in Hartford, and was taken with the mumps, so that the
reading trip Was postponed.
Cable recovered in time, and out of gratitude planned a
great April-fool surprise for his host. He was a systematic
man, and did it in his usual thorough way. He sent a “ private
and confidential ” suggestion to a hundred and fifty of Mark
Twain’s friends and admirers, nearly all distinguished literary
men. The suggestion was that each one of them should send
a request for Mark Twain’s autograph, timing it so that it would
arrive on the 1st of April. A11 seemed to have responded.
Mark Twain’s writing-table on April Fool morning was heaped
with letters, asking in every ridiculous fashion for his “ valuable
autograph.” The one from Aldrich was a fair sample. He
wrote : “ I am making a collection of autographs of our dis-
tinguished writers, and having read one of your works, Gabriel
Conroy, I would like to add your name to the list.”
Of course, the joke in this was that Gabriel Conroy was by
Bret Harte, who by this time was thoroughly delested by Mark
Twain. The first one or two of the letters puzzled the victim ;
then he comprehended the size and character of the joke and
entered into it thoroughly. One of the letters was from Blood-
good H. Cutter, the “ Poet Lariat ” of Innocents Abroad. Cutler,
of course, wrote in “ poetry,” that is to say, doggerel.
!To IF. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, Apl 8, '84.
My deab Howeixs, — It took my breath away, and I
haven’t recovered it yet, entirely — I mean the generosity
of your proposal to read the proofs of Huck Finn.
Now if you mem it, old man — if you are in earnest —
MVKK l\\ \I\ VM> lilOlUL. \N t VJJI 1
PROOF-READING Ml
proceed, In God’s name, and be by me forever blest, I
cannot conceive of a rational man deliberately piling such
an atrocious job upon himself ; but if there is such a man
and you be that man, why then pile it on. It will cost me
a pang every time I think of it, but this anguish will be
eingebtisst to me in the joy and comfort I shall get out
of the not' having to read the verfluchtete proofs myself.
But if you have repented of your augenblichlicher Tob-
sucht and got back to calm cold reason again, I won’t hold
you to it* unless I find I have got you down in writing
somewhere. Herr, I would not read the proof of one of
my books for any fair and reasonable sum whatever, if
I could get out of it.
The proof-reading on the P & P cost me the last rags
of my religion. M.
Howells had written that he would be glad to help out in the
reading of the proofs of fiuck Finn, which book Webster by
this time had in hand. Replying to Clemens’s eager and grateful
acceptance now, he wrote : “ It is all perfectly true about the
generosity, unless I am going to read your proofs from one of
the shabby motives which I always find at the bottom of my
soul if I examine it.” A characteristic utterance, though we
may be permitted to believe that his shabby motives were fewer
and less shabby than those of mankind in general.
The proofs which Howells was reading pleased him mightily.
Once, during the summer, he wrote : “ If I had written half as
good a book as Huck Finn I shouldn’t ask anything better than
to read the proofs ; even as it is, I don’t, so send them on ; they
will always find me somewhere.”
Clemens and Cable set out on their reading-tour in November.
They were a curiously-assorted pair. Cable was of orthodox
religion, exact as to habits, neat, prim, all that Clemens was not.
In the beginning Cable undertook to read the .Bible aloud to
Clemens each evening, but this part of the day’s programme was
presently omitted by request. If they spent Sunday in a town,
Cable was up bright and early visiting the various churches and
Sunday-schools, while Mark Twain remained at the hotel, In
bed, reading oar asleep.
The year 1885 was in some respects the most important,
certainly the most pleasantly exciting, in Mark Twain’s life.
It was the year in which he entered fully into the publishing
B
242
letters of mark twain
business and launched one of the most spectacular of all pub-
lishing adventures, The Personal Memoirs of General V. S.
Grant. Clemens had not intended to do general publishing
when he arranged with Webster to become sales-agent /or the
Mississippi book, and later general agent for lluck Finn’s adven-
tures ; he had intended only to handle his own books, because t
he was pretty thoroughly dissatisfied with other publishing*
arrangements. Even the Library of Humour, which Iloweus,
with Clark, of the Courant, had put together for him, he left with
Osgood until that publisher failed, during the*spring«of 1885.
Certainly he never dreamed of undertaking anything of the
proportions of the Grant book. t
He had always believed that Grant could make a book. More
than once, when they had met, he had urged the General to
prepare his memoirs for publication. Howells, in his My Mark
Twain, tells of going with Clemens to see Grant, then a member
of the ill-fated firm of Grant and Ward, and how they lunched on
beans, bacon and coffee brought in from a near-by restaurant.
It was while they were eating this soldier fare that Cl creeps —
very likely abetted by Ilowells — especially urged the great com-
mander to prepare his memoirs. But Grant had become a
financier, as he believed, and the prospect of literary earnings,
however large, did not appeal to him. Furthermore, he was
convinced that he was without literary ability and that a book
by him would prove a failure.
But then, by and by, came a failure more disastrous than
anything he had foreseen — the downfall of his firm through the
Napoleonic rascality of Ward. General Grant was utterly
ruined; he was left without income and apparently without
the means of earning one. It was the period when the great
War Series was appearing in the Century Magazine. General
Grant, hard-pressed, was induced by the editors to prepare one
or more articles, and, finding that he could write them, became
interested in the idea of a book. It is unnecessary to repeat
here the story of how the publication of this important work
passed into the hands of Mark Twain ; that is to say, the firm
of Charles L. Webster & Co.
In the nc> 4 t letter we reach the end of the Olemcns-Cable
venture and get a characteristic summing up of Mark Twain’s
general attitude toward the companion of his travels. It must
be read only in the clear realization of Mark Twain’s attitude
toward orthodoxy, and his habit of humour. Cable was as
rigidly orthodox as Mark Twain was revolutionary. The two
were never anything but the best of friends.
RELIGION 243
To W, D, llowclls, in Boston :
Philada. Feb. 27, '85.
My DEAR H.OWELLS, — To-night in Baltimore, to-morrow
afternoon and night in Washington, and my four-months
•platform campaign is ended at last. It has been a curious
experience. . It has taught me that Cable’s gifts of mind
are greater and higher than I had suspeeted. But —
That’ 1,4 But*” is pointing toward his religion. You will
never, never know, never divine, guess, imagine, how loath-
some a thing the Christian religion can be made until you
come to know and study Cable daily and hourly. Mind
you, I like him ; no is pleasant company ; I rage and swear
at him sometimes, but we do not quarrel ; we get along
mighty happily together ; but in him and his person 1
havg learned to hate all religions. lie has taught me to
abhor and detest the Sabbath-day and hunt up new and
troublesome ways to dishonor it.
Nat Goodwin was on the train yesterday. He plays in
Washington all the coining week. lie is very anxious to
get our Sellers play and play it under changed names. 1
said the only thing 1 could do would be to write to you.
Well, I’ve done it. Ys Ever Mark.
Something has hem mentioned before of Mark Twain’s
investments and the generally unprofitable habit of them, lie
had a trusting nature, and was usually willing to invest money
on any plausible recommendation, lie was one of thousands
such, and being a person of distinction he now and then received
letters of inquiry, complaint, or condolence. A minister wrot c
him that he had bought some stocks recommended by a Hart-
ford banker arid advertised in a religious paper, lie added,
“ After I made that purchase they wrote me that you had just
bought a hundred shares and that you were a ‘ shrewu ’ man.”
The writer closed by asking for further information. He
received it, as follows :
To the liev. J — , in Baltimore:
Washington, Mch. 2, ’85.
My dear Sir, — I take my earliest opportunity to answer
your favor.of Feb. 28 .
244
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
B — was premature in calling me a “ shrewd man.” I
wasn’t one at that time, but am one now — that is, I am
at least too shrewd to ever again invest in anything put
on the market by B — . I know nothing whatever about
the Bank Note Co., and never did know anything about
it. B — sold me about $4,000 or $5,000 worth of the st^ck
at $110, and I own it yet. He sold me $10,000 worth of
another rose-tinted stock about the samd timer I have
got that yet, also. I judge that a peculiarity of B — ’s
stocks is that they are of the staying kind. 1 think you
should have asked somebody else whether T was a shrewd
man or not — for two reasons : the stock was advertised
in a religious paper, a circumstance which was very sus-
picious ; and the compliment came to you from a man
who was interested to make a purchaser of you. % I am
afraid you deserve your loss. A financial scheme adver-
tised in any religious paper is a thing which any living
person ought to know enough to avoid ; and when the
factor is added that M. runs that religious paper, a dead
person ought to know enough to avoid it.
Very Truly Yours
S. L. Clemens.
The story of Huck Finn was having a wide success. Webster
handled it skilfully, and the sales were large. * In almost every
quarter its welcome was enthusiastic. Here and there, however,
could be found an exception ; Iluek’s morals were not always
approved of by library reading-committees. The first instance
of this kind was reported from Concord, and would seem not
to have depressed the author-publisher.
To Ckas. L. Webster, in New York :
Moh 18, ’85.
Dear Charley, — The Committee of the Public Library
of Concord, Mass, have given us a rattling tip-top puff
which will go into every paper in the country. They have
< xpelled Iluck from their library as “ trash {ind suitable
PUBLIC READINGS
245
only lot tt\B slums.” That will sell 25,000 copies for us
sure.
Ys S. L. C.
Perhaps the Concord Free Trade Chib had some idea of
•making amends to Mark Twain for the slight put upon his book
by their librarians, for immediately after the IIucJc Finn incident
they notified* him of his election to honorary membership.
Those were $he days of “ authors’ readings,” and Clemens
and Howells not infrequently assisted at these functions, usually
given as benefits of one kind or another. From the next letter,
written following an entertainment given for the Longfellow
memorial, we gather that Mark Twain’s opinion of Howells’s
reading was steadily improving.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, May 5, *85.
1®y dear Howells, — . . Who taught you to road ?
Observation and thought, I guess. And practice at the
Tavern Club ? — yes ; and that was the best teaching of
all.
Well, you sent even your daintiest and most delicate
and fleeting points home to that audience — absolute 'proof
of good reading. But you couldn’t read worth a damn a
few years ago. I do not say this to flatter. It is true 1
looked around for you when I was leaving, but you had
already gone.
Alas, Osgood has failed at last. It was easy to see
that he was on the very verge of it a year ago, and it was
also easy to see that he was still on the verge of it a month
or two ago ; but I continued to hope — but not expect —
that he would pull through. The Library of Humor is at
his dwelling house, and he will liarul it to you whenever
you want it.
To save it from any possibility of getting mixed up in
the failure, perhaps you had better send down and get it.
I told him, the other day, that an order of any kind from
you would be his sufficient warrant for its delivery to you.
In two days General Grant has dictated 50 pages of
2^6 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
foolscap, and thus the Wilderness and Appomattox stand
for all time in his own words. This makes the second
volume of liis book as valuable as the first.
He looks mighty well, these latter days.
Yrs Ever
Mark.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston *
Elmira, July-,21, 1885.
My dear Howells, — You are really my only author ;
I am restricted to you, I wouldn’t give a damn for the rest.
I bored through Middlemarch during the past week,
with its labored and tedious analyses of feelings and
motives, its paltry and tiresome people, its unexciting
and uninteresting story, and its frequent blinding flashes
of single-sentence poetry, philosophy, wit, and what not,
and nearly died from the overwork. I wouldn’t read
another of those books for a farm. I did try to read one
other — Daniel Dcronda. I dragged through three chapters,
losing flesh all the time, and then was honest enough
to quit, and confess to myself that I haven’t any romance
literature appetite, as far as 1 can see, except for your
books.
Rut what I started to say, was, that I have just read
Part II of Indian Summer, and to my mind there isn’t
a waste line in it, or one that could be improved. I read
it yesterday, ending with that opinion ; and read it again
to-day, ending with the same opinion emphasized. I
haven’t read Part I yet, because that number must have
reached Hartford after we left but we arc going to send
down town for a copy, and when it comes I am to read
both parts aloud to the family. It is a beautiful story,
and makes a body laugh all the time, and cry inside, and
feel so old and so forlorn ; and gives him gracious glimpses
of his lost youth that fill him with a measureless regret, and
build up in him a cloudy sense of his having been a prince;
GEORGE ELIOT
247
once, in some enchanted far-off land, and of being an exile
now, and desolate — and Lord, no chance ever to get back
there again ! That is the thing that hurts. W ell, you have
done it with marvelous facility and you make all the
motives and feelings perfectly clear without analyzing
the guts out of them, the way George Eliot does. I
can’t stand George Eliot and Hawthorne and those people ;
I see what tfyey are at a hundred years before they get
to it and they just tire me to death. And as for “ The
Bostonians,” I would rather be damned to John Bunyan’s
heaven than read that.
Yrs Ever
Mark.
It is as easy to understand Mark Twain’s enjoyment of
Indian Summer as his revolt against Daniel Deronda and
The Bostonians . He cared little for writing that did not con-
vey its purpose in the simplest and most direct terms. It is
interesting to note that in thanking Clemens for his compli-
ment Howells wrot e ; “ What people cannot see is tliat I analyze
as little as possible ; they go on talking about the analytical
school, which I am supposed to belong to, and I want to thank
you for using your eyes. . . . Did you ever read Defoe’s
Roxana? If not, then read it, not merely for some of the
deepest insights into the lying, suffering, sinning, well-meaning
human soul, but for the best and most natural English that a
book was ever written in.”
•a
General Grant worked steadily on his book, dictating when
he could, making brief notes on slips of paper when he could
no longer speak. Clemens visited him at Mt, McGregor and
brought the dying soldier the comforting news that enough of
his books wi re already sold to provide generously for his family,
and that the sales would aggregate at least twice as much by
t he end of the year. This was some time in July. On the 23rd
of that month General Grant died.
General Grant’s early indulgence in liquors had long been
a matter of wide, though not very definite, knowledge. Every
one had heard how Lincoln, on being told that Grant drank,
remarked something to the effect that he would like to know
what kind of whisky Grant used so that he might get some of it
for his other gene rals. Henry Ward Bceclier, selected to deliver
a eulogy on the dead soldier, and doubtless wishing neither to
248
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
ignore the matter nor to make loo much of it, naturally turned
for information to the publisher of Grant’s own memoirs, hoping
from an advance copy to obtain light.
To Henry Ward Beecher , Brooklyn :
Elmira, N. Y. SejV. 11, ’85.
My dear Mr. Beecher, — My nephew \Vebster is in
Europe making contracts for the Memoirs. Before he
sailed he came to me with a writing, directed to the printers
and binders, to this effect :
“Honor no order for a sight or copy of the Memoirs
while I am absent, even though it be signed by Mr. Clemens
himself.”
I gave my permission. There were weighty reasons
why I should not only give my permission, but hold it a
matter of honor to not dissolve the order or modify it
at any time. So I did all of that — said the order should
stand undisturbed to the end. If a principal could dis-
solve his promise as innocently as he can dissolve his
written order unguarded by his promise, I would send
you a copy of the Memoirs instantly. I did not forsee
you, or I would have made an exception.
My idea gained from army men, is that the? drunkenness
(and sometimes pretty reckless spreeing, nights,) ceased
before he came East to be Lt. General. (Refer especially
to Gen. Wm. B. Franklin. 1 ) It was while Grant was still
in the West that Mr. Lincoln said he wished he could find
out what brand of whisky that fellow used, so he could
furnish it to ^ome of the other generals. Franklin saw
Grant tumble from his horse drunk, while reviewing
troops in New Orleans. The fall gave him a good deal of
a hurt. He was then on the point of leaving for the
Chattanooga region. I naturally put “ that and that
together ” when I read Gen. 0. O. Howard’s article in
1 If you oould see Franklin and talk with him — then ho won^ unbosom-
DRINK
249
the Christian Union, three or four weeks ago— where he
mentions that the new General arrived lame from a
recent accident. (See that article.) And why not write
Howard ?
Franklin spoke positively of the frequent spreeing. In
camp — in time of war.
Captain Gj-ant was frequently threatened by the Com-
mandant of his Oregon post with a report to the War
Department of his conduct unless he modified his intem-
perance. The report would mean dismissal from the
service. At last the report had to be made out ; and then,
so greatly was the captain beloved, that he was privately
informed, and was thus enabled to rush his resignation
to Washington ahead of the report. Did the report go,
nevertheless ? I don’t know. If it did, it is in the War
Department now, possibly, and seeable. I got all this
from a regular army man, but I can’t name him to
save me.
The only time General Grant ever mentioned liquor to
me was about last April or possibly May. He said :
“ If I could only build up my strength ! The doctors
urge whisky and champagne ; but I can’t take them ; I
can’t abide the taste of any kind of liquor.’*
Had he rliarlc a conquest so complete that even the
taste of liquor was become an offense ? Or was he so sore
over what had been said about his habit that he wanted
to persuade others and likewise himself that he hadn’t
even ever had any taste for it ? It sounded like the latter,
but that’s no evidence.
He told me in the fall of ’84 that there .was something
the matter with his throat, and that at the suggestion of
his physicians he had reduced his smoking to one cigar a
day. Then he added, in a casual fashion, that he didn’t
care for that one, and seldom smoked it.
I could understand that feeling. lie had set out to
conquer not the habit but the inclination — the desire.
250 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
He had gone at the root, not the trunk. It’s the perfebl
way and the only true way (I speak from experience.)
How I do hate those enemies of the human race who go
around enslaving God’s free people with pledges — to quit
drinking instead of to quit wanting to drink.
But Sherman and Van Vlict know everything concerning
Grant ; and if you tell them how you want to use the
facts, both of them will testify. Regular army men have
no concealments about each other ; and yet they make
their awful statements without shade or color or, malice —
with a frankness and a child-like naivety, indeed, which
is enchanting — and stupefying. West Point seems to
teach them that, among other priceless things not to
be got in any other college in this world. If we talked
about our guild-mates as I have heard Sherman, Grant,
Van Vlict and others talk about theirs — mates vritli
whom they were on the best possible terms — we could
never expect them to speak to us again.
I am reminded, now, of another matter. The day of the
funeral I sat an hour over a single drink and several cigars
with VanVliet and Sherman and Senator Sherman; and
amongotlier tilings Gen. Sherman said, with impatient scorn :
“ The idea of all tliis nonsense about Grant not being
able to stand rude language and indelicate st\>rics ! Why
Grant was full of humor, and full of the appreciation of it.
I have sat with him by the hour listening to Jim Nye’s
yarns, and I reckon you know the style of Jim Nye’s
histories, Clemens. It makes me sick — that newspaper
nonsense. Grant was no namby-pamby fool, he was a
nan —all over-r-rounded and complete.”
I wish I had thought of it 1 I would have said to
General Grant : “ Put the drunkenness in the Memoirs —
and the repentance and reform. Trust the people.”
But I will wager there is not a hint in the book. He
was sore, there. As much of the book as I have read gives
no liint, as far a? I recollect.
GEN. ULYSSES S. GRANT
251
The sick-room brought out the points of Gen. Grant’s
character — some of them particularly, to wit :
His patience ; his indestructible equability of temper ;
his exceeding gentleness, kindness, forbearance, loving-
ne?s, charity ; his loyalty : to friends, to convictions, to
promises, half-promises, infinitesimal fractions and shadows
of promises ; (There was a requirement of him which
I considered an atrocity, an injustice, an outrage ; I
wanted to implore him to repudiate it ; Fred Grant
said, “ iiave your labor, I know him ; he is in doubt as to
whether he made that half-promise or not — and he will
give the thing the benefit of the doubt ; he will fulfil that
half-promise or kill himself trying ; ” Fred Grant was
right — he did fulfil it ;) his aggravatingly trustful nature ;
his genuineness, simplicity, modesty, diffidence, self-
di^rcciation, poverty in the quality of vanity — and, in
no contradiction of this last, his simple pleasure in the
flowers and general ruck sent to him by Tom, Dick and
Harry from everywhere — a pleasure that suggested a
perennial surprise that he should be the object of so much
fine attention— he was the most lovable great child in the
world ; (I mentioned his loyalty ; you remember Harrison,
the colored body-servant ? the whole family hated him,
but that did not make any difference, the General always
stood at hfe back, wouldn’t allow him to be scolded ;
always excused his failures and deficiencies with the one
unvarying formula, “ We are responsible for these things
in his race — it is not fair to visit our fault upon them —
let him alone ; ” so they did let him alone, under compul-
sion, until the great heart that was his shield was taken
away ; then — well they simply couldn’t ftand him, and
so they "were excusable for determining to discharge him
- a thing which they mortally hated to do, and by lucky
accident were saved from the necessity of doing ;) his
toughness as a bargainer when doing business for other
people or for his country (witness his “ terms ” at Donel-
$on, Vicksburg, etc. ; Fred Grant told me his father
252 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
wound up an estate for the widow and orphans of a friend
in St. Louis — it took several years ; at the end every com-
plication had been straightened out, and the property
put upon a prosperous basis ; great sums had passed
through his hands, and when he handed over the papers
there were vouchers to show what had been done with
every penny) and his trusting, easy, unexacting fashion
when doing business for himself (at that same tipxe he
was paying out money in driblets to a man who was
running his farm for him — and in his first Presidency he
paid every one of those driblets again (total, $3,000 F.
said,) for he hadn’t a scrap of paper to show that he had
ever paid them before ; in his dealings with me he would
not listen to terms which would place my money at risk
and leave him protected — the thought plainly gave
him pain, and he put it from him, waved it off with His
hands, as one does accounts of crushings and mutilations
— wouldn’t listen, changed the subject ;) and his fortitude !
He was under sentence of death last spring ; he sat think-
ing, musing, several days — nobody knows what about ;
then he pulled himself together and set to work to finish
that book, a colossal task for a dying man. Presently his
hand gave out ; fate seemed to have got him checkmated.
Dictation was suggested. No, he never could do that ;
had never tried it ; too old to leam, now. Ify and by —
if he could only do Appomattox — well. So he sent for a
stenographer, and dictated 9,000 words at a single sit-
ting ! — never pausing, never hesitating for a word, never
repeating — and in the written-out copy he made hardly a
correction. He dictated again, every two or three days —
the intervals wrre intervals of exhaustion and slow re-
cuperation — and at last he was able to tell me that he
had written more matter than could be got into the book.
I then enlarged the book — had to. Then he lost his voice.
He was not quite done yet, however : — there was no end
of little plums and spices to be stuck in, here and there ;
and this work he patiently continued, a few lines a day,
AUTOBIOGRAPHY
253
with pad and pencil, till far into July, at Mt. McGregor.
One day he put his pencil aside, and said he was done —
there was nothing more to do. If I had been there I
could have foretold the shock that struck the world three
days later.
Well, I’ve written all this, and it doesn’t seem to
amount *to anything. But I do want to help, if I only
could, I will enclose some scraps from my Autobiography
— scraps about General Grant — they may be of some
trifle ofluse, and they may not — they at least verify known
traits of his character. My Autobiography is pretty
freely dictated, but my idea is to jack-plane it a little
before I die, some day or other ; 1 mean the rude con-
struction and rotten grammar. It is the only dictating
^ ever did, and it was most troublesome and awkward
work. You may return it to Hartford.
Sincerely Yours
S. L. Clemens.
The old long-deferred Library of lluinovr came up again for
discussion, when in the fall of 1885 llowells associated himself
with Harper & llrol hers. IIowclls’s contract provided that his
name was not to appear on any book not published by the
Harper firm. He wrote, therefore, offering to sell out his
interest in the enterprise for two thousand dollars, in addition to
the live hundred which he had already received — an amount
considered to be less than he was to have received as joint author
and compiler. Mark Twain’s answer pretty fully covers the
details of this undertaking.
To IV. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, ( et. 18, 1885.
Private.
My dear Howells, — I reckon it would ruin the book —
that is, make it necessary to pigeon-hole it and leave it
unpublished. I couldn’t publish it without a very re-
sponsible name to support my own on the title page,
because it has so much of my own matter in it. I bought
254
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
Osgood’s rights for $3,000 cash, I have paid Clark $500
and owe him $700 more, which must of course be paid
whether I publish or not. Yet I fully recognize that I
have no sort of moral right to let that ancient and pro-
crastinated contract hamper you in any way, and I most
certainly won’t. So, it is my decision, — after^ thinking
over and rejecting the idea of trying to buy permission
of the Harpers for $2,500 to use your namd, (a proposi-
tion which they would hate to refuse to a man in a per-
plexed position, and yet would naturally have £o refuse
it,) to pigeon-hole the “ Library ” : not destroy it, but
merely pigeon-hole it and wait a few years and see what
new notion Pro\ idcnce will take concerning it. He will
not desert us now, after putting in four licks to our one
on this book all this time. It really seems in a sei^se
discourteous not to call it “ Providence’s Library of
Humor.”
Now that deal is all settled, the next question is, do
you need and must you require that $2,000 now ? Since
last March, you know, I am carrying a mighty load,
solitary and alone— General Grant’s book — and must
carry it till the first volume is 30 days old (Jan. 1st)
before the relief money will begin to flow in. From now
till the first of January every dollar is as valuable to me
as it could be to a famishing tramp. If you can wait till
then — I mean without discomfort, without inconvenience
— it will be a large accommodation to me ; but I will not
allow you to do this favor if it will discommode you. So,
speak right out, frankly, and if you need the money I will
go out on the highway and get it, using violence, if
necessary.
Mind, I am not in financial difficulties, and am not
going to be. I am merely a starving beggar standing
outside the door of plenty — obstructed by a Yale time-
lock which is set for Jan. 1st. 1 can stand it, and stand
it perfectly well ; but the days do seem to fool along
considerable slower than they used to. •
“THE MEMOIRS OF GEN. U. S. GRANT” 255
I am mighty glad you arc with the Harpers. I have
noticed that good men in their employ go there to stay.
Yours ever, Mark.
In the next letter we begin to get some idea of the size of
Mark Twain’s first publishing venture, and a brief summary of
results may not be out of place here.
The Grant Life was issued in two volumes. In the early
months of the ^ear when the agents’ canvass was just beginning,
Mark Twain, with what seems now almost clairvoyant vision,
prophesied a sale of three hundred thousand sets. The actual
sales ran somewhat more than this number. On February 27,
1886, Charles L. Webster & Co. paid to Mrs. Grant the largest
single royalty cheque in the history of book-publishing. The
amount of it was two hundred thousand dollars. Subsequent
cheques increased the aggregate return to considerably more
than double this figure. In a memorandum made by Clemens
in the midst of the canvass he wrote :
During 100 consecutive days the sales (i.c., subscriptions) of
General Grant’s book averaged 3,000 sets (6,000 single volumes)
per day. Roughly stated, Mrs. Grunt’s income during all that
time was $5,000 a day.”
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hotel Normandie
Now York, Dec. 2, '85.
My dear Howells,— I told Webster, this afternoon,
to send you that $2,000 ; but he is in such a rush, these
first days of publication, that he may possibly forget it ;
so I write lest I forget it too. Remind me, if he should
forget. When I postponed you lately, I did it because I
thought 1 should be cramped for money until January,
but that has turned out to be an error, so I hasten to
cut short the postponement.
I judge by the newspapers that you are fir Auoumdale,
but I don’t know it officially.
I’ve got the first volume launched safely ; consequently
half of the suspense is over, and I am that much nearer
the goal. We’ve bound and shipped 200,000 books ; and
by the 10th shall finish and ship the remaining 125,000
of the fijst edition. I got nervous and came down to'
m
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
help hump-up the binderies ; and I mean to stay here
pretty much all the time till the first days of March,
when the second volume will issue. Shan’t have so much
trouble, this time, though, if we get to press pretty soon,
because we can get more binderies then than are to be ,
had in front of the holidays. One lives and learns. I find
it takes 7 binderies four months to bind 325,00Gf books.
This is a good book to publish. I hcand a canvasser
say, yesterday, that while delivering eleven books he took
7 new subscriptions. But we shall be in a hell *of a fix if
that goes on — it will “ ball up ” the binderies again.
Yrs evcr Mark.
November 30th that year was Mark Twain’s fiftieth birthday,
an event noticed by the newspapers generally, and especially
observed by many of his friends. Warner, Stockton and ij^ny
others sent letters ; Andrew Lang contributed a fine poem ;
also Oliver Wendell Holmes — the latter by special request of
Miss Gilder — for th< Critic . These attentions came as a sort of
crowning happiness at the end of a golden year. At no time in
his life were Mark Twain’s fortunes and prospects brighter;
he had a beautiful family and a perfect home. Also, he had
great prosperity. The reading-tour with Cable had been a fine
success. His latest book. The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn ,
had added largely to his fame and income. The publication of
the Grant Mernoirs had been a dazzling triumph. Mark Twain
had become recognized, not only as America’s most distinguished
author, but as its most envied publisher.
Jane Clemens now lived with her son Orion and his wife, in
Keokuk, where she was more contented than elsewhere. In
these later days her memory had become erratic, her realiza-
tion of events about her uncertain, but there were times when
she was quite her former self, remembering clearly and talking
with her old-time gaiety of spirit. Mark Twain frequently sent
her playful letters to amuse her, letters full of such boyish
gaiety as had Amused her long years before.
To Jane Clemens , in Keokuk :
Elmira, Aug. 7, '86.
Deah Ma, — I heard that Molly and Orion and Pamela
had been sick, but I see by your letter that they f are much
HEAT
257
better now, or nearly well. When we visited you a month
ago, it seemed to us that your Keokuk weather was pretty
hot ; Jean and Clara sat up in bed at Mrs. McEJroy’s and
cried about it, and so did I ; but I judge by your letter
that it has cooled down, now, so that a person is com-
paratively^ comfortable, with his skin off. Well it did need
cooling ; I remember that I burnt a hole in my shirt, there,
with some ict cream that fell on it ; and Miss Jenkins
told me they never used a stove, hut cooked their meals
on a marble-topped table in the drawing-room, just with
the natural heat. If anybody else had told me, I would
not have believed it. I was told by the Bishop of Keokuk
that he did not allow crying at funerals, because it scalded
the furniture. If Miss Jenkins had told me that, 1 would
ha^f believed it. This reminds me that you speak of Dr.
Jenkins and his family as if they were strangers to me.
Indeed they are not. Don’t you suppose I remember
gratefully how tender the doctor was with Jean when she
hurt her arm, and how quickly he got the pain out of the
hurt, whereas I supposed it was going to last at least an
hour ? No, I don’t forget some things as easily as I do
others.
Yes, it was pretty hot weather. Now here, when a
person is going to die, he is always in a sweat about where
he is going to ; but in Keokuk of course they don’t care,
because they are fixed for everything. It has set me re-
flecting, it has taught me a lesson. By and by, when my
health fails, I am going to put all my affairs in order, and
bid good-bye to my friends here, and kill all the people
I don’t like, and go out to Keokuk and prepare ftn death.
They are all well m this family, and we all send love.
Affly Your Son
Sam.
The ways of city officials and corporations are often past
understanding, and Mark Twain sometimes found it necessary
to write picturesque letters of protest.
258
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To a gas and electric-lighting company , in Hartford :
Gentlemen.— There are but two places in our whole
street where lights could be of any value, by any accident,
and you have measured and appointed your intervals so
ingeniously as to leave each of those places in the centre
of a couple of hundred yards of solid darkness. When I
noticed that you were setting one of your Jights # in such
a way that I could almost see how to get into my gate at
night, I suspected that it was a piece of carelessness on
the part of the workmen, and would be corrected as soon
as you should go around inspecting and find it out. My
judgment was right ; it is always right, when you are
concerned. For fifteen years, in spite of my prayers and
tears, you persistently kept a gas lamp exactly half way
between my gates, so that I couldn’t find either of tTiem
after dark ; and then furnished such execrable gas that I
had to hang a danger signal on the lamp post to keep
teams from running into it, nights. Now I suppose your
present idea is, to leave us a little more in the dark.
Don’t mind us — out our way ; we possess but one vote
apiece, and no rights which you are in any way bound to
respect. Please take your electric light and go to — but
never mind, it is not for me to suggest ; you will probably
find the way ; and any way you can reasonably count on
divine assistance if you lose your bearings.
S. L. Clemens.
Frequently Clemens did not send letters of this sort after they
were written. Sometimes he realized the uselessness of such
piotest, sometimes the mere writing of them had furnished the
necessary relief, and he put the letter away, or into the waste-
basket, and wrote something more temperate, or nothing
at all.
Clemens >vas all the time receiving applications from people
who wished him to recommend one article or another; books,
plays, tobacco, and what not. The manager of a travelling
theatrical company wrote that he had taken the liberty of
dramatizing lom Sawyer , and would like also the use of the
author’s name— -the idea being to convey to the p/hblic that it
A MODEST REQUEST
259
was a Mark Twain play. In return for this slight favour the
manager sent an invitation for Mark Twain to come and see
the play — to be present on the opening night, as it were, at his
(the manager’s) expense. He added that if the play should be
a go in the cities there might be some “ arrangement ” of
profits.
Unmailed Answer :
Hartford, Sept. 8, ’87.
Deak Sin, — And so it has got around to you, at last ;
and you also have “ taken the liberty.” You are No.
1865. When 1364 sweeter and better people, ineluding
the author, have “ tried ” to dramatize Tom Sawyer and
did not arrive, what sort of show do you suppose you
stand ? That is a book, dear sir, which cannot be drama-
tized!* One might as well try to dramatize any other hymn
Tom Sawyer is simply a hymn, put into prose form to give
it a worldly air.
Why the pale doubt that flitteth dim and nebulous
athwart the forecastle of your third sentence? Have no
fears. Your piece will be a Go. It will go out the back
door on the first night. They’ve all done it — the 1361.
So will — 1365. Not one of us ever thought of the simple
device of half-soling himself with a stove-lid. Ah, what
suffering a little hindsight would have saved us. Treasure
this hint.
IIow kind of you to invite me to the funeral. Go to ;
I have attended a thousand of them. I have seen Tom
Sawyer’s remains in all the different kinds of dramatic
shrouds there are. You cannot start anything fresh. Are
you serious when you propose to pay my expeticc — if that
is the Susquehannian way of spelling it ? And can you
be aware that I charge a hundred dollars a mile when I
travel for pleasure ? Do you realize that it is 432 miles
to Susquehanna ? Would it be handy for you to send
me the $18,200 first, so 1 could be counting it as I come
along ; because railroading is pretty dreary to a sensitive
260 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
nature when there’s nothing sordid to buck at for Zeit-
vertreib.
Now as I understand it, dear and magnanimous 1865,
you are going to re-create Tom Sawyer dramatically, and
then do me the compliment to put me in the bills as fathes
of this shady offspring. Sir, do you know that this kind
of a compliment has destroyed people before now ? Listen.
Twenty-four years ago, I was strangely handsome. The
remains of it are still visible through the rifts of time. I
was so handsome that human activities ceased* as if spell-
bound when I came in view, and even inanimate things
stopped to look — like locomotives, and district messenger
boys and so-on. In San Francisco, in the rainy season I
was often mistaken for fair weather. Upon one occasion
I was traveling in the Sonora region, and stopped for an
hour’s nooning, to rest my horse and myself. All the town
came out to look. The tribes of Indians gathered to look.
A Piute squaw named her baby for me, — a voluntary
compliment which pleased me greatly. Other attentions
were paid me. Last of all arrived the president and faculty
of Sonora University and offered me the post of Professor
of Moral Culture and the Dogmatic Humanities ; which
I accepted gratefully, and entered at once upon my duties.
But my name had pleased the Indians, aqd in the deadly
kindness of their hearts they went on naming their babies
after me. I tried to stop it, but the Indians could not
understand why I should object to so manifest a compli-
ment. The thing grew and grew and spread and spread
and became exceedingly embarrassing. The University
stood it a gouple of years ; but then for the sake of the
college they felt obliged to call a halt, although I had the
sympathy of the whole faculty. The president himself
said to me, “ I am as sorry as I can be for you, and would
still hold out if there were any hope ahead ; but you see
how it is : there are a hundred and thirty-two of them
already, and fourteen precincts to hear from. The cir-
cumstance has brought your name into mest wide and
THE ANSWER
261
unfortunate renown. It causes much comment — I believe
that that is not an over-statement. Some of this comment
is palliative, but some of it — by patrons at a distance, who
only know the statistics without the explanation, — is
.offensive, and in some cases even violent. Nine students
have been called home. The trustees of the college have
been growing more and more uneasy all these last months
— steadily along with the implacable increase in your
census — and I will not conceal from you that more than
once they have touched upon the expediency of a change in
the Professorship of Moral Culture. The coarsely sarcastic
editorial in yesterday’s Alta, — headed Give the Moral
Acrobat a Rest — has brought things to a crisis, and I am
charged with the unpleasant duty of receiving your
resignation.”
lknow you only mean 'me a kindness, dear 3365, but
it is a most deadly mistake. Please do not name your
Injun for me. Truly Yours.
Mailed Answer :
Now York, Sopt. 8. 1887.
Dear Sir, — Necessarily I cannot assent to so strange a
proposition. And I think it but fair to warn you that if
you put the pipee on the stage, you must take the legal
consequences.
Yours respectfully, S. L. Clemens.
Before the days of international copyright no American
author’s books were pirated more freely by Canadian publishers
than those of Mark Twain. It was always a sore point with
him that these books, cheaply printed, found their way into the
United States, and were sold in competition with 1 is better
editions.
Unmailed Letter to H. C. Christiancy, on book Piracy :
Hartford, Deo. 18, *87.
H. C. Christiancy, Esq.
Dear Sir, — As I understand it, the position of the
U. S. Government is this : If a person be captured on
362 LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
the border with counterfeit bonds in his hands — bonds
of the N. Y. Central Railway, for instance — the procediire
in his case shall be as follows :
1. If the N. Y. C. have not previously filed in the sever
police offices along the border, proof of ownership of tue
originals of the bonds, the government ofliciajs must col-
lect a duty on the counterfeits, and then let them go ahead
and circulate in this country. *
2. But if there is proof already on file, then the N. Y. C.
may pay the duty and take the counterfeits. '
But in no case will the United States consent to go
without its share of the swag. It is delicious. The biggest
and proudest government on earth turned sneak-thief ;
collecting pennies on stolen property, and pocketing them
with a greasy and libidinous leer ; going into partnership
with foreign thieves to rob its own children ; and when the
child escapes the foreigner, descending to the abysmal
baseness of hanging on and robbing the infant all alone
by itself 1 Dear sir, this is not any more respectable than
for a father to collect toll on the forced prostitution of his
own daughter; in fact it is the same thing. Upon these
terms, what is a U. S. custom house but a “ fence ? ” That
is all it is : a legalized trader in stolen goods.
And this nasty law, this filthy law, this unspeakable
law calls itself a “regulation for the protection of owners
of copyright ! ” Can sarcasm go further than that ? In
what way does it protect them ? Inspiration itself could
not furnish a rational answer to that question. Whom
does it protect, then ? Nobody, as far as I can see, but
the foreign thief — sometimes — and his fellow-footpad the
U. S. Government, all the time. What could the Central
Company do with the counterfeit bonds after it had bought
them of the star spangled banner Master-thief ? Sell
them at a dollar apiece and fetch down the market for
the genuine hundred-dollar bond ? What could I do with
that 20-ccnt copy of “ Roughing It ” which the United
States has collared on the border and is waitiflg to release
COPYRIGHT AND CUSTOMS
268
to me for cash in case I am willing to come down to its
moral level and help rob myself ? Sell it at ten or fifteen
cents — duty added — and destroy the market for the
original $8,50 book ? Who ever did invent that law ? I
would like to know the name of that immortal jackass.
Dear sir, I appreciate your courtesy in stretching your
authority in the desire to do me a kindness, and I sin-
cerely thank you for it. But I have no use for that book ;
and if* I were even starving for it I would not pay duty on
in cither to get it or suppress it. No doubt there are ways
in wliicli I might consent to go into partnership with
thieves and fences, but this is not one of them. This one
revolts the remains of my self-respect ; turns my stomach.
I think I could companion with a highwayman who
carried a shot-gun and took many risks ; yes, I think I
should like that if I were younger ; but to go in with a
big rich government that robs paupers, and the widows
and orphans of paupers and takes no risk — why the
thought just gags me.
Oh, no, I shall never pay any duties on pirated books
of mine. I am much too respectable for that — yet awhile.
But here — one thing that grovels me is this : as far as I
can discover — while freely granting that the U. S. copy-
fight laws are far and away the most idiotic that exist
anywhere on the face of the earth — they don’t authorize
the government to admit pirated books into this country,
toll or no toll. And so I think that that regulation is the
invention of one of those people— as a rule, early stricken
of God, intellectually — the departmental interpreters of
the laws, in Washington. They can always be depended
on to take any reasonably good law and interpret the
common sense all out of it. They can \>e depended on,
every time, to defeat a good law, and make it inoperative
— yes, and utterly grotesque, too, mere matter for laughter
and derision. Take some of the decisions of the Post-office
Department, for instance — though I do not mean to sug-
gest that that asylum is any worse than the others for
m LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
the breeding and nourishing of incredible lunatics — I
merely instance it because it happens to be the first to
come into my mind. Take that case of a few years ago
where the P. M. General suddenly issued an edict requiring
you to add the name of the Stale after Boston, New York,
Chicago, &c, in your superscriptions, on pain of having
your letter stopped and forwarded to the dqad-lctter
office ; yes, and I believe he required the county, too. He
made one little concession in favor of New York: you
could say “New York City,” and stop there; but if you
left off the “ city,” you must add “ N. Y.” to your “ New
York.” Why, it threw the business of the whole country
into chaos and brought commerce almost to a stand-still.
Now think of that ! When that man goes to — to — well,
wherever he is going to — we shan’t want the microscopic
details of his address. I guess we can find him. ••
Well, as I was saying, I believe that this whole paltry
and ridiculous swindle ia a pure creation of one of those
cabbages that used to be at the head of one of those
Retreats down there — Departments you know — and that
you will find it so, if you will look into it. And moreover
— but land, I reckon we are both tired by this time.
Truly Yours,
Mark Twain.
To Mrs. T. — Concerning unearned credentials, etc.
Hartford, 1887.
My dear Madam, — It is an idea which many people
have had, but it is of no value. I have seen it tried out
many and many a time. 1 have seen a lady lecturer urged
and urged upon the public in a lavishly complimentary
document signed by Longfellow, Whittier, Holmes and
some others of supreme celebrity, but — there was nothing
in her and she failed. If there had been any great merit
in her she never would have needed those men’s help and
(at her rather mature age,) would never have consented
to ask for it.
secrets of Success ses
There is an unwritten law about hum successes, and
your sister must bow to that law, she must submit to its
requirements. In brief this law is :
1. No occupation without an apprenticeship.
2. No pay to the apprentice.
This law stands right in the way of the subaltern who
wants to he a General before he has smelt powder ; and
it stands (an£ should stand) in everybody’s way who
applies for pay or position before he has served his appren-
ticeship apd proved himself. Your sister’s course is per-
fectly plain. Let her enclose this letter to Maj. J. II.
Pond, and offer to lecture a year for $10 a week and her
expenses, the contract to be annullable by him at any
time, after a month’s notice, but not annullable by her at
all. The second year, he to have her services, if he wants
the**, at a trifle under the best price offered her by anybody
else.
She can learn her trade in those two years, and then be
entitled to remuneration — but she can not learn it in any
less time than that , unless she is a human miracle.
Try it, and do not be afraid. It is the fair and right
thing. If she wins, she will win squarely and righteously,
and never have to blush.
Truly yours,
S. L. Clemens.
Jeanette Gilder, then of the Critic, was one of Mark Twain’s
valued friends. In the comment which he made, when it was
shown to him twenty-two years later, he tells us why he thinks
this letter was not sent. The name, “ Rest-and-be-Thankful,”
was the official title given to the summer place at Elmira, but
it was more often known as “ Quarry Farm.”
To Jeannette Gilder ( not mailed) :
Hartford, May 14, '87.
My deab Miss Gildek, — We shall spend the summer
at the same old place — the remote farm called “ Rest-and-
be-Thankful,” on top of the hills three miles from Elmira,
266 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
4
N. Y. Your other question is harder to answer. It is
my habit to keep four or five books in process of erection
all the time, and every summer add a few courses of
bricks to two or three of them ; but I cannot forecast which
of the two or three it is going to be. It takes seven years
to complete a book by this method, but still it is a good '
method : gives the public a rest. I have been„accuscd of
“ rushing into print ” prematurely, moved thereto by
greediness for money ; but in truth I have never done
that. Do you care for trifles of information ? Well,
then, “ Tom Sawyer *’ and “ The Prince and the Pauper ”
were each on the stocks two or three years, and “ Old
Times on the Mississippi ” eight. One of my unfinished
books has been on the stocks sixteen years ; another
seventeen. This latter book eould have been finished in
a day, at any rate during the past five years. But «*. in
the first of these two narratives all the action takes place
in Noah’s ark, and as in the other the action takes place
in heaven, there seemed to be no hurry, and so I have not
hurried. Tales of stirring adventure in those localities
do not need to be rushed to publication lest they get stale
by waiting. In twenty-one years, with all my time at
my free disposal I have written and completed only eleven
books, whereas with half the labor that a journalist does
I could have written sixty in that time. I*do not greatly
mind being accused of a proclivity for rushing into print,
but at the same time I don’t believe that the charge is
really well founded. Suppose I did write eleven books,
have you nothing to be grateful for ? Go to — remember
the forty-nine which I didn’t write.
Truly Yours
S. L. Clemens.
Notes ( added Iwcnty-lwo years later) :
Stormfield, April 30, 1909. It seems the letter was not
sent. 1 probably feared she might print it, and I couldn’t
267
METHOD OF WRITING
find a way to say so without running a risk of hurting'^her.
No one would hurt Jeannette Gilder purposely, and no
one would want to run the risk of doing it unintentionally.
She is my neighbor, six miles away, now, and I must ask
her about this ancient letter.
I note with pride and pleasure that I told no untruths
in my finsent answer. I still have the habit of keeping
unfinished books lying around years and years, waiting.
I have four or five novels on hand at present in a half-
finished condition, and it is more than three years since
I have looked at any of them. I have no intention of
finishing them. I could complete all of them in less than
a year, if the impulse should come powerfully upon me.
Long, long ago money -necessity furnished that impulse
jfljice, (“ Following the Equator ”), but mere desire for
money has never furnislied it, so far as 1 remember. Not
even money-necessity was able to overcome me on a
couple of occasions when perhaps I ought to have allowed
it to succeed. While I was a bankrupt and in debt two
offers were made me for weekly literary contributions to
continue during a year, and they would have made a
debtless man of me, but I declined them, with my wife’s
full approval, for I had known of no instance where a man
had pumped himself out once a week and failed to run
“ emptyings ” before the year was finished.
As to that “ Noah’s Ark ” book, I began it in Edin-
burgh in 1873 ; I don’t know where the manuscript is
now. It was a Diary, which professed to be the work of
Shem, but wasn’t. I began it again several months ago,
but only for recreation ; I hadn’t any intention of carrying
it to a finish— or even to the end of tHc fixst chapter, in
fact.
As to the book whose action “ takes place in Heaven.”
That was a small thing, (“ Captain Stormfield’s Visit to
Heaven.”) It lay in my pigeon-holes 40 years, then I
took it out and printed it in Harper’s Monthly last year.
• S. L. C.
268 '
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Mark Twain had a few books that he read regularly every
year or two. Among these were Pepys's Diary , Suetonius’s
Lives of the Twelve Ccesars, and Thomas Carlyle’s French Revo-
lution. He had a passion for history, biography, and personal
memoirs of any sort. In Ins early life he had cared very little
for poetry, but along in the middle eighties he somehow acquired
a taste for Browning and became absorbed in it. A Browning
club assembled as often as once a week at the Clemens home in
Hartford to listen to his readings of the master. He was an
impressive reader, and he carefully prepared himielf for these
occasions, indicating by graduated underscorings the exact
values he wished to give to word and phrases. ,
To W. D. Howells , in Boston :
Elmira, Aug. 22, ’87.
My dear Howells, — -How stunning arc the changes
which age makes in a man while he sleeps. When *1
finished Carlyle’s French Revolution in 1871, I was a
Girondin ; every time I have read it since, I have read
it differently — being influenced and changed, little by
little, by life and environment (and Taine and St. Simon) :
and now I lay the book down once more, and recognize
that I am a Sansculotte 1 — And not a pale, characterless
Sansculotte, but a Marat. Carlyle teaches no such gospel :
so the change is in me — in my vision of the evidences.
People pretend that the Bible means the same to them
at 50 that it did at all former milestones in their journey.
I wonder how they can lie so. It comes of practice, no
doubt. They would not say that of Dickens’s or Scott’s
books. Nothing remains the same. When a man goes
back to look at the house of his childhood, it has always
shrunk : there is.no instance of such a house being as big
as the picture in memory and imagination call for. Shrunk
how ? Why, to its correct dimensions : the house hasn’t
altered ; this is the first time it has been in focus.
Well, that’s loss. To have house and Bible shrink so,
under the disillusioning corrected angle, is loss — for a
moment. But there are compensations. You tjjt the
ENGLISH INCOME TAX
269
tube skyward and bring planets and comets and corona
flames a hundred and fifty thousand miles high into the
field. Which I see you have done, and found Tolstoi. I
haven’t got him in focus yet, but I’ve got Browning. . . .
Ys Ever
Mark.
Samuel (Jlcmens was one of the very few authors to copyright
a book in England before the enactment of the international
copyright law. As early as 1872 he copyrighted Roughing It in
England. Finally, in 1887, the inland revenue ofiicc assessed
him with income tax, which he very willingly paid, instructing
his London publishers, Chatto & Windus, to pay on the full
amount he had received from them. But when the receipt for
his taxes came it was nearly a yard square with due postage of
considerable amount. Then he wrote :
To Mr. Chatto, of Chatto & Windus, in London :
Hartford, Deo. 5, ’87.
My dear Chatto,— Look here, I don’t mind paying
the tax, but don’t you let the Inland Revenue Office send
me any more receipts for it, for the postage is something
perfectly demoralizing. If they feel obliged to print a
receipt on a horse-blanket, why don’t they hire a ship and
send it over at their own expense ?
Wasn’t it good that they caught me out with an old
book instead of a new one ? The tax on a new book would
bankrupt a body. It was my purpose to go to England
next May and stay the rest of the year, but I’ve found that
tax office out just in time. My new book would issue in
March, and they would tax the sale ip both countries.
Come, we must get up a compromise somehow. You go
and work it on the good side of those revenue people and
get them to take the profits and give me the tax. Then I
will come over and we will divide the swag and have a
good time.
I yish you to thank Mr. Christmas for me ; but we
270
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
won’t resist. The country that allows me copyright has
a right to tax me.
Sincerely Yours
S. L. Clemens.
Another English tax assessment eame that year, based on
the report that it was understood that he was going to become
an English resident, and had leased Buckcnham Hall, 'Norwich,
for a year. Clemens wrote his publishers : “ I., will explain
that all that about Buckenham Hall was an English newspaper’s
mistake. I was not in England, and if I had been I wouldn’t
have been at Buckenham Hall, anyway, but at Buckcnham
Palace, or I would have endeavoured to find out the reason why.”
Clemens made literature out of this tax experience. He wrote
an open letter to Her Majesty Queen Victoria. It was published
in the “ Drawer ” of Harper's Magazine, December, 1887, and
is now included in the uniform edition of his works under the
title of, “ A Petition to the Queen of England.”
Authors were always sending their books to Mark Twain to
read, and no busy man was ever more kindly disposed toward
such offerings, more generously considerate of the senders.
Louis Pendleton was a young unknown writer in 1888, but
Clemens took time to read his story carefully, and to write
to him about it a letter that cost precious time, thought, and
effort.
To Louis Pendleton , in Georgia :
Elmira, N. Y., Aug. 4, ’88.
My dear Sir, — I found your letter an hour ago among
some others which had lain forgotten a couple of weeks,
and I at once stole time enough to read Ariadne. Stole
is the right word, for the summer “ Vacation ” is the only
chance I get for work ; so, no minute subtracted from
work is borrowed, it is stolen. But this time I do not
repent. As a rule, people don’t send me books which I
can thank them for, and so I say nothing — which looks
uncourteous. But I thank you. Ariadne is a beautiful
and satisfying story ; and true, too — which is the best
part of a story ; or indeed of any other thing. Even liars
have to admit that, if they are intelligent liars ; J mean
LITERARY CRITICISM 271
in their private [the word conscientious written but erased]
intervals. (I struck that word out because a man’s
private thought can never be a lie ; what he thinks, is to
him the truth, always ; what he speaks — but these be
platitudes.)
If you want me to pick some flaws — very well — but I
do it unwillingly. I notice one thing — which one may
notice also in»my books, and in all books whether written
by man or God : trifling carelessness of statement or
Expression. If I think that you meant that she took
the lizard from the water which she had drawn from the
well, it is evidence — it is almost proof — that your words
were not as clear as they should have been. True, it is
only a trifling thing ; but so is mist on a mirror. I would
have hung a pail on Ariadne’s arm. You did not deceive
me when you said that she carried it under her arm, for I
knew she didn’t ; still it was not your right to mar my
enjoyment of the graceful picture. If the pail had been
a portfolio, I wouldn’t be making these remarks. The
engraver of a line picture revises, and revises, and revises
— and then revises, and revises, and revises ; and then
repeats. And always the charm of that picture grows,
under his hand. It was good enough before — told its
story, and jvas beautiful. True : and a lovely girl is
lovely, with freckles ; but she isn’t at her level best with
them.
This is not hypercriticism ; you have had training
enough to know that.
So much concerning exactness of statement. In that
other not -small matter — selection of the exact single word
— you are hard to catch. Still, I should *ho!J that Mrs.
Walker considered that there was no occasion for con-
cealment ; that “ motive ” implied a deeper mental search
than she expended on the matter ; that it doesn’t reflect
the attitude of her mind with precision. Is this hyper-
criticism ? I shan’t dispute it. I only say, that if Mrs.
Walker didn’t go so far as to have a motive, I had ; to
* snake
i&it^mfe-
{: $ty:|&e>. speck-hunting spirit* but : ib : , p$ spirit
'"'“ They would ^ usefUl to : me it
'% month, they may be useful tb you* sftid
. ;■ . „ , . T w ,v fl >; f
stories for hay real' y^^h^^icb: i| ; :
^ $<, my sorrow* '' I "' c
Truly Yours ;,; 'V -‘* } ; S N "-'
" u ' ^&'''lj*'' ; ''CiiMslSlB.' 'i'
was working pretty steadily on The
Cowl, a book which he had begun
.... hadlpubfidied nothmg sinee t he tluek
and his company was badlyin needof a new book
fbjy f» : &uthor, of distinction. Also 'it was 'highly fterirablc to
himself ; -.wherefore he set to work to finish
; ;b^ ; ',irniife!p::StOTy, , . Hehad worked pretty steadilythat summer
Ids Elmira study, but' on .his return to Hartford found a good
;’ ! i| j^bfeonf usionin the house, so went aver 'to Twichefl’s, where
woriewas in progress . 1 He .seams to have worked
mat improvement of conditions he
oyer those at home
"Wf L T?Wr™*? ^ , 7 p t 'WT' WWW WW I
; »y* &*>
ami I move lay feet into position of relief tri&duft know-
ing ifhen X do it I began here Monday morning, dad have
done eighty pages since* X was so tired last nfgM that X
thought I Would tie abed and rest, to-day ; bat X couldn’t
# resist, I mean to try to knock off to-morrow, but it’s
’ doubtful if I do, I want to finish the day the machine
finishes, and a week ago the closest calculations for that
indicated Oct # 22 — but experience teaches me that their
calculations will miss fire, as usual.
The other day the children were projecting a purchase,
Livy and I to furnish the money — a dollar and a half,
Jean discouraged the idea. She said : ** We haven’t gat
any money. Children, if you would think, you would
remember the machine isn’t done.”
It’s billiards to-night. I wish you were here.
•With love to you both — . S. L. C.
P.S. I got it all wrong. It wasn’t the children, it was
Marie. She wanted a box of blacking, for the children’s
shoes. Jean reproved her — and said :
“Why, Marie, you mustn’t ask for things now. The
machine isn’t done.” S. L. C.
Evidently the type-setting conditions had alarmed Orion,
and he was undertaking some economies with a view of retrench-
ment. Orion was always reducing economy to science. Once,
at an earlier date, he recorded that he had figured his personal
living expenses down to sixty cents a week, but inasmuch as
he was then, by his own confession, unable to earn the sixty
cents, this particular economy was wasted. Orion was a trial,
certainly, and the explosion that follows was not without
excuse. Furthermore, it was not as bad as it sounds. Mark
Twain’s rages always had an element of humour in them, a
fact which no one more than Orion himself wqpld appreciate*
He preserved this letter, quietly noting on the envelope,
“ Letter from Sam, about ma’s nurse.”
Letter to Orion Clemens, in Keokuk, Iowa :
Nov. 29, m
Jesus Christ ! — It is perilous to write sucb a man. You
can go c$assy on less material than anybody that ever
274 .
letters of mark twain
lived. What in hell has produced all these maniacal
imaginings ? You told me you had hired an attendant for
ma. Now hire one instantly, and stop this nonsen of
wearing Mollie and yourself out trying to do i at
nursing yourselves. Hire the attendant, and tell me icr
cost so that I can instruct Webster & Co. to add it every
month to what they already send. Don’t fool. away any
more time about this. And don’t write pe any more
damned rot about “ storms,” and inability to pay trivial
sums of money and — and — hell and damnation /, You see
I’ve read only the first page of your letter ; I wouldn’t read
the rest for a million dollars. Yr Sam.
P.S. Don’t imagine that I have lost my temper, be-
cause l swear. I swear all day, but I do not lose my tem-
per. And don’t imagine that I am on my way to the flop-
house, for I am not ; or that 1 am uneasy, for I am not ;
or that I am uncomfortable or unhappy— for I never am.
I don’t know what it is to be unhappy or uneasy ; and I
am not going to try to learn how, at this late date.
Sam.
Few men were ever interviewed oftoncr than Mark Twain,
yet he never welcomed interviewers and was seldom satisfied
with them. “ What I say in an interview loses its character in
print,” he often remarked, “ all its life and personality. The
reporter realizes this himself, and tries to improve upon me, but
he doesn’t help matters any.”
Edward W. Bok, before he became editor of the Ladies'
Home Journal, was conducting a we ekly syndicate column under
the title of “ Bok’s Literary Leaves.” It usually consisted of
news and gossip of writers, comment, etc., literary odds and
ends, and occasional intervi. ws with distinguished authors.
(Ic went up to Hartford one day to interview Mark Twain.
The result seemed satisfactory to Bok, but wishing to be certain
that it would be satisfactory to Clemens, he sent him a copy
for approval.
To Edward W. Bok , in New York :
Mv Dear Mr. Bok, — N o, no. It is like most inter-
views, pure twaddle and valueless.
INTERVIEWS
275
For several quite plain and simple reasons, an “ inter-
view ” must, as a rule, be an absurdity, and chiefly for this
reason — It is an attempt to use a boat on land or a wagon
on water, to speak figuratively. Spoken speech is one
thing, written speech is quite another. Print is the proper
vehicle for the latter, but it isn’t for the former. The
moment talk ” is put into print you recognize that it is
not what it was when you heard it ; you perceive tiiatan
immense something has disappeared from it. That is its
soul. You have nothing but a dead earoass left on your
hands. Color, play of feature, the varying modulations
of the voice, the laugh, the smile, the informing inflections,
everything that gave that body warmth, grace, friendli-
ness and charm and commended it to your affections — or,
at least, to your tolerance - is gone and nothing is left but
a*pallid, stiff and repulsive cadaver.
Such is “ talk ” almost invariably, as you see it lying in
state in an “ interview.” The interviewer seldom tries to
tell one how a thing was said ; he merely puts in the naked
remark and stops there. When one writes for print his
methods are very different, lie follows forms which have
but little resemblance to conversation, but they make the
reader understand what the writer is trying to convey.
And when tljc writer is making a story and finds it neces-
sary to report some of the talk of his characters observe
how cautiously and anxiously he goes at that risky and
difficult thing. “ If he had dared to say that thing in my
presence,” said Alfred, taking a mock heroic attitude,
and casting an arch glance upon the company, “ blood
would have flowed.”
“ If he had dared to say that thing in*mv presence,”
said Hawkwood, with that in his eye which caused more
than one heart in that guilty assemblage to quake, “ blood
would have flowed.”
“ If he had dared to say that thing in my presence,” said
the paltry blusterer, with valor on his tongue and pallor
on his lips, “ blood would have flowed.”
276
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
4
So painfully aware is the novelist that naked talk in
print conveys no meaning that he loads, and often over-
loads, almost every utterance of his characters with ex-
planations and interpretations. It is a loud confession
that print is a poor vehicle for “ talk ” ; it is a recognition
that uninterpreted talk in print would result in confusion
to the reader, not instruction. *
Now, in your intervieAV, you have certaiply been most
accurate ; you have set down the sentences I uttered as I
said them. But you have not a word of explanation ;
what my manner was at several points is not indicated.
Therefore, no reader can possibly know where I was in
earnest and where I was joking ; or whether I was joking
altogether or in earnest altogether. Such a report of a
conversation has no value. It can convey many mean-
ings to the reader, but never the right one. To add inter-
pretations wliich would convey the right meaning is a
something wliich would require — what ? An art so high
and fine and difficult that no possessor of it would ever
be allowed to waste it on interviews.
No ; spare the reader and spare me ; leave the whole
interview out ; it is rubbish. I wouldn’t talk in my sleep
if I couldn’t talk better than that.
If you wish to print anything print this letter ; it may
have some value, for it may explain to a reader here and
there why it is that in interviews, as a rule, men seem to
talk like anybody but themselves.
Very sincerely yours,
Mauk. Twain.
In January, 1889, Clemens believed, after his long seven
years of waiting fruition had come in the matter of the type
mac h i n e. Paige, the inventor, seemed at last to have given it
its finishing touches. The mechanical marvel that had cost so
much time, mental stress, and a fortune in money, stood com-
plete. responsive to the human will and touch — the latest, and
oik' of the greatest, wonders of the world. To George Standring,
a London printer and publisher, Clemens wrote : “ The machine
is finished ! ” and udded, “ This is by far the most marvellous
THE PAIGE COMPOSITOR
277
invention ever contrived by man. And it is not a thing of
rags and patches ; it is made of massive steel, and will last a
century.”
To Orion Clemens, in Keokuk :
Hartford, Jan. 5, ’89.
Deau*Orion, — A t 12.20 this afternoon a line of movable
types was spaced and justified by machinery, for the first
time in the history of the world ! And I was there to see.
It was done automatically — instantly — perfectly. This is
indeed the first line of movable types that ever was per-
fectly spaced and perfectly justified on this earth.
This was the last function that remained to be tested —
and so by long odds the most amazing and extraordinary
invention ever born of the brain of man stands completed
ancf perfect. Livy is down stairs celebrating.
But it’s a cunning devil, is that machine ! — and knows
more than any man that ever lived. You shall see. We
made the test in this way. We set up a lot of random
letters in a stick — three-fourths of a line ; then filled out
the line with quads representing 14 spaces, each space to
be 35-1000 of an inch thick. Then we threw aside the
quads and put the letters into the machine and formed
them into 15j, two-letter words, leaving the words separated
by two-inch vacancies. Then we started up the machine
slowly, by hand, and fastened our eyes on the space-
selecting pins. The first pin-block projected its third pin
as the first word came traveling along the race-way ;
second block did the same ; but the third block projected
its second pin !
“ Oh, hell ! stop the machine — something wrong — it’s
going to set a 30-1000 space ! ”
General consternation. “ A foreign substance has got
into the spacing plates.” This from the head mathema-
tician.
“ Yes, that is the trouble,” assented the foreman.
Paiga examined. “ No— look in, and you can see thak
278
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
there’s nothing of the kind. ” Further examination. “ Now
I know what it is — what it must be : one of those plates
projects and binds. It’s too bad — the first test is a failure.”
A pause. “ Well, boys, no use to cry. Get to work — take
the machine down. — No — Hold on ! don’t touch a thing ! .
Go right ahead ! We are fools, the machine isn’t. The
machine knows what it’s about. There is a spick of dirt
on one of those types, and the machine is* putting in a
thinner space to allow for it ! ”
That was just it. The machine went right ahead,
spaced the line, justified it to a hair, and shoved it into
the galley complete and perfect ! We took it out and
examined it with a glass. You could not tell by your eye
that the third space was thinner than the others, but the
glass and the calipers showed the difference. Paige had
always said that the machine would measure invisible
particles of dirt and allpw for them, but even he had for-
gotten that vast fact for the moment.
All the witnesses made written record of the immense
historical birth — the first justification of a line of mov-
able type by machinery — and also set down the hour
and the minute. Nobody had drank anything, and yet
everybody seemed drunk. Well — dizzy, stupefied, stunned.
All the other wonderful inventions of the .human brain
sink pretty nearly into commonplace contrasted with
this awful mechanical miracle. Telephones, telegraphs,
locomotives, cotton gins, sewing machines, Babbage cal-
culators, Jacquard looms, perfecting presses, Arkwright’s
frames — all mere toys, simplicities ! The Paige Com-
positor marches alone and far in the lead of human in-
ventions. •
In two or three weeks we shall work the stiffness out of
her joints and have her performing as smoothly and
softly as human muscles, and then we shall speak out the
big secret and Jet the world come and gaze.
Return me this letter when you have read it.
• Sam.
DAN BEARD
279
Judge of the elation which such a letter would produce in
Keokuk \ Yet it was no greater than that which existed in
Hartford — for a time.
Then further delays. Before the machine got “ the stiffness
out of her joints ” that “ cunning devil ” manifested a tendency
to break the types, and Paige, who was never happier than when
he was pulling things to pieces and making improvements, had
the type-setter apart again and the day of complete triumph
was postponed.
A Connecticut Yankee at King Arthur's Court was brought to
an end that year and given to the artist and printer. Dan
Beard was selected for the drawings, and was given a free hand,
as the next letter shows.
To Fred J. Hall, Manager Charles L, Webster c fc Co. : 1
Elmira, July 24, '89.
0 Dear Mr. Hall, — Upon reflection — thus : tell Beard
to obey his own inspiration, and when he sees a picture
in his mind put that picture on paper, be it humorous or
be it serious. I want his genius to be wholly unhampered,
I shan’t have fears as to the result. They will be better
pictures than if 1 mixed in and tried to give him points on
his own trade.
Send this note and he’ll understand.
Yr— S. L. C.
Clemens had made a good choice in selecting Beard for the
illustrations. He was well qualified for the work, and being of
a socialistic turn of mind put his whole soul into it. When the
drawings were completed, Clemens wrote : “ Hold me under
permanent obligations. What luck it was to find you I There
are hundreds of artists that could illustrate any other book of
mine, but there was only one who could illustrate this one.
Yes, it was a fortunate hour that I went netting for lightning
bugs and caught a meteor. Live forever 1 ” *
Clemens, of course, was anxious for Howells to read The
Yankee, and Mrs. Clemens particularly so. Her eyes were
giving her trouble that summer, so that she could not read the
MS. for herself, and she had grave doubts as to some of its
chapters. It may be said here that the book to-day might have
1 Gharlos L. Webster, owing to poor health, had by this time retired
from the firm.
ago LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
been better if Mrs. Clemens had been able to read it* Howells
was a peerless critic, but the revolutionary subject-matter of
the book so delighted him that he was perhaps somewhat
blinded to its literary defects.
Ilowclls’s approval of the Yankee came almost in the form of
exultant shouts, one after reading each batch of proof. First
he wrote : “ It’s charming, original, wonderful ! good in fancy
and sound to the core in morals,” And again, “ It ? i$ a mighty
great book, and it makes my heart burn with wrath. It seems
God did not forget to put a soul into you. Ee shifts most
literary men off with a brain, merely.”
The type-setting machine began to loom large in*the back-
ground. Clemens believed it perfected by this time. Paige
had got it together again and it was running steadily — or ap-
proximately so — setting type at a marvellous speed and with
perfect accuracy. In time an expert operator would be able to
set as high as eight thousand ems per hour, or about ten times
as mucli as a good compositor could set and distribute by hand.
Those who saw it were convinced — most of them — thatftke
type-setting problem was solved by this great mechanical
miracle. If there were any who doubted, it was because of its
marvellously minute accuracy which the others only admired.
Such accuracy, it was sometimes whispered, required absolutely
perfect adjustment, and what would happen when the great
inventor — “ the poet in steel,” as Clemens once called him —
was no longer at hand to supervise and to correct the slightest
variation ? But no such breath of doubt came to Mark Twain ;
he believed the machine as reliable as a constellation.
But now there was need of capital to manufacture and
market the wonder. Clemens, casting about in his mind,
remembered Senator Jones, of Nevada, a man of great wealth,
and his old friend, Joe Goodman, of Nevada, in whom Jones had
unlimited confidence. lie wrote to Goodman, and in this letter
we get a pretty full exposition of the whole matter as it stood
in the fall of 1889. We note in this communication that
Clemens says that he has been at the machine three years and
seven months, but this was only the period during which he had
spent the regular monthly sum of three thousand dollars,
llis interest in the invention had begun as far back as 1880.
To Joseph T. Goodman , in Nevada :
Private . Hartford, Oct. 7, ’89.
Dear Joe,— I had a letter from Aleck Badlam day
before yesterday, and in answering him I mentioned a
THE TYPE-SETTING MACHINE
281
matter which I asked him to consider a secret except to
you and John McComb , 1 as I am not ready yet to get into
the newspapers.
I have come near writing you about this matter several
times, but it wasn’t ripe, and I waited. It is ripe, now.
It is a type-setting machine which I undertook to build
for the idventor (for a consideration). I have been at it
three ytars and seven months without losing a day, at a
cost of $3,000 a month, and in so private a way that Hart-
ford has*known nothing about it. Indeed only a dozen
men have known of the matter. I have reported progress
from time to time to the proprietors of the N. Y. Sun,
Herald, Times, World, Harper Brothers and John F.
Trow ; also to the proprietors of the Boston Herald and
t(je # Boston Globe. Three years ago I asked all these
people to squelch their frantic desire to load up their
offices with the Mergenthaler (N. Y. Tribune) machine,
and wait for mine and then choose between the two. They
have waited — with no very gaudy patience — but still they
have waited ; and I could prove to them to-day that they
have not lost anything by it. But I reserve the proof for
the present — except in the case of the N. Y. Herald ; 1
sent an invitation there the other day — a courtesy due a
paper which *ordered $240,000 worth of our machines long
ago when it was still in a crude condition. The Herald
has ordered its foreman to come up here next Thursday ;
but that is the only invitation which will go out for some
time yet.
The machine was finished several weeks ago, and has
been running ever since in the machine shop. It is a
magnificent creature of steel, all of Pratf & Whitney’s
superbest workmanship, and as nicely adjusted and as
accurate as a watch. In construction it is as elaborate and
complex as that machine which it ranks next to, by every
right — Man — and in performance it is as simple and sure.
1 This is Col. McComb, of the Alta-California, who had sent Mark
Twain on t£e Quaker City excursion.
m LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Anybody can set type on it who can read — and can do it
after only 15 minutes’ instruction. The operator does
not need to leave his scat at the keyboard ; for the reason
that he is not required to do anything but strike the keys
and set the type — merely one function ; the spacing, justify-
ing, emptying into the galley, and distributing of de^i
matter is all done by the machine without Anybody’s
help — four functions. •
The ease with which a cub can learn is surprising. Day
before yesterday I saw our newest cub set, perfedtly space
and perfectly justify 2,150 ems of solid nonpareil in an
hour and distribute the like amount in the same hour —
and six hours previously he had never seen the machine
or its keyboard. It was a good hour’s work for 3-year
veterans on the other type-setting machines to do.
have 3 cubs. The dean of the trio is a school youth of 18.
Yesterday morning he had been an apprentice on the
machine 16 working days (8-hour days) ; and we speeded
him to sec what he could do in an hour. In the hour he
set 5,900 ems solid nonpareil, and the machine perfectly
spaced and justified it, and of course distributed the like
amount in the same hour. Considering that a good fair
compositor sets 700 and distributes 700 in the one hour,
this boy did the work of about 8| compositors in that
hour. This fact sends all other type-setting machines a
thousand miles to the rear, and the best of them will
never be heard of again after we publicly exhibit in New
York.
We shall put on 3 more cubs. We have one school boy
and two compositors, now, and we think of putting on a
type writer, a‘ stenographer, and perhaps a shoemaker,
to show that no special gifts or training are required with
this machine. We shall train these beginners two or
three months — or until some of them get up to 7,000
an hour— then we will show up in New York and run the
machine 24 hours a day 7 days in the week, for several
months — to prove that this is a machine which >1111 never
FINANCING THE MACHINE
288
get out of order or cause delay, and can stand anything
an anvil can stand. You know there is no other type-
setting machine that can run two hours on a stretch with-
out causing trouble and delay with its incurable caprices.
Wc own the whole field — every inch of it — and nothing
can dislodge us.
Now then, above is my preachment, and hero follows
the reason apd purpose of it. 1 want you to run over
here, roost over the machine a week and satisfy yourself,
and then* go to John P. Jones or to whom you please, and
sell me a hundred thousand dollars’ worth of this property
and take ten per cent in cash or the “ property ” for your
trouble— the latter, if you are wise, because the price I
ask is a long way short of the value.
What I call “ property ” is this. A small part of my
ofofership consists of a royalty of $500 on every machine
marketed under the American patents. My selling-terms
are a permanent royalty of one dollar on every American-
marketed machine for a thousand dollars cash to me in
hand paid. Wc shan’t market any fewer than 15,000
machines in 15 years — a return of liftecn thousand dollars
for one thousand. A royalty is better than stock, in one
way — it must be paid, every six months, rain or shine;
it is a debt,, and must be paid before dividends are de-
clared. By and by, when wc become a stock company I
shall buy these royalties back for stock if I can get them
for anything like reasonable terms.
I have never borrowed a penny to use on the machine,
and never sold a penny’s worth of the property until the
machine was entirely finished and proven by the severest
tests to be what she started out to be*— penect, per-
manent, and occupying the position, as regards all kin-
dred machines, which the City of Paris occupies as regards
the canvas-backs of the mercantile marine.
It is my purpose to sell two hundred dollars of my
royalties at the above price during the next two months
and keep»the other $300.
284
letters of mark twain
Mrs. Clemens begs Mrs. Goodman to come with you,
and asks pardon for not writing the message herself—
which would be a pathetically-welcome spectacle to me;
for I have been her amanuensis for 8 months, now, since
her eyes failed her.
Yours as always
Mark.
The Yankee was now ready for publication, and advance
sheets were already in the reviewers’ hands. Just at this moment
the Brazilian monarchy crumbled, and Clemens was? moved to
write Sylvester Baxter, of the Boston Herald, a letter which is
of special interest in its prophecy of the new day, the dawn of
which was even nearer than he suspected.
Dear Mr. Baxter, — Another throne lias gone down,
and I swim in oceans of satisfaction. I wish I might *live
fifty years longer ; I believe I should see the thrones of
Europe selling at auction for old iron. I believe I should
really see the end of what is surely the grotesquest of all
the swindles ever invented by man — monarchy. It is
enough to make a graven image laugh, to sec apparently
rational people, away down here in this wholesome and
merciless slaughter-day for shams, still mouthing empty
reverence for those moss-backed frauds and scoundrel-
isms, hereditary kingship and so-called “ nobility.” It
is enough to make the monarchs and nobles themselves
laugh — and in private they do ; there can be no question
about that. I think there is only one funnier thing, and
that is the .spectacle of these bastard Americans — these
Hamersleys and Huntingtons and such — offering cash,
encumbered by themselves, for rotten carcases and stolen
titles. When our great brethren the disenslaved Brazil-
ians frame their Declaration of Independence, I hope
they will insert this missing link : “ We hold these truths
to he self-evident: that all monarchs are usurpers, and
descendants of usurpers ; for the reason that no throne
was ever set up in this world by the will, freely ^exercised,
VIEWS ON MONARCHY 283
of the only body possessing the legitimate right to set it
up — the numerical mass of the nation,”
You already have the advance sheets of my forthcoming
book in your hands. If you will turn to about the five
, hundredth page, you will find a state paper of my Con-
necticut Yankee in which he announces the dissolution
of King Arthur’s monarchy and proclaims the English
Republic. Cqmpare it with the state paper which an-
nounces the downfall of the Brazilian monarchy and
proclaims* the Republic of the United States of Brazil,
and stand by to defend the Yankee from plagiarism. There
is merely a resemblance of ideas, nothing more. The
Yankee’s proclamation was already in print a week
ago. This is merely one of those odd coincidences which
are always turning up. Come, protect the Yank from
tlftit* cheapest and easiest of all charges — plagiarism.
Otherwise, you see, he will have to protect himself by
charging approximate and indefinite plagiarism upon the
official servants of our majestic twin down yonder, and
then there might be war, or some similar annoyance.
Have you noticed the rumor that the Portuguese throne
is unsteady, and that the Portuguese slaves are getting
restive ? Also, that the head slave-driver of Europe,
Alexander III,, has so reduced his usilal monthly order for
chains that the Russian foundries are running on only
half time now ? Also that other rumor that English
nobility acquired an added stench the other day — and
had to ship it to India and the continent because there
wasn’t any more room for it at home ? Things arc work-
ing. By and by there is going to be an emigration, may
be. Of course we shall make no preparation ; wc never
do. In a few years from now we shall have nothing but
played-out kings and dukes on the police, and driving the
horse-cars, and whitewashing fences, and in fact overcrowd-
ing all the avenues of unskilled labor ; and then we shall
wish, when it is too late, that we had taken common and
reasonable,precautions and drowned them at Castle Garden.
286
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
The Yankee had come from the press, and Howells had
praised it in the “ Editor’s Study ” in Harper's Magazine. He
had given it his highest commendation, and it seems that his
opinion of it did not change with time.
The Yankee did not find a very hearty welcome in England.
English readers did not fancy any burlesque of their Arthurian ,
tales, or American strictures on their institutions. Mark
Twain’s publishers had feared this, and asked that the story
be especially edited for the English edition. Clement, however,
would not listen to any suggestion of the sort. ♦
To Messrs. Chatlo ds W Indus, in London, Eng. :
Gentlemen,— Concerning The Yankee, I have already
revised the story twice ; and it has been read critically
by W. D. Howells and Edmund Clarence Stedman, and
my wife lias caused me to strike out several passages
that have been brought to her attention, and to sdffcn
others. Furthermore, I have read chapters of the book
in public where Englishmen were present and have
profited by their suggestions.
Now, mind you, I have taken all this pains because I
wanted to say a Yankee mechanic’s say against monarchy
and its several natural props, and yet make a book which
you would be willing to print exactly as it comes to you,
without altering a word. ».
We are spoken of (by Englishmen) as a thin-skinned
people. It is you who are thin-skinned. An Englishman
may write with the most brutal frankness about any
man or institution among us and we re-publish him with-
out dreaming of altering a line or a word. But England
cannot stand that kind of a book written about herself.
It is England that is thin-skinned. It causeth me to
smile when 1 read the modifications of my language which
have been made in my English editions to fit them for
the sensitive English palate.
Now, as I say, I have taken laborious pains to so trim
this book of offense that you might not lack the nerve
to print it just as it stands. I am going to get ^he proofs
THE HIGHBROW CRITIC
287
to you just as early as I can. I want you to read it care-
fully. If you can publish it without altering a single
word, go ahead. Otherwise, please hand it to J. R. Osgood
in time for him to have it published at my expense.
This is important, for the reason that the book was not
written for America ; it was written for England. So many
Englishmen have done their sincercst best to teach us
something for our betterment that it seems to me high
time that some of us should substantially recognize the
good intent by trying to pry up the English nation to a
little higher level of manhood in turn.
Very truly yours,
S. L. Clemens.
The English papers pretty generally denounced the book
S coarse ; in fact, a vulgar travesty. Some of the critics
neluded that England, after all, had made a mistake in
admiring Mark Twain.
To Andrew Lan%, in London :
1889.
. . . The critic assumes, every time, that if a book
doesn’t meet the cultivated-class standard, it isn’t valuable.
Let us apply his law all around : for if it is sound in the
case of novels, narratives, pictures, and such things, it is
ce rtainl y sound and applicable to all the steps which lead
up to culture and make culture possible. It condemns
the spelling book, for a spelling book is of no use to a
person of culture ; it condemns all school books and all
schools which lie between the child’s primer and Greek,
and between the infant school and the jinive sity ; it
condemns all the rounds of art which lie between the cheap
terra cotta groups and the Venus de Medici, and between
the chromo and the Transfiguration ; it requires Whitcomb
Riley to sing no more till he can sing like Shakespeare,
a nd it forbids all amateur music and will grant its sanction
to nothing below the “ classic.”
288 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Is this an extravagant statement ? No, it is a mere
statement of fact. It is the fact itself that is extravagant
and grotesque. And what is the result ? This — and it is
sufficiently curious : the critic has actually imposed upon
the world the superstition that a painting by Raphael is
more valuable to the civilizations of the earth than is a
chromo ; and the august opera than the hurdy-gurdy and
the villagers’ singing society ; and Homer than tl>e little
everybody’s-poet whose rhymes are in all mouths to-day
and will be in nobody’s mouth next generation ; L and the
Latin classics than Kipling’s far-reaching bugle-note ;
and Jonathan Edwards than the Salvation Army ; and
the Venus de Medici than the plaster-cast peddler ; the
superstition, m a word, that the vast and awful comet that
trails its cold lustre through the remote abysses of space
once a century and interests and instructs a cultivated
handful of astronomers is worth more to the world than
the sun which warms and cheers all the nations every day
and makes the crops to grow.
If a critic should start a religion it would not have any
object but to convert angels : and they wouldn’t need it.
The thin top crust of humanity — the cultivated — are
worth pacifying, worth pleasing, worth coddling, worth
nourishing and preserving with dainties and delicacies,
it is true ; but to be caterer to that little faction is no very
dignified or valuable occupation, it seems to me ; it is
merely feeding the over-fed, and there must be small
satisfaction in that. It is not that little minority who are
already saved that are best worth trying to uplift, I
should think, but the mighty mass of the uncultivated
who are underneath. That mass will never see the Old
Masters— that sight is for the few ; but the chromo maker
can lift them all one step upward toward appreciation
of art ; they cannot have the opera, but the hurdy-gurdy
and the singing class lift them a little way toward that far
light; they will never know Homer, but the passing
rhymester of their day leaves them higher thai\ he found
HIS PUBLIC
289
them ; they may never even hear of the Latin classics, but
they will strike step with Kipling’s drum-beat, and they
will march ; for all Jonathan Edward’s help they
would die in their slums, but the Salvation Army will
beguile some of them up to pure air and a cleaner life ;
they know no sculpture, the Venus is not even a name to
them, but they are a grade higher in the scale of civiliza-
tion by* the jninistrations of the plaster-cast than they
were before it took its place upon their mantel and made
it beautifal to their unexacting eyes.
Indeed I have been misjudged, from the very first. I
have never tried in even one single instance, to help culti-
vate the cultivated classes. I was not equipped for it,
either by native gifts or training. And I never had any
ambition in that direction, but always hunted for bigger
gifrrft — the masses. I have seldom deliberately tried to
instruct them, but have done my best to entertain them.
To simply amuse them would have satisfied my dearest
ambition at any time ; for they could get instruction
elsewhere, and I had two chances to help to the teacher’s
one : for amusement is a good preparation for study and
a good healer of fatigue after it My audience is dumb,
it has no voice in print, and so I cannot know whether I
have won its approbation or only got its censure.
Yes, you see, I have always catered for the Belly and
the Members, but have been served like the others — criti-
cized from the culture-standard — to my sorrow and pain ;
because, honestly, I never cared what became of the cul-
tured classes ; they could go to the theatre and the opera,
they had no use for me and the mclodeon.
And now at last I arrive at my object and tender my
petition, making supplication to this effect : that the
critics adopt a rule recognizing the Belly and the Mem-
bers, and formulate a standard whereby work done for
them shall be judged. Help me, Mr. Lang ; no voice can
reach further than yours in a case of this kind, or carry
greater weight of authority.
u
290
letters of mark twain
Lang’s reply was an article in the Illustrated London News
on “ The Art of Mark Twain.” Lang had no admiration to
express for the Yankee, wliich he confessed he had not cared to
read, but he glorified Huck Finn to the highest. “ I can never
forget, nor be ungrateful for the exquisite pleasure with which
I read Huckleberry Finn for the first time, years ago,” he wrote ; ,
“ I read it again last night, deserting Kenilworth for Huck.
I naver laid it down till I had finished it.”
The Mergenthaler machine, like the Paige, was dlso at this
time in the middle stages of experimental development. It
was a slower machine, but it was simpler, less expensive,
occupied less room. There was not so much about it; to get out
of order ; it was not so delicate, not so human. These were
immense advantages.
But no one at this time could say with certainty which type-
setter would reap the harvest of millions. It was only sure
that at least one of them would, and the Mergenthaler people
were willing to trade stock for stock with the Paige company
in order to ensure financial success for both, whichever
Clemens, with a faith that never faltered, declined this offer,
a decision that was to cost him millions.
Winter and spring had gone and summer had come, but still
there had been no financial conclusion with Jones, Mackay, and
the other rich Californians who were to put up the necessary
million for the machine’s manufacture.
To Joe T. Goodman, in Washington :
Hartford v June, 22 ’90.
Dear Joe, — I have been sitting by the machine 2$
hours, this afternoon, and my admiration of it towers
higher than ever. There is no sort of mistake about it,
it is the Big Bonanza. In the hours, the time lost
by type-breakage was 3 minutes.
This machine is totally without a rival. Rivalry with
it is impossible. Last Friday, Fred Whitmore (it was the
28th day of his apprenticeship on the machine) stacked
up 49,700 ems of solid nonpareil in 8 hours, and the type-
breaking delay was only 6 minutes for the day.
I claim yet, as I have always claimed, that the machine’s
market (abroad and here together), is today worth
$150,000,000, without saying anything about the doubling
RUSSIA
291
and trebling of this sum that will follow within the life
of the patents. Now hero is a queer fact : I am one of
the wealthiest grandees in America — one of the Vander-
bilt gang, in fact — and yet if you asked me to lend you a
couple of dollars I should have to ask you to take my note
instead.
It makes me cheerful to sit by the machine : come up
with Mrs. Goodman and refresh yourself with a draught
of the same. Ys ever Mark.
•
The machine was still breaking the types now and then, and
no doubt Paige was itching to take it to pieces, and only
restrained by force from doing so. Finally, he was allowed to
go at it — a disastrous permission, for it was just then that
Jones decided to steal a day or two from the Silver Bill
and watch the type-setter in operation. Paige already had
y iji parts when this word came from Goodman, and Jones’s
visit had to be called off. ' His enthusiasm would seem to have
weakened from that day. In July, Goodman wrote that both
Maekay and Jones had become somewhat diffident in the
matter of huge capitalization.
An unpublished letter on the Czar.
Ontoora, 1890.
To toe Editor of Free Russ-ia, — I thank you for the
compliment of your invitation to say something, but
when I ponder the bottom paragraph on your first page,
and then study your statement on your third page, of
the objects of the several Russian liberation-parties, I
do not quite know how to proceed. Let me quote here
the paragraph referred to :
“ But men’s hearts are so made that the light of one
voluntary victim for a noble idea stirs them more deeply
than the sight of a crowd submitting to a dire fate they
cannot escape. Besides, foreigners could not see so clearly
as the Russians how much the Government was respon-
sible for the grinding poverty of the masses ; nor could
they vejy well realize the moral wretchedness imposed
292
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
by that Government upon the whole of educated Russia.
But the atrocities committed upon the defenceless pris-
oners are there in all their baseness, concrete and palpable,
admitting of no excuse, no doubt or hesitation, crying
out to the heart of humanity against Russian tyranny.
And the Czar’s Government, stupidly confident in its
apparently unassailable position, instead of takipg warn-
ing from the first rebukes, seems to mock Jhis humani-
tarian age by the aggravation of brutalities. Not satis-
fied with slowly killing its prisoners, and with* burying
the flower of our young generation in the Siberian deserts,
the Government of Alexander III. resolved to break their
spirit by deliberately submitting them to a regime of
unheard-of brutality and degradation.”
When one reads that paragraph in the glare of George
Kennan’s revelations, and considers how much it meafis
considers that all earthly figures fail to typify the Czar’s
government, and that one must descend into hell to find
its counterpart, one turns hopefully to your statement of
the objects of the several liberation-parties — and is dis-
appointed. Apparently none of them can bear to think of
losing the present hell entirely, they merely want the
temperature cooled down a little.
I now perceive why all men are the deadly .and uncom-
promising enemies of the rattlesnake : it is merely because
the rattlesnake has not speech. Monarchy has speech,
and by it has been able to persuade men that it differs
somehow from the rattlesnake, has something valuable
about it somewhere, something worth preserving, some-
thing even good and high and fine, when properly “ modi-
fied,” something entitling it to protection from the club
of the first comer who catches it out of its hole. It seems
a most strange delusion and not reconcilable with our
superstition that man is a reasoning being. If a house is
afire, we reason confidently that it is the first comer’s
plain duty to put the fire out in any way he can — drown
it with water, blow it up with dynamite, use any and all
A PLEA FOR ASSASSINATION 293
means to stop the spread of the fire and save the rest of
the city. What is the Czar of Russia but a house afire
in the midst of a city of eighty millions of inhabitants ?
Yet instead of extinguishing him, together with his nest
and system, the liberation-parties are all anxious to
merely cool him down a little and keep him.
It seems to me that this is illogical — idiotic, in fact.
Suppose you had this granite-hearted, bloody-jawed
maniac of Russia loose in your house, chasing the help-
less worAen and little children — your own. What would
you do with him, supposing you had a shotgun ? Well,
he is loose in your house — Russia. And with your shot-
gun in your hand, you stand trying to think up ways to
“ modify ” him.
jDo these liberation-parties think that they can succeed
in a project which has 'been attempted a million times in
the history of the world and has never in one single in-
stance been successful — the “ modification ” of a despot-
ism by other means than bloodshed ? They seem to
think they can. My privilege to write these sanguinary
sentences in soft security was bought for me by rivers of
blood poured upon many fields, in many lands, but I
possess not one single little paltry right or privilege that
comes to me as a result of petition, persuasion, agitation
for reform, or any kindred method of procedure. When we
consider that not even the most responsible English
monarch ever yielded back a stolen public right until it was
wrenched from them by bloody violence, is it rational to
suppose that gentler methods can win privileges in Russia ?
Of course I know that the properest way to demolish
the Russian throne would be by revolution* liut it is not
possible to get up a revolution there ; so the only thing
left to do, apparently, is to keep the throne vacant by
dynamite until a day when candidates shall decline with
thanks. Then organize the Republic. And on the whole
this method has some large advantages ; lor whereas a
revoluticfh destroys some lives which cannot well be
294
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
spared, the dynamite way doesn’t. Consider this : the
conspirators against the Czar’s life are caught in every
rank of life, from the low to the high. And consider : if so
many take an active part, where the peril is so dire, is
this not evidence that the sympathizers who keep still
and do not show their hands, are countless for multitudes ?
Can you break the hearts of thousands of families with
the awful Siberian exodus every year for generations and
not eventually cover all Russia from limit to limit with
bereaved fathers and mothers and brothers arid sisters
who secretly hate the perpetrator of this prodigious crime
and hunger and thirst for his life ? Do you not believe
that if your wile or your child or your father was exiled
to the mines of Siberia for some trivial utterances wrung
from a smarting spirit by the Czar’s intolerable tyranny,
and you got a chance to kill him and did not do it, that
you would always be ashamed to be in your own society
the rest of your life ? Suppose that that refined and lovely
Russian lady who was lately stripped bare before a brutal
soldiery and whipped to death by the Czar’s hand in the
person of the Czar’s creature had been your wife, or your
daughter or your sister, and to-day the Czar should pass
within reach of your hand, how would you feel — and what
would you do ? Consider, that all over vast Russia, from
boundary to boundary, a myriad of eyes filled with tears
when that piteous news came, and through those tears
that myriad of eyes saw, not that poor lady, but lost
darlings of their own whose fate her fate brought back
with new access of grief out of a black and bitter past
never to be forgotten or forgiven.
If I am a Swinburnian — and clear to the marrow I
am — I hold human nature in sufficient honor to believe
there are eighty million mute Russians that are of the
same stripe, and only one Russian family that isn’t.
Mark Twain.
Clemens was still not without hope in the machine, at the
beginning of the new year (1891), but it was a hope Vio longer
HIS CAREER
295
active, and it presently became moribund. Jones, about
the middle of February, backed out altogether, laying the
blame chiefly on Mackay and the others, who, he said, had
decided not to invest.
It was also the end of Mark Twain’s capital. His publishing
business was not good. It was already in debt and needing
more money. There was just one thing for him to do and he
did it at once, not stopping to cry over spilt milk, but with
good courage and the old enthusiasm that never failed him,
he returned tq the trade of authorship.
Fragment of Letter to [ Person Unknown ], 1891 :
.... I confine myself to life with which I am familiar
when pretending to portray life. But I confined myself
to the toiy-life out on the Mississippi because that had a
peculiar charm for me, and not because 1 was not familiar
<fvi#h other phases of life. I was a soldier two weeks once
in the beginning of the war, and was hunted like a rat
the whole time. Familiar ? My splendid Kipling himself
hasn’t a more burnt-in, hard-baked, and unforgetable
familiarity with that death-on-the-pale-horse-with-hell-
following-after, which is a raw soldier’s first fortnight in the
field — and which, without any doubt, is the most tremend-
ous fortnight and the vividest he is ever going to see.
Yes, an(j I have shoveled silver tailings in a quartz-mill
a couple of weeks, and acquired the last possibilities of
culture in that direction. And I’ve done “ pocket-mining ”
during three months in the one little patch of ground in
the whole globe where Nature conceals gold in pockets —
or did before we robbed all of those pockets and exhausted,
obliterated, annihilated the most curious freak Nature
ever indulged in. There are not thirty mqn left alive who,
being told there was a pocket hidden on the broad slope
of a mountain, would know how to go and find it, or have
even the faintest idea of how to set about it ; but I am
one of the possible 20 or 30 who possess the secret, and I
could go and put my hand on that hidden treasure with
a most {leadly precision.
296 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
And I’ve been a prospector, and know pay rock frqm
poor when I find it — just with a touch of the tongue.
And I’ve been a silver miner and know how to dig and
shovel and drill and put in a blast. And so I know the
mines and the miners interiorly as well as Bret Harte
knows them exteriorly.
And I was a newspaper reporter four years t in cities,
and so saw the inside of many things ; and^was reporter
in a legislature two sessions and the same in Congress one
session, and thus learned to know personally thrae sample
bodies of the smallest minds and the selfisliest souls and
the cowardliest hearts that God makes.
And I was some years a Mississippi pilot, and familiarly
knew all the different kinds of steamboalmen — a race
apart, and not like other folk.
And I was for some years a traveling “ jour ” printer?
and wandered from city to city — and so I know that sect
familiarly.
And I was a lecturer on the public platform a number
of seasons and was a responder to toasts at all the different
kinds of banquets — and so I know a great many secrets
about audiences — secrets not to be got out of books, but
only acquirable by experience.
And I watched over one dear project of miije for years,
spent a fortune on it, and failed to make it go — and the
history of that would make a large book in which a million
men would see themselves as in a mirror ; and they would
testify and say, Verily, this is not imagination ; this fellow
has been there — and after would cast dust upon their
heads, cursing and blaspheming.
And I am a^ publisher, and did pay to one author’s
widow (General Grant’s) the largest copyright checks this
world has seen — aggregating more than £80,000 in the
first year.
And 1 have been an author for 20 years and an ass
for 55.
Now then ; .is the most valuable capital or culture or
PHONOGRAPHS 297
education, usable in the building of novels is personal
experience I ought to be well equipped for that trade.
I surely have the equipment, a wide culture, and all of
it real, none of it artificial, for I don’t know anything
about books.
[No signature.]
Clemens for several years had been bothered by rheumatism
in his shouldc?. The return now to the steady use of the pen
aggravated his trouble, and at times he was nearly disabled.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, Feb. 28, '91.
Dear Howells, — Won’t you drop in at the Boylston
Building (New England Phonograph Co) and talk into
phonograph in an ordinary conversation-voice and see
if another person (who didn’t hear you do it) can take the
words from the thing without difficulty and repeat them
to you. If the experiment is satisfactory (also make
somebody put in a message which you don’t hear, and see
if afterward you can get it out without difficulty) won’t
you then ask them on what terms they will rent me a
phonograph for 3 months and furjiish me cylinders
enough to carry 75,000 words. 175 cylinders, ain’f it ?
1 don’t want to erase any of them. My right arm is
nearly disabled by rheumatism, but I am bound to write
this book (and sell 100,000 copies of it — no, I mean a
million— next fall). I feel sure I can dictate the book into
a phonograph if I don’t have to yell. I write 2,000 words
a day ; I think 1 can dictate twice as many.
But mind, if this is going to be too much trouble to you —
go ahead and do it, all the same.
Ys ever Mark.
Clemens did not find the phonograph entirely satisfactory,
at least not for a time, and he appears never to have used it
steadily.
His residence in Hartford was drawing rapidly to a close.
298
letters of mark twain
Mrs. Clemens was poorly, and his own health was, uncertain.
They believed that some of the European baths would help
them. Furthermore, he could no longer afford the luxuiy of
his Har tford home. In Europe life could be simpler and vastly
cheaper. He was offered a thousand dollars apiece for six
European letters, by the McClure syndicate and W. M. Laffan,
of the Sun. Howells, strangely enough, seems to have been
about the last one to be told of their European plans ; in fact,
he first got wind of it from the papers, and wrote for information.
Likely enough Clemens had not until then had «the courage to
confess.
To W. D. Howells, in Boston :
Hartford, May 20, ’91.
Dear Howells, — For her health’s sake Mrs. Clemens
must try baths somewhere, and this it is that has deter-
mined us to go to Europe. The water required seenfc bo
be provided at a little obscure and little-visited nook up
in the hills back of the Rliine somewhere and you get to
it by Rhine traffic-boat and country stage-coach. Come,
get “ sick or sorry enough ” and join us. We shall be a
little while at that bath, and the rest of the summer at
Annecy (this confidential to you) in Haute Savoie, 22
miles from Geneva. Spend the winters in Berlin. I don’t
know how long we shall be in Europe — I Jiave a vote,
but I don’t cast it. I’m going to do whatever the others
desire, with leave to change their mind, without preju-
dice, whenever they want to. Travel has no longer any
charm for me. I have seen all the foreign countries I
want to see except heaven and hell, and I have only a
vague curiosity as concerns one of those. . . .
Oh, look here — I did to-day what I have several times
in past years thought of doing : answered an interviewing
proposition from a rich newspaper with the reminder that
they had not stated the terms ; that my time was all
occupied with writing, at good pay, and that as talking
was harder work I should not care to venture it unless
I knew the pay was going to be proportionately higher.
THE RHONE
299
I wish I had thought of this the other day when Charley
Stoddard turned a pleasant Englishman loose on me and
I couldn’t think of any rational excuse.
Ys Ever
» Mark.
The house in Hartford was closed early in June, and on the
6th the family, with one maid, Katie Leary, sailed on the
Gascogne. Twb weeks later they had begun a residence abroad
which was to last for more than nine years.
It was mot easy to get to work in Europe. Clemens’s arm
remained lame, and any effort at writing brought suffering.
The Century Magazine proposed another set of letters, but by
the end of July he had barely begun on those promised to
McClure and Laffan. lie decided that he would arrange for
no more European letters when the six were finished, but would
gather material for a book. The idea finally matured when he
rgacked Switzerland and settled the family at the Hotel Beau
Rivage, Ouchy, Lausanne, facing Lake Leman. He decided to
make a floating trip down the Rhone, and he engaged Joseph
Very, a courier that had served him on a former European trip,
to accompany him.
To Mrs. Clemens . in Ouchy, Switzerland :
On the Rhone below VilIeboiB,
Tuesday noon
Good mosning, sweetheart. Night caught us yesterday
where we had to take quarters in a peasant’s house which
was occupied by the family and a lot of cows and calves —
also several rabbits. 1 The latter had a ball, and 1 was the
ball-room ; but they were very friendly and didn’t bite.
The peasants were mighty kind and hearty, and flew
around and did their best to make us comfortable. This
morning I breakfasted on the shore in the* open air with
two sociable dogs and a cat. Clean cloth, napkin and
table furniture, white sugar, a vast hunk of excellent
butter, good bread, first class coffee with pure milk, fried
fish just caught. Wonderful that so much cleanliness
should come out of such a phenomenally dirty house. . . .
• 1 His word for fleas.
300
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Afloat —
2 Hoars below Bourg St. AndeoL
Monday, 11 turn., Sept. 28.
Livy darling, I didn’t write yesterday. Wc left La
Voulte in a driving storm of cold rain — couldn’t write
in it — and at 1 p.m. when we were not thinking of stop-
ping, wc saw a picturesque and mighty ruin on ® high hill
back of a village, and I was seized with a desire to> explore
it ; so we landed at once and set out with rubbers and
umbrella, sending the boat ahead to St. Andeoi, and we
spent 3 hours clambering about those cloudy heights
among those worn and vast and idiotic ruins of a castle
built by two crusaders 650 years ago. The work of these
asses was full of interest, and we had a good time inspect-
ing, examining and scrutinizing it. All the hills on both
sides of the Rhone have peaks and precipices, and £adh
has its grey and wasted pile of mouldy walls and broken
towers. The Romans displaced the Gauls, the Visigoths
displaced the Romans, the Saracens displaced the Visi-
goths, the Christians displaced the Saracens, and it was
these pious animals who built these strange lairs and cut
each other’s throats in the name and for the glory of God,
and robbed and burned and slew in peace and war ; and
the pauper and the slave built churches, and the credit
of it went to the Bishop who racked the money out of
them. These are pathetic shores, and they make one
despise the human race.
We came down in an hour by rail, but I couldn’t
get your telegram till this morning, for it was Sunday
and they had shut up the post office to go to the circus.
I went, too. It was all one family — parents and 5 chil-
dren — performing in the open air to 200 of these enchanted
villagers, who contributed coppers when called on. It
was a most gay and strange and pathetic show. 1 got
up at 7 this morning to see the poor devils cook their poor
breakfast and pack up their sordid fineries.
This is a 9 k-m. current and the wind is withr us ; we
ROUGH WATER
801
shall make Avignon before 4 o’clock. I saw watermelons
and pomegranates for sale at St. Andeol.
With a power of love, Sweetheart,
Saml.
To Clara Clemens , in Ouchy, Switzerland :
• • Afloat, 11.20 a.m., Sept. 29, Tuesday.
Dear old Ben, — The vast stone masses and huge
towers of* the ancient papal palace of Avignon arc pro-
jected above an intervening wooded island a mile up the
river behind me— for we are already on our way to Arles.
It is a perfectly still morning, with a brilliant sun, and
very hot — outside ; but I am under eover of the linen
hood, and it is cool and shady in here. . . .
* The only adventures we have is in drifting into rough
seas now and then. They are not dangerous, but they go
thro’ all the motions of it. Yesterday when we shot the
Bridge of the Holy Spirit it was probably in charge of
some inexperienced deputy spirit for the day, for we
were allowed to go through the wrong arch, which brought
us into a tourbillon below which tried to make this old
scow stand on its head. Of course I lost my temper and
blew it off in a way to be heard above the roar of the
tossing waters. I lost it because the admiral had taken
that arch in deference to my opinion that it was the best
one, while his own judgment told him to take the one
nearest the other side of the river. I could have poisoned
him I was so mad to think I had hired such a turnip. A
boatman in command should obey nobody’s orders but
his own, and yield to nobody’s suggestions. *
It was very sweet of you to write me, dear, and I thank
you ever so much. With greatest love and kisses,
Papa,
The Clemenses settled in Berlin for the winter, at 7 Komer-
btrasse, and later at the Hotel Royal. Young Hall, his
802
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN .
publishing manager in America, was working hard to keep the
business afloat, and being full of the optimism of his years did
not fail to make as good a showing as he could.
To Mr. Hall, in New York :
Berlin, Nov. 27, ’91.
f
Dear Mr. Hall, — That kind of a statement is valuable.
It came this morning. This is the first time since the
business began that I have had a report that, furnished
the kind of information I wanted, and was really en-
lightening and satisfactory. Keep it up. Don’t let it fall
into desuetude.
Everything looks so fine and handsome with the busi-
ness, now, that I feel a great let-up from depression. The
rewards of your long and patient industry are on thoir
way, and their arrival safe in port, presently, seems
assured.
By George, I shall be glad when the ship comes in !
My arm is so much better that I was able to make a
speech last night to 250 Americans. But when they
threw my portrait on the screen it was a sorrowful reminder
for it was from a negative of 15 years ago, and hadn’t a
gray hair in it. And now that my ami is better, I have
stolen a couple of days and finished up a couple of McClure
letters that have been lying a long time.
I shall mail one of them to you next Tuesday — regis-
tered. Look out for it.
I shall register and mail the other one (concerning the
“ Jungfrau ”) next Friday — look out for it also, and drop
me a line to let me know they have arrived.
I shall write the 6th and last letter by and by when I
have studied Berlin sufficiently.
Yours in a most cheerful frame of mind, and with my
and all the family’s Thanksgiving greetings and best
wishes,
S. L. Clemens.
BERLIN AND MENTONE 808
Mark Twain was the notable literary figure in Berlin that
winter, the centre of every great gathering. He was enter-
tained by the Kaiser, and shown many special attentions by
Germans of every rank. He was too popular for his own good ;
the gaiety of the capital told on him. Finally, one night, after
delivering a lecture in a hot room, he contracted a severe cold,
driving to a ball at General von Versen’s, and a few days later
was confined to his bed with pneumonia. It was not a severe
attack, but it was long continued.
Clemens aijd his wife were advised to leave the cold of
Berlin as soon as he was able to travel. This was not until the
first of March, when, taking their old courier, Joseph Very,
they left tne children in good hands and journeyed to the south
of France.
To Susy Clemens, in Berlin :
Mentone, March 22,’ 92.
• Susy dear, — I have been delighted to note your easy
facility with your pen and proud to note also your literary
superiorities of one kind and another — clearness of state-
ment, directness, felicity of expression, photographic
ability in setting forth an incident — style — good style —
no barnacles on it in the way of unnecessary, retarding
words (the shipman scrapes off the barnacles when he
wants his racer to go her best gait and straight to the
buoy.) You should write a letter every day, long or short
— and so ought I, but I don’t.
Mamm a says, tell Clara yes, she will have to write a
note if the fan comes back mended.
We couldn’t go to Nice to-day — had to give it up, on
various accounts — and this was the last chance. I am
sorry for Mamma — I wish she could have gone. She
got a heavy fall yesterday evening and was pretty stiff
and lame this morning, but is working it off trunk packing.
Joseph is gone to Nice to educate himself in Kodacking
— and to get the pictures mounted which Mamma thinks
she took here ; but I noticed she didn’t take the plug out,
as a rule. When she did, she took nine pictures on top
of each ciher — composites. With lots of love. Papa.
&04 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
In the course of their Italian wanderings they reached
Florence, where they were so comfortable and well that they
decided to engage a villa for the next winter. Through Prof.
Willard Fiske, they discovered the Villa Viviani, near Settignano,
an old palace beautifully located on the hilltops east of Florence,
commanding a wonderful view of the ancient city. Clemens
felt that he could work there, and time proved that he was right.
For the summer, however, they returned to Germany, and
located at Bad-Nauheim.
To Fred J. Hall, in New York :
Aug. 10, ’92.
Dear Mr. Hall, — I have dropped that novel I wrote
you about, because I saw a more effective way of using
the main episode — to wit : by telling it through the lips
of Huck Finn. So I have started Huck Finn and Tom
Sawyer (still 15 years old) and their friend the freed slave
Jim around the world in a stray balloon, with Huck as
narrator, and somewhere after the end of that great voyage
he will work in the said episode and then nobody will sus-
pect that a whole book has been written and the globe
circumnavigated merely to get in that episode in an effective
(and at the same time apparently unintentional) way. I
have written 12,000 words of this narrative, and find that
the humor flows as easily as the adventures and sur-
prises — so I shall go along and make a book of from 50,000
to 100,000 words.
It is a story for boys, of course, and I think will interest
any boy between 8 years and 80.
When I was in New York the other day Mrs. Dodge,
editor of St. Nicholas, wrote and offered me $5,000 for
(serial right) a ctory for boys 50,000 words long. I wrote
back and declined, for I had other matter in my mind,
then.
I conceive that the right way to write a story for boys
is to write so that it will not only interest boys but will
also strongly interest any man who has ever been a boy .
That immensely enlarges the audience. *
VILLA VIVIANI
305
Now this story doesn’t need to be restricted to a child’s
magazine — it is proper enough for any magazine, I should
think, or for a syndicate. I don’t swear it, but I think so.
Proposed title of the story, “New Adventures of
Huckleberry Finn.”
[No signature.]
The* “ novel ” mentioned in the foregoing was The Extraor-
dinary Twins, a story from which Pudd'nhead Wilson would
be evolvud later. It was wildly extravagant farce — just the
sort of thing that now and then Mark Twain plunged into
with an enthusiasm that had to work itself out and die a natural
death, or mellow into something worth while. Tom Sawyer
Abroad, as the new Huck story was finally called, was completed
and disposed of to St. Nicholas for serial publication.
Clemens and family left Uad-Nauheim for Italy by way of
Switzerland.
Clemens got well settled down to work presently. lie found
the situation, the climate, the background, entirely suited to
literary production, and in a little while he had accomplished
more than at any other time since his arrival in Europe.
To Mrs. Crane, in Elmira :
Villa Viviani
• Settignano, Florence.
Oct. 22, '92.
Dear Sue, — We are getting wonted. The open fires
have driven away the cold and the doubt, and now a cheery
spirit pervades the place. Livy and the Kings and Made-
moiselle have been taking their tea a number of times,
lately, on the open terrace with the city and the hills and
the sunset for company. I stop work, a feft minutes, as a
rule, when the sun gets down to the hilltops west of
Florence, and join the tea-group to wonder and exclaim.
There is always some new miracle in the view, a new and
exquisite variation in the show, a variation which occurs
every 15 minutes between dawn and night. Once early
in the morning, a multitude of white villas not before
806
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
perceived, revealed themselves on the tar hills ; then we
recognized that all those great hills are snowed thick with
them, clear to the summit.
The variety of lovely effects, the infinitude of change,
is something not to be believed by any who has not seen
it. No view that I am acquainted with in the world is °t
all comparable to this for delicacy, charm, exqyisiteness,
dainty coloring, and bewildering rapidity of change. It
keeps a person drunk with pleasure all the time. Some-
times Florence ceases to be substantial, and becomes just a
faint soft dream, with domes and towers of air, and one is
persuaded that he might blow it away with a puff of his
breath.
Livy is progressing admirably. This is just the place
for her. [Remainder missing.]
♦ ,
The reader may have suspected that young Mr. Hall in
New York was having his troubles. He was by this time
one-third owner in the business of Charles L. Webster & Co.,
as well as its general manager. The business had been drained
of its capital one way and another — partly by the publication of
unprofitable books ; partly by the earlier demands of the type-
setter, but more than all by the manufacturing cost and agents’
commissions demanded by L. A. L. ; that is to say, the eleven
large volumes constituting the Library of American Literature,
which Webster had undertaken to place in a million American
homes.
Clemens had faith in Hall and was fond of him. He never
found fault with him ; he tried to accept his encouraging reports
at their face value. He lent the firm every dollar of his literary
earnings not absolutely needed for the family’s support; he
signed new notes ; he allowed Mrs. Clemens to put in such
remnants of her patrimony as the type-setter had spared. He
was not hopeless yet, but he was clearly a good deal disheartened
— anxious for freedom.
To Fred J. Hall, in New York.
Florenoe May 30, '93 ,
Dear Mr. Hall, — You were to cable me if you sold
any machine royalties — so I judge you have not ’succeeded.
THE FINANCIAL SITUATION 307
This has depressed me. I have been looking over the
past year’s letters and statements ^nd am depressed still
more.
I am terribly tired of business. I am by nature and
disposition unfitted for it and I want to get. out of it. I
am standing on the Mount Morris volcano with help
from th« machine a long way off — doubtless a long way
further' off than the Connecticut Co. imagines.
Now here is my idea for getting out.
The firm owes Mrs. Clemens and me — I do not know
quite how much, but it is about $170,000 or $175,000, I
suppose (I make this guess from the documents here,
whose technicalities confuse me horribly.)
The firm owes other sums, but there is stock and cash
assets to cover the entire indebtedness and $110,G79,20
T)ver. Is that it ? In 'addition we have the L. A. L.
plates and copyright, worth more than $130,000 — is
that correct ?
That is to say, we have property worth about $250,000
above indebtedness, I suppose — or, by one of your esti-
mates, $300,000 ? The greater part of the first debts to
me is in notes paying 6 percent. The rest (the old $70,000
or whatever it is) pays no interest.
Now them, will Harper or Appleton, or Putnam give
me $200,000 for those debts and my two-thirds interest
in the firm ? (The firm of course taking the Mount Morris
and all such obligations off my hands and leaving me clear
of all responsibility.)
I don’t want much money. I only want first class
notes — $200,000 worth of them at 6 per cent, payable
monthly ; — yearly notes, renewable annualfy for 3 years,
with $5,000 of the principal payable at the beginning and
middle of each year. After that, the notes renewable
annu all y and (perhaps) a larger part of the principal
payable semi-annually.
Please advise me and suggest alterations and emenda-
tions of the above scheme, for I need that sort of help,
808 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
being ignorant of business and not able to leam a single
detail of it. ^
Such a deal would make it easy for a big firm to pour
in a big cash capital and jump L. A. L. up to enormous
prosperity. Then your one-third would be a fortune —
and I hope to see that day !
I enclose an authority to use with Whitmore in case
you have sold any royalties. But if you can’t make this
deal don’t make any. Wait a little and see if you can’t
make the deal. Do make the deal if you posstfbly can.
And if my presence shall be necessary in order to complete
it I will come over, though I hope it can be done without
that.
Get me out of business !
And I will be yours forever gratefully,
• S. L. Clemens.
My idea is, that I am offering my \ of L. A. L. and the
business for thirty or forty thousand dollars. Is that it ?
P. S. S. The new firm could retain my books and reduce
them to a 10 percent royalty.
S. L. C.
Hall, naturally, did not wish to be left alone with the business.
He wrote, therefore, proposing as an alternative that they dispose
of the big subscription set that was swamping them. It was
a good plan — if it would work — and we find Clemens entering
into it heartily.
Those who arc old enough to remember the summer of 1893
may recall it as a black financial season. Banks were denying
credit, businesses were forced to the wall. It was a poor time
to float any cosjly enterprise. The Chicago company who were
trying to build the machines made little progress. The book
business everywhere was bad. In a brief note Clemens wrote
Hall :
“ It is now past the middle of July and no cablegram to say
the machine is finished. We arc afraid you are having miserable
days and worried nights, and we sincerely wish we could
relieve you, but it is all black with us and we don’t know any
helpful thing to say or do." *
HENRY H. ROGERS
809
But soon he could endure the suspense no longer, and on
August 29th sailed once more for Amjfrica. In New York,
Clemens settled down at the Players Club, where he could live
cheaply, and undertook some literary work while he was casting
about for ways and means to relieve the financial situation.
.Nothing promising occurred, until one night at the Murray
Hill Hotel he was introduced by Dr. Clarence C. Rice to Henry
II. Rogers, of the Standard Oil group of financiers. Rogers
had a keen'sense of humour and had always been a great admirer
of Mark 'Twain’s work. It was a mirthful evening, and cer-
tainly an eventful one in Mark Twain’s life. A day or two
later Doctpr Rice asked the millionaire lo interest himself a
little in Clemens’s business affairs, which he thought a good deal
confused. Just what happened is not remembered now, but
from the date of the next letter wc realize that a discussion of
the matter by Clemens and Rogers must have followed pretty
promptly.
To Mrs. Clemens , in Europe :
Oot. 18, *93.
Dear, dear Sweetheart, — I don’t seem to get even
half a chance to write you, these last two days, and yet
there’s lots to say.
Apparently everything is at last settled as to the give-
away of L. A. L., and the papers will be signed and the
transfer made to-morrow morning.
Meantime I have got the best and wisest man in the
whole Standard Oil group of multi-millionaires a good
deal interested in looking into the type-setter (this is
private, don’t mention it.) He has been searching into
that thing for three weeks, and yesterday he said to me,
“ I find the machine to be all you represented it — I have
here exhaustive reports from my own ejtpcus, and I
know every detail of its capacity, its immense value, its
construction, cost, history, and all about its inventor’s
character. I know that the New York Co. and the Chicago
Co. are both stupid, and that they are unbusinesslike
people, destitute of money and in a hopeless boggle.”
Then tie told me the scheme he had planned, then
310
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
said : “ If I can arrange with these people on this basis —
it will take several wis^ks to find out — I will see to it that
they get the money they need. Then the thing will move
right along and your royalties will cease to be waste paper.
I will post you the minute my scheme fails or succeeds.
In the meantime, you stop walking the floor. Go off to tb'*
country and try to be gay. You may have to go, to walk-
ing again, but don’t begin till I tell you my scheme has
failed.” And he added : “ Keep me posted always as to
where you are — for if I need you and can use you I want
to know where to put my hand on you.”
If I should even divulge the fact that the Standard Oil
is merely talking remotely about going into the type-setter,
it would send my royalties up.
With worlds and worlds of love and kisses to you all,
Saml.' •
With so great a burden of care shifted to the broad financial
shoulders of H. H. Rogers, Mark Twain’s spirits went ballooning,
soaring toward the stars. lie awoke, too, to some of the social
gaieties about him, and found pleasure in the things that in
the hour of his gloom had seemed mainly mockery.
It was decided that Rogers and Clemens should make a trip
to Chicago to investigate personally the type-setter situation
there.
To Mrs. Clemens, in Paris.
The Players, Xmas, 1893.
. . . We had nice trips, going and coming. Mr. Rogers
had telegraphed the Pennsylvania Railroad for a couple
of sections for us in the fast train leaving at 2 p. m. the
22nd. The Vice President telegraphed back that every
berth was engaged (which was not true — it goes without
saying) but that he was sending his own car for us. It
was mighty nice and comfortable. In its parlor it had two
sofas, which could become beds at night. It had four
comfortably-cushioned cane arm-chairs. It had a very
nice bedroom with a wide bed in it ; which I said I would
. TRAIN-TRAVELLING DE LUXE 811
take because I believed 1 was a little wider than Mr. Rogers
— which turned out to be true ; sy I took it. It had a
darling back-porch — railed, roofed and roomy ; and there
we sat, most of the time, and viewed the scenery and talked,
for the weather was May weather, and the soft dream-
pictures of hill and river and mountain and sky were clear
and away beyond anything I have ever seen for exquisite-
ness and daintiness.
The colored waiter knew his business, and the colored
cook was a finished artist. Breakfasts : coffee with real
cream ; beefsteaks, sausage, bacon, chops, eggs in various
ways, potatoes in various — yes, and quite wonderful baked
potatoes, and hot as fire. Dinners — all manner of things,
including canvas-back duck, apollinaris, claret, cham-
pagne, etc.
• • We sat up chatting .till midnight, going and coming ;
seldom read a line, day or night, though we were well fixed
with magazines, etc. ; then I finished off with a hot Scotch
and we went to bed and slept till 9.30 a.m. I honestly
tried to pay my share of hotel bills, fees, etc., but I was
not allowed — and I knew the reason why, and respected
the motive. I will explain when I see you, and then you
will understand.
We we^e 25 hours going to Chicago ; we were there 24
hours ; we were 30 hours returning. Brisk work, but all
of it enjoyable. We insisted on leaving the car at Phila-
delphia so that our waiter and cook (to whom Mr. R.
gave $10 apiece,) could have their Christmas-eve at home.
Mr. Rogers’s carriage was waiting for us in Jersey City
and deposited me at the Players. There — that’s all.
This letter is to make up for the three lf*tter ] ^ss days. I
love you, dear heart, I love you all.
Saml.
The beginning of the new year found Mark Twain sailing
buoyantly on a tide of optimism. He believed that with
H. H. Rogers as his financial pilot he could weather safely any
storm or stress. He could divert himself, or rest, or work, and
812
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
consider his business affairs with interest and amusement*
instead of with haggarti anxiety. lie ran over to Hartford to
see an amateur play ; toyBoston to give a charity reading ; to
Fair Haven to open the library which Mr. Rogers had estab-
lished there; he attended gay dinners, receptions, and late
studio parties, acquiring the name of the “ Belle of New York.”
Clemens and Oliver Wendell Holmes had met and become
friends soon after the publication of Innocents Abroad, inlSGC.
Now, twenty-five years later, we find a record of what, without
doubt was their last meeting. It occurred at the home af Mrs.
James T. Fields. 9
To Mrs. Clemens , in Paris :
Boston, Jan. 25, ’94
Livy darling, I am caught out worse this time than ever
before, in the matter of letters. Tuesday morning I was
smart enough to finish and mail my long letter to y«u «
before breakfast — for I was suspecting that I would not
have another spare moment during the day. It turned
out just so.
In a thoughtless moment I agreed to come up here and
read for the poor. I did not reflect that it would cost me
three days. I could not get released. Yesterday 1 had
myself called at 8 and ran out to Mr. Rogers’s house at 9,
and talked business until half past 10 ; then caught 11
o’clock train and arrived here at G ; was shaven and dressed
by 7 and ready for dinner here in Mrs. Fields’ charming
house.
Dr. Oliver Wendell Holmes never goes out now (he is
m his 84th year,) but he came out this time — said he
wanted to “ have a time ” once more with me.
Mrs. Fields s^id Aldrich begged to come and went away
crying because she wouldn’t let him. She allowed only
her family (Sarah Ome Jewett and sister) to be present,
because much company would overtax Dr. Holmes.
Well, he was just delightful 1 He did as brilliant and
beautiful talking (and listening) as ever he did in his life,
I guess. Fiel (island Jewett said he hadn’t been jui such
.OLIVER WENDELL HOLMES 318
splendid form in years. He had ordered his carriage {or 9.
The coachman sent in for him at 9 y but he said, “Oh,
nonsense ! — leave glories and grandeurs like these ? Tell
him to go away and come in an hour I ”
. At 10 he was called for again, and Mrs. Fields, getting
uneasy, rose, but he wouldn’t go — and so we rattled ahead
the same as ever. Twice more Mrs. Fields rose, but he
wouldn’t, go — and he didn’t go till half past 10 — an un-
warrantable dissipation for him in these days. He was
prodigiousjy complimentary about some of my books, and
is having Pudd’nhcad read to him. I told him you and
I used the Autocrat as a courting book and marked it all
through, and that you keep it in the sacred green box with
the love letters, and it pleased him.
Good-bye, my dear darling, it is 15 minutes to dinner
and 4’m not dressed yet. 1 have a reception to-night and
will be out very late at that place and at Irving’s Theatre
where I have a complimentary box. I wish you were all
here. Sami..
In the next letter we meet James J. Corbett — “ Gentleman
Jim,” as he was sometimes called — the champion pugilist of
that day.
The Howells incident so amusingly dramatized will perhaps
be more appreciated if the reader remembers that Mark Twain
himself had jft intervals been a mind-healing enthusiast. In-
deed, in spite of his strictures on Mrs. Eddy, his interest in the
subject of mind-cure continued to the end of his life.
To Mrs. Clemens , in Paris :
Sunday, 0.30 a.m.
Livy dear, when we got out to the house Ifist night, Mrs.
Rogers, who is up and around, now, didn’t want to go
down stairs to dinner, but Mr. R. persuaded her and we
Iiad a very good time indeed. By 8 o’clock we were down
again and bought a fifteen-dollar box in the Madison
Square Garden (Rogers bought it, not I,) then he went
and fetched Dr, Rice while I (went) to the Players and
' 314 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN ,
picked up two arti|ts — Reid and Simmons — and thus we
filled 5 of the 6 s»ts. There was a vast multitude of
people in the brilliant place. Stanford White came along
presently and invited me to go to the World-Champion’s
dressing room, which I was very glad to do. Corbett has (
a fine face and is modest and diffident, besides being the
most perfectly and beautifully constructed human animal
in the world. I said — * .
“ You have whipped Mitchell, and maybe you will whip
Jackson in June — but you are not done, then. , You will
have to tackle me.”
lie answered, so gravely that one might easily have
thought him in earnest —
“ No — I am not going to meet you in the ring. It is
not fair or right to require it. You might chance to
knock me out, by no merit of your own, but by a purely
accidental blow ; and then my reputation would be gone
and you would have a double one. You have fame
enough and you ought not to want to take mine away
from me.”
Corbett was for a long time a clerk in the Nevada Bank
in San Francisco.
There were lots of little boxing matches, to entertain
the crowd : then at last Corbett appeared in^ the ring and
the 8,000 people present went mad with enthusiasm. My
two artists went mad about his form. They said they
had never seen anything that came reasonably near
equaling its perfection except Greek statues, and they
didn’t surpass it.
Corbett boxed 3 rounds with the middle-weight Aus-
tralian champion — oh, beautiful to see ! — then the show
was over and we struggled out through a perfect wash of
humanity. When we reached the street I found I had
left my arctics in the box. I had to have them, so Simmons
said he would go back and get them, and I didn’t dissuade
him. I couldn’t see how he was going to make his way a
single yard into that solid oncoming wave ot people —
NEW YORK NIGHTS
315
yet he must plow through it full i>0 yards. He was
back with the shoes in 8 minutes ! "
How do you reckon he accomfflished that miracle ?
By saying—
* “ Way, gentlemen, please — coming to fetch Mr. Cor-
bett’s overshoes.”
The iiyord flew from mouth to mouth, the Red: Sea
divided,* and ^Simmons walked comfortably through and
back, dry shod. Simmons (this was revealed to me under
seal of searecy by Reid) is the hero of “ Gwen,” and he and
Gwen’s author were once engaged to marry. This is
“ fire-escape ” Simmons, the inveterate talker, you know :
“ Exit — in case of Simmons .”
I had an engagement at a beautiful dwelling close to
the Players for 10.30 ; I was there by 10.45. Thirty
Cultivated and very musical ladies and gentlemen present
— all of them acquaintances and many of them personal
friends of mine. That wonderful Hungarian Band was
there (they charge $500 for an evening.) Conversation
and Band until midnight ; then a bite of supper ; then
the company was compactly grouped before me and I
told about Dr. E. B. Martin and the etchings, and followed
it with the Scotch-Irish Christening. My, but the Martin
is a darling.story ! Next, the head tenor from the Opera
sang half a dozen great songs that set the company wild,
yes, mad with delight, that nobly handsome young Dam-
rosch accompanying on the piano.
Just a little pause — then the Band burst out into an
explosion of weird and tremendous dance music, a Hun-
garian celebrity and his wife took the floor. — I followed ;
I couldn’t help it ; the others drifted in, one by one, and
it was Onteora over again.
By half past 4 I had danced all those people down —
and yet was not tired ; merely breathless. I was in bed
at 5, and asleep in ten minutes. Up at 9 and presently
at work on this letter to you. I think I wrote until 2 or
half past. Then I walked leisurely out to Mr. Rogers’s
816
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
(it is called 8 miles but it is short of it) arriving at 8.80,
but he was out — flb return at 5.80 — (and a person
was in, whom I don’t particularly like) — so I didn’t
stay, but dropped over and chatted with the Howellses
until 6.
First, Howells and I had a chat together. I asked
about Mrs. H. He said she was fine, still steadily improving
and nearly back to her old best health. I asked (as if
I didn’t know) :
“ What do you attribute this strange miracle to ? ’
“ Mind-cure — simply mind-cure.”
“ Lord, what a conversion ! You were a scoffer three
months ago.”
“I? I wasn’t.”
“ You were. You made elaborate fun of me in this
very room.” * *
“ I did not, Clemens.”
“ It’s a lie, Howells, you did”
I detailed to him the conversation of that time — with
the stately argument furnished by Boycsen in the fact
that a patient had actually been killed by a mind-curist ;
and Howells’s own smart remark that when the mind-
curist is done with you, you have to call in a “ regular ” at
last because the former can't procure you a burial permit.
At last he gave in — he said he remembered that talk,
but had now been a mind-curist so long it was difficult for
him to realize that he had ever been anything else.
Mrs. H. came skipping in, presently, the very person,
to a dot, that she used to be, so many years ago.
Mrs. H. said : “ People may call it what they like, but
it is just hypnotism, and that’s all it is — hypnotism pure
and simple. Mind-cure ! — the idea ! Why, this woman
that cured me hasn’t got any mind. She’s a good creature,
but she’s dull and dumb and illiterate and — ”
“ Now Eleanor ! ”
“ I know what I’m talking about I — don’t I go there
twice a week? And Mr. Clemens, if you could only see
MIND-CURE
317
her wooden and satisfied face wherf she snubs me for
forgetting myself and showing by thoughtless remark
that to me weather is still weather instead of being just
an abstraction and a superstition — oh, it’s the funniest
' thing you ever saw 1 A-n-d — when she tilts up her nose —
well, it’s — it’s — Well it’s that kind of a nose that — ”
“ Now Eleanor ! — the woman is not responsible for her
nose — ” andwso-on and so-on. It didn’t seem to me that
I had any right to be having this feast and you not there.
She convinced me before she got through, that she and
William James are right — hypnotism and mind-eure are
the same thing ; no difference between them. Very well ;
the very source, the very centre of hypnotism is Paris.
Dr. Charcot’s pupils and disciples are right there and
ready to your hand without fetching poor dear old Susy
hcross the stormy sea. Let Mrs. Mackay (to whom I send
my best respects) tell you whom to go to to learn all you
need to learn and how to proceed. Do, do it, honey.
Don’t lose a minute.
... At 11 o’clock last night Mr. Rogers said :
“ I am able to feel physical fatigue — and I feel it now.
You never show any, either in your eyes or your move-
ments ; do you ever feel any ? ”
I was able to say that I had forgotten what that feeling
was like. Don’t you remember how almost impossible it
was for me to tire myself at the Villa ? Well, it is just so
in New York. I go to bed unfatigued at 3, I get up fresh
and fine six hours later. I believe I have taken only one
daylight nap since I have been here.
When the anchor is down, then I shall s&y :
“ Farewell — a long farewell — to business ! I will never
touch it again 1 ”
I will live in literature, I will wallow in it, revel in it,
I will swim in ink I Joan of Are — but all this is premature ;
the anchor is not down yet.
818
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To-morrow (Tudsday) I will add a P. S. if I’ve any to
add ; but, whetheAor no, I must mail this to morrow,
for the mail steamer g >es next day.
5.30 p. m. Great Scott, this is Tuesday ! I must rush
this letter into the mail instantly.
Tell that sassy Ben I’ve got her welcome letter, »ud
I’ll write her as soon as I get a daylight chance. ( I’ve most
time at night, but I’d druther write daytimes, Saml.
The Reid and Simmons mentioned in the foregoing were
Robert Reid and Edward Simmons, distinguished painter —
the latter a brilliant, fluent, and industrious talker. The title,
“ Fire-escape Simmons,” which Clemens gives him, originated
when Oliver Herford, whose quaint wit has so long delighted
New-Yorkers, one day pinned up by the back door of the
Players the notice : “ Exit in case of Simmons.” Gwen, a
popular novel of that day, was written by Blanche Willis
Howard. ' *
“ Jamie ” Dodge, in the next letter, was the son of Mrs.
Mary Mapcs Dodge, editor of St. Nicholas.
To Clara Clemens , in Paris :
Mr. Rogers’s Office, Feb. 6, ’04.
Dear Benny — I was intending to answer your letter
to-day, but I am away down town, and will -simply whirl
together a sentence or two for good-fellowship. I have
bought photographs of Coquelin and Jane Hading and
will ask them to sign them. I shall meet Coquelin to-
morrow night, and if Hading is not present I will send
her picture to her by somebody.
I am to breakfast with Madame Nordica in a few days,
and mcantime«I hope to get a good picture of her to sign.
She was of the breakfast company yesterday, but the
picture of herself which she signed and gave me does not
do her majestic beauty justice.
I am too busy to attend to the photo-collecting right,
because I have to live up to the name which Jamie Dodge
has given me — the “ Belle of New York ” — and it just
COQUELIN AND OTHERS
319
keeps me rushing. Yesterday I h4d engagements to
breakfast at noon, dine at 8, and dine again at 7. I got
away from the long breakfast at 2 y.m., went and excused
myself from the 8 o’clock dinner, 4hen lunched with Mrs.
Dodge in 58th street, returned to the Players and dressed,
dined out at 7, and was back at Mrs. Dodge’s at 10 p. m.
where w^ had magic-lantern views of a superb sort, and
a lot of yams until an hour after midnight, and got to
bed at 2 this morning — a good deal of a gain on my recent
hours. But I don’t get tired ; I sleep as sound as a dead
person, and always wake up fresh and strong — usually
at exactly 9.
I was at breakfast lately where people of seven separate
nationalities sat and the seven languages were going all
the time. At my side sat a charming gentleman who was
3, delightful and active- talker, and interesting. He
talked glibly to those folks in all those seven languages
— and still had a language to spare 1 I wanted to kill him,
for very envy.
I greet you with love and kisses. Papa.
To Mrs. Clemens , in Paris :
, • Feb. — .
Livy dear, last night I played billiards with Mr. Rogers
until 11, then went to Robert Reid’s studio and had a most
delightful time until 4 this morning. No ladies were
invited this time. Among the people present were —
Coquelin ; Richard Harding Davis ; Harrison, the
great out-door painter ; Wm. H. Chase, the artist ; Bettini,
inventor of the new phonograph ; Nikola Tbsla, Lhe world-
wide illustrious electrician ; see article about him in Jan.
or Feb. Century ; John Drew, actor ; James Barnes, a
marvelous mimic ; my, you should see. him 1 Smedley the
artist ; Zom the artist ; Zogbaum the artist ; Reinhart
the artist ; Metcalf the artist ; Ancona, head tenor at the
Opera. *
320 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Oh, a great lotfaf others. Everybody there had done
something and was in his way famous.
Somebody welcomed Coquelin in a nice little French
speech; John Drew did the like for me in English, and
then the fun began. Coquelin did some excellent French*
monologues — one of them an ungrammatical Eng ,; dh-
man telling a* colorless historiette in French. t It nearly
killed the fifteen or twenty people who understood* it.
I told a yam, Ancona sang half a dozen songs, Barnes
did his darling imitations, Harding Davis sang tke hanging
of Danny Deever, which was of course good, but he fol-
lowed it with that most fascinating (for what reason I
don’t know) of all Kipling’s poems, “ On the Road to
Mandalay,” sang it tenderly, and it searched me deeper
and charmed me more than the Deever.
Young Gerrit Smith played some ravishing daned-
music and we all danced about an hour. There couldn’t
be a pleasanter night than that one was. Some of those
people complained of fatigue but I don’t seem to know
what the sense of fatigue is.
Coquelin talks quite good English now. He said —
“ I have a brother who has the fine mind — ah, a charm-
ing and delicate fancy, and he knows your writings so
well, and loves them — and that is the same with me.
It will stir him so when I write and tell him I have seen
you ! ”
Wasn’t that nice ? We talked a good deal together. He
is as winning as his own face. But he wouldn’t sign that
photograph for Clara. “ That ? No ! She shall have a
better one. I will send it to you.”
He is mudh driven, and will forget it, but Reid has
promised to get the picture for me, and I will try and keep
him reminded.
Oh, dear, my time is all used up and your letters are not
answered.
Mama, dear, I don’t go everywhere — I decline most
things. But there are plenty that I can’t well gtet out of.
tfARK TWAIN AND H. H. ROGERS 821
I will remember what you say and rfot make my yarning
too common.
I am so glad Susy has gone on Jthat trip and that you
are trying the electric. May yoi/both prosper. For you
are mighty dear to me and in my thoughts always.
Saml.
The affairs of the Webster Publishing Company were by this
time getting into a very serious condition indeed. The effects
of the panic of the year before could not be overcome. Creditors
were pressing their claims and profits were negligible.
To Mrs . Clemens, in Paris :
Tho Players, Feb. 15, ’94. 11.30 p.m.
Livy darling. Yesterday I talked all my various matters
ovc? with Mr. Rogers and wc decided that it would be
safe for me to leave here the 7th of March, in the New
York. So his private secretary. Miss Harrison, wrote and
ordered a berth for me and then I lost no time in cabling
you that I should reach Southampton March 14, and
Paris the 15th. Land, but it made my pulses leap, to
think I was going to see you again ! . . . One thing at a
time. I never fully laid Webster’s disastrous condition
before Mr. Rogers until to-night after billiards. I did
hate to burden his good heart and over-worked head
with it, but he took hold with avidity and said it was no
burden to work for his friends, but a pleasure. We dis-
cussed it from various standpoints, and found it a suffi-
ciently difficult problem to solve ; but he thinks that after
he has slept upon it and thought it over he will know what
to suggest. ■»
You must not think I am ever rude with Mr. Rogers,
I am not. He is not common clay, but fine — fine and
delicate — and that sort do not call out the coarsenesses
that are in my sort. I am never afraid of wounding him ;
I do not need to watch myself in that matter. The sight
of him is ppacc,
Y
822
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
He wants to go Ho Japan— it is his dream ; wants to
go with me — which means, the two families — and hear
no more about businAw for awhile, and have a rest. And
he needs it. But it is ike all the dreams of all busy men —
fated to remain dreams.
You perceive that he is a pleasant text for me. Jt is
easy to write about him. When I arrived in September,
lord how black the prospect was — how desperate, how
incurably desperate 1 Webster and Co. had to have a
small sum of money or go under at once. I flew to Hart-
ford — to my friends — but they were not moved, not
strongly interested, and I was ashamed that I went.
It was from Mr. Rogers, a stranger, that I got the money
and was by it saved. And then — while still a stranger —
he set himself the task of saving my financial life without
putting upon me (in his native delicacy) any sense \hdt
I was the recipient of a charity, a benevolence — and he
has accomplished that task ; accomplished it at a cost of
three months of wearing and difficult labor. He gave
that time to me — time which could not be bought by
any man at a hundred thousand dollars a month — no,
nor for three times the money.
Well, in the midst of that great fight, that long and
admirable fight, George Warner came to me and said —
“ There is a splendid chance open to you. I know a
man — a prominent man — who has written a book that
will go like wildfire ; a book that arraigns the Standard
Oil fiends, and gives them unmitigated hell, individual by
individual. It is the very book for you to publish ; there
is a fortune in it, and 1 can put you in communication
with the author.”
I wanted to say —
“ The only man 1 care for in the world ; the only man
l would give a damn for ; the only man who is lavishing
his sweat and blood to save me and mine from starvation
and shame, is a Standard Oil fiend. If you know me, you
know whether I want the book or not.” *
EUROPE AGAIN
828
But 1 didn’t say that. I said I didn’t want any book ;
I wanted to get out of the publishing business and out
of all business, and was here for at purpose and would
accomplish it if I could. /
But there’s enough. I shall be asleep by 3, and I don’t
need much sleep, because I am never drowsy or tired these
days. Dear, dear Susy — my strength reproaches me when
I think, of her and you, my darling.
* Saml.
But eVcn so able a man as ITenry Rogers could not accom-
plish the impossible. The affairs of the Webster Company were
hopeless, the business was not worth saving. By Mr. Rogers’s
advice an assignment was made April 18, 1894. After its early
spectacular success less than ten years had brought the business
to failure. The publication of the Grant memoirs had been its
only great achievement.
• Xlemens sailed for Europe as soon as his affairs would permit
him to go. He must get settled where he could work com-
fortably. Type-setter prospects seemed promising, but mean-
time there was need of funds.
In August we find him writing to Mr. Rogers from Etrctat,
a little Norman watering-place. The reader may remember that
Clemens had written the first half of his Joan of Arc book at
the Villa Viviani, in Florence, nearly two years before. He
had closed the manuscript then with the taking of Orleans,
and was by no means sure that he would continue the story
beyond that.point.
Rouen, where Joan met her martyrdom, was only a short
distance away, and they halted there en route to Paris, where
they had arranged to spend the winter. The health of Susy
Clemens was not good, and they lingered in Rouen while Clemens
explored the old city and incidentally did some writing of
another sort. In a note to Mr. Rogers he said : “ To put in
my odd time I am writing some articles about Paul Bourgct
and his Outre-Mer chapters — laughing at them and at some of
our oracular owls who find them important* Wnat the hell
makes them important, I should like- to know 1 ”
He was still at Rouen two weeks later and had received
encouraging news from Rogers concerning the type-setter, which
had been placed for trial in the office of the Chicago Herald.
Clemens wrote : “ 1 can hardly keep from sending a hurrah by
cable. I would certainly do it if I wasn’t superstitious.” His
restraint* though wise, was wasted — the end was near.
824 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To II. K. Rogers, in New York :
169 Rue do I'Universit^,
Paris, Deo. 22, '94.
Dear Mr. Rogers, -M seemed to be entirely expecting
your letter, and also prepared and resigned ; but Lord,
it shows how little wc know ourselves and how easily we
can deceive ourselves. It hit me like a thunder-clap. It
knocked every rag of sense out of my head, and *1 went
flying here and there and yonder, not knowing what I
was doing, and only one clearly defined thought standing
up visible and substantial out of the crazy storm-drift —
that my dream of ten years was in desperate peril, and
out of the 60,000 or 70,000 projects for its rescue that
came floating through my skull, not one would hold still
long enough for me to examine it and size it up. Have
you ever been like that ? Not so much so, I reckon. * •
There was another clearly defined idea — I must be
there and see it die. That is, if it must die ; and maybe
if I were there we might hatch up some next-to-impossible
way to make it take up its bed, and take a walk.
So, at the end of four hours I started, still whirling and
walked over to the rue Scribe — 4 P. M. — and asked a
question or two and was told I should be running a big
risk if I look the 9 P. M. train for London jand South-
ampton ; “ better come right along at 6.52 per Havre
special and step aboard the New York all easy and com-
fortable.” Very l and I about two miles from home, with
no packing done.
Then it occurred to me that none of these salvation-
notions that were whirl-winding through my head could
he examined oi»madc available unless at least a month’s
time could be secured. So I cabled you, and said to myself
that I would take the French steamer tomorrow (which
will be Sunday).
By bedtime Mrs. Clemehs had reasoned me into a
fairly rational and contented state of mind ; but of course
it didn’t last long. So I went on thinking — mixing it
RELIEF
825
with a smoke in the dressing room once an hour — until
dawn this morning. Result — a sane resolution ; no matter
what your answer to my cable j^ight be, I would hold
still and not sail until I shou^T get an answer to this
present letter which I am now writing, or a cable answer
from you saying “ Come,” or “ Remain.”
I haue slept 6 hours, my pond has clarified, and I find
the sediment »of my 70,000 projects to be of this character :
{Scvcsol pages of suggestions for reconstructing tlic machine
follow.]
Don’t say I’m wild. For really I’m sane again this
morning. . . .
With love, S. L. Clemens.
• •
To II. II. Rogers, in New York :
169 Rue do l’Univorflit6,
Paris, Deo. 27, '94.
Dear Mr. Rogebs, — Notwithstanding your heart is
“ old and hard,” you make a body choke up. I know
you “ mean every word you say ” and I do take it “ in
the same spirit in which you tender it.” I shall keep
your regard* while we two live — that I know ; for I shall
always remember what you have done for me, and that
will insure me against ever doing anything that could
forfeit it or impair it. 1 am 50 years old ; yet I never had
a friend before who put out a hand and tried to pull me
ashore when he found me in deep waters.
It is six days or seven days ago that I lived through that
despairing day, and then through a night*without sleep ;
then settled down next day into my right mind (or there-
abouts), and wrote you. I put in the rest of that day till
7 p. m. plenty comfortably enough writing a long chapter
of my book ; then went to a masked ball blacked up as
Uncle Remus, taking Clara along; and we had a good
time. I* have lost no day since and suffered no discom-
326 LETTERS OF MARX TWAIN
o
fort to speak of, but drove my troubles out of my mind
and had good success in keeping them out — through
watchfulness. I have \one a good week’s work and put
the book a good way alvad in the Great Trial, which is
the difficult part which requires the most thought and
carefulness. I cannot see the end of the Trial yet, but
I am on the road. I am creeping surely toward ito.
“ Why not leave them all to me.” My business bothers ?
I take you by the hand ! I jump at the chance I . . .
m
P .S. Madam says No, I must face the music. So I
enclose my effort — to be used if you approve, but not
otherwise.
There ! Now if you will alter it to suit your judgment
and bang away, I shall be eternally obliged.
We shall try to find a tenant for our Hartford house ;*
not an easy matter, for it costs heavily to live in. Wc
can never live in it again ; though it would break the
family’s hearts if they could believe it.
Nothing daunts Mrs. Clemens or makes the world look
black to her — which is the reason I haven’t drow'ned
myself.
We all send our deepest and warmest greetings to you
and all of yours and a Happy New Year ! *
S. L. Clemens.
To H. 17. Rogers, in New York City :
[No date.]
He as Me. ^Rogers, — Yours of Dec. 21 has arrived,
containing the* circular to stockholders and I guess the
Co. will really quit— there doesn’t seem to be any other
wise course.
There’s one thing which makes it difficult for me to
soberly realize that my ten year dream is actually dis-
solved ; and that is, that it reverses my horoscope. The
proverb says, “ Bom lucky, always lucky,” and I am very
LUCK
327
superstitious. As a small boy I wal notoriously- lucky.
It was usual for one or two of our lads (per annum) to
get drowned in the Mississippi or. in Bear Creek, but I
was pulled out in a § drowned «Midition 9 times before
I learned to swim, and was considered to be a eat in
disguise. When the “ Pennsylvania ” blew up and the
telegraph reported my brother as fatally injured (with 60
others) but n^ade no mention of me, my uncle said to my
mother “ It means that Sam was somewhere else, after
being on«that boat a year and a half — he was born lucky.”
Yes, I was somewhere else. I am so superstitious that 1
have always been afraid to have business dealings with
certain relatives and friends of mine because they were
unlucky people. All my life I have stumbled upon lucky
chances of large size, and whenever they were wasted it
VaS because of my own stupidity and carelessness. And
so I have felt entirely certain that that machine would
turn up trumps eventually. It disappointed me lots of
times, but I couldn’t shake off the confidence of a life-time
in my luck.
Well, whatever I get out of the wreckage will be due to
good luck — the good luck of getting you into the scheme
— for, but for that, there wouldn’t be any wreckage; it
would be total loss.
I wish you had been in at the beginning. Then we
should have had the good luck to step promptly ashore.
Miss Harrison has had a dream which promises me a
large bank account, and I want her to go ahead and
dream it twice more, so as to make the prediction sure
to be fulfilled.
I’ve got a first rate subj ect for a book. It kcj i me awake
all night, and I began it and completed it in my mind.
The minute I finish Joan I will take it up.
Love and Happy New Year to you all.
Sincerely yours,
S. L. Clemens.
928 , lEOTBS Of max TWAIN
JfMijLras about tJt end of the machine interests so far as
Clefflen^vas concerned. Paige succeeded in getting some new
people interested, bat nothing important happened, or that in
any way affected Mark Vwain. Characteristically he put the
whole matter behind hinfcand plunged into his work, facing
comparative poverty and a 1 burden of debts with a stout heart. .
The beginning of the new year found him really poorer in purse
than he had ever been in his life, but certainly not crushed, or
even discouraged — at least, not permanently — and never more
industrious or capable. ,
In February Clemens returned to New York to look after
matters connected with his failure and to close arrangements
for a reading-tour around the world. He was nearly sixty
years old, and time had not lessened his loathing for the plat-
form. More than once, however, in earlier years, he had turned
to it as a debt-payer, and never yet had his burden been so
great as nnw. He concluded arrangements with Major Pond
to take him as far as the Pacific Coast, and with R. S. Smythe,
ef Australia, for the rest of the tour. t
Mark Twain, on this long tour, was accompanied by his wifi?
and his daughter Clara — Susy and Jean Clemens remaining
with their aunt at Quarry Farm. The tour was a financial
success from the start. By the time they were ready to sail
from Vancouver five thousand dollars had been remitted to Mr.
Rogers against that day of settlement when the debts of Webster
& Co. were to be paid. Perhaps it should be stated heic that a
legal settlement had been arranged on a basis of fifty cents on
the dollar, but neither Clemens nor his wife consented to this
as final. They would pay in full.
They sailed from Vancouver August 28, 1895« About the
only letter of this time is an amusing note to Rudyard Kipling,
written at the moment of departure.
To Rudyard Kipling, in England :
August, 1895.
Dear Kipling, — It is reported that you are about to
visit India. This has moved me to journey to that far
country in order that I may unload from my conscience
a debt long due to you. Years ago you came from India
to Elmira to visit me, as you said at the time. It has
always been my purpose to return that visit and that
great compliment some day. I shall arrive next -January
\ k t\\ un on Hi 1 ** "tip p* ni» rar w ni>
\ tiifk i hrto-i n l ini tr hi n^ati\n
HUDYARD KIPLING 800
and you must be ready, I shall comeriding my ayah with
his tusks adorned with silver bells and ribbons and es-
corted by a troop of native ho^vdahs richly clad and
mounted upon a herd of wild bwogalows ; and you must
• be on hand with a few bottld of ghee, for I shall be
thirsty.
Affectionately, »
S. L, Clemens.
Clemens, platforming in Australia, was too busy to write
letters. Everywhere he was welcomed by great audiences, and
everywhere lavishly entertained*
To Rev. Jos . II. Twichell, in Hartford :
Pretoria, South Afrioan Republic,
The Queen's Birthday, *96.
(May 24)
Deab oia> Joe,— Harper for May was given to me
yesterday in Johannesburg by an American lady who
lives there, and I read your article on me while coming
up in the train with her and an old friend and fcllow-
Missourian of mine, Mrs. John Hays Hammond, the
handsome and spirited wife of the chief of the 4 Reformers,
who lies in. prison here under a 15-year sentence, along
with 50 minor Reformers who are in for 1 and 5-year
terms. Thank you a thousand times, Joe, you have
praised me away above my deserts, but I am not the man
to quarrel with you for that ; and as for Livy, she will
take your very hardiest statements at par, and be grateful
to you to the bottom of her heart* Between y r u and
Punch and Brander Matthews, I am hhe to have my
opinion of myself raised sufficiently high ; and I guess
the children will be after you, for it is the study of their
lives to keep my self-appreciation down somewhere within
bounds*
I had a note from Mrs. Rev* Gray (n£e Tyler) yesterday,
and called on her to-day. She is well.
330
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Yesterday I was allowed to enter the prison with Mrs.
Hammond. A Boer guard was at my elbow a 11 the time,
but was courteous and ^polite, only he barred the way in
the compound (quadrang^ or big open court) and wouldn’t
let me cross a white marK that was on the ground — the
“ death-line ” one of the prisoners called it. Not in earned,
though, I think. I found that I had met Hammond once
when he was a Yale senior and a guest of Gep. Franklin’s.
I also found that I had known Capt. Mein intimately 32
years ago. One of the English prisoners had heard me
lecture in London 23 years ago. After being introduced
in turn to all the prisoners, I was allowed to see some
of the cells and examine their food, beds, etc. I was told
in Johannesburg that Hammond’s salary of $150,000 a
year is not stopped, and that the salaries of some of the
others are still continued. Hammond was looking very*
well indeed, and I can say the same of all the others.
When the trouble first fell upon them it hit some of them
very hard ; several fell sick (Hammond among them), two
or three had to be removed to the hospital, and one of the
favorites lost his mind and killed himself, poor fellow, last
week. His funeral, with a sorrowing following of 10,000,
took the place of the public demonstration the Americans
were getting up for me.
These prisoners are strong men, prominent men, and
I believe they are all educated men. They are well off ;
some of them are wealthy. They have a lot of books to
read, they play games and smoke, and for awhile they will
be able to bear up in their captivity ; but not for Jong, not
for very long, I take it. I am told they have times of
deadly brooding and depression. I made them a speech —
sitting down. It just happened so. I don’t prefer that
attitude. Still, it has one advantage — it is only a talk,
it doesn’t take the form of a speech. I have tried it once
before on this trip. However, if a body wants to make
Sure of having “ liberty,” and feeling at home, he had
better stand up, of course. I advised them at coifsiderable
PRETORIA
331
length to stay where they were — they would get used to
it and like it presently ; if they got out they would only
get in again somewhere else, by the look of their coun-
tenances ; and I promised to go eiid see the President and
’ do what I could to get him to douole their Jail-terms.
We had a very good sociable time till the permitted
time was.up and a little over, and we outsiders had to go.
I went ‘again, to-day, but the ltev. Mr. Gray had just
arrived, and the warden, a genial, elderly Boer named
Du Plessls, explained that his orders wouldn’t allow him
to admit saint and sinner at the same time, particularly
on a Sunday. Du Plessis — descended from the Huguenot
fugitives, you see, of 200 years ago — but he hasn’t any
French left in him now — all Dutch.
It gravels me to think what a goose I was to make
Livy and Clara remain in “Durban ; but I wanted to save
them the 30-hour railway trip to Johannesburg. And
Durban and its climate and opulent foliage were so
lovely, and the friends there were so choice and so hearty
that I sacrificed myself in their interests, as I thought. It
is just the beginning of winter, and although the days are
hot, the nights are cool. But it’s lovely weather in these
regions, too ; and the friends are as lovely as the weather,
and Johannesburg and Pretoria are brimming with interest.
I talk here twice more, then return to Johannesburg next
Wednesday for a fifth talk there ; then to the Orange Free
State capital, then to some town on the way to Port
Elizabeth, where the two will join us by sea from Durban ;
then the gang will go to Kimberley and presently to the
Cape — and so, in the course of time, we shall get through
and sail for England ; and then we will hunt up a quiet
village and I will write and Livy edit, for a few months,
while Clara and Susy and Jean study music and things
in London.
We have had noble good times everywhere and every
day, from Cleveland, July 15, to Pretoria, May 24, and
never a 'dull day either on sea or land, notwithstanding
332
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
the carbuncles and Ihings. Even when I was laid up 10
days at Jcypore in India wc had the charmingest times
with English friends. All over India the English — well,
you will never know hoar good and fine they are till you
sec them. ** <
Midnight and after ! and I must do many things to-dr.y,
and lecture to-night.
A world of thanks to you, Joe dear, and $ world of love
to all of you. Mark.
©
The Clemens party sailed from South Africa the middle of
July, 189C, and on the last day of the month reached England.
They had not planned to return to America, but to spend the
winter in or near London in some quiet place where Clemens
could write the book of his travels.
The two daughters in America, Susy and Jean, were expected
to arrive August 12th, but on that day there came, instead, a
letter saying that Susy Clemens was not well enough to sail!
A cable inquiry was immediately sent, but the reply when it
came was not satisfactory, and Mrs. Clemens and Clara sailed
for America without further delay. This w r as on August 15th,
Three days later, in the old home at Hartford, Susy Clemens
died of cerebral fever. She had been visiting Mrs. Charles
Dudley Warner, but by the physician’s advice had been
removed to the comfort and quiet of her own home, only a few
steps away.
Mark Twain, returning from his triumphant tour of the world
in the hope that soon, now, he might be free from debt, with his
family happily gathered about him, had to face alone this cruel
blow. There was no purpose in Iris going to America ; Susy
would be buried long before his arrival. He awaited in England
the return of his broken family. They lived that winter in a
quiet corner of Chelsea, No. 23 Tedworth Square.
To Rev. {Joseph H. Twzchell , in Hartford , Conn . :
Permanent address :
c/o Chatto & Windus
111, St. Martin's Lane, London,
Sept. 27, '96.
Through Livy and Katy I have learned, dear old Joe,
how loyally you stood poor Susy’s friend, and mine, and
Livy’s : how you came all the way down, twice, from your
838
DEATH OF SUSY CLEMENS
summer refuge on your merciful ewands to bring the
peace and comf oft of your beloved presence, first to that
poor child, and again to the broken heart of her poor
desolate mother. It was like you ; like your good great
» heart, like your matchless and unmatchable self. It was
no surprise to me to learn that you stayed by Susy long
hours, careless of fatigue and heat, it was no surprise to
me to ICam tjiat you could still the storms that swept
her spirit when no other could ; for she loved you, revered
you, trusted you, and “ Uncle Joe ” was no empty phrase
upon her lips ! I am grateful to you, Joe, grateful to the
bottom of my heart, which has always been filled with
love for you, and respect and admiration ; and I would
have chosen you out of all the world to take my place
at Susy’s side and Livy’s ih those black hours.
• Susy was a rare creature ; the rarest that has been
reared in Hartford in this generation. And Livy knew it,
and you knew it, and Charley Warner and George, and
Harmony, and the Hilly ers and the Dunhams and the
Cheneys, and Susy and Lilly, and the Dunces, and Henry
Robinson and Dick Burton, and perhaps others. And I
also was of the number, but not in the same degree — for
she was above my duller comprehension. I merely knew
that she was my superior in fineness of mind, in the delicacy
and subtlety of her intellect, but to fully measure her I
was not competent. I know her better now ; for I have
read her private writings and sounded the deeps of her
mind; and I know better, now, the treasure that was
mine than I knew it when I had it. But 1 have this
consolation ; that dull as I was, I always knew enough to
be proud when she commended me or my wftrk— as proud
as if Livy had done it herself — and I took it as the accolade
from the hand of genius. I see now — as Livy always saw —
that she had greatness in her; and that she herself was
dimly conscious of it.
And now she is dead — and I can never tell her.
God bless you Joe — and all of your house. S. L, C,
334
LETTf HS OF MARK TWAIN
Following the EgJilor did not finish easily, and more than
once when he thought it completed he found it necessary to
cut and add and change. The final chapters were not sent to
the printer until the middle of May, and in a letter to Mr,
Rogers he commented : 4‘ A successful book is not made of
what is in it, but what isWt out of it.” Clemens was at the,
time contemplating a uniform edition of his books, and in one
of his letters to Mr. Rogers on the matter he wrote, whimsically,
“ Now l was proposing to make a thousand sets at,a hundred
dollars a set, and do the whole canvassing myse[f. . . I would
load up every important jail and saloon in America with dc
luxe editions of my books. But Mrs. Clemens and the children
object to this, I do not know why.” And, in a moment of
depression : “ You see the lightning refuses to strike me — there
is where the defect is. We have to do our own striking as
Barney Bamato did. But nobody ever gets the courage until
he goes crazy.”
They went to Switzerland for the summer to the village of
Weggis, on Lake Lucerne — “ The charmingest place we ever
lived in,” he declared, “ for repose, and restfulness, and superb
scenery.” It was here that he began work on a new story of
Tom and lluck, and at least upon one other manuscript.
To Rev. ,1. H. Tmchell, in Hartford :
Lucerne, Aug. 22, ’97.
Dear Joe, — Livy made a noble find on the Lucerne
boat the other day on one of her shopping Jrips — George
Williamson Smith — did I tell you about it ? We had a
lovely time with him, and such intellectual refreshment as
wc had not tasted in many a month.
And the other night we had a detachment of the Jubilee
Singers — 0. I had known one of them in London 24 years
ago. Three of the 6 were bom in slavery, the others were
children of slaves. How charming they were — in spirit,
manner, language, pronunciation, enunciation, grammar,
phrasing, matter, carriage, clothes — in every detail that
goes to make the real lady and gentleman, and welcome
guest. We went down to the village hotel and bought
our tickets and entered the beer-hall, where a crowd of
German and Swiss men and women sat grouped at round
THE JUBILEE SINGERS 885
tables with their beer mugs in front of them — self-con-
tained and unimpressionable looking people, an indifferent
and unposted and disheartened audience — and up at the
far end of the room sat the Jubiloes in a row. The Singers
got up and stood — the talking aid glass jingling went on.
Then rose and swelled out above those common earthly
sounds one of those rich chords the secret of whojse make
only the ’jubilees possess, and a spell fell upon that house.
It was fine to see the faces light up with the pleased
wonder and surprise of it. No one was indifferent any
more ; and when the singers finished, the camp was
theirs. It was a triumph. It reminded me of Launcclot
riding in Sir Kay’s armor and astonishing complacent
Knights who thought they had struck a soft thing. The
Jubilees sang a lot of pieces. Arduous and painstaking
■cultivation has not dimini, shed or artificial ized their music,
but on the contrary — to my surprise — has mightily rein-
forced its eloquence and beauty. Away back in the
beginning — to my mind — their music made all other vocal
music cheap ; and that early notion is emphasized now,
It is utterly beautiful, to me ; and it moves me infinitely
more than any other music can. I think that in the
Jubilees and their songs America has produced the per-
fectest flower of the ages ; and I wish it were a foreign
product, so that she would worship it and lavish money
on it and go properly crazy over it.
Now, these countries are different : they would do all
that, if it were native. It is true they praise God, but that
is merely a formality, and nothing in it; they open out
their whole hearts to no foreigner.
The musical critics of the German press praise the
Jubilees with great enthusiasm — acquired technique, etc.
included.
One of the Jubilee men is a son of General Joe Johnson,
and was educated by him after the war. The party came
up to the house and we had a pleasant time.
This «is paradise, here — but of course we have got to
m Lmtifiw 0 mm twain
leave it by and by. * The 18th of August 1 has come and
gone* Joe — and we still seem to live. *
With love from us all. Mark.
Following the Equator Was issued by subscription through
Mark Twain* s old publishers, the Blisses, of Hartford. The slue
of it was large, not only on account of the value of the book
itself, but also because of the sympathy of the American people
with Mark Twain’s brave struggle to pay his debts. "When the
newspapers began to print exaggerated stories of the vast profits
that were piling up. Bliss became worried, for he thought it
would modify the sympathy. He cabled Clemens for a denial,
with the following result :
To Frank E. Bliss, in Hartford :
Vienna, Nov. 4, 1897.
Dear Buss, — Your cablegram informing me that %
report is in circulation which purports to come from me
and which says I have recently made $82,000 and paid
all my debts has just reached me, and I have cabled
back my regret to you that it is not true. I wrote a
letter — a private letter — a short time ago, in which I ex-
pressed the belief that I should be out of debt within the
next twelvemonth. If you make as much as usual for
me out of the book, that belief will crystallize into a fact,
and I shall be wholly out of debt. I am encoring you now.
It is out of that moderate letter that the Eighty-Two-
Thousand-Dollar mare’s nest has developed. But why
do you worry about the various reports ? They do not
worry me. They are not unfriendly, and I don’t see how
they can do any harm. Be patient ; you have but a little
while to wait the possible reports arc nearly all in. It
has been reported that I was seriously ill — it was another
man ; dying — it was another man ; dead — the other man
again. It has been reported that I have received a legacy —
it was another man ; that I am out of debt — it was another
man ; and now comes this $82,000 — still another man. It
1 Anniversary of Susy Clemens’s death. ,
RlVhk 1\\ VI N IN 1 S9l»
4JIEBTS FAIfiJ WT
im Iwga^eported that I ana writing bodfea-lo* publica-
tion ; t am not doing anything of the kind. It would sur-
prise (and gratify) me if I should be able to get another
boole ready for the press within the next three years. You
‘ can see, yourself, that there isn’t anything more to be
reported — invention is exhausted. Therefore, don’t worry,
Bliss — the long night is breaking. As far as I Can see,
nothing remains to be reported, except that I have be-
come a foreigner. When you hear it, don’t you believe
it. And 'don’t you take the trouble to deny it. Merely just
raise the American flag on our house in Hartford, and let
it talk. Truly yours,
Mark Twain.
P. S. This is not a private letter. I am getting tired
S*f private letters.
The end of January saw the payment of the last of Mark
Twain’s debts. Once more he stood free before the world —
a world that sounded his praises. The latter fact rather
amused him. “ Honest men must be pretty scarce,” he said,
” when they make so much fuss over even a defective specimen.”
When the end was in sight Clemens wrote the news to Howells
in a letter as full of sadness as of triumph.
To fP. D. Howells, in New York :
Hotel Motropole,
Vienna, Jan. 22 , ’ 98 .
Dear Howells,-— Look at those ghastly figures. I
used to write it “ Hartford, 1871." There was no Susy
then — there is no Susy now. And how much lies between
— one long lovely stretch of scented fields, mid meadows,
and shady woodlands, and suddenly Sahara 1 You speak
of ihe glorious days of that old time — and they were.
It is my quarrel — that traps like that arc set. Susy and
Winnie given us, in miserable sport, and then taken away.
About the last time I saw you I described to you the
culminating disaster in a book I was going to write (and
388 LETTEliS OF MARK TWAIN
will yet, when the stroke is further away} — a man’s dead
daughter. brought to him when he had been through all
other possible misfortunes — and I said it couldn’t be
done as it ought to be c|one except by a man who had
lived it — it must be written with the blood out of a man’s
heart. I couldn’t know, then, how soon I was to be made
competent. I have thought of it many a time since. If
you were here I think we could cry down each other’s
necks, as in your dream. For we arc a pair of old derelicts
drifting around, now, with some of our passengers gone
and the sunniness of the others in eclipse.
I couldn’t get along without work now. I bury myself
in it up to the ears. Long hours — 8 and 9 on a stretch,
sometimes. And all the days, Sundays included. It
isn’t all for print, by any means, for much of it fails to juit
me ; 50,000 words of it in the past year. It was because
of the deadness which invaded me when Susy died. But
I have made a change lately — into dramatic work — and I
find it absorbingly entertaining. I don’t know that I can
write a play that will play : but no matter, I’ll write
half a dozen that won’t, anyway. Dear me, I didn’t
know there was such fun in it. I’ll write twenty that
won’t play. I get into immense spirits as soon as my day
is fairly started. Of course a good deal of tiiis friskiness
comes of my being in sight of land — on the Webster & Co.
debts, I mean. (Private.) We’ve lived close to the bone
and saved every cent we could, and there’s no undisputed
claim, now, that we can’t cash. I have marked this
“ private ” because it is for the friends who are attending
to the matter for us in New York to reveal it when they
want to and it they want to. There are only two claims
which I dispute and which I mean to look into personally
before I pay them. But they are small. Both together
they amount to only $12,500. I hope you will never get
the like of the load saddled onto you that was saddled onto
me 8 years ago. And yet there is such a solid pleasure in
paying the things that I reckon maybe it is worth while
AN AUSTRIAN PRINCESS 339
. #
to get into tha| kind of a hobble, after all. Mrs.' Clemens
gets millions of delight out of it ; and the children have
never uttered one complaint about the scrimping, from
the beginning. t
We all send you and all of you our love.
Mark.
•
Howells vyotc : “ I wish you could understand how un-
shaken you are, you old tower, in every way ; your foundations
arc' struejt so deep that you will catch the sunshine of immortal
years, and bask in the same light as Cervantes and Shakespeare.”
The Clemens apartments at the Metropole became* a sort of
social clearing-house of the Viennese art and literary life, much
more like an embassy than the home of a mere literary man.
Wherever Mark Twain appeared in public he was a central
figure.
• •
(Private)
To Rev. J. II. Twiehell, in Hartford :
Hotel Mctropolo,
Vienna, Feb. 3, ’98.
Dear Joe, — There’s that letter that I began so long
ago — you see how it is : can’t get time to finish anything.
I pile up lots of work, nevertheless. There may be idle
people in the world, but I’m not one of them. I say
“ Private ” up there because I’ve got an adventure to
tell, and you mustn’t let a breath of it get out. First 1
thought I would lay it up along with a thousand others
that I’ve laid up for the same purpose — to talk to you
about, but — those others have vanished out of my memory ;
and that must not happen with this.
The other night I lectured for a Vienna charity; and
at the end of it Livy and I were introduced to a princess
who is aunt to the heir apparent of the imperial throne —
a beautiful lady, with a beautiful spirit, and very cordial
in her praises of my books and thanks to me for writing
them ; and glad to meet me face to face and shake me by
the hand — just the kind of princess that adoms a fairy
talc and makes it the prettiest tale there is.
810
LETTERS of mark twain
f
Very well, we long ago found that whenjyou are noticed
by supremacies, the correct etiquette is to go, within a
couple of days, and pay your respects in the quite simple
form of writing your naxqe in the Visitors’ Book kept in
the office of the establishment. That is the end of it, and
everything is squared up and ship-shape.
So at noon to-day Livy and I drove to the Arehducal
palace, and got by the sentries all right, and asked the
grandly-uniformed porter for the book and said we wished
to write our names in it. And he called a servant 'in livery
and was sending us up stairs ; and said her Royal Highness
was out but would soon be in. Of course Livy said “ No —
no — we only want the book ; ” but he was firm, and said,
“ You are Americans ? ”
“ Yes.”
“ Then you are expected, please go up stairs.”
“ But indeed we are not expected — please let us have
the book and — ”
“ Her Royal Highness will be back in a very little
while — she commanded me to tell you so — and you must
wait.”
Well, the soldiers were there close by — there was no use
trying to resist — so we followed the servant up ; but when
he tried to beguile us into a drawing-room, Lfvy drew the
line ; she wouldn’t go in. And she wouldn’t stay up there,
either. She said the princess might come in at any moment
and catch us, and it would be too infernally ridiculous for
anything. So we went down stairs again — to my unspeak-
able regret. For it was too darling a comedy to spoil. 1
was hoping apd praying the princess would come, and
catch us up there, and that those other Americans who
were expected would arrive, and be taken for impostors
by the porticr, and shot by the sentinels — and then it
would all go into the papers, and be cabled all over the
world, and make an immense stir and be perfectly lovely.
And by that time the princess would discover that ws
were not the right ones, and the Minister of \$ar would
A SOCIAL COMFlDY
341
be ordered out. and the garrison, rind they would come
for us, and there would be another prodigious time, and
that would get cabled too, and — well, Joe, I was*in a state
of perfect bliss. But happily, oh, so happily, that big
portier wouldn’t let us out — hfc was sorry, but he must
obey orders — we must go back up stairs and wait. Poor
Livy — I t couldn’t help but enjoy her distress. -She said
we wertj in a,, fix, and how were we going to explain, if the
princess should arrive before the rightful Americans came ?
We went up stairs again — laid off our wraps, and were
conducted through one drawing room and into another,
and left alone there and the door closed upon us.
Livy was in a state of mind ! She said it was too
theatrically ridiculous ; and that I would never be able to
keep my mouth shut ; that I would be sure to let it out
* anti it would get into the papers — and she tried to make me
promise — “ Promise what ? ” I said — “ to be quiet about
this ? Indeed I won’t — it’s the best thing that ever hap-
pened ; I’ll tell it, and add to it ; and I wish Joe and
Howells were here to make it perfect ; I can’t make all
the rightful blunders myself — it takes all three of us to
do justice to an opportunity like this. I would just like
to see Howells get down to his work and explain, and lie,
and work his futile and inventionless subterfuges when
that princess comes raging in here and wanting to know”
But Livy could not hear fun — it was not a time to be trying
to be funny — we were in a most miserable and shameful
situation, and if —
Just then the door spread wide and our princess and 4
more, and 8 little princes flowed in ! Our princess, and
her sister the Archduchess Marie Th<5r&se (mother to the
imperial Heir and to the young girl Archduchesses present,
and aunt to the 3 little princes) — and we shook hands all
around and sat down and had a most sociable good time
for half an hour — and by and by it turned out that we
were the right ones, and had been sent for by a messenger
who started too late to catch us at the hotel. We were
, w letters of mark twain
invited for 2 o’clock, (put we beat that arrangement by an
hour and a half.
Wasn’t it a rattling good comedy situation ? Seems a
kind of pity we were the right ones. It would have been
such nuts to see the rigid* ones come, and get fired out,
and we chatting along comfortably and nobody suspecting
us for investors.
We send lots and lots of love.-
Mark.
The year 1898 brought the Spanish- American War. ‘Clemens
was constitutionally against all wars, but writing to Twichell,
whose son had enlisted, we gather that this one was an exception.
To Rev. J. II. Twichell, in Hartford :
Kaltenloutgobcn, near Vienna,
Juno 17, ’98.
Dear Joe, — You are living your war-days over again
in Dave, and it must be a strong pleasure, mixed with a
sauce of apprehension — enough to make it just schnicck,
as the Germans say. Dave will come out with two or
three stars on his shoulder-straps if the war holds, and
then we shall all be glad it happened.
We started with Bull Run, before. Dewey {ind Hobson
have introduced an improvement on the game this time.
I have never enjoyed a war — even in written history —
as I am enjoying this one. For this is the worthiest one
that was ever fought, so far as my knowledge goes. It
is a worthy thing to fight for one’s freedom ; it is another
sight finer to fight for another man’s. And I think this
is the first time«it has been done.
Oh, never mind Charley Warner, he would interrupt
the raising of Lazarus. He would say, the will has been
probated, the property distributed, it will be a world of
trouble to settle the rows — better leave well enough alone ;
don’t ever disturb anything, where it’s going to break
the soft smooth flow of things and wobble our trasquillity.
A DISCARDED ST^RY
343
Company ! (Sh ! it happens cvcjpy day — and we came
out here to be (Juict.)
Love to you all.
Mark.
They were spending the sunfmer at Kaltonleutgcben, a
pleasant village near Vienna, but apparently not entirely quiet.
Many friends came out from Vienna, including a lyimber of
visiting. Americans. Clemens, however, appears to have had
considerable time for writing, as we gather from the next to
Howells.
To W. D. Ilowclls, in America :
Kaltenieutgcben, Bei Wien
Aug. 16, '98.
Dear Howells, — Your letter came yesterday. It then
,oc*urrcd to me that I might have known (per mental tele-
graph) that it was due ; for a couple of weeks ago when the
Weekly came containing that handsome reference to me
I was powerfully moved to write you ; and my letter went
on writing itself while I was at work at my other literature
during the day. But next day my other literature was
still urgent — and so on and so on ; so my letter didn’t
get put into ink at all. But I see now, that you were
writing, about that time, therefore a part of my stir
could have come across the Atlantic per mental telegraph.
In 1870 or ’75 I wrote 40,000 words of a story called
“ Simon Wheeler ” wherein the nub was the preventing
of an execution through testimony furnished by mental
telegraph from the other side of the globe. 1 had a lot of
people scattered about the globe who carried in their
pockets something like the old mesmerizej’-bu + ton, made
of different metals, and when they wanted to call up each
other and have a talk, they “ pressed the button ” or did
something, I don’t remember what, and communication
was at once opened. I didn’t finish the story, though I
re-began it in several new ways, and spent altogether
70,000 wprds on it, then gave it up and threw it aside.
844 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
This much as preliminary lo this remark : some day
people will be able to call each other up flom any part ol
the world* and talk by mental telegraph — and not merely
by impression, the impression will be articulated into
words. It could be a terrible thing, but it won’t be, because
in the upper civilizations everything like sentimentality
(I was going to say sentiment) will presently get materialized
out of people along with the already fading spiritualities ;
and so when a man is called who doesn’t wish to talk he
will be like those visitors you mention : “ not chosen ” —
and will be frankly damned and shut off.
Speaking of the ill luck of starting a piece of literary
work wrong — and again and again ; always aware that
there is a way, if you could only think it out, which
would make the thing slide effortless from the pen — the
one right way, the sole form for you, the other forms being*
for men whose line those forms are, or who are capablcr
than yourself : I’ve had no end of experience in that (and
maybe I am the only one — let us hope so.) Last summer
I started 16 things wrong — 3 books and 13 mag. articles —
and could only make 2 little wee things, 1500 words alto-
gether, succeed : — only that out of piles and stacks of
diligently-wrought MS., the labor of 6 weeks’ unremitting
effort. I could make all of those things go if I would take
the trouble to re-begin each one half a dozen times on a
new plan. But none of them was important enough
except one : the story I (in the wrong form) mapped out
in Paris three or four years ago and told you about in
New York under seal of confidence — no other person knows
of it but Mrs. Clemens — the story to be called “ Which was
the Dream ? ” .
A week ago I examined the MS — 10,000 words — and
saw that the plan was a totally impossible one — for me ;
but a new plan suggested itself, and straightway the tale
began to slide from the pen with case and confidence. I
think I’ve struck the right one this time. I have already
put 12,000 words of it on paper and Mrs. Clemens is
WRITING AND DESIGN
345
pretty outspokenly satisfied with §t — a hard critic to
content. I feel iure that all of the first half of the story —
and I hope three-fourths — will be comedy ; but by the
former plan the whole of it (except the first 3 chapters)
would have been tragedy and* unendurable, almost. I
think I can carry the reader a long way before he suspects
that I am laying a tragedy-trap. In the present form I
could spin 16 books out of it with comfort and joy; but
I shall deny myself and restrict it to one. If you should
sec a little short story in a magazine in the autumn called
“ My Platonic Sweetheart ” (written 3 weeks ago) that
is not this one. It may have been a suggester, though.
I expect all these singular privacies to interest you, and
you arc not to let on that they don’t.
We are leaving, this afternoon, for Ischl, to use that as
•a Wsc for the baggage, and then gad around ten days
among the lakes and mountains to rest-up Mrs. Clemens,
who is jaded with housekeeping. I hope I can get a chance
to work a little in spots — I can’t tell. But you do it —
therefore why should you think I can’t ?
[Remainder missing.]
The dream story was never completed. It was the same
that he had worked on in London, and perhaps again in Switzer-
land. It would be tried at other times and in other forms, but
it never seemed to accommodate itself to a central idea, so
that the good writing in it eventually went to waste. The short
story mentioned, “ My Platonic Sweetheart,” a charming,
idyllic tale, was not published during Mark Twain’s lifetime.
Two years after his death it appeared in Harper's Magazine.
The assassination of the Empress of Austria at Geneva was
the startling event of that summer.
To Rev. J. H, Twichcll, in Hartford :
Kaltcnlcutgoben, Sop. 13, ’98.
Dear Joe, — Y ou are mistaken ; people don’t send us
the magazines. No — Harper, Century and McClure do;
1 846 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
an example I should like to recommend to other pub-
lishers. And so I thank you very muclJfor sending me
Brander’s article. When you say “ I like Brander
Matthews ; he impresses me as a man of parts and power,”
I back you, right up to trhc hub — I feel the same way — .
And when you say he has earned your gratitude for cuffing
me for my crimes against the Leather stockings^ and the
Vicar, I ain’t making any objection. Dern yqwr grdtitude !
His article is as sound as a nut. Brander knows litera-
ture, and loves it ; he can talk about it and keep his
temper ; he can state his case so lucidly and so fairly and
so forcibly that you have to agree with him, even when you
don't agree with him ; and he can discover and praise
such merits as a book has, even when they are half a
dozen diamonds scattered through an acre of mud. And
so he has a right to be a critic. ‘
To detail just the opposite of the above invoice is to
describe me. I haven’t any right to criticise books, and
I don’t do it except when I hate them. I often want to
criticise Jane Austen, but her books madden me so that
I can’t conceal my frenzy from the reader ; and therefore
I have to stop every time I begin.
That good and unoffending lady the Empress is killed
by a mad-man, and I am living in the midst of world-
history again. The Queen’s jubilee last year, the invasion
of the Reichsrath by the police, and now this murder,
which will still be talked of and described and painted a
thousand years from now. To have a personal friend of
the wearer of the crown burst in at the gate in the deep
dusk of the evening and say in a voice broken with tears,
“ My God ! tlie*Empress is murdered,” and fly toward her
home before we can utter a question — why, it brings the
giant event home to you, makes you a part of it and per-
sonally interested : it is as if your neighbor Antony should
come flying and say “ Csesar is butchered — the head of
the world is fallen ! ”
Of course there is no talk but of this. The mourning
‘THE DEMI-MONDE”
347
is universal and genuine, the consternation is stupefying.
The Austrian Empire is being draped with black. Vienna
will be a spectacle to see, by next Saturday, when the
funeral cortege inarches. We are invited to occupy a
* room in the sumptuous new hotel (the “ Krantz ” where
we are to Jive during the Fall and Winter) and view it,
and we shall go. .
Speaking of Mrs. Loiter, there is a noble dame in Vienna,
about whom they retail similar slanders. She said in
French — the is weak in French — that she had been spend-
ing a Sunday afternoon in a gathering of the “ demi-
monde.” Meaning the unknown land, that mercantile
land, that mysterious ha If -world which underlies the
aristocracy. But these Malaproperies are always
inventions — they don’t happen.
* Ves, I wish we could have some talks ; I’m full to the
eye-lids. Had a noble good one with Parker and Dunham
—land, but we were grateful for that visit !
Yours with all our loves.
Makk.
[Inclosed with the foregoing.]
Among the inadequate attempts to account for the
assassination* we must concede high rank to the German
Emperor’s. lie justly describes it as a “ deed unparalleled
for ruthlessncss,” and then adds that it was “ordained
from above.”
I think this verdict will not be popular “ above.” A
man is either a free agent or he isn’t. If a man is a free
agent, this prisoner is responsible for what ho has done ;
but if a man is not a free agent, if the deed was ordained
from above, there is no rational way of making this prisoner
even partially responsible for it, and the German court
cannot condemn him without manifestly committing a
crime. Logic is logic ; and by disregarding its laws
even Emperors as capable and acute as William II can
be beguiled into making charges which should not
848
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
be ventured upon except in the shelter of plenty of
lightning-rods. *
Mark.
The end of the year 1898 found Mark Twain onee more in
easy, even luxurious, circumstances.
The beginning of 1899 found the Clemens family still in
Vienna, .occupying handsome apartments at the Hotel Krantz.
Their rooms, so often thronged with gay and distinguished
people, were sometimes called the “ Second Erfibassy.”
A project for world disarmament promulgated by the Czar
of Russia would naturally interest Mark Twain, ttnd when
William T. Stead, of the Review of Reviews, cabled him for an
opinion on the matter, he sent at first a brief word and on the
same day followed it with more extended comment.
To Wm. T. Stead, in London :
No. 1.
Vienna, Jan. 9.
Dear Mr. Stead, — The Czar is ready to disarm : 1
am ready to disarm. Collect the others, it should not be
much of a task now. Mark Twain.
To Wm. T. Stead, in London :
No. 2.
Dear Mr. Stead, — Peace by compulsion. That seems
a better idea than the other. Peace by persuasion has a
pleasant sound, but I think we should not be able to work
it. We should have to tame the human race lirst, and
history seems to show that that cannot be done. Can’t
we reduce the armaments little by little— on a pro rata
basis — by concert of the powers ? Can’t we get four great
powers to agree to reduce their strength 10 per cent a year
and thrash the others into doing likewise ? For, of course,
we cannot expect all of the powers to be in their right
minds at one time. It has been tried. We are not going
to try to get all of them to go into the scheme peaceably,
are we? In that case I must withdraw my influence;
PEACE AND ARMAMENTS
849
because, for business reasons, I mu^t preserve the out-
ward signs of sfenity. Four is enough if they can be
securely harnessed together. They can compel pdace, and
peace without compulsion would be against nature and not
operative. A sliding scale of induction of 10 per cent
a year has a sort of plausible look, and I am willing to
try that if three other powers will join. 1 feel syre that
the armament^ are now many times greater than necessary
for the requirements of either peace or war. Take war-
time for instance. Suppose circumstances made it neces-
sary for us to fight another Waterloo, and that it would do
what it did before — settle a large question and bring
peace. I will guess that 400,000 men were on hand
at Waterloo (I have forgotten the figures). In five
hours they disabled 50,000 men. It took them that
tedious, long time because the firearms delivered only
two or three shots a minute. But we would do the work
now as it was done at Omdurman, with shower guns, rain-
ing 600 balls a minute. Four men to a gun — is that the
number ? A hundred and fifty shots a minute per man.
Thus a modern soldier is 149 Waterloo soldiers in one.
Thus, also we can now retain one man out of each 150 in
service, disband the others, and fight our Waterloos just
as effectively as w'o did eighty -five years ago. We should
do the same beneficent job with 2,800 men now that we
did with 400,000 then. The allies could take 1,400 of
the men, and give Napoleon 1,400 and then whip him.
But instead what do we see ? In war-time in Germany,
Russia and Franee taken together, we find about 8 million
men equipped for the field. Each man represents 149
Waterloo men, in usefulness and killing capacity. Alto-
gether they constitute about 850 million Waterloo men,
and there are not quite that many grown males of the
human race now on this planet. Thus we have this insane
fact — that whereas those three countries could arm 18,000
men with modem weapons and make them the equals of
8 millioil men of Napoleon’s day, and accomplish with
350 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
them all necessary war work, they wast^ their money and
their prosperity creating forces of thefr populations in
piling together 349,982,000 extra Waterloo equivalents
which they would have no sort of use for if they would
only stop drinking and sit, down and cipher a little.
Perpetual peace we cannot have on any terms, 1 sup-
pose ; feut I hope we can gradually reduce the wty strength
of Europe till we get it down to where it pught’ to be —
20,000 men, properly armed. Then we can have all the
peace that is worth while, and when we want a*war any-
body can afford it.
Vienna, January 9.
P. S. — In the article I sent the figures are wrong —
“ 350 million ” ought to be 450 million ; “ 349,982,000 ”
ought to be 449,982,000, and the remark about the sunl
being a little more than the present number of males on
the planet — that is wrong, of course ; it represents really
one and a half the existing males.
To W. D. Howells, in New York :
Hotel Krantz
Wien i. Ncuer Markt 6
‘April 2, ’99.
Deah Howells, — I am waiting for the April Harper,
which is about due now ; waiting, and strongly interested.
You are old enough to be a weary man, with paling
interests, but you do not show it. You do your work in
the same old delicate and delicious and forceful and search-
ing and perfect way. I don’t know how you can— but 1
suspect. I suspect that to you there is still dignity in
human life, and l hat Man is not a joke — a poor joke — the
poorest that was ever contrived*. Since I wrote my Bible
(last year) 1 — which Mrs. Clemens loathes, and shudders
over, and will not listen to the last half nor allow me to
1 What it Man t
“WHAT IS MAN?”
351
print any part of it, Man is not to nje the respect-worthy
person he was before ; and so I have lost my pride in him,
and can’t write gaily nor praisefully about him any more.
And I don’t intend to try. I mean to go on writing, for
- that is my best amusement, but, I shan’t print much, (for
I don’t wish to be scalped, any more than another.)
April 5. The Harper has come. I have been iij Leipzig
with yoUr pa^ty, and then went on to Karlsbad and saw
Mrs. Marsh’s encounter with the swine with the tooth-
pick and* the other manners. 1 — At this point Jean carried
the magazine away.
Is it imagination, or — Anyway I seem to get furtive
and fleeting glimpses which I take to be the weariness
and condolence of age ; indifference to sights and things
once brisk with interest ; tasteless stale stuff which used
•to be champagne ; the boredom of travel : the secret sigh
behind the public smile, the private What-in-hell-did-1-
come-for 1
But maybe that is your art. Maybe that is what you
intend the reader to delect and think he has made a
Columbus-discoveiy. Then it is well done, perfectly
done. I wrote my last travel book 2 — in hell ; but 1 let on,
the best I could, that it was an excursion through heaven.
Some day 1 .will read it, and if its lying cheerfulness fools
me, then I shall believe it fooled the reader. How 1 did
loathe that journey around the world ! — except the sea-part
and India.
Evening. My tail hangs low. I thought I was a financier
— and I bragged to you. I am not bragging, now. The
stock which 1 sold at such a fine profit early in January,
has never ceased to advance, and is now worth .$00,000 more
than 1 sold it for. I feel just as if I had been spending
$20,000 a month, and I feel reproached for this showy and
unbecoming extravagance.
Last week 1 was going down with the family to Budapest
1 In “Thoir Silver Wodding Journey.”
• * FoUomng the Equator.
352
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
to lecture, and to make a speech at a banquet. Just os I
was leaving here I got a telegram from London asking for
the speech for a New York paper. I ( this is strictly private)
sent it. And then 1 didn't make that speech , but another of
a quite different character — a speech bom of something
which the introducer said. If that said speech got cabled
and printed, you needn’t let on that it was never uttered.
That was a darling night, and those Hungarians were
lovely people. We were there a week and ha5 a great time.
At the banquet I heard their chief orator make a most
graceful and easy and beautiful and delicious speech — I
never heard one that enchanted me more — although I did
not understand a word of it, since it was in Hungarian.
But the art of it 1 — it was superlative.
They are wonderful English scholars, these people ; my
lecture audience — all Hungarians — understood me ]5cr-»
fectly — to judge by the effects. The English clergyman
told me that in his congregation are 150 young English
women who earn their living teaching their language ; and
that there are others besides these.
For CO cents a week the telephone reads the morning
news to you at home ; gives you the stocks and markets
at noon ; gives you lessons in 3 foreign languages during
8 hours ; gives you the afternoon telegrams ; pnd at night
the concerts and operas. Of course even the clerks and
seamstresses and bootblacks and everybody else are
subscribers.
(> Correction . Mrs. Clemens says it is 60 cents a month.)
1 am renewing my youth. I made 4 speeches at one
banquet here last Saturday night. And I’ve been to a
lot of football matches.
Jean lias been in here examining the poll for the Im-
mortals (“ Literature,” March 24,) in the hope, I think,
that at last she should find me at the top and you in
second place ; and if that is her ambition she has suffered
disappointment for the third time — and will never fare
any better, 1 hope, for you are where you belong, «by every
THE AMERICAN GIRL
858
right. She wanted to know who it is that does the voting,
but I was not able to tell her. Nor when the election will
be completed and decided. •
Next Morning. I have been reading the morning paper.
I do it every morning — well knowing that I shall find in
it the usual depravities and basenesses and hypocrisies
and cruelties that make up civilization, and cause me to
put in the rest of the day pleading for the damnation of
the human race. I cannot seem to get my prayers answered,
yet I do.not despair.
{Escaped from) 5 o’clock tea. (’sh !) Oh, the American
girl in Europe ! Often she is creditable, but sometimes
she is just shocking. This one, a minute ago — 19, fat-
face, raspy voice, pert ways, the self-complacency of God ;
and with it all a silly laugh (embarrassed) which kept
# breaking out through her chatter all along, whereas there
was no call for it, for she said nothing that was funny.
Spose so many ’ve told y’ how they ’njoyed y’r chapt’r
on the Germ’ tongue it’s bringin’ coals to Newcastle Ke-
he ! say anything ’ bout it Ke-hehe ! Spent m* vacation ’n
Russia, ’n saw Tolstoi ; he said — ” It made me shudder.
April 12. Jean has been in here with a copy of Litera-
ture, complaining that I am again behind you in the elec-
tion of the 10 consecrated members ; and seems troubled
about it and not quite able to understand it. But I have
explained to her that you are right there on the ground,
inside the pool-booth, keeping game — and that that
makes a large difference in these things.
13th. I have been to the Kunstausstellung with Mrs.
Clemens. The office of art seems to be to grovel in the
dirt before Emperors and this and that *and the other
damned breed of priests.
Yrs ever Mark.
Howells and Clemens were corresponding regularly again
though not with the frequency of former years. Perhaps neither
of them was bubbling over with things to say ; perhaps it was
becoming yearly less attractive to pick up a pen and write,
2 A ,
854 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
and then, of course, there was always the discouragement of
distance.
To W. D. Howells t in Hew York :
May 12, 1899.
Dear Howells, — 7.15 p. m. Tea (for Mr. and Mrs.
Tower, who are leaving for Russia) just over ; nice people
and rather creditable to the human race : Mr. and Mrs.
Tower ; the new Minister and his wife ; the Secretary of
Legation ; the Naval (and Military) Attach^ ; < several
English ladies ; an Irish lady : a Scotch lady ; a particularly
nice young Austrian baron who wasn’t invited but ~ ' v >«
and went supposing it was the usual thing and wondered
at the unusually large gathering ; two other Austrian? and
several Americans who were also in his fix ; the old Baronin
Langeman, the only Austrian invited ; — the rest w£re *
Americans. It made just a comfortable crowd in our
parlor, with an overflow into Clara’s tl rough the folding’
doors. I don’t enjoy teas, and am daily spared them by
Mrs. Clemens, but this was a pleasant one. I had only
one accident. The old Baronin Langeman is a person I
have a strong fondness for, for we violently disagree on
some subjects and as violently agree m others : for
instance, she is temperance and r am no* : he has religious
beliefs and feelings and T have none (she’ 1 a Methodist !) ;
she is a democrat and so am I • she is woman’s rights and
so am I ; she is laborers’ rights and approves trades; unions
and strikes, and that is me. And so on. After she was
gone an English lady whom I greatly like, began to talk
sharply against her for contributing money, time, labor,
and public expression of favor to a strike that is on (for
an II -hour day) in the silk factories of Bohemia — and she
caught me unprepared and betrayed me into over-warm
argument. I am sorry; for she didn’t know anything
about the subject, and I did ; and one should be gentle
with the ignorant, for they are the chosen of God.
(The new Minister is a good man, but out of place.
“THE kYSTERJOUS STRANGER”
855
The Sec. of Legation is a good man,*but out of place. The
Attach6 is a good man, but out of place. Our government
for displacement beats the new White Star ship ; and her
possible is 17,200 tons.)
Mai/ 18, 4 p- »». A beautiful English girl and her hand-
some English husband came up and spent the evening,
and she certainly is a bird. English parents*— she was
born and rcjprcd in Roumania and couldn’t talk English
till she was 8 or 10. Stic came up clothed like the sunset,
aii 1 was a delight to look at (Roumanian costume.) . . .
Twenty-four young pooole have gone out to the Sena-
tor’ ing to-day (and to-m rrowi ana Mrs. Clemens and an
^ugli'li lady and old Lesehctitzky and his wife have
goi.< to chaperon them. They gav< m a chance to go,
i>ut there are no snow mountains l tun * ••ant to look at.
Three hours out, three hours back, am l up all night
( watching the v n»g people dane< yelling conversationally
and being y ell 1 at, conversationally, by new acquaint-
ances, through me deafening music, about how I like
Vienna, and ■> it s my lirst visit, and how long we expect
to slay, nils aid 1 sec the foot-washing, and am I writing
a book about Vienna, anu so on. 1 u rms seemed too
severe. Snow me .utains ,r io< iea> .it the price. .
I* >r .everal yea F ,w m N 'mg to stop writing
for pnui as somi l eouid chord t / last I can afford
>t, a, ,ive put die pot-bode p< n " t.> What I have
been wanting is •« chan*’* to witr • book ’vtliout reserves
— a bo«. r which should * >k< account of no one's feelings,
and no one’s prejudices, opinions, beliefs, hopes, illusions,
delusions ; a book which should say my say, right out of
my heart, in the plainest language and witlfou* a limitation
of any sort. I judged that that would be an unimaginable
luxury, heaven on earth.
It is under way, now, and it is a luxury ! an intellectual
drunk. Twice I didn’t start it right ; and got pretty far
in, both times, before I found it out. But I am sure it is
started right this time. It is in talc-form. I believe I can
m LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
make it tell what I think of Man, and ty>w he is con-
structed, and what a shabby poor ridiculous thing he is,
and how mistaken he is m his estimate of his character
and powers and qualities and his place among the animals.
So far, I think I am succeeding. I let the madam into
the secret day before yesterday, and locked the doors and
read to her the opening chapters. She said —
“ It is perfectly horrible — and perfectly beautiful’! ”
“ Within the due limits of modesty, that is what 1
think.” •
I hope it will take me a year or two to write it, and that
it will turn out to be the right vessel to contain all the
abuse I am planning to dump into it.
Yours ever
Mask.
The story mentioned in the foregoing, in which Mark Twain
was to give his opinion of man, was The Mysterious Stranger.
It was not finished at the time, and its closing chapter was not
found until after his death.
To W. D. Ilowells, in America :
London, July 3, '99.
Dear Howells, — . . . I’ve a lot of things tq write you,
but it’s no use — I can’t get time for anything these days.
I must break off and write a postscript to Canon Wilber-
force before I go to bed. This afternoon he left a luncheon-
party half an hour ahead of the rest, and carried off my
hat (which has Mark Twain in a big hand written in it.)
When the rest of us came out there was but one hat that
would go on m f head — it fitted exactly, too. So wore it
away. It had no name in it, but the Canon was the only
man who was absent. I wrote him a note at 8 p. m. ;
saying that for four hours I had not been able to take
anything that did not belong to me, nor stretch a fact
beyond the frontiers of truth, and my family were getting
alarmed. Could be explain my trouble ? And now at 8.80
PUBLIC READING
357
p. m. comes a^note from him to say that all the afternoon
he has been exhibiting a wonder-compelling mental
vivacity and grace of expression, etc., etc., and have I
missed a hat ? Our letters have crossed.
Yours ever
Marx.
HoWells wrote that he was going on a reading-tour — dreading
it, of course — and asking for any advice that Clemens felt
qualified to give.
t
To W. D. Howells, in America :
Sanna, Swcdon, Sopt. 26, ’99.
Dear IIowells, — G et your lecture by heart — it will
pay you. I learned a. trick in Vienna — by accident —
which I wish I had learned years ago. I meant to read
from a Tauchnitz, because I knew I hadn’t well memorized
the pieces ; and I came on with the book and read a few
sentences, then remembered that the sketch needed a
few words of explanatory introduction ; and so, lowering
the book and now and then unconsciously using it to gesture
with, I talked the introduction, and it happened to carry
me into the sketch itself, and then I went on, pretending
that I was merely talking extraneous matter and would
come to the sketch presently. It was a beautiful success.
I knew the substance of the sketch and the telling phrases
of it ; and so, the throwing of the rest of it into informal
talk as I went along limbered it up and gave it the snap
and go and freshness of an impromptu. I was to read
several pieces, and I played the same game with all of
them, and always the audience thought* I was being re-
minded of outside things and throwing them in, and was
going to hold up the book and begin on the sketch presently
— and so I always got through the sketch before they were
entirely sure that it had begun. I did the same thing in
Budapest and had the same good time over again. It’s
a new*dodge, and the best one that was ever invented.
358
letters op mark twain
Try it. you’ll never lose your audience — pot even for a
moment. Their attention is fixed, and never wavers.
And that is not the case where one -reads from book or
MS., or where he stands up without a note and frankly
exposes the fact, by his aonfident manner and smooth
phrasing, that he is not improvising, but reciting from
memory. .And in the heat of telling a thing fhat is
memorised in substance only, one flashes out the happiest
suddenly-begotten phrases every now and then 1 Try it.
Such a phrase has a life and sparkle about it that twice
as good a one could not exhibit if prepared beforehand,
and it “ fetches ” an audience in such an enthusing and
inspiring and uplifting way that that lucky phrase breeds
another one, sure.
Your September instalment 1 was delicious — every worjl
of it. You haven’t lost any of your splendid art. Callers
have arrived.
With love
Mark.
“ Yes,” wrote Howells, “ if I were a great histrionic artist like
you I would get my poor essays by heart, and recite them, but
being what I am I should do the thing so lifelessly that I had
better recognize their deadness frankly and read them.”
To Rev. J. 11. Twichell, in Hartford :
London, Jan. 8, 1900.
Dear Joe, — Mental Telepathy has scored another.
Mental Telegraphy will be greatly respected a century
hence.
By the accident of writing my sister and describing to
her the remarkable cures made by Kellgren with his
hands and vithout drugs, I brought upon myself a quite
stunning surprise ; for she wrote to me that she had been
taking this very treatment in Buffalo — and that it was
an American invention.
1 “ Their Silver Wedding Journey*”
MEDICINE
m
Well, it doeg really turn out that Dr. Still, in the middle
of Kansas, in a village, began to experiment in 187 4, only
five years after Kellgren began the same work obscurely
in the village of Gotha, in Germany. Dr. Still seems to
be an honest man ; therefore J[ am persuaded that Kell-
gren moved him to his experiments by Mental Telegraphy
across sjx hours of longitude, without need of a .wire. By
the time Still began to experiment, Kellgren had com-
pleted his development of the principles of his system
and established himself in a good practice in London —
1874 — and was in good shape to convey his discovery to
Kansas, Mental Telegraphically. . . .
Presently the Osteopath will come over here from
America and will soon make himself a power that must
b£ recognized and reckoned with ; and then, 25 years
from now, England will begin to claim the invention and
tell all about its origin, in the Cyclopedia B — as in the
case of the telegraph, applied anaesthetics and the other
benefactions which she heaped her abuse upon when her
inventors first offered them to her.
I cannot help feeling rather inordinately proud of
America for the gay and hearty way in which she takes
hold of any new thing that comes along and gives it a
first rate trial. Many an ass in America is getting a deal
of benefit out of X-Science’s new exploitation of an age-
old healing principle — faith, combined with the patient’s
imagination — let it boom along ! I have no objection.
Let them call it by what name they choose, so long as it
does helpful work among the class which is numerically
vastly the largest bulk of the human race, i.c the fools,
the idiots, the pudd’nheads. *
We do not guess, we know that 9 in 10 of the species
arc pudd’nheads. We know it by various evidences ; and
one of them is, that for ages the race has respected (and
almost venerated) the physician’s grotesque system — the
emptying of miscellaneous and harmful drugs into a
person's stomach to remove ailments which in many cases
860
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
the drugs could not .reach at all ; in m%ny cases could
reach and help, but only at cost of damage to some other
part of tile man ; and in the remainder of the cases the
drug either retarded the cure, or the disease was cured by
nature in spite of the nostrums. The doctor’s insane
system has not only been permitted to continue its follies
for ages, but has been protected by the State and, made a
close monopoly — an infamous thing, a crime against a
free-man’s proper right to choose his own assassin or his
own method of defending his body against disease and
death.
And yet at the same time, with curious and senile
inconsistency, the State has allowed the man to choose his
own assassin — in one detail — the patent-medicine detail —
making itself the protector of that perilous business, cql-
lecting money out of it, and appointing no committee of
experts to examine the medicines and forbid them when .
extra dangerous. Really, when a man can prove that he
is not a jackass, I think he is in the way to prove that he
is no legitimate member of the race.
I have by me a list of 52 human ailments — common
ones — and in this list I count 19 which the physician’s
art cannot cure. But there isn’t one which Osteopathy
or Kellgren cannot cure, if the patient comes early.
Fifteen years ago I had a deep reverence for the physi-
cian and the surgeon. But 6 months of closely watching
the Kellgren business has revolutionized all that, and now
I have neither reverence nor respect for the physician’s
trade, and scarcely any for the surgeon’s. I am convinced
that of all quackeries, the physician’s is the grotesquest
and the silliest.* And they know they are shams and
humbugs. They have taken the place of those augurs
who couldn’t look each other in the face without laughing.
See what a powerful hold our ancient superstitions have
upon us : two weeks ago, when Livy committed an in-
credible imprudence and by consequence was promptly
stricken down with a heavy triple attack — influenza,
LECTURE TOURS
361
bronchitis, and it lung affected — she recognized the gravity
of the situation ,and her old superstitions rose : she thought
she ought to send for a doctor — Think of it— the last man
in the world I should want around at such a time. Of
course I did not say no — not ihat I was indisposed to
take the responsibility, for I was not, my notion of a
dangeroup responsibility being quite the other way — but
because it is unsafe to distress a sick person ; I only said
we knew no good doctor, and it could not be good policy
to choosd at hazard ; so she allowed me to send for Kellgren.
To-day she is up and around — cured. It is safe to say
that persons hit in the same way at the same time arc in
bed yet, and booked to stay there a good while, and to be
in a shackly condition and afraid of their shadows for a
couple of years or more to -come.
To W. D. Howells , in Boston :
Wellington Court, Knightubrnige,
Jan. 25, 1900.
Dear Howells, — If you got half as much as Pond
prophesied, be content and praise God — it has not hap-
pened to another. But I am sorry he didn’t go with you ;
for it is marvelous to hear him yarn. He is good company,
cheery and Ijearty, and his mill is never idle. Your doing
a lecture tour was heroic. It was the highest order of
grit, and you have a right to be proud of yourself. No
amount of applause or money or both could save it from
being a hell to a man constituted as you are. It is that
even to me, who am made of coarser stuff.
I knew the audiences would come forward and shake
hands with you — that one infallible sign «of sincere ap-
proval. In all my life, wherever it failed me I left the hall
sick and ashamed, knowing what it meant.
Privately speaking, this is a sordid and criminal war,
and in every way shameful and exeuselcss. Every day
I write (in my head) bitter magazine articles about it,
but I have to stop with that. For England must not fall ;
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
it would meap an inundation of Russian and German
political .degradations which would envelop the globe and
steep it in a sort of Middle-Age night and slavery which
would last till Christ comes again. Even wrong — and she
is wrong — England must«be upheld. He is an enemy of
the human race who shall speak against her now. Why
was the* human race created ? Or at least why wasn’t
something creditable created in place of it.* God had his
opportunity. lie could have made a reputation. But no.
He must commit this grotesque folly — a lark winch must
have cost him a regret or two when He came to think it
over and observe effects. For a giddy and unbecoming
caprice there has been nothing like it till this war. I talk
the war with both sides — always waiting until the other
man introduces the topic. Then I say “ My head is with^
the Briton, but my heart and such rags of morals as I have
are with the Boer — now we will talk, unembarrassed and
without prejudice.” And so we discuss, and have no
trouble.
Jan. 26.
It was my intention to make some disparaging remarks
about the human race ; and so I kept this letter open for
that purpose, and for the purpose of telling my dream,
wherein the Trinity were trying to guess a conundrum,
but I can do better — for I can snip out of the “ Times ”
various samples and side-lights which bring the race down
to date, and expose it as of yesterday. If you will notice,
there is seldom a telegram in a paper which fails to show
up one or more members and beneficiaries of our Civiliza-
tion as promenading in his shirt-tail, with the rest of his
regalia in the wash.
I love to see the holy ones air their smug pieties and
admire them and smirk over them, and at the same
moment frankly and publicly show their contempt for
the pieties ol the Boer — confidently expecting the approval
of the country and the pulpit, and getting it. *
THE BOER WAR
363
I notice that pod is on both sides in this war ; thus
history repeats itself. But I am the only person who has
noticed this ; everybody here thinks He is playing the
game for this side, and for this side only.
With gyeat love to you all
Mark.
To "Rev. J. 11. Twichell, in Hartford :
London, Jan. 27, 1900.
Dear Joe, — Apparently we are not proposing to set
the Filipinos free and give their islands to them ; and
apparently we are not proposing to hang the priests and
confiscate their property. If these things are so, the war
out # there has no interest for me.
* I have just been examining chapter LXX of “ Following
the Equator,” to see if the Boer’s old military effectiveness
is holding out. It reads curiously as if it had been written
about the present war.
I believe that in the next chapter my notion of the
Boer was rightly conceived. lie is popularly called un-
civilized, I do not know why. Happiness, food, shelter,
clothing, wholesale labor, modest and rational ambitions,
honesty, kindliness, hospitality, love of freedom and
limitless courage to fight for it, composure and fortitude
in time of disaster, patience in time of hardship and
privation, absence of noise and brag in time of victory,
contentment with a humble and peaceful life void of
insane excitements — if there is a higher and better form
of civilization than this, I am not aware of it and do not
know where to look for it. I suppose we Have the habit
of imagining that a lot of artistic, intellectual and other
artificialities must be added, or it isn’t complete. We
and the English have these latter ; but as we lack the
great bulk of these others, I think the Boer civilization
is the best of the two. My idea of our civilization is that
it is a shabby poor thing and full of cruelties, vanities,
864
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
arrogancies, meannesses, and hypocrisies. As for the
word, I hate the sound of it, for it conveys a lie ; and as
for the' thing itself, I wish it was in hell, where it
belongs.
Provided we could ge^ something better in the place of •
it. But that is not possible, perhaps. Poor as it is, it is
better than real savagery, therefore we must stand by it,
extend it, and (in public) praise it. And sp we must not
utter any hateful word about England in these days, nor
fail to hope that she will win in this war, for her defeat
and fall would be an irremediable disaster for the mangy
human race. Naturally, then, I am for England ; but
she is profoundly in the wrong, Joe, and no (instructed)
Englishman doubts it. At least that is my belief. . . .
To Rev. J. H. Twichell, in Hartford :
Wellington Court,
Knightsbridgo, Moh. 4, '00.
. . . London is happy-hearted at last. The British
victories have swept the clouds away and there are no
unchcerful faces. For three months the private dinner
parties (we go to no public ones) have been Lodges of
Sorrow, and just a little depressing sometimes ; but now
they arc smily and animated again. Joe, do you know the
Irish gentleman and the Irish lady, the Scotch gentleman
and the Scotch lady ? These are darlings, every one.
Night before last it was all Irish — 24. One would
have to travel far to match their case and sociability and
animation and sparkle and absence of shyness and self-
consciousness.
It was American in these fine qualities. This was at
Mr. Lecky’s, He is Irish, you know. Last night it was
Irish again, at Lady Gregory’s. Lord Roberts is Irish ;
and Sir William Butler ; and Kitchener, I think ; and a
disproportion of the other prominent Generals are of
IRISH AND SCOTCH
805
Irish and Scotch breed — keeping up the traditions of
Wellington, and Sir Colin Campbell of the Mutiny. You
will have noticed that in S. A., as in the Mutiny, it is
usually the Irish and the Scotch that are placed in the
•fore-front of the battle. An Irish friend of mine says this
is because the Kelts are idealists, and enthusiasts, with
age-old heroisms to emulate and keep bright before the
world; but that the low-class Englishman is dull and
without ideals, fighting bull-doggishly while he has a
leader, but losing his head and going to pieces when his
leader falls — not so with the Kelt. Sir Wm. Butler said
“ the Kelt is the spear-head of the British lance.”
Love to you all.
Mabk.
* Lecky ” was W. E. H. Lecky, the Irish historian whose
History of European Morals had been, for many years, one of
Mark Twain’s favourite books.
In July the Clemenses left the small apartment at 30 Welling-
ton Court and established a summer household a little way out
of London, at Dollis Ilill.
To the Editor of the Times , in London :
Sib, — It has often been claimed that the London postal
service was swifter than that of New York, and I have
always believed that the claim was justified. But a doubt
has lately sprung up in my mind. I live eight miles from
Printing House Square ; the Times leaves that point at
4 o’clock in the morning, by mail, and reaches me at 5 in
the afternoon, thus making the trip in thirteen hours.
It is my conviction that in New York we s*hould do it in
eleven. C.
Dollis Hill, N. W.
The Clemenses closed Dollis Hill House near the end of
September, and put up for a brief period at a family hotel, an
amusing picture of which follows.
306 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To J. Y. M. MacAlister, in London :
. Sep. 1900.
My dear MacAlister, — We do really start next
Saturday. I meant to sail earlier, but waited to finish t
some studies of what are*callcd Family Hotels. They are
a London specialty, God has not permitted them to exist
elsewhere ; they are ramshackle clubs which wero dwellings
at the time of the Heptarchy. Dover dnd Albemarle
Streets are filled with them. The once spacious rooms are
split up into coops which afford as much discomfort as
can be had anywhere out of jail for any money. All the
modern inconveniences are furnished, and some that have
been obsolete for a century. The prices are astonishingly
high for what you get. The bedrooms are hospitals for
incurable furniture. I find it so in this one. They eicist
upon a tradition ; they represent the vanishing home-like
inn of fifty years ago, and are mistaken by foreigners far
it. Some quite respectable Englishmen still frequent
them through inherited habit and arrested development ;
many Americans also, through ignorance and superstition.
The rooms are as interesting as the Tower of London, but
older I think. Older and dearer. The lift was a gift of
William the Conqueror, some of the beds are prehistoric.
They represent geological periods. Mine it? the oldest.
It is formed in strata of Old Red Sandstone, volcanic tufa,
ignis fatuus, and bicarbonate of hornblende, superimposed
upon argillaceous shale, and contains the prints of pre-
historic man. It is in No. 149. Thousands of scientists
come to see it. They consider it holy. They want to
blast out the prints but cannot. Dynamite rebounds
from it.
Finished studies and sail Saturday in Minneliaha.
Yours ever affectionately,
Mare Twain.
They sailed for New York October Gth, and something more
than a week later America gave them a royal welcome. The
PSYCHIC PHENOMENA
867
S ress, far and wide, sounded Mark Twain’s praises once more ;
inners and receptions were offered on every hand ; editors and
lecture agents clamoured for him.
The family settled in the Earlington Hotel during a*pcriod of
house-hunting. They hoped eventually to return to Hartford,
but after a brief visit paid by Clemens alone to the old place
k he wrote :
To Sylvester Baxter , in Boston :
New York, Oot. 26, 1000.
Dear Mr. Baxter, — I t was a great pleasure to me to
renew the other days with you, and there was a pathetic
pleasure in seeing Hartford and the house again ; but I
realize that if we ever enter the house again to live, our
hearts will break. I am not sure that we shall ever be
strong enough to endure that strain.
Sincerely yours,
S. L. Clemens.
# Mr. and Mrs. Rogers wished to have them in their neighbour-
hood, but the houses there were not suitable, or were too expen-
sive. Through Mr. Frank Doubleday they eventually found,
at 14 West Tenth Street, a large residence handsomely furnished,
and this they engaged for the winter.
Mark Twain’s religion had to do chieily with humanity in its
present incarnation and concerned itself very little with any
possible measure of reward or punishment in some supposed
court of the .hereafter. Nevertheless, psychic investigation
always interested him, and he was good-naturedly willing to
explore, even hoping, perhaps, to be convinced that indi-
viduality continues beyond death.
To Mrs. Charles McQuiston :
Dobbs Ferry, N. Y.
M^rch 26, 1901.
Dear Mrs. McQuiston, — I have never had an experi-
ence which moved me to believe the living can communi-
cate with the dead, but my wife and I have experimented
in the matter when opportunity offered and shall continue
to do so.
I enclose a letter which came this morning — the second
368
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
from the same source. Mrs. K — is a Missourian, and
lately she discovered by accident, that site was a remark*
able hypnotiser. Her best subject is a Missouri girl, Miss
White, who is to come here soon and sustain strictly
scientific tests before professors at Columbia University. »
Mrs. Clemens and I intefid to be present. And we shall
ask the pair to come to our house to do whatever things
they can do. Meantime, if you thought well d£ it, you
might write her and arrange a meeting, telling her it is by
my suggestion and that I gave you her address.
Someone has told me that Mrs. Piper is discredited. I
cannot be sure, but I think it was Mr. Myers, President
of the London Psychical Research Society — wc heard of
his death yesterday. He was a spiritualist. I am afraid
he was a very easily convinced man. We visited two
mediums whom he and Andrew Lang considered qfiite*
wonderful, but they were quite transparent frauds.
Mrs. Clemens corrects me : One of those women was a
fraud, the other not a fraud, but only an innocent, well-
meaning, driveling vacancy.
Sincerely yours, S. L. Clemens.
In Mark Twain’s Bermuda chapters entitled Idle Notes of an
Idle Excursion he tells of an old sea captain, one Hurricane
Jones, who explained biblical miracles in a practical, even if
somewhat startling, fashion. In his story of the prophets of
Baal, for instance, the old captain declared that the burning
water was nothing more nor less than petroleum. Upon reading
the “ Notes,” Professor Phelps of Yale wrote that the same
method of explaining miracles had been offered by Sir Thomas
Browne.
Captain Hurricane Jones also appears in Roughing It, as
Captain Ned Blakely.
To Professor William Lyon Phelps :
Yale University,
New York, April 24, 1901,
My dear Sir, — I was not aware that old Sir Thomas
had anticipated that story, and I am much obliged to
MISSOURI
869
you lor furnishing me the paragraph. It is curious that
the same idea should have entered two heads so unlike
as the head of that wise old philosopher and' that of
Captain Ned Wakcman, a splendidly uncultured old
. sailor, but in his own opinion a thinker by divine right.
He was an old friend of mine Of many years’ standing ;
I made two or three voyages with him, and found him a
darling iiv many ways. The petroleum story was not told
to me ; he tofil it to Joe Twichell, who ran across him by
aecident pn a sea voyage where I think the two were the
only passengers. A delicious pair, and admirably mated,
they took to each other at once and became as thick as
thieves. Joe was passing under a fictitious name, and old
Wakeman didn’t suspect that he was a parson ; so he
gave his profanity full swing, and he was a master of that
,grcM art. You probably know Twichell, and will know
that that is a kind of refreshment which he is very capable
df enjoying.
Sincerely yours,
S. L. Clemens.
For I he summer Clemens and his family found a comfortable
lodge in tlie Adirondacks — a log cabin called “ The Lair on
Saranac Lake. Soon after his arrival there he received an
invitation to attend the celebration of Missouri’s eightieth
anniversary. *IIe sent the following letter :
To Edward L. Dimmitt, in St. Louis :
Among the Adirondack Lakes, July 13, 1901.
Deak Mr. Dimmitt, — By an error in the plans, things
go wrong end first in this world, and much ^precious time
is lost and matters of urgent importance are fatally
retarded. Invitations which a brisk young fellow should
get, and which would transport him with joy, arc delayed
and impeded and obstructed until they are fifty years
overdue when they reach him.
It hasjhappened again in this case.
2 b
370
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
When I was a boy in Missouri I was always on the look-
out for invitations but they always miscarried and went
wandering through the aisles of time ; and now they are
arriving when I am old and rheumatic and can’t travel
and must lose my chance.
I have lost a world oi delight through this matter of
delaying invitations. Fifty years ago I would have gone
eagerly across the world to help celebrate anything that
might turn up. It would have made no difference to me
what it was, so that I was there and allowed a chance to
make a noise.
The whole scheme of things is turned wrong end to.
Life should begin with age and its privileges and accumula-
tions, and end with youth and its capacity to splendidly
enjoy such advantages. As things are now, when in youth
a dollar would bring a hundred pleasures, you can’t have
it. When you are old, you get it and there is nothing
worth buying with it then. •
It’s an epitome of life. The first half of it consists of
the capacity to enjoy without the chance; the last half
consists of the chance without the capacity.
I am admonished in many ways that time is pushing
me inexorably along. I am approaching the threshold
of age ; in 1977 I shall be 142. This is no time to be
flitting about the earth. I must cease from the activities
proper to youth and begin to take on the dignities and
gravities and inertia proper to that season of honorable
senility which is on its way and imminent as indicated
above.
Yours is a great and memorable occasion, and as a son
of Missouri l should hold it a high privilege to be there
and share your just pride in the state’s achievements;
but I must deny myself the indulgence, while thanking
you earnestly for the prized honor you have done me in
asking me to be present.
Very truly yours,
S. L. Clemens.
ASSASSINATION OF PRES. McKINLEY 871
6 1901 assass ^ na ^'i on P rcs idcnt McKinley occurred September
To Rev. J. II. Twichell, in Hartford :
AmpersAd, Tuesday. (Sopt. 10, 1901 )
Dear Joe, — It is another off day, but tomorrow I shall
resume “work^to a certainty, and bid a long farewell to
letter-scribbling.
The news of the President looks decidedly hopeful,
and we are all glad, and the household faces are much
unproved, as to cheerfulness. Oh, the talk in the news-
papers 1 Evidently the Human Race is the same old
Human Race. And how unjust, and unreflectingly dis-
criminating, the talkers arc. Under the unsettling effects
«of*powerful emotion the talkers are saying wild things,
crazy things — they are out of themselves, and do not
tnow it ; they arc temporarily insane, yet with one voice
they declare the assassin sane — a man who has been
entertaining fiery and reason-debauching maggots in his
head for weeks and months. Why, no one is sane, straight
along, year in and year out, and we all know it. Our
insanities are of varying sorts, and express themselves in
varying forms — fortunately harmless forms as a rule —
but in whatever form they occur an immense upheaval
of feeling can at any time topple us distinctly over the
sanity-line for a little while ; and then if our form happens
to be of the murderous kind we must look out — and so
must the spectator.
This ass with the unpronounceable name was probably
more insane than usual this week or twe hack, and may
get back upon his bearings by and by, but he was over
the sanity-border when he shot the President. It is pos-
sible that it has taken him the whole interval since the
murder of the King of Italy to get insane enough to
attempt the President’s life. Without a doubt some
thousand* of men have been meditating the same act
372
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
in the same interval, but new and strong interests have
intervened and diverted their over-excited minds long
enough t'o give them a chance to settle, and tranquilize,
and get back upon a healthy level again. Every extra*
ordinary occurrence unsettles the heads of hundreds of
thousands of men for a few moments or hours or days.
If there Jiad been ten kings around when Humbert fell
they would have been in great peril for a day ot-more —
and from men in whose presence they would have been
quite safe, after the excess of their excitement had had an
interval in which to cool down. I bought a revolver once
and travelled twelve hundred miles to kill a man. He
was away. He was gone a day. With nothing else to
do, I had to stop and think — and did. Within an hour—
within half of it — I was ashamed of myself — and felt
unspeakably ridiculous. I do not know what to call it if,
I was not insane. During a whole week my head was in
a turmoil night and day fierce enough and exhausting
enough to upset a stronger reason than mine.
All over the world, every day, there are some millions
of men in that condition temporarily. And in that time
there is always a moment— perhaps only a single one —
when they would do murder if their man was at hand.
If the opportunity comes a shade too late, the chances
are that it has come permanently too late. 'Opportunity
seldom comes exactly at the supreme moment. This saves
a million lives a day in the world — for sure.
No Ruler is ever slain but the tremendous details of it
are ravenously devoured by a hundred thousand, men
whose minds dwell, unaware, near the temporary-insanity
frontier — and over they go, now I There is a day — two
days — three — during which no Ruler would be safe from
perhaps the half of them ; and there is a single moment
wherein he would not be safe from any of them, no doubt.
It may take this present shooting-case six months to
breed another ruler-tragedy, but it will breed it. There is
ut least one mind somewhere which will brood, qnd wear.
MURDERS AND LUNATICS 879
and decay itsctf to the killing-point and produce that
tragedy.
Every negro burned at the stake unsettles the*cxcitablc
brain of another one — I mean the inflaming details of his
crime, and the lurid theatricality of his exit do it — and
the duplicate crime follows ; and that begets a repetition,
and thai # one another one — and so on. Every . lynching-
account* unsettles the brains of another set of excitable
white men, and lights another pyre— 115 lynchings last
year, 108 inside of 8 months this year ; in ten years this
will be habit, on these terms.
Yes, the wild talk you see in the papers ! And from
men who are sane when not upset by overwhelming excite-
ment. A U. S. Senator — Cullom — wants this Buffalo
criminal lynched ! It would breed other lynchings — of
' men who are not dreaming of committing murders, now,
^nd will commit none if Cullom will keep quiet and not
provide the exciting cause.
And a District Attorney wants a law which shall punish
with death attempts upon a President’s life — this, mind
you, as a deterrent. It would have no effect — or the
opposite one. The lunatic’s mind-space is all occupied —
as mine was — with the matter in hand ; there is no room
in it for reflections upon what may happen to him. That
comes after the crime.
It is the noise the attempt would make in the world
that would breed the subsequent attempts, by unsettling
the rickety minds of men who envy the criminal his vast
notoriety — his obscure name tongued by stupendous
Kings and Emperors — his picture printed everywhere,
the trivialest detail of his movements, *what he eats,
what he drinks ; how he sleeps, what he says, cabled
abroad over the whole globe at cost of fifty thousand
dollars a day — and he only a lowly shoemaker yesterday !
— like the assassin of the President of France — in debt,
three francs to his landlady, and insulted by her — and
to-day She is proud to be able to say she knew him “ a§
874
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
familiarly os you know your own brother,” and glad to
stand till she drops and pour out columns and pages of*
her grandeur and her happiness upon the eager interviewer.
Nothing will check the lynchings and ruler-murder but
absolute silence — the absence of pow-pow about them,
flow arc you going to manage that ? By gagging every
witness and jamming him into a dungeon for life ; by
abolishing all newspapers ; by exterminating all news-
paper men ; and by extinguishing God’s most elegant
invention, the Human Race. It is quite simple, quite
easy, and I hope you will take a day off and attend to it,
Joe.
I blow a kiss to you, and am
Lovingly Yours,
Mark.
«
<
When the Adirondack summer ended Clemens settled for
the winter in the beautiful Appleton home at Riverdale-on-the*
Hudson. It was a place of wide-spreading grass and shade — a
house of ample room. They were established in it in time for
Mark Twain to take on active interest in the New York elec-
tions and assist a ticket for good govt rnment to defeat Tammany
Ilall.
The year 1902 was an c\entful one for Mark Twain. In
April he received a d< grcc of LL.D. from the University of
Missouri and returned to his native State to accept it. This
was his last journey to the Mississippi River. During the
summer Mrs. Clemens’s health broke down and illnesses of one
sort or another visited other members of the family.
At York Harbour, Maine, where they had taken a cottage
for the summer — a pretty place, with Howells not far distant,
at Kittery Point — Mrs. Clemens’s health gave way. This was
at a period when telegraphic communication was far from
reliable.
i
To the President of The Western Union, in New York :
“The Pines”
York Harbor, Maine.
Dear Sir, —I desire to make a complaint, and I bring
it to you, the head of the company, because by experience
I know better than to carry it to a subordinate. •
THE PUBLIC TELEGRAPH SYSTEM 875
I have been here a month and a half, and by testimony
of friends, reinforced by personal experience, I now feci
qualified to claim as an established fact that* the tele-
graphic service here is the worst in the world except that of
Boston. m
These services are actually slower than was the New
York ai^d Hartford service in the days when Hast com-
plained to you — which was fifteen or eighteen years ago,
when telegraphic time and train time between the men-
tioned joints was exactly the same, to-wit, three hours
and a half.
Six days ago — it was that raw day which provoked so
much comment — my daughter was on her way up from
New York, and at noon she telegraphed me from New
Haven asking that I meet her with a cloak at Portsmouth.
Her telegram reached me four hours and a quarter later —
• just 15 minutes too late for me to catch my train and
meet her.
1 judge that the telegram traveled about 200 miles. It
is the best telegraphic work I have seen since I have been
here, and I am mentioning it in this place not as a com-
plaint but as a compliment. I think a compliment ought
always to precede a complaint, where one is possible,
because it softens resentment and insures for the complaint
a courteous and gentle reception.
Still, there is a detail or two connected with this matter
which ought perhaps to be mentioned. And now, having
smoothed the way with the compliment, I will venture
them. The head corpse in the York Harbor office sent
me that telegram altho (1) he knew it would reach me too
late to be of any value ; (2) also, that he tfas going to send
it to me by his boy ; (3) that the boy would not take the
trolley and come the 2 miles in 12 minutes, but would walk ;
(4) that he would be two hours and a quarter on the road ;
(5) and that he would collect 25 cents for transportation,
for a telegram which the h. c. knew to be worthless before
he started it. From these data I infer that the Western
876 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Union owes me 75 cents ; that is to say, t&e amount paid
for combined wire and land transportation — a recoup
provided for in the printed paragraph which heads the
telegraph-blank.
By these humane and phristian stages we now arrive
at the complaint proper. Wc have had a grave case of
illness in the family, and a relative was coming some six
hundred miles to help in the sick-room during the con-
valescing period. It was an anxious time, of course, and I
wrote and asked to be notified as to the hour of the Expected
arrival of this relative in Boston or in York Harbor.
Being afraid of the telegraph — which I think ought not
to be used in times of hurry and emergency — I asked that
the desired message be brought to me by some swift
method of transportation. By the milkman, if he was
coming this way. But there are always people who think
they know more than you do, especially young people;,
so of course the young fellow in charge of this lady used
the telegraph. And at Boston, of all places ! Except
York Harbor.
The result was as usual ; let me employ a statelier and
exacter term, and say, historical.
The dispatch was handed to the h. c. of the Boston
office at 9 this morning. It said, “ Shall bring A. S. to
you eleven forty-five this morning.” The distance traveled
by the dispatch is forty or fifty miles, I suppose, as the
train-time is five minutes short of two hours, and the trains
are so slow that they can’t give a W. U. telegram two
hours and twenty minutes start and overtake it.
As I have said, the dispatch was handed in at Boston at
9. The cxpectdU visitors left Boston at 9.40, and reached
my house at 12 noon, beating the telegram 2 solid hours,
and 5 minutes over.
The boy brought the telegram. It was bald-headed
with age, but still legible. The boy was prostrate with
travel and exposure, but still alive, and I went out to
condole with him and get his last wishes and send or the
THE FUEL STORY
877
ambulance. He was waiting to collect transportation
before turning his passing spirit to less serious affairs.
I found him strangely intelligent, considering his condition
and where he is getting his training. I asked him at what
hour the telegram was handed to the li. c. in Boston. He
answered brightly, that he didn’t know.
I examined the blank, and sure enough the wary Boston
h. c. had thoughtfully concealed that statistic. I asked
him at what hour it had started from Boston. lie answered
up as brightly as ever, and said he didn’t know.
I examined the blank, and sure enough the Boston h. c.
had left that statistic out in the cold, too. In fact it
turned out to be an official concealment — no blank was
provided for its exposure. And none required by the law,
I # supposc. “ It is a good one-sided idea,” I remarked ;
“ They can take your money and ship your telegram next
•year if they want to — you’ve no redress. The law ought
to extend the privilege to all of us.”
The boy looked upon me coldly.
I asked him when the telegram reached York Harbor.
He pointed to some figures following the signature at the
bottom of the blank — “ 12.14.” I said it was now 1.45
and asked —
“ Do you mean that it reached your morgue an hour
and a half ago ? ”
He nodded assent.
“ It was at that time half an hour too late to be of any
use to me, if I wanted to go and meet my people — which
was the case — for by the wording of the message you can
see that they were to arrive at the station at 11.45. Why
did your h. c. send me this useless message ? Can’t he
read ? Is he dead ? ”
“ It’s the rules.”
“No, that does not account for it. Would he have
sent it if it had been three years old, I in the meantime
deceased, and he aware of it ? ”
The'boy didn’t know.
878
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
“Because, you know, a rule which required him to
forward t° the cemetery to-day a dispatch due three
years ago, would be as good a rule as one which should
require him to forward a telegram to me to-day which he
knew had lost all its value an hour or two before he started
it. The construction of such a rule would discredit an
idiot; in "fact an idiot — I mean a common ordinary
Christian idiot, you understand — would be -ashamed of
it, and for the sake of his reputation wouldn’t make it.
What do you think ? ” "
He replied with much natural brilliancy that he wasn’t
paid for thinking.
This gave me a better opinion of the commercial
intelligence pervading his morgue than I had had before ;
it also softened my feelings toward him, and also njy
tone, which had hitherto been tinged with bitterness.
“ Let bygones be bygones,” I said, gently, “ we are all ,
erring creatures, and mainly idiots, but God made us so
and it is dangerous to criticise.”
Sincerely
S. L. Clemens.
Mrs. Clemens’s improvement was scarcely perceptible. It
was not until October that they were able to remove her to
River dale, and then only in a specially arranged" invalid-car.
At the end of the long journey she was carried to her room and
did not leave it again for many months.
To Rev. J. H. Twichell , in Hartford :
Riverdalo, N. Y., Oot. 31, '02.
Dear Joe,— It is ten days since Susy [Twichell] wrote
that you were laid up with a sprained shoulder, since
which time we have had no news about it. I hope that
no news is good news, according to the proverb ; still,
authoritative confirmation of it will be gladly received in
this family, if some of you will furnish it. Moreover, I
should like to know how and where it happened. • In the
“BANGING THE BIBLE ”
379
pulpit, as like ms not, otherwise you would not be taking
so much pains to conceal it. This is not a malicious sug-
gestion, and not a personally-invented one : you told me
yourself, once, that you threw artificial power and im-
pressiveness into places in yaur sermons where needed,
by “ banging the bible ” — (your own words.) You have
reachcc^ a time of life when it is not wise to ‘take these
risks. You »would better jump around. We all have to
change our methods as the infirmities of age creep upon
us. Jifmping around will be impressive now, whereas
before you were gray it would have excited remark.
Poor Livy drags along drearily. It must be hard
times for that turbulent spirit. It will be a long time
before she is on her feet again. It is a most pathetic
Qpse. I wish I could transfer it to myself. Between
ripping and raging and smoking and reading, I could get a
• good deal of a holiday out of it.
Clara runs the house smoothly and capably. She is
discharging a trial-cook to-day and hiring another.
A power of love to you all !
Mark.
Such was the state of Mrs. Clemons’s health that visitors were
excluded from the sick room, and even Clemons himself was
allowed to see her no more than a few moments at a time.
These brief, precious visits were the chief interests of his long
days. Occasionally he was allowed to send her a few lines,
reporting his occupations, and these she was sometimes per-
mitted to answer. Only one of his notes has been preserved,
written after a day, now rare, of literary effort. Its signature,
the letter Y, stands for “ Youth,” always her name for him.
To Mrs. Clemens :
Dear Heart, — I’ve done another full day’s work, and
finished before 4. I have been reading and dozing since —
and would have had a real sleep a few minutes ago but
for an incursion to bring me a couple of unimportant
letters. • I’ve stuck to the bed all day and am getting back
880
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
my lost ground. Next time I will be strictly careful and
make my .visit very short — just a kiss and a rush. Thank
you for your dear, dear note, you who are my own and
only sweetheart.
Sleep well 1
Y.
f
The burden of the Clemens household had falleft' almost
entirely upon Clara Clemens. In addition to supervising its
customary affairs, she also shouldered ihe responsibility of an
unusual combination of misfortunes, for besides th<5 critical
condition of her mother, her sister, Jean Clemens, was down
with pneumonia, no word of which must eome to Mrs. Clemens.
In some account of it, which he set down later, Clemens wrote :
“ It was fortunate for us all that Clara’s reputation for truth-
fulness was so well established in her mother’s mind. It was
our daily protection from disaster. The mother never doubted
Clara’s word. Clara could tell her large improbabilities without
exciting any suspicion, whereas if I tried to market even a
small and simple one the case would have been different. I*
was never able to get a reputation like Clara’s.”
To J. Y. M. MacAlistcr, in London :
Rivertlale, New York.
April, 7, ’03.
Dear MacAlister, — Yours arrived last night, and
God knows I was glad to get it, for I was afraid I had
blundered into an oflencc in some way and forfeited your
friendship — a kind of blunder I have made so many times
in my life that I am always standing in a waiting and
morbid dread of its occurrence.
Three days ago I was in condition — during one horribly
long night — to ‘‘sympathetically roast with you in your
“ hell of troubles.” During that night I was back again
where I was in the black days when I was buried under a
mountain of debt. I called the daughters to me in private
council and paralysed them with the announcement, “ Our
outgo has increased in the past 8 months until our expenses
are now 125 per cent, greater than our income.” •
A NIGHTMARE
8 81
It was a mistake. When I came down m the morning
a gray and aged wreck, and went over the figures again,
I found that in some unaccountable way (unaacountable
to a business man but not to mo) I had multiplied the totals
by 2. By God I dropped 75 years on the floor where I
stood. •
Do you know it affected me as one is affected when he
wakes <fut of a hideous dream and finds that it* was only a
dream. It was a great comfort and satisfaction to me to
call thc # daughters to a private meeting of the Board again
and say, “ Y o't need not worry any more; our outgo is
mdy i thud mon than our meomt ; in a few months your
..'thi i will be >ul ol her Ixd and on her feet again — then
shn’J diop back f or mat and be all right.”
Certainly tin re hstering and awful reality about a
flell-a rranged unn . It is quite withm the possibilities
at two or three ok' that night ot nunc could drive
f*a to suicide. odd reluse to examine the figures ;
„r. .vould rev oh so, and he could go to his death
u vare tli there was notleng serious about them. I
cannot get J ighl out of ' head, iL was so vivid, so
real, o gha. In any othti year of these 88 the relief
would have been simple * pr whore you can cut your cloth
to tit your irrom' You can’t do that when your wife
car> l In mo fro e io '' the next.
Clara spe lann irsc a to .noons ; 1 am allowed
to see Mrs. Clemens 20 j • .tes twice a day and write her
two letters a day provided l put no news in them. No
other person ever sees her except the physician and now
and then a nerve-specialist from New' York. She saw
there was something th matter that looming, but she
got no facts out of me. But that is nothing — she hasn’t
had anything but lies for 8 months. A fact would give her
a relapse.
The doctor and a specialist met in conspiracy five days
ago, and in their belief she will by and by come out of
this as # good as new, substantially. They ordered her to
882
letters of mark twain
Italy for next winter — which seems to indicate that by
autumn she will be able to undertake tfie voyage. So
Clara is writing a Florence friend to take a look round
among the villas for us in the regions near that city. It
seems early to do this, but Joan Bergheim thought it
would be wise. ... °
Mark Twain could never get up much enthusiasm for the
writings of Scott. His praise of Quentin Durward is about the
only approval he ever accorded to the works of the great
romanticist.
To Brander Matthews, in New York :
New York City, May 4, '03.
Dear Brander, — I haven’t been out of my bed for
four weeks, but — well, I have been reading, a good deaS*,
and it occurs to me to ask you to sit down, some time or
other when you have 8 or 9 months to spare, and jot
me down a certain few literary particulars for my help
and elevation. Your time need not be thrown away, for
at your further leisure you can make Columbian lectures
out of the results and do your students a good turn.
1. Arc there in Sir Walter’s novels passages done in
good English — English which is neither slovenly nor
involved ?
2. Are there passages whose English is not poor and
thin and commonplace, but is of a quality above that ?
8. Are there passages which burn with real fire — not
punk, fox-fire, make believe ?
4. Has he heroes and heroines who are not cads and
cadesses ? t
5. Has he personages whose acts and talk correspond
with their characters as described by him ?
6. Has he heroes and heroines whom the reader admires,
admires, and knows why ?
7. Has he funny characters that are funny, and
humorous passages that are humorous ? (
SIR WALTER SCOTT
8 88
8. Does he ever chain the reader’s interest, andfmake
him reluctant to lay the book down ?
9. Are there pages where he ceases from posing, ceases
from admiring the placid flood and flow of his own dilutions,
ceases from being artificial, and is for a time, long or short,
recognizably sincere and in earnest ?
10. Did he know how to write English, and didn’t do
it because he didn’t want to ? *
11. Did Tie use the right word only when he couldn’t
think of another one, or did he run so much to wrong
because he didn’t know the right one when he saw it ?
12. Can you read him ? and keep your respect for him ?
Of course a person could in his day — an era of sentimen-
tality and sloppy romantics — but land ! can a body do it
today ?
• Brander, I lie here dying, slowly dying, under the blight
of Sir Walter. I have read the first volume of Rob Roy,
and as far as chapter XIX of Guy Mannering, and I can
no longer hold my head up nor take any nourishment.
Lord, it’s all so juvenile ! so artificial, so shoddy ; and such
wax figures and skeletons and spectres. Interest ? Why,
it is impossible to feel an interest in these bloodless shams,
these milk-and-water humbugs. And oh, the poverty of
the invention 1 Not poverty in inventing situations, but
poverty in’furnishing reasons for them. Sir Walter usually
gives himself away when he arranges for a situation —
elaborates, and elaborates, and elaborates, till if you live
to get to it you don’t believe in it when it happens.
I can’t find the rest of Rob Roy, I can’t stand any more
Mannering — I do not know just what to do, but I will
reflect, and not quit this great study jashly. He was
great, in his day, and to his proper audience ; and so was
God in Jewish times, for that matter, but why should
either of them rank high now ? And do they ? — honest,
now, do they ? Darn’d if I believe it.
My, I wish I could see you and Leigh Hunt !
Sincerely Yours S. L. Clemens.
384
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To Brander Matthews, in New York :
Rivordale, May 8, ’03 (Mailod June, 1910).
Dear Brander, — I’m still in bed, but the days have
lost their dulness since I broke into Sir Walter and lost
my temper. I finished Quy Manncring — that curious,
curious book, with its mob of squalid shadows jabbering
around a single flcsb-and-blood being — Dinmont ; , a book
crazily put together out of the very refuse of the romance-
artist’s stage properties — finished it and took up Quentin
Durward, and finished that.
It was like leaving the dead to mingle with the living :
it was like withdrawing from the infant class in the College
of Journalism to sit under the lectures in English literature
in Columbia University.
I wonder who wrote Quentin Durward ?
Yrs ever
Mark.
In 1903, preparations were going on for a great world’s fair,
to be held in St. Louis, and among other features proposed was
a World’s Literary Convention, with a week to be set apart in
honour of Mark Twain, and a special Mark Twain Day in it, on
which the National Association would hold grand services in
honour of the distinguished Missourian.
To T. F. Gaits , of Missouri :
New York, May 30, 1903.
Dear Mr. Gatts, — It is indeed a high compliment
which you offer me in naming an association after me and
in proposing thq setting apart of a Mark Twain day at the
great St. Louis fair, but such compliments are not proper
for the living ; they are proper and safe for the dead only.
I value the impulse which moves you to tender me these
honors. I value it as highly as any one can, and am grate-
ful for it, but I should stand in a sort of terror of the honors
themselves. So long as we remain alive we are not safe
mS MODESTY
885
from doing things which, however righteously and honor-
ably intended, can wreck our repute and extinguish our
friendships. *
I hope that no society will be named for me while I
am still alive, for I might at some time or other do some-
thing which would cause its Aiembcrs to regret having
done me that honor. After I shall have joined the dead I
shall follow the customs of those people and be guilty of
no conduct that can wound any friend ; but until that
time sl^ll come I shall be a doubtful quantity like the
rest of our race.
Very truly yours,
S. L. Clemens.
The National Mark Twain Association did not surrender
easily. Mr. Gatts wrote a second letter full of urgent appeal.
If Mark Twain was tempted, we get no hint of it in his answer.
To T. F. Gaits, of Missouri :
New York, June 8, 1903.
Dear Mr. Gatts, — While I am deeply touched by
the desire of my friends of Hannibal to confer these great
honors upon me, I must still forbear to accept them.
Spontaneous and unpremeditated honors, like those which
came to me at Hannibal, Columbia, St. Louis and at the
village stations all down the line, are beyond all price and
are a treasure for life in the memory, for they are a free
gift out of the heart and they come without solicitations ;
but I am a Missourian and so I shrink from distinctions
which have to be arranged beforehand and with my
privity, for I then become a party to my own exalting.
I am humanly fond of honors that happen but chary of
those that come by canvass and intention. With sincere
thanks to you and your associates for this high compliment
which you have been minded to offer me, I am,
Very truly yours,
S. L. Clemens.
2 c
886
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
By the end of June Mrs. Clemens was able to leave River-
dale, and she made the journey to Quarry FaJm, Elmira, The
house in Hartford had been sold ; and a house which, prior to
Mrs. Clemens’s breakdown, Clemens had bought near Tarrytown
(expecting to settle permenently on the Hudson) had been let.
At Quarry Farm Mrs. Clemens continued to improve, and
Clemens, once more able to<- work, occupied the study which
Mrs. Crane had built for him thirty years before, and where
Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn and the Wandering Prince had been
called into being.
To Rev. J. II. Twichell, in Hartford , Conn. , l
Quarry Farm, Elmira, N. Y.,
July 21, ’03.
Deab Joe, — That love-letter delighted Livy beyond
any like utterance received by her these thirty years and
more. I was going to answer it for her right away, ai,d
said so ; but she reserved the privilege to herself. I
judge she is accumulating Hot Stuff — as George Ade*
would say. . . .
Livy is coming along : eats well, sleeps some, is mostly
very gay, not very often depressed ; spends all day on
the porch, sleeps there a part of the night, makes excursions
in carriage and in wheel-chair ; and, in the matter of
superintending everything and everybody, has resumed
business at the old stand.
Did you ever go house-hunting 8,000 miles away ? It
costs three months of writing and telegraphing to pull
off a success. We finished 8 or 4 days ago, and took the
Villa Papiniano (dam the name, I have to look at it 2
minutes after writing it, and then am always in doubt)
for a year by k cable. Three miles outside of Florence,
under Ficsole — a darling location, and apparently a choice
house, near Fiske.
There’s 7 in our gang. All women but me. It means
trunks and things. But thanks be 1 To-day (this is
private) comes a most handsome voluntary document
with ->eals and escutcheons on it from the Italian Am-
KIPLING’S POETRY
387
bkssador (who, is a stranger to me) commanding the
Customs people to keep their hands off the Clemens’s things.
Now wasn’t it lovely of him ? And wasn’t it lovely of me
to let Livy take a pencil and edit my answer and knock a
good third of it out ? #
And that’s a nice ship — the Irene ! new — swift — 18,000
tons — rooms up in the sky, open to sun and air — and all
that. ‘1 wag desperately troubled — for Livy — about the
down-cellar cells in the ancient “ Lalin.”
The. cubs are in Rivcrdale, yet ; they come to us the
first week in August.
With lots and lots of love to you all,
Mark.
Clemens and family left Elmira October the 5th for New
TJork City. They remained at the Hotel Grosvcnor until their
sailing date, October 24th. A few days earlier, Mr. Frank
Doubleday sent a volume of Kipling’s poems,,and de Blowitz’s *
° Memoirs for entertainment on the ship. Mark Twain’s acknow-
ledgment follows.
To F. N. Doubleday, in New York :
The Grosvenor,
October 12, '03.
Dear Doubleday, — The books came — ever so many
thanks. I* have been reading “The Bell Buoy” and
“ The Old Men ” over and over again — my custom with
Kipling’s work — and saving up the rest for other leisurely
and luxurious meals. A bell-buoy is a deeply impressive
fellow-being. In these many recent trips up and down
the Sound in the Kanawha 1 he has talked to me nightly,
sometimes in his pathetic and melancholy way, sometimes
with his strenuous and urgent note, and I got his meaning
— now I have his words ! No one but Kipling could do
this strong and vivid thing. Some day I hope to hear the
poem chanted or sung — with the bell-buoy breaking in,
out of the distance.
1 Mr. Rogett’s yacht.
388
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
“ The Old Men,” delicious, isn’t it ? Apd so comically
true. I haven’t arrived there yet, but I suppose I am on
the way. f . . .
Yours ever,
Mark.
P. S. ,Your letter has arrived. It makes me proud
and glad — what Kipling says. I hope Fate \yill fetch him
to Florence while we are there. I would rather see him
than any other man. .
We’ve let the Tarry town house for a year. Man, you
would never have believed a person could let a house in
these times. That one’s for sale, the Hartford one is sold.
When we buy again may we — may I — be damned.
I’ve dipped into Blowitz and find him quaintly and
curiously interesting. I think he tells the straight truth,
too. I knew him a little, 23 years ago.
The appreciative word which Kipling had sent Double-
day was : “ I love to think of the great and God-like Clemens.
He is the biggest man you have on your side of the water by
a damn sight, and don’t you forget it. Cervantes was a
relation of his.”
Mrs. Clemens stood the voyage to Italy very well and, in
due time, the family were installed in the Villa He ale di Quarto,
the picturesque old Palace of Cosimo, a spacious, luxurious
place, even if not entirely cheerful or always co m fortable during
the changeable Tuscan winter.
To Rev. J. II. Twichell, in Hartford, :
Villa di Quarto,
* Florence, Jan. 7, ’04.
Dear Joe, — . . . I have had a handsome success, in
one way, here. I left New York under a sort of half
promise to furnish to the Harper magazines 80,000 words
this year. Magazining is difficult work because every
third page represents 2 pages that you have put in the
fire ; (because you are nearly sure to start wrong twice)
TUSCAN SCENES
389
and so when yftu have finished an article and are willing
to let it go to print it represents only 10 cen^s a word
instead of 80.
But this time I had the curious (and unprecedented)
luck to start right in each oase. I turned out 87,000
words in 25 working days ; and the reason I think I
started, fight every time is, that not only have I approved
and accepted the several articles, but the court of last
resort (Livy) has done the same.
On fnany of the between-days I did some work, but
only of an idle and not necessarily necessary sort, since
it will not see print until I am dead. I shall continue this
(an hour per day) but the rest of the year I expect to put
in on a couple of long books (half-completed ones.) No
more magazine-work hanging over my head.
This secluded and silent solitude, this clean, soft air and
uthis enchanting view of Florence, the great valley and the
snow-mountains that frame it are the right conditions for
work. They are a persistent inspiration. To-day is very
lovely ; when the afternoon arrives there will be a new
picture every hour till dark, and each of them divine — or
progressing from divine to diviner and divinest. On this
(second) floor Clara’s room .commands the finest ; she
keeps a window ten feet high wide open all the time and
frames it in. I go in from time to time, every day and
trade sass for a look. The central detail is a distant and
stately snow-hump that rises above and behind black-
forested hills, and its sloping vast buttresses, velvety and
sun-polished with purple shadows between, make the
sort of picture we knew that time we walked in Switzer-
land in the days of our youth.
I wish I could show your letter to Livy — but she must
wait a week or so for it. I think 1 told you she had a
prostrating week of tonsilitis a month ago ; she has
remained very feeble ever since, and confined to the bed
of course, but we allow ourselves to believe she will regain
the losf ground in another month. Her physician is
890
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Professor Grocco— she could not have £ better. And
she has a yery good trained nurse.
Love to all of you from all of us. And to all of our
dear Hartford friends.
Mabk.
P. S. 3 days later.
Livy is as remarkable as ever. The day I, wrote you —
that night, I mean — she had a bitter attack of gout or
rheumatism occupying the whole left arm from shoulder
to fingers, accompanied by fever. The pains racked her
50 or 60 horns ; they have departed, now — and already
she is planning a trip to Egypt next fall, and a winter’s
sojourn there ! This is life in her yet.
You will be surprised that I was willing to do so much
magazine-writing — a thing I have always been chary
about — but I had good reasons. Our expenses have been t
so prodigious for a year and a half, and are still so pro-
digious, that Livy was worrying altogether too much about
them, and doing a very dangerous amount of lying awake
on their account. It was necessary to stop that, and it is
now stopped.
Yes, she is remarkable, Joe. Her rheumatic attack set
me to cursing and swearing, without limit a$, to time or
energy, but it merely concentrated her patience and her
unconquerable fortitude. It is the difference between us.
I can’t count the different kinds of ailments which have
assaulted her in this fiendish year and a half — and I forgive
none of them — but here she comes up again as bright and
fresh and enterprising as ever, and goes to planning about
Egypt, with a‘ hope and a confidence which are to me
amazing.
Clara is calling for me — we have to go into town and
pay calls. Mabk.
In Florence, that winter, Clemens began dictating to his
secretary some autobiographical chapters. This was the work
which was “ not to see print until I am dead.” He found it a
AUTOBIOGRAPHY
891
pleasant, lazy occupation and wrote his delight in it to Howells
in a letter which seems not to have survived. In his reply,
Howells wrote : “ You do stir me mightily with the hope of
dictating and I will try it when I get the chance. But there is
the temperamental difference. You are dramatic and uncon-
scious ; you count the thing more than yourself ; I am cursed
with consciousness to the core, anS can’t say myself out ; I am
always saying myself in, and setting myself above all that I say,
as of more worth. Lately I have felt as if [ were dotting with
egotism. I don’t admire myself ; I am sick of myself ; but I
can’t think of anything else. Here I am at it now, when I ought
to be rejoicing with you at the blessing you have found. . . .
I’d like immensely, to read your autobiography. You always
rather bewildered me by your veracity, and I fancy you may tell
the truth about yourself. But all of it ? The black truth which
we all know of ourselves in our hearts, or only the whity-brown
truth of the pericardium, or the nice, whitened truth of the shirt-
front ? Even you won’t tell the black heart’s-truth. The man
Mifao could do it would be famed to the last day the sun shone
upon.”
We gather from Mark Twain’s answer that he was not
deceiving himself in the matter of his confessions.
To W. D. Howells, in New York :
Villa di Quarto, Florence,
March 14, ’04.
Dear Howells, — Yes, I set up the safeguards, in the
first day’s dictating ; — taking' this position : that an auto-
biography is the truest of all books ; for while it inevitably
consists mainly of extinctions of the truth, shirkings of the
truth, partial revealments of the truth, with hardly an
instance of plain straight truth, the remorseless truth is
there, between the lines, where the author is raking dust
upon it, the result being that the reader knows the author
in spite of his wily diligences. •
The summer in England ! you can’t ask better luck than
that. Then you will run over to Florence ; we shall all
be hungry to see you all. We are hunting for another
villa, (this one is plenty large enough but has no room in
it) but even if we find it I am afraid it will be months
before .we can move Mrs. Clemens. Of course it will.
392
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
But it comforts us to let on that we think otherwise, and
these pretensions help to keep hope alive in her.
Good-bye, with love, Amen,
Yours ever
Mark.
The year of the World’s Fair had come, and an invitation
from Gov. Francis, of Missouri, came to Mark Twain in Elorencc,
personally inviting him to attend the great celebration and
carry off first prize.
To Gov. Francis, of Missouri ;
Villa di Quarto, Firenze,
May 26, 1904.
Dear Governor Francis, — It has been a dear wish of
mine to exhibit myself at the Great Fair and get a prize,
but circumstances beyond my control have interfered,
and I must remain in Florence. Although I have never
taken prizes anywhere else I used to take them at school
in Missouri half a century ago, and I ought to be able to
repeat, now, if I could have a chance. I used to get the
medal for good spelling, every week, and I could have had
the medal for good conduct if there hadn’t been so much
corruption in Missouri in those days ; still, I got it several
times by trading medals and giving boot. I am willing
to give boot now, if — however, those days are forever
gone by in Missouri, and perhaps it is better so. Nothing
ever stops the way it was in this changeable world.
Although I cannot be at the Fair, I am going to be repre-
sented there anyway, by a portrait, by Professor Gelli.
You will find St excellent. Good judges here say it is
better than the original. They say it has all the merits
of the original and keeps still, besides. It sounds like
flattery, but it is just true.
I suppose you will get a prize, because you have created
the most prodigious and in all ways most wonderful Fair
the planet has ever seen. Very well, you have* indeed
DEATH OF MRS. CLEMENS
893
earned it : andl with it the gratitude of the State and the
nation. Sincerely yours,
Mark Twain.
It was only a few days after the foregoing was written that
death entered Villa Quarto — unexpectedly at last — for with the
first June days Mrs. Clemens had seemed really to improve. It
was on £ unday, June 5 th, that the end came. Clemens, with
his daughter^ Jean, had returned from a long drive, during
which they had visited a Villa with the thought of purchase.
On their return they were told that their patient had been
better that afternoon than for three months. Yet is was only
a few hours later that she left them, so suddenly and quietly
that even those near her did not at first realize that she was
gone.
To fV. D. Howells, in New York.
Villa di Quarto, Florence,
Juno 6, '04.
Dear Howells, — Last night at 9.20 I entered Mrs.
Clemens’s room to say the usual goodnight — and she
was dead — tho’ no one knew it. She had been cheerfully
talking, a moment before. She was sitting up in bed —
she had not lain down for months — and Katie and the
nurse weye supporting her. They supposed she had
fainted, and they were holding the oxygen pipe to her
mouth, expecting to revive her. I bent over her and
looked in her face, and I think I spoke — I was surprised
and troubled that she did not notice me. Then we under-
stood, and our hearts broke. How poor we arc to-day !
But how thankful 1 am that her persecutions are
ended. I would not call her back if 1 coi*ld.
To-day, treasured in her worn old Testament, I found
a dear and gentle letter from you, dated Far Rockaway,
Sept. 13, 1896, about our poor Susy’s death. I am tired
and old ; I wish I were with Livy.
I send my love — and hers — to you all.
S. L. C.
894
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
The Clemens family arrived in America in,, July, and were
accompanied by Twichell to Elmira, and on the 14th Mrs.
Clemens was laid to rest by the side of Susy and little Langdon.
R. W. Gilder had arranged for them to occupy, for the summer,
a cottage on his place at Tyringham, in the Berkshire Hills.
By November they were at the Grosvenor, in New York,
preparing to establish theniselves in a house which they
had taken on the corner of Ninth Street and Fifth Avenue —
Number 21..
To F. N. Doubleday,, in New York :
Dear Dottbleday, — I did not know you were going
to England : I would have freighted you with such messages
of homage and affection to Kipling. And I would have
pressed his hand, through you, for his sympathy with me
in my crushing loss, as expressed by him in his letter to
Gilder. You know my feeling for Kipling and that it
antedates that expression.
I was glad that the boys came here to invite me to
the house-warming and I think they understood why a
man in the shadow of a calamity like mine could
not go.
It has taken three months to repair and renovate
our house — corner of 9th and 5th Avenue, but I shall be
in it in 10 or 15 days hence. Much of the furniture went
into it today (from Hartford). We have not seen it for
13 years. Katy Leary, our old housekeeper, who has
been in our service more than 24 years, cried when she
told me about it to-day. She said “ I had forgotten it was
so beautiful, and it brought Mrs. Clemens right back to
me — in that old iime when she was so young and lovely.”
Jean and my secretary and the servants whom we
brought from Italy because Mrs. Clemens liked them
so well, are still keeping house in the Berkshire hills — and
waiting. Clara (nervously wrecked by her mother's
death) is in the hands of a specialist in 69th St., and I
shall not be allowed to have any communication with
PARTY POLITICS
395
her — even telephone — for a year. I am in this com-
fortable little hotel, and still in bed — for I dasn’t budge
till I’m safe from my pet devil, bronchitis. *
Isn’t it pathetic ? One hour and ten minutes before
Mrs. Clemens died I was saying to her “ To-day, after
five months search, I’ve found the villa that will con-
tent you: to-morrow you will examine the m plans and
give it your jeonsent and I will buy it.” Iler eyes danced
with pleasure, for she longed for a home of her own. And
there, on that morrow, she lay white and cold. And un-
responsive to my reverent caresses — a new thing to me
and a new thing to her; that had not happened before
in five and thirty years.
I am coming to see you and Mrs. Doubleday by and
bye. She loved and honored Mrs. Doubleday and her
work. ' Always yours, Mark.
It was a presidential year and the air was thick with politics.
Mark Twain was no longer actively interested in the political
situation ; he was only disheartened by the hollowness and
pretence of ollice-seeking, and the methods of office-seekers in
general. Grieved that Twicliell should still pin his faith to any
party when all parties were so obviously venal and time-serving,
he wrote in outspoken and rather sombre protest.
• To Rev. J. II. Twicliell, in Hartford :
The Groavenor, Nov. 4, ’04.
Oh, dear ! get out of that sewer — party politics — dear
Joe. At least with your mouth. We had only two men
who could make speeches for their parties and preserve
their honor and their dignity. One of them is dead. Pos-
sibly there were four. I am sorry for John Hay ; sorry
and ashamed. And yet I know he couldn’t help it. He
wears the collar, and he had to pay the penalty. Cer-
tainly he had no more desire to stand up before a mob
of confiding human incapables and debauch them than
you had. Certainly he took no more real pleasure in dis-
torting history, concealing facts, propagating immoralities,
896
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
and appealing to the sordid side of Jiuman nature
than did you ; but he was his party’s property, and he
had to climb away down and do it.
It is interesting, wonderfully interesting — the miracles
which party-politics can do with a man’s mental and
moral make-up. Look at McKinley, Roosevelt, and
yourself : jn private life spotless in character ; honorable,
honest, just, humane, generous ; scorning trickeiies,
treacheries, suppressions of the truth, mistranslations of
the meanings of facts, the filching of credit earned by
another, the condoning of crime, the glorifying of base
acts : in public political life the reverse of all this. . . .
By George, Joe, you are as handy at the game as if you
had been in training for it all your life. Your campaign
Address is built from the ground up upon the oldest and
best models. There isn’t a paragraph in it whose facts or
morals will wash — not even a sentence, I believe.
But you will soon be out of this. You didn’t want to
do it — that is sufficiently apparent, thanks be 1 — but you
couldn’t well get out of it. In a few days you will be out
of it, and then you can fumigate yourself and take up
your legitimate work again and resume your clean and
wholesome private character once more and be happy —
and useful.
I know I ought to hand you some guff, now, as propitia-
tion and apology for these reproaches, but on the whole
I believe I won’t.
I have inquired, and find that Mitsikuri does not
arrive here until to-morrow night. 1 shall watch out, and
telephone again, for I greatly want to see him.
Always Yours,
Mark.
To Rev. J. II. Twichell, in Hartford :
Feb. 16, 'OS.
Beak Joe, — I knew I had in me somewhere a definite
feeling about the President if I could only find the words
ROOSEVELT
897
to define it witfc. Here they are, to a hair — from Leonard
Jerome : “ For twenty years I have loved Roosevelt the
man and hated Roosevelt the statesman and politician.”
It’s mighty good. Every time, in 25 years, that I have
met Roosevelt the man, a wave of welcome has streaked
through me with the hand-grip ; but whenever (as a rule)
I meet Roosevelt the statesman and politician,. I find him
destitute of .morals and not respectworthy. It is plain
that where his political self and his party self are con-
cerned Jie has nothing resembling a conscience ; that
under those inspirations he is naively indifferent to the
restraints of duty and even unaware of them ; ready to
kick the Constitution into the back yard whenever it
gets in the way ; and whenever he smells a vote, not only
filling but eager to buy it, give extravagant rates for
it and pay the bill — not out of his own pocket or the
m party’s, but out of the nation’s, by cold pillage. As
per Order 78 and the appropriation of the Indian trust
funds.
But Roosevelt is excusable — I recognize it and (ought
to) concede it. We are all insane, each in his own way,
and with insanity goes irresponsibility. Theodore the man
is sane ; in fairness we ought to keep in mind that Theodore,
as statesman and politician, is insane and irresponsible.
Do not throw these enlightenments aside, but study
them, let them raise you to higher planes and make you
better. You taught me in my callow days, let me pay
back the debt now in my old age out of a thesaurus with
wisdom smelted from the golden ores of experience.
Ever vours for sweetness and light.
Mark.
To Rev. J. H. Twichell, in Hartford, :
March 14, ’06.
Dear Joe,— I have a Puddn’head maxim :
“ When a m an is a pessimist before 48 he knows
898 LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
too much ; if he is an optimist after it* he knows too
little.”
It is with contentment, therefore, that I reflect that I
am better and wiser than you. Joe, you seem to be deal-
ing in 14 bulks,” now ; the 44 bulk ” of the farmers and U. S.
Senators are 44 honest.” As regards purchase and sale
with money ? Who doubts it ? Is that the only measure
of honesty ? Aren’t there a dozen kinds of bpnesty which
can’t be measured by the money-standard ? Treason is
treason — and there’s more than one form of «it ; the
money-form is but one of them. When a person is dis-
loyal to any confessed duty, he is plainly and simply
dishonest, and knows it ; knows it, and is privately
troubled about it and not proud of himself. Judged by
this standard — and who will challenge the validity of
it ? — there isn’t an honest man in Connecticut, nor in
the Senate, nor anywhere else. I do not even except
myself, this time. 4
Am I finding fault with you and the rest of the populace ?
No — I assure you I am not. For I know the human
race’s limitations, and this makes it my duty — my pleasant
duty — to be fair to it. Each person in it is honest in one
or several ways, but no member of it is honest in all the
ways required by — by what ? By his own standard . Out-
side of that, as I look at it, there is no obligation
upon him.
Am I honest ? I give you my word of honor (private) I
am not. For seven years I have suppressed a book which
my conscience tells me I ought to publish. I hold it a
duty to publish it. There are other difficult duties which
I am equal to, but I am not equal to that one. Yes, even
I am dishonest. Not in many ways, but in some. Forty-
one, l think it is. We are certainly all honest in one or
several ways — every man in the world — though I have
reason to think I am the only one whose black-list runs
so light. Sometimes I feel lonely enough in this lofty
solitude.
PROGRESS
399
Yes, oh, yes 4 1 am not overlooking the “ steady progress
from age to age of the coming of the kingdom of God
and righteousness.” “ From age to age ” — yes, if describes
that giddy gait. I (and the rocks) will not live to see it
arrive, but that is all right — it will arrive, it surely will.
But you ought not to be always ironically apologizing for
the Deity. If that thing is going to arrive, it js inferable
that He* wants it to arrive ; and so it is not quite kind of
you, and it hurts me, to see you flinging sarcasms at the
gait of it. And yet it would not be fair in me not to
admit that the sarcasms are deserved. When the Deity
wants a thing, and after working at it for “ ages and ages ”
can’t show even a shade of progress toward its accom-
plishment, we — well, we don’t laugh, but it is only be-
cause we dasn’t. The source of “ righteousness ” — is in
the heart ? Yes. And engineered and directed by the
brain ? Yes. Well, history and tradition testify that the
•heart is just about what it was in the beginning ; it has
undergone no shade of change. Its good and evil im-
pulses and their consequences are the same to-day that
they were in Old Bible times, in Egyptian times, in Greek
times, in Middle Age times, in Twentieth Century times.
There has been no change.
Meantime, the brain has undergone no change. It is
what it always was. There are a few good brains and a
multitude of poor ones. It was so in Old Bible times and
in all other times — Greek, Roman, Middle Ages and
Twentieth Century. Among the savages — all the savages
— the average brain is as competent as the average brain
here or elsewhere. I will prove it to you, some time, if
you like. And there are great brains among them, too.
I will prove that also, if you like.
Well, the I9th century made progress — the first pro-
gress after “ ages and ages ” — colossal progress. In what ?
Materialities. Prodigious acquisitions were made in
things which add to the comfort of many and make
life harder for as many more. But the addition to
400
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
righteousness ? Is that discoverable. I |hink not. The
materialities were not invented in the interest of right-
eousness; that there is more righteousness in the world
because of them than there was before, is hardly demon-
strable, I think. In Europe and America there is a
vast change (due to them) in ideals — do you admire it ?
All Europe and all America are feverishly scrambling for
money. Money is the supreme ideal — all others take
tenth place with the great bulk of the nations named.
Money-lust has always existed, but not in the (> history
of the world was it ever a craze, a madness, until your
time and mine. This lust has rotted these nations ; it
has made them hard, sordid, ungentle, dishonest, oppres-
sive.
Did England rise against the infamy of the Boer war ?
No — rose in favor of it. Did America rise against the
infamy of the Philippine war ? No — rose in favor of it.
Did Russia rise against the infamy of the present war ?'
No — sat still and said nothing. Has the Kingdom of God
advanced in Russia since the beginning of time ?
Or in Europe and America, considering the vast back-
ward step of the money-lust ? Or anywhere else ? If there
has been any progress toward righteousness since the
early days of Creation — which, in my ineradicable
honesty, I am obliged to doubt — I think we must confine
it to ten per cent of the - populations of Christendom,
(but leaving Russia, Spain and South America entirely
out.) This gives us 820,000,000 to draw the ten per cent
from. That is to say, 82,000,000 have advanced toward
righteousness and the Kingdom of God since the “ ages and
ages ” have been flying along, the Deity sitting up there
admiring. Well, you see it leaves 1,200,000,000 out of the
race. They stand just where they have always stood ;
there has been no change.
N.B. No charge for these informations. Do come down
soon, Joe. With love,
Mabk.
AMERICAN RAILWAYS
401
To St. Glair McKelway , in Brooklyn :
21 Fifth Ave. Sunday Morning.
April 30, 1905.
Dear McKelway, — Your innumerable friends are
' grateful, most grateful.
As I understand the telegrams, the engineer of your
train had never seen a locomotive before. Very »well, then,
I am onde m<jre glad that there is an Evcr-watchful Provi-
dence to foresee possible results and send Ogdens and
McIntyres along to save our friends.
The Government’s Official report, showing that our
railways killed twelve hundred persons last year and
injured sixty thousand convinces me that under present
conditions one Providence is not enough to properly and
efficiently take care of our railroad business. But it is
characteristically American — always trying to get along
short-handed and save wages.
# I am helping your family congratulate themselves, and
am your friend as always.
S. L. Clemens.
Clemens did not spend any more summers at Quarry Farm.
All its associations were beautiful and tender, but they could
only sadden him. The life there had been as of another world,
sunlit, idyllic, now forever vanished. For the summer of 1905
he leased the Copley Green house at Dublin, New Hampshire,
where there was a Boston colony of writing and artistic folk,
including many of his loug-time friends.
Clemens found that the air of the New Hampshire hills agreed
with him and stimulated him to work. He began an entirely
new version of The Mysterious Stranger , of which he already had
a bulky and nearly finished manuscript, written in Vienna. He
wrote several hundred pages of an extravaganza entitled, Three
Thousand Years Among the Microbes , and then? having got his
superabundant vitality reduced (it was likely to expend itself
in these weird mental exploits), he settled down one day and
wrote that really tender and beautiful idyl, Eve's Diary 9 which
he had begun, or at least planned, the previous summer at
Tyringham. In a letter to Mr. Frederick A. Duneka, general
manager of Harper & Brothers, he tells something of the manner
of the story ; also his revised opinion of Adam's Diary , written
# 2 D
403
LETTERS 01 MARK TWAIN
in ’98, and originally published as a souvenir of Niagara
Falls. <'
4
To Frederick A. Duneka, in New York :
Dublin, July 16, ’06.
Dear Mr. Duneka, — -j£ wrote Eve’s Diary, she using
Adam’s D,iary as her (unwitting and unconscious) text, of
course, since to use any other text would ha ve 1 ' been an
imbecility — then I took Adam’s Diary and read it. It
turned my stomach. It was not literature ; y$t it had
been literature once — before I sold it to be degraded to an
advertisement of the Buffalo Fair. 1 was going to write
and ask you to melt the plates and put it out of print.
But this morning I examined it without temper, and
saw that if I abolished the advertisement it would be
literature again. *
So I have done it. I have struck out 700 words and
inserted 5 MS pages of new matter (650 words), and novJ
Adam’s Diary is dam good — sixty times as good as it ever
was before.
I believe it is as good as Eve’s Diary now — no, it’s not
quite that good, I guess, but it is good enough to go in
the same cover with Eve’s. I’m sure of that.
I hate to have the old Adam go out any more — don't put
it on the presses again, let’s put the new one in place of it ;
and next Xmas, let us bind Adam and Eve in one cover.
They score points against each other — so, if not bound
together, some of the points would not be perceived. . . .
P. S. Please send another Adam’s Diary, so that I can
make 2 revised copies. Eve’s Diary is Eve’s Love-Story,
but we will not name it that. Yrs ever, Mark.
To Frederick A. Duneka , in New York :
Oct. 3, '05.
Dear Mr. Duneka, — I have just finished a short story
which I “ greatly admire,” and so will you — “ A Horse’s
STORY-WRITING
403
Tale ”* — about 45,000 words, at a rough guess. It has
good fun in it, and several characters, and is lively. I
shall finish revising it in a few days or more, then Jean
will type it.
Don’t you think you can ge$ it into the Jan. and Feb.
numbers and issue it as a dollar booklet just after the
middle of Jan. when you issue the Feb. number ?
It ought to be ably illustrated.
Why not sell simultaneous rights, for this once, to the
Ladies’ Home Journal or Collier’s, or both, and recoup
yourself ? — for I would like to get it to classes that can’t
afford Harper’s. Although it doesn’t preach, there’s a
sermon concealed in it.
Yr sincerely,
Makk.
Five days later he added some rather interesting facts con-
®ceming the new story.
To F. A. Duneka, in New York :
Oot. 7, 1906.
Dear Mr. Duneka, — . . . . I’ve made a poor guess as
to number jaf words. I think there must be 20,000. My
usual page of MS. contains about 1 30 words ; but when I
am deeply interested in my work and dead to everything
else, my hand-writing shrinks and shrinks until there’s a
great deal more than 130 on a page, — oh yes, a deal more.
Well, I discover, this morning, that this tale is written in
that small hand.
This strong interest is natural, for the* heroine is my
daughter, Susy, whom we lost. It was not intentional — it
was a good while before I found it out.
So I am sending you her picture to use — and to repro-
duce with photographic exactness the unsurpassable
expression and all. May you find an artist who has lost
an idol L
404 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Take as good care of the picture as you can and restore
it to me when I come.
I hope you will illustrate this talc considerably. Not
humorous pictures. No. When they are good (or bad)
one’s humor gets no chance to play surprises on the
reader. A humorous subject illustrated seriously is all
right, but »a humorous artist is no fit person for such work.
You see, the humorous writer pretends to absolute serious-
ness (when he knows his trade) then for an artist to step
in and give his calculated gravity all away withr a funny
picture — oh, my land ! It gives me the dry gripes just to
think of it. It would be just about up to the average
comic artist’s intellectual level to make a funny picture
of the horse kicking the lungs out of a trader. Hang it,
the remark is funny — because the horse is not aware of
it — but the fact is not humorous, it is tragic and it is no
subject for a humorous picture. (
Could I be allowed to sit in judgment upon the pictures
before they are accepted — at least those in which Cathy
may figure ?
This is not essential. It is but a suggestion, and it is
hereby withdrawn, if it would be troublesome or cause
delay.
I hope you will reproduce the cat-pile, full page.
And save the photo for me in as good condition as pos-
sible. When Susy and Clara were little tots those cats had
their profoundest worship, and there is no duplicate of
this picture. These cats all had thundering names, or
inappropriate ones — furnished by the children with my
help. One was named Buffalo Bill.
Are you interested in coincidences ?
After discovering, about the middle of the book, that
Cathy was Susy Clemens, I put her picture with my MS.,
to be reproduced. After the book was finished it was
discovered that Susy had a dim model of Soldier Boy in
her arms ; I had forgotten all about that toy.
Then I examined the cat-picture and laid it Jwith the
SUMMER HAUNTS
405
MS. for introduction ; but it was not until yesterday
that I remembered that one of the cats was named Buffalo
Bill.
Sincerely yours,
Mark.
There was always a run of reporters at Mark Twain’s New
York home. When it was learned that lie was to* spend the
summer in Nfw Hampshire, the reporters had all wanted to
find out about it. As they frequently applied to his publishers
for these* details it was finally suggested to him that he write
a letter furnishing the required information.
Mem. for Mr. Duneka :
Dublin, Oct. 9, 1900.
... As to the other matters, here are the details.
J Yes, I have tried a number of summer homes, here and
in Europe together.
Each of these homes had charms of its own ; charms and
delights of its own, and some of them — even in Europe —
had comforts. Several of them had conveniences, too.
They all had a “ view.”
It is my conviction that there should always be some
water in a. view — a lake or a river, but not the ocean,
if you are down on its level. 1 think that when you are
down on its level it seldom inflames you with an ecstasy
which you could not get out of a sand-flat. It is like
being on board ship, over again ; indeed it is worse than
that, for there’s three months of it. On board ship one
tires of the aspects in a couple of days, and quits looking.
The same vast circle of heaving humps is? spread around
you all the time, with you in the centre of it and never
gaining an inch on the horizon, so far as you can see ;
for variety, a flight of flying-fish, mornings ; a flock of
porpoises throwing summersaults afternoons ; a remote
whale spouting, Sundays ; occasional phosphorescent
effects* nights ; every other day a streak of black smoke
406 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
trailing along under the horizon ; on the* one single red
letter day, the illustrious iceberg. I have seen that ice-
berg thirty-four times in thirty-seven voyages ; it is
always the same shape, it is always the same size, it
always throws up the sam§ old flash when the sun strikes '
it ; you may set it on any New York door-step of a June
morning and light it up with a mirror-flash ; and I will
engage to recognize it. It is artificial, and it is provided
and anchored out by the steamer companies. I used to
like the sea, but I was young then, and could easily get
excited over any kind of monotony, and keep it up till
the monotonies ran out, if it was a fortnight.
Last January, when we were beginning to inquire about
a home for this summer, I remembered that Abbott
Thayer had said, three years before, that the New Hamp-
shire Highlands was a good place. He was right — it was
a good place. Any place that is good for an artist in,
paint is good for an artist in morals and ink. Brush is
here, too ; so is Col. T. W. Iligginson ; so is Raphael
Pumpelly ; so is Mr. Secretary Hitchcock ; so is Hender-
son ; so is Learned ; so is Sumner ; so is Franklin Mac-
Veigh ; so is Joseph L. Smith ; so is Henry Copley Greene,
when I am not occupying his house, which I am doing
this season. Paint, literature, science, statesmanship,
history, professorship, law, morals, — these are all repre-
sented here, yet crime is substantially unknown.
The summer homes of these refugees are sprinkled, a
ihile apart, among the forest-clad hills, with access to
each other by firm smooth country roads which are so
embowered in dense foliage that it is always twilight in
there, and conffortable. The forests are spider-webbed
with these good roads, they go cveiywhere ; but for the
help of the guide-boards, the stranger would not arrive
anywhere.
The village — Dublin — is bunched together in its own
place, but a good telephone service makes its markets
handy to all those outliars. I have spelt it that way to
THE NEW HAMPSHIRE HIGHLANDS 407
be witty. The village executes orders on the Boston
plan — promptness and courtesy.
The summer homes are high-perched, as a ‘rule, and
have contenting outlooks. The house we occupy has
one. Monadnock, a soaring double hump, rises into the
sky at its left elbow — that is to say, it is close at hand.
Prom the base of the long slant of the mountain' the
valley spreads away to the circling frame of the hills,
and beyond the frame the billowy sweep of remote great
ranges rises to view and flows, fold upon fold, wave upon
wave, soft and blue and unworldly, to the horizon fifty
miles away. In these October days Monadnock and the
valley and its framing hills make an inspiring picture to
look at, for they are sumptuously splashed and mottled
find be-torched from sky-line to sky-line with the richest
dyes the autumn can furnish ; and when they lie flaming
in the full drench of the mid-afternoon sun, the sight
affects the spectator physically, it stirs his blood like
military music.
These summer homes are commodious, well built, —
and well furnished — facts which sufficiently indicate that
the owners built them to live in themselves. They have
furnaces and wood fireplaces, and the rest of the com-
forts and.convcniences of a city home, and can be com-
fortably occupied all the year round.
We cannot have this house next season, but I have
secured Mrs. Upton’s house which is over in the law and
science quarter, two or three miles from here, and aboftt
the same distance from the art, literary, and scholastic
groups. The science and law quarter has needed improving,
this good while. *
The nearest railway-station is distant something like
an hour’s drive ; it is three hours from there to Boston,
over a branch line. You can go to New York in six hours
per branch lines if you change cars every time you think
of it, but it is better to go to Boston and stop over and
take the trunk line next day, then you do not get lost.
408 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
It is claimed that the atmosphere of the New Hemp*
shire highlands is exceptionally bracing and stimulating,
and a fine aid to hard and continuous work. It is a just
claim, I think. I came in May, and wrought 85 successive
days without a break. It is possible that I could not have
done it elsewhere. I do not know ; I have not had any
disposition Jx> try it, before. I think I got the disposition
out of the atmosphere, this time. I feel quite sure, in
fact, that that is where it came from.
I am ashamed to confess what an intolerable «pilc of
manuscript I ground out in the 35 days, therefore I will
keep the number of words to myself. I wrote the first
half of a long tale — “ The Adventures of a Microbe
and put it away for a finish next summer, and started
another long tale — “ The Mysterious Stranger ; ” I wrotq
the first half of it and put it with the other for a finish
next summer. I stopped, then. I was not tired, but I had
no books on hand that needed finishing this year except
one that was seven years old. After a little I took that
one up and finished it. Not for publication, but to have
it ready for revision next summer.
Since I stopped work I have had a two months’ holi-
day. The summer has been my working time for 85
years ; to have a holiday in it (in America) is new for me.
I have not broken it, except to write “ Eve’s Diary ” and
“A Horse’s Tale” — short things occupying the mill 12
days.
# This year our summer is C months long and ends
with November and the flight home to New York, but
next year we hope and expect to stretch it another month
and end it the first of December.
[No signature.]
The fact that he was a persistent smoker was widely known,
and many friends and admirers of Mark Twain sent him cigars,
most of which he could not use, because they were too good.
He did ipt care for Havana cigars, but smoked the fragrant,
inexpensive domestic tobacco with plenty of “ pep ” in itf>as we
CIGARS
409
say to-day. Now and then he had an opportunity to head off
some liberal friend, who wrote asking permission to contribute
to his cigar collection, as instance the following.
To Rev. L. M. Powers , in Haverhill, Mass. :
Not. 9, 190&.
Dej?r Mr. Powers, — I should accept your hospitable
offer at once but for the fact I couldn’t do it and remain
honest.. That is to say if I allowed you to send me what
you believe to be good cigars it would distinctly mean that
I meant to smoke them, whereas 1 should do nothing of
the kind. I know a good cigar better than you do, for I
have had 60 years experience.
No, that is not what I mean ; I mean I know a bad
liigar better than anybody else ; I judge by the price
only ; if it costs above 5 cents I know it to be either
foreign or half-foreign, and unsmokeable. By me. I
have many boxes of Havana cigars, of all prices from 20
cts apiece up to 1.66 apiece ; I bought none of them, they
were all presents, they are an accumulation of several
years. I have never smoked one of them and never shall,
I work them off on the visitor. You shall have a chance
when you^come.
Pessimists are born not made ; optimists are bom not
made; but no man is bom either pessimist wholly or
optimist wholly, perhaps ; he is pessimistic along certain
lines and optimistic along certain others. That is my
case. Sincerely yours,
S. L. Clemens.
In spite of all the fine photographs that were made of him,
there recurred constantly among those sent him to be auto-
graphed a print of one which, years before, Sarony had made
and placed on public sale. It was a good photograph, mechani-
cally and even artistically, but it did not please Mark Twain.
Whenever he saw it he recalled Sarony with bitterness and
severity. Once he received an inquiry concerning it, and thus
feelingly^expresscd himself.
410
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
To Mr. Row (no address) :
21 Fifth Avenue, New York,
November 14, 1905.
Dear Mr. Row, — That alleged portrait has a private
history. Sarony was as much of an enthusiast about wild
animals as ,he was about photography ; and when Du
Chaillu brought the first Gorilla to this country in 1819
he came to me in a fever of excitement and asked me if
my father was of record and authentic. I said he was ;
then Sarony, without any abatement of his excitement
asked if my grandfather also was of record and authentic.
I said he was. Then Sarony, with still rising excitement
and with joy added to it, said he had found my great
grandfather in the person of the gorilla and had recog-
nized him at once by his resemblance to me. I was deeply
hurt but did not reveal this, because I knew Sarony
meant no offense, for the gorilla had not done him any
harm, and he was not a man who would say an unkind
thing about a gorilla wantonly. I went with him to
inspect the ancestor, and examined him from several
points of view, without being able to detect anything
more than a passing resemblance. “ Wait,” said Sarony
with strong confidence, “ let me show you.” Hq, borrowed
my overcoat and put it on the gorilla. The result was
surprising. I saw that the gorilla while not looking
distinctly like me was exactly what my great grand-
father would have looked like if I had had one. Sarony
photographed the creature in that overcoat, and spread
the picture about the world. It has remained spread
about the world ever since. It turns up every week in
some newspaper somewhere or other. It .is not my
favorite, but to my exasperation it is everybody else’s.
Do you think you could get it suppressed for me ? I will
pay the limit.
Sincerely yours,
S. L. Clemens.
SCOTCH WHISKY
411
Though he used very little liquor of any kind, it was Mark
Twain’s custom to keep a bottle of Scotch whisky with his
collection of pipes and cigars and tobacco on a little table by his
bed-side. During restless nights he found a small quantity of it
conducive to sleep. Andrew Carnegie, learning of this custom,
made it his business to supply Scotch of his own special importa-
tion. The first ease came direct from Scotland. When it arrived
Clemens sent this characteristic acknowledgment. B
To Andrew Carnegie, in Scotland :
21 fifth Avc. Feb. 10, '06.
Dear St. Andrew, — The whisky arrived in due course
from over the water ; last week one bottle of it was ex-
tracted from the wood and inserted into me, on the instal-
ment plan, with this result : that 1 believe it to be the
^best, smoothest whisky now on the planet. Thanks, oh,
thanks : I have discarded Peruna.
' Hoping that you three are well and happy and will be
coming back before the winter sets in.
I am,
Sincerely yours, Mare.
There came another summer at Dublin, New Hampshire,
this time in the fine Upton residence on the other slope of
Monadnock, a place of equally beautiful surroundings, and an
even more extended view. Clemens was at this time working
steadily on his so-called Autobiography, which was not that, in
fact, but a series of remarkable chapte rs, reminiscent, reflective,
commentative, written without any particular sequence as to
time or subject-matter. He dictated these chapters to a steno-
grapher, usually in the open air, sitting in a comfortable rocker
or pacing up and down the long veranda that faced a vast
expanse of wooded slope and lake and distant blue mountains.
It became one of the happiest occupations o f his later years.
To W. D. Howells , in Maine :
Dublin, Sunday, June 17, '06.
Dear Howells, — . . . The dictating goes lazily and
pleasantly on. With intervals. I find that I have been
412
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
at it, off and on, nearly two hours a day*for 155 days,
since Jan. 9. To be exact I’ve dictated 75 hours in 80 days
and loafed 75 days. I’ve added 60,000 words in the month
that I’ve been here ; which indicates that I’ve dictated
during 20 days of that timq — 40 hours, at an average of
1,50Q words an hour. It’s a plenty, and I am satisfied.
There’s a<good deal of “ fat ” I’ve dictated, (from ^Tan. 9)
210,000 words, and the “ fat ” adds about 50,000 more.
The “ fat ” is old pigeon-holed things, of the years
gone by, which I or editors didn’t dasn’t to print* For
instance, I am dumping in the little old book which I
read to you in Hartford about 80 years ago and which
you said “ publish — and ask Dean Stanley to furnish an
introduction; he’ll do it.” (“ Captain Stormfield’s Visit to
Heaven.”) It reads quite to suit me, without altering a,
word, now that it isn’t to see print until I am dead.
To-morrow I mean to dictate a chapter which will get
my heirs and assigns burnt alive if they venture to print
it this side of 2006 A.D. — which I judge they won’t.
There’ll be lots of such chapters if I live 3 or 4 years longer.
The edition of A.D. 2006 will make a stir when it comes
out. I shall be hovering around taking notice, along with
other dead pals. You are invited. Mabk.
Henry Mills Alden, for nearly forty years editor of Harper's
Magazine, arrived at his seventieth birthday on November lllh
that year, and Harper & Brothers had arranged to give him a
great dinner in the offices of Franklin Square, where, for half a
century, he had been an active force. Mark Twain, threatened
with a cold, and knowing the dinner would be strenuous, did not
feel able to attend, so wrote a letter which, if found suitable,
could be read at the gathering.
To Mr. Henry Alden :
Alden, — dear and ancient friend — it is a solemn
moment. You have now reached the age of discretion.
You have been a long time arriving. Many years ago
you docked me on an article because the subject was
HENRY ALDEN
418
too old ; latej, you docked me on an article because the
subject was too new ; later still, you docked me on an
article because the subject was betwixt and between.
Once, when I wrote a Letter to Queen Victoria, you did
not put it in the respectable part of the Magazine, but
interred it in that potter’s field, the Editor’s Drawer. As
a result, she never answered it. How often we rtcall,
with regre^, that Napoleon once shot at a magazine editor
and missed him and killed a publisher. But we remember,
with Qharity, that his intentions were good.
You will reform, now, Aldcn. You will cease from
these economies, and you will be discharged. But in
your retirement you will carry with you the admiration
and earnest good wishes of the oppressed and toiling
scribes. This will be better than bread. Let this console
you when the bread fails.
You will carry with you another thing, too — the
affection of the scribes ; for they all love you in spite of
your crimes. For you bear a kind heart in your breast,
and the sweet and winning spirit that charms away all
hostilities and animosities, and makes of your enemy your
friend and keeps him so. You have reigned over us
thirty-six years, and, please God, you shall reign another
thirty-si# — “ and peace to Mahmoud on his golden
throne ! ”
Always yours Mabk.
Mark Twain’s own books were always being excommunicated
by some librarian, and the matter never failed to invite the
attention and amusement of the press, and the indignation of
many correspondents. Usually the books were Tom Sawyer and
Hack Finn, the morals of which were not Regarded as wholly
exemplary. But in 1907 a small library, in a very small town,
attained a day’s national notoriety by putting the ban on
Eve's Diary, not so much on account of its text as for the chaste
and exquisite illustrations by Lester Ralph. When the reporters
came in a troop to learn about it, the author said : “ 1 believe
this time the trouble is mainly with the pictures. I did not
dra\y them. I wish I had — they are so beautiful.”
414
LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
Just at this time. Dr. William Lyon Phelgp, of Yale, was
giving a literary talk to the Teachers’ Club, of Hartford, dwelling
on the superlative value of Mark Twain’s writings for readers
old and yofang. Mrs. F. G. Whitmore, an old Hartford friend,
wrote Clemens of the things that Phelps had said, as consola-
tion for Eve’s latest banishment. This gave him a chance to
add something to what he had said to the reporters.
To Mrs. Whitmore, in Hartford :
Feb. 7, *1907.
Dear Mrs. Whitmore, — But the truth is, that when
a Library expels a book of mine and leave an unex-
purgated Bible lying around where unprotected youth and
age can get hold of it, the deep unconscious irony of it
delights me and doesn’t anger me. But even if it angered*
me such words as those of Professor Phelps would take
the sting all out. Nobody attaches weight to the freaks 1
of the Charlton Library, but when a man like Phelps
speaks, the world gives attention. Some day 1 hope to
meet him and thank him for his courage for saying those
things out in public. Custom is, to think a handsome thing
in private but tame it down in the utterance.
I hope you are all well and happy ; and thereto I add
my love. Sincerely yours,
S. L. Clemens.
In May, 1907, Mark Twain was invited to England to receive
from Oxford the degree of Literary Doctor. It was an honour
that came to him as a sort of laurel crown at the end of a
great career, and gratified him exceedingly.
Mark Twain's extraordinary reception and triumph in
England was, in iact, the crowning glory of his career. Per-
haps one of the most satisfactory incidents of his sojourn was a
dinner given to him by the staff of Punch, in the historic offices
at 10 llouverie Street, where no other foreign visitor had been
thus honoured — a notable distinction. When the dinner ended,
little Joy Agncw, daughter of the chief editor, entered and
presented to the chief guest the original drawing of a cartoon
by Bernard Partridge, which had appeared on the frontpage
PUNCH
41 r >
of Punch. In this picture the presiding genius of the paper
is offering to Murk Twain health, long life, and happiness from
“ The Punch Bowl”
To Mias Joy Agnew, in London :
Tuxedo Park, New Yojk.
Unto you greetings and salutation and Worship, you
dear, sweet? little rightly-named Joy 1 I can see you now
almost as vividly as I saw you that night when you sat
flas hing and beaming upon those sombre swallow-tails.
“ Fair as a star when only one
Is shining in the sky.”
Oh, you were indeed the only one — there wasn’t even
the remotest chance of competition with you , dear !
«Ah, you are a decoration, you little witch !
The idea of your house going to the wanton expense
> of a flower garden 1 — aren’t you enough ? And what do
you want to go and discourage the other flowers for ? Is
that the .right spirit ? is it considerate ? is it kind ? How
do you suppose they feel when you come around — looking
the way you look ? And you so pink and sweet and dainty
and lovely and supernatural ? Why, it makes them feel
embarrassed and artificial, of course ; and in my opinion
it is jusfas pathetic as it can be. Now then you want to
reform — dear — and do right.
Well certainly you are well off, Joy :
8 bantams ;
3 goldfish ;
3 doves ;
0 canaries ;
2 dogs ;
1 cat ;
All you need, now, to be permanently beyond the
reach of want, is one more dog — just one more good,
gentle, high-principled, affectionate, loyal dog who wouldn’t
want any nobler service than the golden privilege of
UK rjemTgPK fit
lying At yout door,' £gbt^ biting evetytbing that
came along— and X am that very one, and ready to come
At Hie dropping of a hat.
Do you think you could convey my love And thanks
to your “daddy** and Owen Seaman and those other
oppressed and down-trodden subjects of yours, yon darling
small tyrant ?
On my knees 1 These-— with the kiss of fealty from
your other subject— Mark Twain.
Clemens could never accustom himself to the loss of his
wife. From the time of her death, marriage— which had
brought him his greatest joy in life — presented itself to him
always with the thought of bereavement, waiting somewhere
just behind. The news of an approaching wedding saddened
him and there was nearly always a sombre tinge m bis con-
gratulations, of which the following to a dear friend is an
To Father Fitz-Simon, in Washington :
June 8 , *08.
Bear Father Fitz-Simon, — Marriage — yes, it is the
supreme felicity of life, I concede it. And it is also the
supreme tragedy of life. The deeper the love the surer
the tragedy. And the more disconsolating when it comes.
And so I congratulate you. Not perfunctorily, not
lukewarmly, but with a fervency and fire that no word in
the dictionary is strong enough to convey. And in
the same breath and with the same depth and sincerity,
I grieve for you. Not for both of you and not for the
one that shall go first, but for the one that is fated to be
left behind. For that one there is no recompense — For
that one no recompense is possible.
There are times — thousands of times — when X can
expose the half of my mind, and conceal the other half,
but in the matter of the tragedy of marriage % fed ioo
deeply for that, and I have to bleed it all out m shut ft aft
t i»»4 colter vM £h»ye,l«m» IjMfMfi* ,
. wCttgn ip a be charitable wtp awb" f
rppp the ra*** of the s unsh i n e 1 and I hope It
I *d© bot **»fiy want to be present ; yet f&jtyffepfe
‘ ‘*s take W»d because I honor you so, I would be.ifepre
Most sincerely your Mend, »
s. &. cxmwki "
The new home at Redding was completed in the spring of
1908, and on the 18th of June, when it was entirely fitted and
furnished, Mark Twain entered it for the first time. Be mid
never even seen the place nor carefully examined plans which
John Howells had made for his house. He preferred the sur-
prise of it, and the general avoidance of detail. That he was
satisfied with the result wifi be seen in his letters. He mufied
it at first “ Innocence at Home ” j later changing this title to
>“ Stonnfield.”
In his philosophy, What Is Man t and now and again ip his
other writings, we find Mark Twain giving small credit to the
hitman mind as an originator of ideas. The most original writer
of his time, he took no credit for pure invention and allowed none
to others. The mind, he declared, adapted, consciously or
Unconsciously ; it did not create. In a letter which follows he
elucidates this doctrine. The reference in it to the “ captain ”
and to the kerosene points to Captain “ Hurricane ” Jones and
his theory of the miracles of “ Isaac and of the prophets of
Baal,” as expounded in Same Rambling Nates of mldteEketirfim.
By a trick of memory Clemens gives The Little DuJce as his
suggestion for The Prince and the Pauper ; he should have
written The Prince and the Page, by the same author.
To Rev. F. V. Christ, in New York.
Redding, Conn., Aug. ’08.
Deab Sib, — You say “ I often owe my’ best sermons to
a" suggestion received in reading or from other exterior
sources.” Your remark is not quite in accordance with,
tip facts. We must change it to— “ I owe all my thoughts,
sermons and ideas to suggestions received %om
outside of myself.” Thesimplified English of this pnqppsi-
S B
418
LETTERS OP MARK TWAIN
tion is— No man’s brains ev6r originated an idea.*’ It
is an astonishing thing that after all these ages the world
goes on thinking the human brain machinery can originate
a thought.
It can’t. It never has done it. In all cases, little and
big, the thought is bom of a suggestion ; and in all cases
the suggestions come to the brain from the outside. The
brain never acts except from exterior impulse.
A man can satisfy himself of the truth of this by a
single process, — let him examine every idea that occurs
to him in an hour ; a day ; in a week — in a lifetime if he
please. He will always find that an outside something
suggested the thought, something which he saw with his
eyes or heard with his ears or perceived by his touch —
not necessarily to-day, nor yesterday, nor last year, nor
twenty years ago, but sometime or other. Usually the
source of the suggestion is immediately traceable, but
sometimes it isn’t.
However, if you will examine every thought that occurs
to you for the next two days, you will find that in at least
nine cases out of ten you can put your finger on the out-
side suggestion — And that ought to convince you that No.
10 had that source too, although you cannot at present
hunt it down and find it.
The idea of writing to me would have had to wait a
long time if it waited until your brain originated it. It
was bom of an outside suggestion — Sir Thomas and my
old Captain.
The hypnotist thinks he has invented a new thing —
suggestion. This is very sad. I don’t know where my
captain got hir kerosene idea. (It was forty-one years
ago, and he is long ago dead.) But I know that it didn’t
originate in his head, but it was bom from a suggestion
from the outside.
Yesterday a guest said, “ How did you come to think
of writing ‘ The Prince and the Pauper ’ ? ” I didn’t. The
thought came to me from the outside — suggested by that
“THE CHILDREN’S THEATRE” 419
pleasant and picturesque little history-book, Charlotte
M. Yonge’s ‘HLittle Duke.” I doubt if Mrs. Burnett knows
whence came to her the suggestion to write “(Little Lord
Fauntleroy,” but I know ; it came to her from reading
“ The Prince and the Pauper.” In all my life 1 have never
originated an idea, and neithlr has she, nor anybody else.
Man’s mind is a clever machine, and can wo£k up
materials into ingenious fancies and ideas, but it can’t
create the material ; none but the gods can do that. In
Sweden I saw a vast machine receive a block of wood, and
turn ft into marketable matches in two minutes. It could
do everything but make the wood. That is the kind of
machine the human mind is. Maybe this is not a large
compliment, but it is all I can afford. . . .
Your friend and well-wisher.
S. L. Clemens.
The “ Children’s Theatre ” of the next letter was an institu-
tion of the New York East Side in which Mark Twain was deeply
interested. The children were most, if not all, of Hebrew
parentage, and the performances they gave, under the direction
of Alice M. Herts, were really remarkable.
The following letter was in reply to one enclosing a newspaper
clipping reporting a performance of The Prince and the Pauper ,
given by Chicago school children.
O
To Mrs. Hookway , in Chicago :
Sept., 1908.
Dear Mrs. Hookway, — Although I am full of the
spirit of work this morning, a rarity with me lately — I
must steal a moment or two for a word in person : for I
have been reading the eloquent accom 1 * in the Record-
Herald and am pleasurably stirred, to my deepest deeps.
The reading brings vividly back to me my pet and pride.
The Children’s Theatre of the East side, New York. And
it supports and re-affirms what I have so often and
strenuously said in public that a children’s theatre is
easily the most valuable adjunct that any educational
420 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
institution for the young can have, and that no otherwise
good school is complete without it.
It is Dr.uch the most effective teacher of morals and
promoter of good conduct that the ingenuity of man has
yet devised, for the reason that its lessons are not taught
wearily by book and by drehry homily, but by visible and
enth&sing action ; and they go straight to the heart,
which is the Tightest of right places for them.' Book
morals often get no further than the intellect, if they
even get that far on their spectral and shadowy pilgrimage :
but when they travel from a Children’s Theatre they do not
stop permanently at that halfway house, but go on home.
The children’s theatre is the only teacher of morals and
conduct and high ideals that never bores the pupil, but
always leaves him sorry when the lesson is over. And
as for history, no other teacher is for a moment com- 5
parable to it : no other can make the dead heroes of the
world rise up and shake the dust of the ages from their
bones and live and move and breathe and speak and be
real to the looker and listener : no other can make the
study of the lives and times of the illustrious dead a
delight, a splendid interest, a passion ; and no other can
paint a history-lesson in colors that will stay, and stay,
and never fade.
It is my conviction that the children’s theatre is one
of the very, very great inventions of the twentieth century ;
and that its vast educational value — now but dimly
perceived and but vaguely understood — will presently
come to be recognized. By the article which I have been
reading I find the same things happening in the Howland
School that we have become familiar with in our Children’s
Theatre (of which I am President, and sufficiently vain of
the distinction.) These things among others ;
1. The educating history-study does not stop with the
little players, but the whole school catches the infection
and revels in it.
2. And it doesn’t even stop there ; the children carry
HENNIKER-HK1T0N 421
it home and infect the family with it— even the parents
and grandparents ; and the whole household fall to study-
ing history, and bygone manners and customs and costumes
.with eager interest. And this interest is carried along
to the studying of costumes in old book-plates; and
beyond that to the selecting f)i fabrics and the making of
clothes. Hundreds of our children learn the play% by
listening without book, and by making notes ; then the
listener goes home and plays the piece — all the parts ! —
to the family. And the family are glad and proud ; glad
to listen to the explanations and analyses, glad to leam,
glad to be lifted to planes above their dreary workaday
lives. Our children’s theatre is educating 7,000 children
— and their families. When we put on a play of Shake-
speare they fall to studying it diligently ; so that they
may be qualified to enjoy it to the limit when the piece is
staged.
8. Your Howland School children do the construction-
work, stage-decorations, etc. That is our way too. Our
young folks do everything that is needed by the theatre,
with their own hands ; scene-designing, scene-painting,
gas-fitting, electric work, costume-designing — costume-
making, everything and all things indeed — and their
orchestra and its leader are from their own ranks. . . .
o
One of Mark Twain’s friends was Henniker-Heaton, the
so-called “ Father of Penny Postage ” between England and
America. When, after long years of effort, he succeeded in
getting the rate established, he at once bent his energies in the
direction of cheap cable service and a letter from him came one
day to Stormfield concerning his new plans. This letter hap-
pened to be over-weight, which gave Mark Twain a chance for
some a musing exaggerations at his expense. r >
/
To Henniker-Heaton, in London :
Stormfield, Bedding, Connecticut,
Jan. 18, 1909.
Dear Henniker-Heaton, — I do hope you will succeed
to your heart’s desire in your cheap-cablegram campaign.
422 ' ' LETTERS OF HARK TWAIN ’ "
and I feel sure you will. Indeed your cheap-postage
victory, achieved in spite of a quarter-century Sf determined
opposition, .is good and rational prophecy that you will.
Wireless, not being as yet imprisoned in a Chinese wall of
private cash and high-placed and formidable influence,
will come to your aid and make your new campaign
briefer and easier than the other one was.
Now then,' after uttering my serious word, am I •privi-
leged to be frivolous for a moment ? When “you shall
have achieved cheap telegraphy, are you going to employ
it for just your own selfish profit and other people’s
pecuniary damage, the way you are doing with your cheap
postage ? You get letter-postage reduced to 2 cents an
ounce, then you mail me a 4-ounce letter with a 2-cent
stamp on it, and I have to pay the extra freight at this
end of the line. I return your envelope for inspection.
Look at it. Stamped in one place is a vast “ T,” and under
it the figures “ 40 ; ” and under those figures appears an
“L,” a sinister and suspicious and mysterious L. In
another place, stamped within a circle, in offensively large
capitals, you find the words “ DUE 8 CENTS.” Finally,
in the midst of a desert space up nor-noreastard from
that circle you find a figure “ 8 ” of quite unnecessarily
aggressive and insolent magnitude — and done with a blue
pencil, so as to be as conspicuous as possible. I inquired
about these strange signs and symbols of the postman.
He said they were P. O. Department signals for his
instruction.
“ Instruction for what ? ”
“ To get extra postage.”
“ Is it so ? Explain. Tell me about the large T and
the 40.”
“ It’s short for Take 40 — or as we postmen say, grab
40.”
“ Go on, please, while I think up some words to swear
with.”
“ Due 8 means, grab 8 more,”
POSTAGE DUES
“ — — — Continue.”
“ The blu#*pencil 8 was an afterthought. There
aren’t any stamps for afterthoughts ; the sums vary,
according to inspiration, and they whirl in the* one that
suggests itself at the last moment. Sometimes they go
severals times higher than this# one. This one only means
hog 8 cents more. And so if you’ve got 51 cents about you,
or can borrow it — ” •
“ Tell nle : who gets this corruption ? ”
“ Half of it goes to the man in England who ships the
letter ftn short postage, and the other half goes to the
P.O.D. to protect cheap postage from inaugurating a
deficit.”
“ I can’t blame you ; I would say it myself in your
> place, if these ladies were not present. But you see I’m
only obeying orders, I can’t help myself.”
“ Oh, I know it ; I’m not blaming you. Finally, what
does that L stand for ? ”
“ Get the money, or give him L. It’s English, you
know.”
“ Take it and go. It’s the last cent I’ve got in the
world .”
After seeing the Oxford pageant file by the grand
stand, picture after picture, t,plendor after splendor, three
thousand five hundred strong, the most moving and
beautiful and impressive and historically-instructive show
conceivable you are not to think I would miss the London
pageant of next year, with its shining host of 15,000
historical English men and women dug from the misty
books of all the vanished ages and marching in the light
of the sun — all alive, and looking just as they were used
to look ! Mr. Lascelles spent yesterday here on the farm,
and told me all about it. I shall be in the middle of
my 75th year then, and interested in pageants for personal
and prospective reasons.
I beg you to give my best thanks to the Bath Club for
424 , LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
the offer of its hospitalities, but I shall not be able to take
advantage of it, because I am to be a gueft in a private
house during my stay in London. Sincerely yours,
S. L. Clemens.
It was in 1907 that Clemen i had seen the Oxford Pageant —
during the week when he had been awarded his doctor’s degree.
It gdve him the greatest delight, and he fully expected to see the
next one, planned for 1910. •
Because Mark Twain amused himself with certain aspects of
Christian Science, and was critical of Mrs. Eddy, there grew up
a wide impression that he jeered at the theory of mental healing ;
when, as a matter of fact, he was one of its earliest converts, and
never lost faith in its power.
To J. Wylie Smith, Glasgow, Scotland :
“ Stormfield," Augtrat 7, 1909.
Deab Sie, — M y view of the matter has not changed.
To wit, that Christian Science is valuable; that it has
just the same value now that it had when Mrs. Eddy
stole it from Quimby ; that its healing principle (its most
valuable asset) possesses the same force now that it
possessed a million years ago before Quimby was bom ;
that Mrs. Eddy . . . organized that force, and is entitled
to high credit for that. Then, with a splendid sagacity
she hitched it to ... a religion, the surest of all ways
to secure friends for it, and support. In a fine and lofty
way — figuratively speaking — it was a tramp stealing a
ride on the lightning express. Ah, how did that ignorant
village-bom peasant woman know the human being so
well ? She has no more intellect than a tadpole — until it
comes to business^— then she is a marvel 1
Am I sorry I wrote the book ? Most certainly not.
You say you have 500 (converts) in Glasgow. Fifty
years from now, your posterity will not count them by
the hundred, but by the thousand. I feel absolutely
sure of tills. Very truly yours,
' S. L. Clemens.
BERMUDA
425
Early in June that year, Clemens had developed unmistakable
symptoms of Heart trouble of a very serious nature. It was
angina pectoris, and while to all appearances he was as well as
ever and usually felt so, he was periodically visited by severe
attacks of acute 44 breast pains ” which, as the months passed,
increased in frequency and severity. He was alarmed and dis-
tressed — not on his own accouift, but because of his daughter
Jean— a handsome girl, who had long been subject to epileptic
seizures. In case of his death he feared that J^an would be
withoift permanent anchorage, his other daughter, Clara —
following her marriage to Ossip Gabrilowitsch in October —
having taken up residence abroad.
Thfe anxiety was soon ended. On the morning of December
24th, Jean Clemens was found dead in her apartment. She
was not drowned in her bath, as was reported, but died from
heart exhaustion, the result of her malady and the shock of
cold wate^.
The blow to her father was terrible, but heavy as it was,
one may perhaps understand that her passing in that swift,
painless way must have afforded him a measure of relief.
Mark Twain had returned from a month’s trip to Bermuda
a few days before Jean died. Now, by his physician’s advice,
he went back to those balmy islands. He had always loved
them, since his first trip there with Twicliell thirty-three years
earlier, and at 46 Bay House,” the residence of Vice-Consul Allen,
where he was always a welcome guest, he could have the
attentions and care and comforts of a home. Taking Claude,
the butler, as his valet, he sailed January 5th, and presently
sent back a letter in which he said, Again I am leading the
ideal life* and am immeasurably content.”
From the early Bermuda letters we may gather that Mark
Twain’s days were enjoyable enough, and that his malady was
not giving him serious trouble, thus far. Through February,
and most of March, letters and reports from him were about the
same. In these letters he seldom mentioned the angina pains
that had tortured him earlier. But once , when he sent a small
photograph of himself, it seemed to us that his face had become
thin and that he had suffered. Yet we did not suspect how
rapidly the end was approaching and only grew vaguely alarmed.
A week later, however, it became evident that his condition was
critical.
Deak Paine,—. ... I have been having a most un-
comfortable time for the past 4 days with that breast-
pain^ which turns out to be an affection of the heart, just
426 LETTERS OF MARK TWAIN
as I originally suspected. The news from New York Is to
the effect that non-bronchial weather has Arrived there
at last, therefore if I can get my breast trouble in traveling'
condition I may sail for home a week or two earlier than
has heretofore been proposed. Yours as ever
S. L. Clemens,
(per H. S. A.)
In this letter he seems to have forgotten that his trouble had
been pronounced an affection of the heart long before he left
America, though at first it had been thought that it might be
gastritis. The same mail brought a letter from Mr.' * Allen
explaining fully the seriousness of his condition. I sailed imme-
diately for Bermuda, arriving there on the 4th of April. He was
not suffering at the moment, though the pains came now with
alarming frequency and violence. He was cheerful and brave.
He did not complain. He gave no suggestion of a man whose
days were nearly ended.
A part of the Stormfield estate had been a farm, which he had
given to Jean Clemens, where she had busied herself raising
some live stock and poultry. After her death he had wished
the place to be sold and the returns devoted to some memorial
purpose. The sale had been made during the winter and the
price received had been paid in cash. I found him full of interest
in all affairs, and anxious to discuss the memorial plan. A day
or two later he dictated the following letter — the last he would
ever send.
It seemed fitting that this final word from one who had so
long given happiness to the whole world should record <a special
gift to his neighbours.
To Charles T. Lark , in New York :
Hamilton, Bermuda.
April 6, 1910.
Dear Mr. L^ek, — I have told Paine that I want the
money derived from the sale of the farm, which I had
given, but not conveyed, to my daughter Jean, to be used
to erect a building for the Mark Twain Library of Red-
ding, the building to be called the Jean L. Clemens
Memorial Building.
I wish to place the money $6,000.00 in the hands of
DEATH
4271
three trustees, — Paine and two others : H. A. Louns-
bury and William E. Haaen, all o! Redding, these trustees
to form a building Committee to decide on the^size and
plan of the building needed and to arrange for and super-
vise the work in such a manner that the fund shall amply
provide for the building complete, with necessary furnish-
ings, leaving, if possible, a balance remaining, sufficient
for such repairs and additional furnishings ’as may be
required for* two years from the time of completion.
Will you please draw a document covering these require-
ments And have it ready by the time I reach New York
(April 14th). Very sincerely,
S. L. Clemens.
We sailed on the 12th of April, reaching New York on the
14th, as he had planned. A day or two later, Mr. and Mrs.
Gabrilowitsch, summoned from Italy by cable, arrived. He
suffered very little after reaching Stormfield, and his mind was
, comparatively clear up to the last day. On the afternoon of
April 21st he sank into a state of coma, and just at sunset he
died. Three days later, at Elmira, New York, he was laid
beside Mrs. Clemens and those others who had preceded him.
INDEX
ADr&ONDACKS — 369-374
Agnew, Joy — 414. Letter to : —
415 *
Alden, Henry Mills — Letter to : —
412
Aldrich, Thomas Bailey— -12, 105-8,
129, 155, 205, 228. Letters
to 105, 106, 130, 210
AUa-California, The — 9, 69, 77-8,
87-8
Amazon — 28-30
American Publishing Co. — 10, 11,
77-9, 81
Angel’s Camp — 6-7
Atlantic Monthly*— 129, 134, 144,
155, 166, 203
Australia — 15
Baxter, Sylvester — Letters to : —
284, 367
Beard, Dan — 279
Beecher, Henry Ward — 80-2, 247.
Letter to : — 248
Berlin— 301-3
Bermuda— 18, 166, 425
Bixby, Horace— 3, 30, 35, 48, 226
Bliss, Elisha, Jr.— 77, 82-3, 108,
136, 138, 144, 156, 201, 212.
Letters to : — 78, 83, 88, 97, 110,
120
Bliss, Frank E.— 213. Letter to
336
Boer War — 361 seq,
Bok, Edward W.— 274. Letter
to 274
Brazil — 3, 28
Brown, Dr, John— 122. Letters
to ;—123, 124, 126
Browning, Robert — 121, 268
Buffah^N.Y.— 11, 97, 108
Buffalo Express, Ther— 11, 94, 105,
109
Burlingame, Anson— 8, 66-8, 87
Cable, George W. — 14, 226, 230,
232 240—3
Californian , The — 5, 63-4, 69
Canada — 216 seq., 224, 235, 261
Carlton — 7, 64, 155-7
Carlyle— 268
Carnegie, Andrew — Letter to ; — 411
Carson City, Nev. — 5, 41
Ceylon — 16
Chatto & W indus — Letters to:—
269, 286
Children’s Theatre— 419
Clemens, Benjamin — 2
Clemens, Clara — 14, 325, 328, 332,
379, 380-1, 404, 425. Letters
to:— 301, 318
Clemens, Henry — 2, 20, 22-3, 27-8,
32. Letter to 28
Clemens, Jane — 20-2, 24-6, 27,
29, 32, 36, 40, 46, 98. Letters
to 27, 41, 43, 50, 57, 59, 60,
63, 64, 65, 67, 69, 70, 71, 72,
75, 79, 81, 84, 89, 90 bis , 92,
98, 120, 136, 177, 256
Clemens, Jean— 14, 18, 170, 208,
328, 332, 352, 380, 393, 425
Clemens, John Marshall — 1, 2
Clemens, Langdon — ’ll, 102, 116,
394
Clemens, Margaret — 2
Clemens, Olivia (Langdon) — 10-6,
79, 80, 89, 91 «c?., 97 seq., 108,
H6 seq., 121, 123, 126, 138 seq.,
148 seq., 162, 171, 178, 189,
192, 206, 22^ 237, 279, 298, 306,
326, 328, 332, 334, 364, 368, 374,
378, 381, 386, 388-394. Letters
to : — 119, 130, 161, 183, 216,
217, 218, 226, 299, 300, 309, 310,
312, 313, 319, 321, 379
Clemens, Orion — 2-4, 20-4, 2WV
36, 40, 47, 64, 62, 86, 136-7, 187,
192-9, 202, 204, 216, 230, 266.
Letters to 24, 30, 36, 37, 64,
429
430
INDEX
55, 86, 99, 100, 101, 108, 118,
196, 203, 212, 238, 273, 277
Clemens, Mrs. Orion — 62. Letter
to : — 33
Clemens, Pamela (Mrs. Moffett) — 2,
20, 22, 24, 40, 41, 98, 266.
Letters to: — 20, 22, 27, 43, 46,
60, 67, 69, 60, 63, 64, 65, 67, C9,
81, 84, 98, 100, 120, 136
Clemens, Samuel Langhome (Mark
Twain) — Life t — Birth — Nov. 30,
183 $ — 1 : Printer's apprentice
and printer — 1847-56 — 2, 20-8 :
Early Journalism — 2 : Pilot on
Mississippi— <1851-61— 3, 30-40:
Civil War — 1861 — 4, 40 : Nevada
-7561-2—40-54 : Minor in Cali-
fornia — 4, 6-7, 54 seq. / “ Josh’*
—1562 —6, 55-7 : “ Mark
Twain ”* — 1563—5, 57 : Journa-
lism in California — 1562-6— 5-8,
57-64 : Sandwich islands — 1866-
8 — 64-8 ; Lecturing — -8-9, 12,
68-71 : Mediterranean trip —
1867 — 8, 69-77 : Literary suc-
cess — 10, 77 : Marriage — 1870 —
10, 97 ; Hartford, Conn. — 1 1-3,
110, passim : England and
Scotland — 1872-4 — 1 1, 118-124:
Quarry Farm, Elmira, N.Y. —
12, 126, passim j Typesetting-
machine — 13, 202, 239, 276 seq.,
296 seq., 323-8 : Publishing — 13,
232, 242, 296 : European tour —
1878-9 — 13, 177 seq . *• Financial
worries — 13, 15, 295, 298, 306,
309 seq . t Europe — 1891-4 —
298-328 : World-tour— 1595-
1900— 14—5, 328—366 : Europe—
1903 — 16, 387-393: Death of
Mrs, Clemens — 1904 — 16, 393 :
Oxford degree — 1907 — 16, 414 :
Stormfield, Redding, Conn. —
1908-1910 — -16-8, 41 7-424 :
Death — April 21, 1910—18, 427
Works : — Adam's Diary — 401-2:
Ah Stn — 164-5, 167-9 : American
Claimant, The~+2 39 : Canvas-
ser's Tale , The — 161 : Captain
Stormfield — 267 : Connecticut
Yankee in King Arthur's Court ,
A.— 13, 272, 279-280, 286-7 :
Following the Equator — 15, 267,
****334, 336, 351, 363 : Gilded Age ,
The— 1, 12, 124, 127, 130, 140:
Morse's Tale , A.— 403, 408 :
Huckleberry Finn— 13, 237, 240-
1, 244, 290, 41J: Innocents
Abroad, Thep~lQ, 11, 24, 72, 81,
83, 93, 97, 101, 110, 212: Joan
of Arc— 14, 323 : Jumping Frog,
The— 7, 63, 69, 155 : Life on the
Mississippi— t3, 13, 35, 133, 228,
23 2, 235, 266: Man that cor-
rupted Hadleyburg, The — 17 ; My
Platonic Sweetheart — 345 : Mys-
terious Stranger, The — 356, 401 :
Prince and the Pauper, The — 13,
202, 210, 216, 266, 41%: Pudd'n-
head Wilson — 305 : Boughing
It- 4, 8, 11, 41, 43, 49, 63,
68, 87, 100, 110-2, 115-7, 148,
212, 368 ; Simon Whqfier, Ama-
teur Detective — 343 : Sketches,
Old and New— 148, 156: Tom
Sawyer — 2, 13, 117, 127, 143-5,
150-6, 258, 266, 413: Tom
Sawyer Abroad — 162 : Tramp
Abroad, A.— 13, m, 188, 200-2,
212 : What is Man 9- 350, 417
Clemens, Susy — 11, 14-6, 116, 123, %1
127, 140, 158, 170, 180, 185,
321, 328, 332-3, 336, 394, 404.
Letter to 303
Copyright — 146-7, 205, 207, 216,
235, 261-4, 269
Coquelin — 318-320
Corbett, James J. (“ Gentleman
Jim ,9 ) — 313-5
Crane, Mrs. Theodore — Letter to : —
305
Crane, Theodore — Letter to : — 272
Czar, The— 73-4, 291 seq.
Davis, Richard Harding — 319
Degrees from Univemties— 374,
414
Dickens, Charles— 12, 119, 268
Dimmitt, Edward L. — Letter to
369 l
Dodge, Mary Napes — 304, 319*
Doubleday, Frank N.— 367, 388*
Letters to 387, 394
Duaeka, Frederick A. — 401. Let*
tera to 402 bis, 403, 405
Eliot, George— 246-7
Elmira, N.Y.— 10, 12, 14, 16, 80,
89 seq., 110, 117, 126 sea., 170,
198 seq., 268 seq,, 386, 394, 401,
427, passim
England— 11, 15, 118, 361-6
INlDEX
481
Fim j>s, Jambs T.— 205
Fitz- Simon, Father — Letter to)
416
Florence— 16, 304 seq., 388
Francis, Gov. Daniel R. — t©r
to s— 392
Franklin, Benjamin — 25-6
Fuller, F. — 9, 70-1
Galaxy, The — 11, 98
Gatts, F. — Letters
386 •
G^winany— 179 eeq.> 301
Gilder, Jeannette— 267
to : — 365
Gilder, Richard Watson-
Gillis, James — 6
Golden Era , The — 5
Goodman, Joseph T.
280, 291. Letters
Grant, Ge& Ulysses
245, 247-253, 255
Gray, John A. — 22
56, 107,
-280, 290
13, 242,
Hall, Fred J.— 3?» 306, 308.
Letters to 279,P-» **04, 306
Hannibal Journal Jhe^-2, 22,24
Hannibal, Mo.— 2,; % 20, 22, 24,
27, 226 /
Harper & Bros.— jf 3 * 281, 401
Harper'* Magazirt~f> 1 4,68
Harris, Joel CbM^r— 213, 22o.
Letters to 215, 224
Harte, Bret.— / 83 * 64, 69, 105,
106, 108, 11#^, 144, 149, 150,
163-5, *140, /> 6 - Letter to
70 /
Hartford, Coh~*l°*
110 seq., V m-> 175 seq 200
sea., 258 ef 332, 367, passim
Hawthorne, /thaniel-247
Hay, John-^r^» 228
Hayes, RiM*d B.-158, ICO,
162-5 I
Henniker^ton— Letter to 421
Holmes, fc> r Wendell— 92, 117,
146 200|®? 312
Howells, F iam Doan — 12, 116,
119 lrf^l, 146, 178, 204-5,
239 2*30, 286, 316 » 353 » 358 >
iters to 116, 128, 129,
m L 135, 138, 142, 143,
146JF * 48 > 149 » 161 » 154 » 155 »
160, 164, 165, 166, 168,
17f 6, 179, 180, 185, 186, 192,
198, 199, 200, 201, 206, 208, 211,
219, 220, 227, 229, 230, 233, 237,
240, 243, 245, 246, 253, 255, 268,
297, 298, 337, 343, 350, 354, 256,
357, 361, 391, 393, *11
Howells, Mrs. W. D.— 138, 148,
157, 1 78, 205, 316, Letter to
/ 139
India — 15, 328
Irving, Henry — 154
James, William — 317
Keokttk, Iowa — 3, 9, 27-8, 30*
177, 212, 266-7, passim
Kipling, Rudyard— 12, 288, 387-8,
394. Letter to : — 328
Lampton, James (“ Col. Sellers —
12, 47, 49, 239
Lang, Andrew — 256, 290. Letter
to 287
Langdon, Charles — 10, 79, 80, 88,
99,171. Letter to 140
Langdon, Jervis — 94, 97, 99, 100
Lewis, John T.— 170-5
London— 11, 15, 119, 121, 228, 332,
358 seq., 414
Longfellow, Henry W. — 146
Lowell, J. R. — 146
MacAlistkr, J. Y. M. — Letters to :
—366, 380
Matthews, Brander — 346. Letters
to 382, 384
McClure Syndicate, The— 298
McKelway, St. Clair — Letter to : —
401
McKinley, President- — 37*
McQuiston, Mrs. Charles — 367
Mergenthalor Composing Machine—
281, 290
“ Modest Clutf’- -205
New York — 3, 7, 9-12, 16, 20-3,
25-9, 70, 77 seq., 167, 240, 281,
309, 366
New York Herald— 11, 81, 281 <#***
New York Tribune— 11, 78, 221,
281
New Zealand — 15
INDEX
48 a
OsgTood, Jambs— 129, 145, 205,
216, 218, 224-5, 228, 232, 245
Oxford University — 16, 414
Paige— 276-*9, 291 seq
Pa me, Albert Bigelow— 426-7. Let-
ter to t — 425 9,
Palestine — 75, 80
Paii^r-198, 323
Phelps, Prof William Lyon— 368,
414. Letter to — 368
Powers, Rev, L M. — Letter to —
409
Fwnc/i— 414-6
Quaker City, 27ic— 9, 10, 70 eeq
Quarry Farm — 110 etc. See Elmira
RedjPath, Jambs — 98, 113, 116,
147. Letters to —98, 112, 113
bis, 114 bu, 115 bis
Reid, Robert— 221, 318-320
Rest -and-be- thankful- — 265 etc See
Elmira.
Rice, Tho “ Unreliable ”—58-9
Riverdale-on-the-Hudson — 15, 374,
386
Rogers, Henry H —170, 309- It,
313, 317, 321-3, 328, 334, 367
Letters to — 324, 325, 326
Roosevelt, Theodore — 397
Sacramento Unton, The — 8, 64, 67
Sandwich Islands— 8, 64, 8
San Francisco — 5-9, 59, 63, 88
San Francisco CaU~~~5, 63
Scott, Sir Walter— 128, 268, 382-4
Slot©, Ban — 80, 83, 118
Smith, J Wylie — Letter to 424
South Africa — 15, 329-332
Spam — 75-6
Stead, William T —Letters to:—
348 Im
Stedraan, Edmund Clarence — 286
St. Louis, Mo.— 4, 9, 20, 22, 24*
26-32, 41 seq .
Stoddard, Charles Warren— 124,
333
Stdrmfield — 16, 417
Stowe, Mrs. Harriet
85, 114
Suetonius— 268 *
Switterland — 15, 183 seq,, 299 sag?*,
334 seq.
Tayboe, Bayard— 179, li
TwicheM, Rev Joseph H.-**!
114, 135, 142, 166, 17" k
205, 219, 220, 224,
Letters to — 102, 10fy i
208, 3*9, 332, 334, 339,
358, 34 1, 364, 371, 378,
395, 396, 397
Typesetting machine- 13, 23
276-9, *80-3, 290-1, 29*i
Van Nostrand, Jack — 80*4
Vienna*— 15, 336 seq
Virginia City Enterprise, Tbs^L %
66, 60, 62
Ward, Artem ts— 7, 63, 107, 111
Warner, Chailes Dudley — 12, rata
124, 150, 200,205, 256 w
Washington — 3, 10, 79 seq *
W ebfet oi , Charle s L — ! 248,
Letter to - — 244
Webstc i & Co , Charles X *#*|l
242, 265, 306, 321, 328 ,
Western Union Co —374
Whittier, John Ortenleaf^m
Wilberforce, Canon— 366
Wolfe, Jim— 21-2, 27*
Yajle University — 16
Y ork Harbour, Marne— 374
THE END
VRIStKD IN ENGLAND BY WILLIAM CLOWES AND SONS, LTD., LONDON AND